Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

A ground war, basically. It hasn't worked in Afghanistan. Ask Russia how it went for them. It didn't work in Iraq, at least not long term.

Problem with ground invasions are, what then? Say you kill all the ISIS you find. Now who rules Iraq? Are you willing to leave US troops permanently in Iraq/Syria? Forever? If not, then how long? And once it comes time to leave, who is in power/control of Iraq/Syria?

You also realize a country's war is only as successful as the will of its citizens back home right? Destroy that and the war is over. Like after 9/11 we were ready for anything. War? Iraq? Afghanistan? Bring it on! we said. Forward ~5 years barely? And we were sick of it. People demanded we leave.

I'm not sure why you'd think it'd be different? 9/11 killed ~3000 Americans and we were good with war on two countries for about 5-6 years before the pull-out talks started. This Paris attack killed 129 total and only a handful of US citizens and the MetroJet killed 0 US citizens. I think perhaps some people may be underestimating the public's will for us to go to war. Again.

So much with this, and not a whole bunch of time. But you keep glossing over the fact of what I'm saying. All. Out. War! Not these skirmishes we keep getting involved in. Then, if they start their crap again, we do it again. Simple. To the point. It worked in the 40's. Times have changed. But we've tried your way. Look at what it's gotten us. We can't just leave. We pretty much already tried that, and look at what that has gotten us.
 
Why are you showing me that picture? Just another thread I was told that bomber is absolutely useless and archaic and stands no chance in battle, which is why we need to order 60 new bombers worth over 70 billion dollars? You mean to tell me that archaic bomber can deliver all that payload and take out ISIS?

What's your solution? Is this gonna be you at home when things get out of control?
image.jpeg
 
So much with this, and not a whole bunch of time. But you keep glossing over the fact of what I'm saying. All. Out. War! Not these skirmishes we keep getting involved in. Then, if they start their crap again, we do it again. Simple. To the point. It worked in the 40's. Times have changed. But we've tried your way. Look at what it's gotten us. We can't just leave. We pretty much already tried that, and look at what that has gotten us.

All out war still has to have an end-state. What do you envision that to be? If you say they start again, we do another all-out war. How long do you think we'll keep doing that? The will of the people? Printing money to pay for all this? The '40s WWII is not the same thing as what ISIS is. In WWII you did not have have sympathetic to Nazi suicide bombers in the United States. WWII was pretty well defined by ideology (true) but also by distinct boundaries! There are no boundaries as far as what the ISIS ideology is today. And no, we have not tried my way. We didn't fully leave Iraq. We left some 'military advisors.' If we had followed what I'm preaching, then ISIS's advance would have had Baghdad fall because the standing army and local police forces were not willing to fight. Those who can't do this don't deserve to be a ruling party. ISIS would take over Iraq/Syria and then be land-locked by the most powerful shia nation in the world to the east, a strong NATO country to the north, Israeli defenders to the west, and a sunni Saudi to the south that wants to protect their own interests and their own royal family power. It would have solved itself in terms of balance of power for Iraq and Syria.

What's your solution? Is this gonna be you at home when things get out of control?View attachment 33487

See above paragraph. And please, ain't no fires buring in the US from ISIS. Sure, like anybody else I'm expecting some kind of lone wolf type attack here but that's always been the case.
 
If we do this, that means we in North American and Europe can boot their "refugees" back to there too.....in the spirit of letting them deal with their own country and it's civil war baggage.

Well, we the North Americans and Europeans bombed Iraq and created what it is today from the actions of 2003-2013ish. We can't just wipe our hands clean of 10 years involvement and then not expect to take some responsibility for the civilians who have been most affected. In the last 10 years we lost more Iraqi civilians in conflict (because war is never clean) than Saddam would have killed in that same timeframe. But that's a moot point, he's dead and gone. I still think those with young children, family units where you have a clear husband, wife, and young children should be allowed refugee status elsewhere/somewhere. And as I stated above, Iraq's standing army ran from ISIS even when they were outnumbering them over 10 to 1. You can't instill a will to fight in someone. You can train them, arm them, etc. But at the end of the day it's about a will to fight. If you send some of these refugees back, they will be lined up in long rows and executed by ISIS into mass graves.
 
