Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

Hard to say as I haven't seen any BDA coming from it in terms of effectiveness. May be very effective, I don't know yet.

What it does show is their level of committment and seriousness. They're not screwing around with ROE that ties their hand behind their backs, that's for sure. Doing this on a military target is probably pretty effective in opening up a target, then flushing out the trash.

The U.S. bombing campaign against ISIS has been window dressing theatre from day one. Hence why the other day, some fuel trucks and fuel depots being hit was big news, why the heck have those survived up until now? And why duid we drop warning leaflets into the area before hitting them, allowing ISIS and whoever is helping them, to melt away? Because we're not serious, that's why. And all we're doing is risking the lives of our aircrews in the process. Only a matter of time before one or more become ISIS POWs.

Putin's objectives are three-fold: reestablish Russia as a front table player, push the USA away from same table, and keep Syria going. The Russians are going after anything that threatens the Assad regime, ISIS as well as anyone else. And Russia is now in the lead of doing that.

Brought to you by the same countrymen that shot down MH17 and the rest of the world did nothing.............. because they can do nothing.

224 dead on a terrorist bomb down of a jet..... all out war in Syria.

298 dead (mostly European/Dutch) on a jet shot by a Russian BUK missile............... finger shaking followed by an international tribunal request - which of course vetoed by Russia.
 
Our civilians were not warned about their attacks. Why should we warn theirs? Isn't that the danger of living there... Or here?

Quite a big difference between a terrorist cell that attacks a foreign land, especially when part of that foreign cell is also a resident of said country. A whole different matter when you have a military of a sovereign nation about to bomb another sovereign nation. Or are you subscribing to the Duke Nukem motto, "Let God sort 'em out!"
 
Quite a big difference between a terrorist cell that attacks a foreign land, especially when part of that foreign cell is also a resident of said country. A whole different matter when you have a military of a sovereign nation about to bomb another sovereign nation. Or are you subscribing to the Duke Nukem motto, "Let God sort 'em out!"

News flash:

CURRENT STRATEGY ISN'T WORKING. Dropping leaflets lets them know we're coming. If someone was after you, and going to kill you, when you found out, would you just sit there and wait for it? No, you'd run for the hills. War is ugly. Innocents die. The sooner you wake up to that, the less innocent people will be caught in the crossfire. Or, we can continue along this path we're on now, and still have innocent people ending up dead from their hands. Either way, people will die. One way, it perpetuates itself, the other actually brings it to an end.
 
Quite a big difference between a terrorist cell that attacks a foreign land, especially when part of that foreign cell is also a resident of said country. A whole different matter when you have a military of a sovereign nation about to bomb another sovereign nation. Or are you subscribing to the Duke Nukem motto, "Let God sort 'em out!"

What's your take on the Japanese Instrument of Surrender?
 
News flash:

CURRENT STRATEGY ISN'T WORKING. Dropping leaflets lets them know we're coming. If someone was after you, and going to kill you, when you found out, would you just sit there and wait for it? No, you'd run for the hills. War is ugly. Innocents die. The sooner you wake up to that, the less innocent people will be caught in the crossfire. Or, we can continue along this path we're on now, and still have innocent people ending up dead from their hands. Either way, people will die. One way, it perpetuates itself, the other actually brings it to an end.

It's their civil war. Leave. Let them deal with it. We get pharked with when we decide to meddle into other people's business. Come on. 298 people are blown out of the sky by a Russian Buk missile and no one raises a finger against Russia or their aggression at the Ukraine border. 224 Russians are blown out of the sky and it's an all out war in Syria.

What's your take on the Japanese Instrument of Surrender?

An unfortunate atomic bombing x2. The other alternative would be an all-out ground war which would have killed more soldiers and civvies on both sides. Still, I don't feel good dropping bombs and killing mostly civvies but for the Japanese at the time, it was the only thing they'd understand and the quickest way to end the war. This ISIS war isn't the same thing. You could nuke/flatten out Iraq/Syria but you'll still leave many angry people who will still want to hurt you for what you did to Iraq/Syria by leveling it out. Also, the sheer hypocrisy of the world having one reaction when Russia blows out an airliner (basically, nothing) and then the reaction when a Russian airliner is blown out.
 
It's their civil war. Leave. Let them deal with it. We get pharked with when we decide to meddle into other people's business. Come on. 298 people are blown out of the sky by a Russian Buk missile and no one raises a finger against Russia or their aggression at the Ukraine border. 224 Russians are blown out of the sky and it's an all out war in Syria.



An unfortunate atomic bombing x2. The other alternative would be an all-out ground war which would have killed more soldiers and civvies on both sides. Still, I don't feel good dropping bombs and killing mostly civvies but for the Japanese at the time, it was the only thing they'd understand and the quickest way to end the war. This ISIS war isn't the same thing. You could nuke/flatten out Iraq/Syria but you'll still leave many angry people who will still want to hurt you for what you did to Iraq/Syria by leveling it out. Also, the sheer hypocrisy of the world having one reaction when Russia blows out an airliner (basically, nothing) and then the reaction when a Russian airliner is blown out.

We can't leave now. Don't you get that? If we just pull up stakes and bounce, they'll keep gaining ground, we'll keep getting bit, and ISIS will become a very serious force that creates pandemonium.

The time to pull out has long since passed. We needed to leave it alone after GW1.
 
