Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

It's clear no one is changing anyone's minds here. We're just pilots trying to dictate foreign policy and best course of action. I should know better than to delve into something like this. So my fault for expressing something that obviously differed from what you believe and hold true. And I say that to who ever feels slighted or offended in this thread.
 
this thread has taught me cherokee has no idea wtf he is talking about

Some points are open to debate. Other points like the House of Saud being more foe than friend, as well as intelligence failures in different places, are things we all agree on I'm sure.
 
I'm also about perspective. Don't get me wrong, 224 people dead on a plane blown out of the sky is terrible. There should be justice. But where is the justice when Russia blows an airliner out of the sky over Europe and kills 298? It seems the whole world just moved on without bombing or arresting anyone...

And 130 dead in a Paris gun shooting terrorist attack is also terrible. Those responsible should be brought to justice. Don't forget though, these were French and Belgian citizens. Not Syrian/Iraqi citizens. They legally belonged to and lived in France and Belgium. Sure, you can blow Iraq/Isis to the stone age, but how do you stop these citizens from carrying out attacks?

We are ready for World War III and it seems some are demanding an all-out ground war/campaign. This all due to the straw breaking the camels back with 130 dead in a Paris attack that involved guns, with a religious/terrorism motivation.

I can't forget that right here we have mentally disturbed individuals with a constitutional right to buy/own a gun that go to Virginia Tech and slaughter 32 college kids and professors, or 30 elementary school children and teachers in Sandy Hook. Two white Christian men (but that's irrelevant) that were "mentally disturbed" gunned down 60+ American citizens....

No one asked for an all out war. No one raised a finger longer than one week after these attacks. All accusations went to a "broken health system." The rest of the country cowered into a corner and said, "don't touch my guns!" Of course there was no religious terrorist motivation behind it, but how did that make the tragedies any less horrific?

So now, instead of a mentally-disturbed individual (although in my personal opinion, anyone who can slaughter human beings has to be mentally disturbed to some level), instead it was a terrorism - religious motivated attack, gunning down innocent Parisians and we want an all out ground war. We want the refugees to stop (despite it being proven that the hardest way to legally enter this country is through the refugee program).


Was what happened in Paris terrible and horrific? Absolutely! Are there deaths any more different than school children in Sandy Hook or Virginia Tech? Not really. Innocent human life is still innocent human life. But my, what different reactions we demand based on one attack that killed 130 people.

Perspective
 
I'm also about perspective. Don't get me wrong, 224 people dead on a plane blown out of the sky is terrible. There should be justice. But where is the justice when Russia blows an airliner out of the sky over Europe and kills 298? It seems the whole world just moved on without bombing or arresting anyone...

And 130 dead in a Paris gun shooting terrorist attack is also terrible. Those responsible should be brought to justice. Don't forget though, these were French and Belgian citizens. Not Syrian/Iraqi citizens. They legally belonged to and lived in France and Belgium. Sure, you can blow Iraq/Isis to the stone age, but how do you stop these citizens from carrying out attacks?

We are ready for World War III and it seems some are demanding an all-out ground war/campaign. This all due to the straw breaking the camels back with 130 dead in a Paris attack that involved guns, with a religious/terrorism motivation.

I can't forget that right here we have mentally disturbed individuals with a constitutional right to buy/own a gun that go to Virginia Tech and slaughter 32 college kids and professors, or 30 elementary school children and teachers in Sandy Hook. Two white Christian men (but that's irrelevant) that were "mentally disturbed" gunned down 60+ American citizens....

No one asked for an all out war. No one raised a finger longer than one week after these attacks. All accusations went to a "broken health system." The rest of the country cowered into a corner and said, "don't touch my guns!" Of course there was no religious terrorist motivation behind it, but how did that make the tragedies any less horrific?

So now, instead of a mentally-disturbed individual (although in my personal opinion, anyone who can slaughter human beings has to be mentally disturbed to some level), instead it was a terrorism - religious motivated attack, gunning down innocent Parisians and we want an all out ground war. We want the refugees to stop (despite it being proven that the hardest way to legally enter this country is through the refugee program).


Was what happened in Paris terrible and horrific? Absolutely! Are there deaths any more different than school children in Sandy Hook or Virginia Tech? Not really. Innocent human life is still innocent human life. But my, what different reactions we demand based on one attack that killed 130 people.

Perspective
I agree with you on some of your points. However we really CAN'T ignore the fact that Paris is a part of a bigger problem/war than the incidents in the States. Sandy Hook and Virgina Tech were obviously horrible beyond belief, but should be approached differently than coordinated attacks carried out by "Jihadists" that are happening in dozens of countries at once, all with the same motivations. Yes it is heartbreaking that the refugees are in this situation, but when ISIS outright threatens to flood terrorists among refugees across borders in Europe, I'd say that is a threat that should be taken seriously.
 
Are there deaths any more different than school children in Sandy Hook or Virginia Tech? Not really.