And as I stated above, Iraq's standing army ran from ISIS even when they were outnumbering them over 10 to 1. You can't instill a will to fight in someone. You can train them, arm them, etc. But at the end of the day it's about a will to fight. If you send some of these refugees back, they will be lined up in long rows and executed by ISIS into mass graves.

THEY need to look into their own hearts and figure that one out. Dig somewhere down deep and find something called spirit, self-determination, initiative, getting off their asses and doing something for themselves and their home.

Or, they can LET themselves be lined up in long rows, and executed by ISIS on film, like weakling sheep.

THEIR choice.

But make no mistake, they do indeed HAVE a choice.
 
THEY need to look into their own hearts and figure that one out. Dig somewhere down deep and find something called spirit, self-determination, initiative, getting off their asses and doing something for themselves and their home.

Or, they can LET themselves be lined up in long rows, and executed by ISIS on film, like weakling sheep.

THEIR choice.

But make no mistake, they do indeed HAVE a choice.

They already chose. They don't want to fight. That's why there are mass graves of these people despite them outnumbering ISIS by a huge amount. And once they don't want to fight is decided, they all ran. Cities fell. Now it's protect Baghdad, and for the rest who really don't want to fight, they are getting their children out of there and heading for the boats across the Mediterranean.

But look, I'll be honest, as a 31 year old father of one and married with a wife, if I was in their shoes, I don't blame them. Because I know if I go fight, I will die, and leave my son and wife alone in the world and she'd have to raise him without a father? Is it worth me dying to save what is Iraq today? Lets be honest, Iraq in 2015 really ain't a country worth dying for. What about those with families who just want to raise a family in a safe place without any war going around them? That's the typical refugee with kids trying to get out. I mean, yeah, it's a choice, but that'd be like one saying you have a choice to get shot in the head by the gun, or you can go live in Montana for the rest of your life, and you go to Montana. I mean, sure, you "had" a choice but in the end there really was only one viable option.
 
Then they get slaughtered like sheep by ISIS
Yes, many did.

Choices have consequences. Running isn't freedom. And there's no guarantee of a place to run to.
It is freedom if you're running from a ****hole. And you are right, there's no guarantee of a place to run to which is why they are still paying smugglers to get on boats that just launch into the Medit sea without any direction, just towards Europe in terms of Greece/Italy/Sicily. Anyone who can take them in. But I will say, I've seen some pics of refugees with knives, single men by themselves fighting other men. I'd say the first priority should be only the ones who have a wife and kid(s)... a family unit. A proven family unit has a lot more to lose than angry single men 18-35 yrs of age. It's probably easier to vet a family too. I just hope that no matter which European or North American country these families end up in, assimilate and love your new nation for the shelter and safety they provided, as opposed to your hell home in which religion was used as a killing force.
 
How do you vet refugees that there are no records of? And apparently with all the selling of fake Syrian passports going on which are not "caught", makes the situation far worse. Entire identities are being created and sold as well. There is not going to be anything in any data base for these people. There are no data bases in Syria. We have no idea who anyone is. It's simply impossible to do any kind of thorough background check.

And again: FBI director, James Comey, said in a congressional testimony in October, “If someone has never made a ripple in the pond in Syria in a way that would get their identity or their interest reflected in our database, we can query our database until the cows come home, but there will be nothing to show up because we have no record of them.”

It doesn't matter if they are with a family or single.......how do we vet them? Six Arab Gulf countries, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Oman and Bahrain, aren’t accepting refugees. Is anyone putting any pressure on them to do so? Not that I've seen.

"Five Syrians trying to make their way to the United States using stolen Greek passports were arrested in Honduras, police there said Wednesday. The men were arrested after they flew into the airport in the Honduran capital of Tegucigalpa late Tuesday night and were questioned by immigration officials, according to La Prensa. They were trying to make their way to northern Honduras to complete their journey to the U.S. by land, crossing Guatemala and Mexico to reach the southwest border of the U.S.

Baca told the newspaper that Greek diplomats visited the airport and confirmed that none of the men spoke a word of Greek. "The passports were stolen (in Greece), those are not their real names, we are trying to confirm their identities," Baca told La Prensa."