I think there's a strong argument to be made that they are different because they are in pursuit of a cause beyond "some chick turned me down". That said, it's a fair point. Why do we care so much about why people murder, rather than that they do? The caveat being (and you knew there would be one), that in a free nation, we will always have the ability to murder one another. The "fix" for that is worse than the disease. To my mind, the thing to remember is that all of this (literally, like DSM literal) insane carnage and bloodshed is over some people believing that other people oughtn't do things that the first bunch of people believe some magical sky-unicorn said they shouldn't do, because, you know, Sky Bully said you gotta die. If your Sky Bully wants people to die, why don't you just go ahead and die for it/him/her?
 
I'm also about perspective. Don't get me wrong, 224 people dead on a plane blown out of the sky is terrible. There should be justice. But where is the justice when Russia blows an airliner out of the sky over Europe and kills 298? It seems the whole world just moved on without bombing or arresting anyone...

And 130 dead in a Paris gun shooting terrorist attack is also terrible. Those responsible should be brought to justice. Don't forget though, these were French and Belgian citizens. Not Syrian/Iraqi citizens. They legally belonged to and lived in France and Belgium. Sure, you can blow Iraq/Isis to the stone age, but how do you stop these citizens from carrying out attacks?

We are ready for World War III and it seems some are demanding an all-out ground war/campaign. This all due to the straw breaking the camels back with 130 dead in a Paris attack that involved guns, with a religious/terrorism motivation.

I can't forget that right here we have mentally disturbed individuals with a constitutional right to buy/own a gun that go to Virginia Tech and slaughter 32 college kids and professors, or 30 elementary school children and teachers in Sandy Hook. Two white Christian men (but that's irrelevant) that were "mentally disturbed" gunned down 60+ American citizens....

No one asked for an all out war. No one raised a finger longer than one week after these attacks. All accusations went to a "broken health system." The rest of the country cowered into a corner and said, "don't touch my guns!" Of course there was no religious terrorist motivation behind it, but how did that make the tragedies any less horrific?

So now, instead of a mentally-disturbed individual (although in my personal opinion, anyone who can slaughter human beings has to be mentally disturbed to some level), instead it was a terrorism - religious motivated attack, gunning down innocent Parisians and we want an all out ground war. We want the refugees to stop (despite it being proven that the hardest way to legally enter this country is through the refugee program).


Was what happened in Paris terrible and horrific? Absolutely! Are there deaths any more different than school children in Sandy Hook or Virginia Tech? Not really. Innocent human life is still innocent human life. But my, what different reactions we demand based on one attack that killed 130 people.

Perspective

The difference is there is a clearly definable enemy with ISIS, not some random lurker, who will carry out an attack by themselves. That makes a HUGE difference when you want to put it to an end.
 
I agree with you on some of your points. However we really CAN'T ignore the fact that Paris is a part of a bigger problem/war than the incidents in the States. Sandy Hook and Virgina Tech were obviously horrible beyond belief, but should be approached differently than coordinated attacks carried out by "Jihadists" that are happening in dozens of countries at once, all with the same motivations. Yes it is heartbreaking that the refugees are in this situation, but when ISIS outright threatens to flood terrorists among refugees across borders in Europe, I'd say that is a threat that should be taken seriously.

I don't know what the refugee process is like for European countries but here in America, pretty much everyone has admit it would be the hardest way for a terrorist to gain access to the United States legally. There are other ways, legal and illegal, for a terrorist to enter here. These 7 Paris attackers were already citizens of European countries, it's not like they were fresh off the boat.

How can you say that is a bigger problem/war? I'd say our problem of unlimited access to guns for the mentally challenged/deranged individuals is a far bigger problem and has killed (collectively) more people than any recent Paris attack.

The difference is there is a clearly definable enemy with ISIS, not some random lurker, who will carry out an attack by themselves. That makes a HUGE difference when you want to put it to an end.

I don't think ISIS is as clearly a defined enemy as one would like to believe. In that end, you can carpet bomb Iraq and Syria and leave it in ruins, and the so called "ISIS" will have fighters that still attack western targets overseas.

In that way, the Boston brothers were also two random lurkers who decided to kill 3 Americans but were 'religiously' motivated. Is that really any "worse" than a white deranged non-Muslim walking into an Aurora movie theater and shooting dead 12 people and injuring 70+? Say what you want about the penalty system, about the political leanings of juries in Colorado versus Massachusetts, but keep in mind the Boston brother got the death penalty for his killing 3 Americans whereas the Colorado movie theater shooter was spared.

We, as a country, have been "conditioned" to accept mass shootings from mentally challenged individuals here on our soil. So when it does happen, it only creates a temporary one-week period of sadness, frustration, and hurt. But then we move on and cling to the constitutional right to buy guns and don't want any infringement. Part of that cost of freedom is that we do allow unfettered access to those who are mental nut cases from also legally buying and owning a gun. I get it, constitutional right.

But it seems a little hypocritical to me that the same action, gun used by a mad man to kill innocent people, can be viewed so differently when it isn't say a mental disease, and instead a religious-terrorist motivated individual. Rest assured, an innocent person will die by a bullet just as quick with either of these two shooters.

My point: only in one case we are demanding an all out war. In the other case, we are literally sitting around and doing nothing. Nothing legally, and nothing in the medical system to help address mental sickness somehow. But some guys go dirka dirka dirka and kill innocent people and now we want WW III in the Middle East?