They had traveled by air from Syria to Lebanon, then to Turkey, Brazil, Argentina, Costa Rica and on to Honduras. From there they were to make their way to Honduras' second city of San Pedro Sula with the aim of going overland through Guatemala, then Mexico and on to the United States, Baca told AFP.

As of today, no one yet knows what the intention of these five men are or even who they are.
 
Last edited:
How do you vet refugees that there are no records of? And apparently with all the selling of fake Syrian passports going on which are not "caught", makes the situation far worse. Entire identities are being created and sold as well. There is not going to be anything in any data base for these people. There are no data bases in Syria. We have no idea who anyone is. It's simply impossible to do any kind of thorough background check.

And again: FBI director, James Comey, said in a congressional testimony in October, “If someone has never made a ripple in the pond in Syria in a way that would get their identity or their interest reflected in our database, we can query our database until the cows come home, but there will be nothing to show up because we have no record of them.”

It doesn't matter if they are with a family or single.......how do we vet them? Six Arab Gulf countries, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Oman and Bahrain, aren’t accepting refugees. Is anyone putting any pressure on them to do so? Not that I've seen.

"Five Syrians trying to make their way to the United States using stolen Greek passports were arrested in Honduras, police there said Wednesday. The men were arrested after they flew into the airport in the Honduran capital of Tegucigalpa late Tuesday night and were questioned by immigration officials, according to La Prensa. They were trying to make their way to northern Honduras to complete their journey to the U.S. by land, crossing Guatemala and Mexico to reach the southwest border of the U.S.

Baca told the newspaper that Greek diplomats visited the airport and confirmed that none of the men spoke a word of Greek. "The passports were stolen (in Greece), those are not their real names, we are trying to confirm their identities," Baca told La Prensa."

They had traveled by air from Syria to Lebanon, then to Turkey, Brazil, Argentina, Costa Rica and on to Honduras. From there they were to make their way to Honduras' second city of San Pedro Sula with the aim of going overland through Guatemala, then Mexico and on to the United States, Baca told AFP.

As of today, no one yet knows what the intention of these five men are or even who they are.

Well, you can't. But like the illegal Mexicans here, it's a risk we take. If we really cared about stopping illegals form entering this country, we'd do something about the border. The current CBP is not enough to patrol and monitor the entire border. Europe's borders are wide open with the whole EU and Euro thing. It's still ridiculous I land in Frankfurt, get a stamp, and then went unimpeded into Zurich, Switzerland, and Paris, France without anyone at anypoint asking me for a passport. That's a little too much relaxed way to go about it. I get that's how the countries are set up as part of the union, but enough is enough. You enter a foreign country, even Germany to Switzerland or France, it's time to pass an immigration checkpoint and get an individual's passport checked.

As for the Charlie Hebdo attack and this recent Paris attack, at least one of the attackers in each case traveled to Syria AND the French national/secret service knew about it and had them on their "watch" list but then nothing really came of it. That's a systematic failure at the French national level amongst their intelligence services and national police force.

I don't want those 5 men entering the US. Instead of these 5 men, I'd rather have one husband, one wife, and their 3 kids. Who do you think would do better for us, 5 grown men with nothing to lose, or a family unit that have young kids?
 
And of course, no male ISIS members or even their sympathizers are married and have children. And if they are, they all just stay home with them instead of fighting with the rest of the ISIS members. And no ISIS member has made any woman a slave, or made them bear children for them or have killed the husbands and taken their wives and their children either. Good grief.
 
Last edited:
And of course, no male ISIS members or even their sympathizers are married and have children. And if they are, they all just stay home with them instead of fighting with the rest of the ISIS members. And no ISIS member has made any woman a slave, or made them bear children for them or have killed the husbands and taken their wives and their children either. Good grief.

This drivel? The right wing fear mongering that some Syrian refugees might be an ISIS member coming to do harm? You're far more likely to be shot dead by a white 'mentally disturbed' individual who had unlimited access to guns in this country than you are some Syrian refugee who was actually an ISIS mole. Just gotta call a spade a spade here.
 
@Cherokee_Cruiser
"There are no fires burning here from ISIS."

Wow. Are you familiar with the term "allies"? Same hold true there?

We will all pay for the Ignorance of some.

When those allies leave their borders open, no passport checking of people from other EU countries, track single men traveling to Syria and then when they get back to France, lose track of them because they are no longer interested in continuing to track them, I'd say it sounds like an intelligence failure. You can't stop all lone wolf attacks or group attacks. But come on, enough signs were there to stop at least part of the individuals involved in the Charlie Hebdo attacks and this recent attack in Paris. In both cases, one of the attackers was "already known" to French intelligent authorities.

And for allies, it depends on the situation. Saudi is an ally but if there's ever an uprising when the Saudis are fed up with the royal family and decide to all-out execute the Royal family, I would not support a US excursion/war to stop someone else's problem. Same goes for Israel. When some country says their sky fairy gave them this land over another peoples' sky fairy, I would not enter a war for them either. Let them deal with it. They are quite capable.
 
Last edited:
Finally CNN front pages an article, "Problem or Political Spin?"

http://www.cnn.com/2015/11/20/politics/paris-attack-refugee-visa-waiver/index.html

Key point: Entering the U.S. as refugees would be the hardest way for would-be terrorists

Washington (CNN)
Even before the debris from the Paris terrorist attacks was swept away, politicians began sounding the alarm that Syrian refugees could be a national security threat to the United States. The issue has dominated the U.S. political conversation during the week since gunmen and suicide bombers terrorized Paris on a Friday night.

All Republican presidential candidates called on President Barack Obama to renege on his pledge to admit 10,000 refugees fleeing Syria's brutal civil war into the U.S. and argued instead for a full stop, fearing terrorists could infiltrate their ranks.

Thirty-one governors have declared Syrian refugees unwelcome in their states and on Thursday the House passed a bill to bar refugees from Syria and Iraq from entering the U.S. Nearly 50 Democrats joined 242 Republicans to pass the bill, which the White House has threatened to veto. Sen. Ted Cruz, a Republican presidential candidate, suggested the U.S. only accept Christian refugees. Ben Carson, another candidate, likened refugees to "rabid dogs" threatening the neighborhood.

But those responses ignore one very important fact: the refugee program is quite simply the toughest way for a foreigner to legally enter the United States. There are other security gaps that would be easier for would-be terrorists to exploit.



Were any of the Paris attackers refugees?

As of now, none of the Paris attackers have been confirmed as having entered Europe as refugees. In fact, most of the Paris attackers were European citizens born in France or Belgium. Two of them appear to have entered Europe through Greece although it doesn't appear that they came in through a refugee program.





How does a refugee get into the U.S.?

Refugees must undergo an 18- to 24-month screening process, minimum, that the United Nations' refugee arm oversees. And that's before individual countries even begin to consider a refugee's application and conduct their own additional interviews and background checks.

The screening process generally includes multiple interviews, background checks and an extensive cross-referencing process that tests refugee's stories against others and accounts from sources on the ground in their home country.

Throughout that process, U.N. officials and local government officials in temporary host countries like Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon look to determine the legitimacy of asylum seekers' claims and ensure that they meet the criteria of a refugee, including that they are not and have not been involved in any fighting or terrorist activities.

Refugees also have their retinas scanned and have their fingerprints lifted.

Christopher Boian, a spokesman for the United Nations High Commission for Refugees, called the process "stringent" and "long and complex."

"If at any stage in that process there is ever the slightest shadow of a doubt or the slightest whisper of suspicion, they are removed from the process. That is that," Boian said.

"The very, very few Syrian refugees who are accepted and referred for consideration for resettlement in another country -- there simply is no more closely scrutinized population on earth these days," he added.

That's because other countries have so far pledged to resettle just 159,000 of the more than 4 million Syrian refugees -- setting an extremely high bar for resettlement.

And refugees aren't automatically considered for resettlement: only the most vulnerable refugees -- such as torture victims, female heads of household, people with serious medical conditions and other especially vulnerable groups.

So after they go through that process by the U.N., the U.S. does an additional screening?

That's right. After a rigorous screening process and several interviews carried out by the U.N. refugee agency, refugees the U.S. agrees to consider for resettlement have to undergo an additional interview, medical evaluation and security screening.
 
Back
Top