Now could an attack by a lone ISIS wolf (or a couple wolves together) happen here in the US? Sure. But do I think it's faaar more likely the next attack here will be a "mentally sick guy" who had legal access to a gun and shot/killed multiple innocent people in the US? Absolutely.

If none is right, then you treat both the same. I can't stand one getting a pass because the only way to stop it might be the restrictions on gun purchasing/ownership, and the other being some vision of an all out war in Iraq and Syria.

Perspective.
 
I don't know what the refugee process is like for European countries but here in America, pretty much everyone has admit it would be the hardest way for a terrorist to gain access to the United States legally. There are other ways, legal and illegal, for a terrorist to enter here. These 7 Paris attackers were already citizens of European countries, it's not like they were fresh off the boat.

How can you say that is a bigger problem/war? I'd say our problem of unlimited access to guns for the mentally challenged/deranged individuals is a far bigger problem and has killed (collectively) more people than any recent Paris attack.

2 of the Paris attackers came through Greece posing as refugees.

I'm more suggesting that Islamic terrorism is a bigger problem because of the scale of the attacks and the fact they're happening in multiple countries seemingly everyday. I honestly see Paris and the other similar attacks as acts of war.
 
2 of the Paris attackers came through Greece posing as refugees.

I'm more suggesting that Islamic terrorism is a bigger problem because of the scale of the attacks and the fact they're happening in multiple countries seemingly everyday. I honestly see Paris and the other similar attacks as acts of war.


They weren't vetted. That's still illegal immigration just coming off a boat. That was not a legal refugee. That involves paperwork, background investigation, and 2 years to process.

Scale and frequency of attacks? Far more common to see mass shooters here. Oregon college, New Orleans theater, are two very recent ones. We seem to have one at least every 12 months. And if you total the last 7 big ones, they killed 130ish. Same scale as 7 in Paris.
 
They weren't vetted. That's still illegal immigration just coming off a boat. That was not a legal refugee. That involves paperwork, background investigation, and 2 years to process.

Scale and frequency of attacks? Far more common to see mass shooters here. Oregon college, New Orleans theater, are two very recent ones. We seem to have one at least every 12 months. And if you total the last 7 big ones, they killed 130ish. Same scale as 7 in Paris.
Like I said... multiple attacks in multiple countries nearly weekly in the name of Allah is a global problem and very different than what happens here with our shootings.
 
Like I said... multiple attacks in multiple countries nearly weekly in the name of Allah is a global problem and very different than what happens here with our shootings.


That's a pretty selective memory. It's also multiple attacks across multiple states here, but only the mass 'mass' shootings make it on CNN. Compare gun killings in the U.S. against innocent people and compare that to Islamist shootings. It doesn't even compare.


So what if a guy shouts dirka dirka versus a quiet guy who walks in and calmly executes our children in elementary school and colleges? Rest assured the innocent victims are just as dead.

Except here in the U.S. We do nothing because anything we do is going to be seen as a an attack on 2A. But ISIS killing others with guns, that means WWIII?

Since the Paris shootings, take a guess in terms of the U.S. How many have died with guns at the hands of others. Do you wager above or below 130?
 
Except here in the U.S. We do nothing because anything we do is going to be seen as a an attack on 2A. But ISIS killing others with guns, that means WWIII?
I'd make my point again, but I might be better off talking to the brick wall outside my house.

Because at this point ISIS has brought their attempt at ethnic cleansing and religious war to the west's doorstep, as well as taking sizeable chunks of land in the Middle East.
 
They weren't vetted. That's still illegal immigration just coming off a boat. That was not a legal refugee. That involves paperwork, background investigation, and 2 years to process.

Scale and frequency of attacks? Far more common to see mass shooters here. Oregon college, New Orleans theater, are two very recent ones. We seem to have one at least every 12 months. And if you total the last 7 big ones, they killed 130ish. Same scale as 7 in Paris.

Dude, you're out of your mind!
 
I'd make my point again, but I might be better off talking to the brick wall outside my house.

Because at this point ISIS has brought their attempt at ethnic cleansing and religious war to the west's doorstep, as well as taking sizeable chunks of land in the Middle East.

I saw a domestic attack in Paris, carried by French and Belgian citizens, with a terrorist motivation.

Ethnic cleansing and religious war is in the eye of the beholder. And seizing chunks of land in the ME? Some would say Israel does all three too. But come on, ISIS came about in what is Iraq/Syria. The Paris attack was a revenge attack by those who sympathize with ISIS. We can go overseas and meddle into others business, and then they or their sympathizers attack back. It is (was) called the Iraq War. A localized conflict in which the Iraq/Syria side is hitting western countries that hit them. Isn't that what war is?

I still don't see how some think an all out ground war will stop ISIS and somehow get all these attacks to stop once the west rules Iraq / Syria. Like it would be all peace then? All these sympathetic line wolfs brought it the world will still carry out an attack.



Dude, you're out of your f****** mind!

Not really. Insanity is defined as doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different outcome.
 
Back
Top