It's their civil war. Leave. Let them deal with it. We get pharked with when we decide to meddle into other people's business. Come on. 298 people are blown out of the sky by a Russian Buk missile and no one raises a finger against Russia or their aggression at the Ukraine border. 224 Russians are blown out of the sky and it's an all out war in Syria.



An unfortunate atomic bombing x2. The other alternative would be an all-out ground war which would have killed more soldiers and civvies on both sides. Still, I don't feel good dropping bombs and killing mostly civvies but for the Japanese at the time, it was the only thing they'd understand and the quickest way to end the war. This ISIS war isn't the same thing. You could nuke/flatten out Iraq/Syria but you'll still leave many angry people who will still want to hurt you for what you did to Iraq/Syria by leveling it out. Also, the sheer hypocrisy of the world having one reaction when Russia blows out an airliner (basically, nothing) and then the reaction when a Russian airliner is blown out.

My take is that it worked. Tokyo was next on the list. I love the Japanese and Japan. At the time they were our enemy. Things and times change. If the children of ISIS fighters want to come here and live the American Dream or turn their world into what Japan is today more power to them. After we finish what ISIS/terrorists started.
 
We can't leave now. Don't you get that? If we just pull up stakes and bounce, they'll keep gaining ground, we'll keep getting bit, and ISIS will become a very serious force that creates pandemonium.

The time to pull out has long since passed. We needed to leave it alone after GW1.

Well, most have admit there's no military solution............... so now what?
 
Well, most have admit there's no military solution............... so now what?

There is a military solution. But it's called war. Like actual declared style war. Not this bull crap "Team America, World Police" crap we do now, where we continually poke each other in the eye.

In war, you don't drop leaflets. You don't play nice. You win, at all costs, screw what the rest of the world thinks about it.
 
There is a military solution. But it's called war. Like actual declared style war. Not this bull crap "Team America, World Police" crap we do now, where we continually poke each other in the eye.

In war, you don't drop leaflets. You don't play nice. You win, at all costs, screw what the rest of the world thinks about it.

To be clear, you're saying send in the cavalry, boots on the ground, and go into a real war, with US soldiers men and women on the ground in both Iraq and Syria.......... correct?
 
To be clear, you're saying send in the cavalry, boots on the ground, and go into a real war, with US soldiers men and women on the ground in both Iraq and Syria.......... correct?

Not sure I could be more clear than I already was.

Yes, it will come at a massive cost. Yes, people will die. And yes, if my country asked me to go, I'd go. But just keeping them at bay hasn't worked, and isn't going to work. Screw the ROE. Screw the Geneva convention. There hasn't been a clear resolution to a real war since its inception.

Go in. Kick ass. And don't stop till it's finished. We are next. And they have the money and support to make it bigger than it was in Paris here.

I thought a month ago when people were calling this the kickoff to WWIII, they were crazy. I'm not so sure now.
 
AAPalmTree said:
My take is that it worked. Tokyo was next on the list. I love the Japanese and Japan. At the time they were our enemy. Things and times change. If the children of ISIS fighters want to come here and live the American Dream or turn their world into what Japan is today more power to them. After we finish what ISIS/terrorists started.
Did we have a third bomb built or that was the bluff saying it was the next target?
 
Not sure I could be more clear than I already was.

Yes, it will come at a massive cost. Yes, people will die. And yes, if my country asked me to go, I'd go. But just keeping them at bay hasn't worked, and isn't going to work. Screw the ROE. Screw the Geneva convention. There hasn't been a clear resolution to a real war since its inception.

Go in. Kick ass. And don't stop till it's finished. We are next. And they have the money and support to make it bigger than it was in Paris here.

I thought a month ago when people were calling this the kickoff to WWIII, they were crazy. I'm not so sure now.

A ground war, basically. It hasn't worked in Afghanistan. Ask Russia how it went for them. It didn't work in Iraq, at least not long term.

Problem with ground invasions are, what then? Say you kill all the ISIS you find. Now who rules Iraq? Are you willing to leave US troops permanently in Iraq/Syria? Forever? If not, then how long? And once it comes time to leave, who is in power/control of Iraq/Syria?

You also realize a country's war is only as successful as the will of its citizens back home right? Destroy that and the war is over. Like after 9/11 we were ready for anything. War? Iraq? Afghanistan? Bring it on! we said. Forward ~5 years barely? And we were sick of it. People demanded we leave.

I'm not sure why you'd think it'd be different? 9/11 killed ~3000 Americans and we were good with war on two countries for about 5-6 years before the pull-out talks started. This Paris attack killed 129 total and only a handful of US citizens and the MetroJet killed 0 US citizens. I think perhaps some people may be underestimating the public's will for us to go to war. Again.
 
A ground war, basically. It hasn't worked in Afghanistan. Ask Russia how it went for them. It didn't work in Iraq, at least not long term.

Problem with ground invasions are, what then? Say you kill all the ISIS you find. Now who rules Iraq? Are you willing to leave US troops permanently in Iraq/Syria? Forever? If not, then how long? And once it comes time to leave, who is in power/control of Iraq/Syria?

You also realize a country's war is only as successful as the will of its citizens back home right? Destroy that and the war is over. Like after 9/11 we were ready for anything. War? Iraq? Afghanistan? Bring it on! we said. Forward ~5 years barely? And we were sick of it. People demanded we leave.

I'm not sure why you'd think it'd be different? 9/11 killed ~3000 Americans and we were good with war on two countries for about 5-6 years before the pull-out talks started. This Paris attack killed 129 total and only a handful of US citizens and the MetroJet killed 0 US citizens. I think perhaps some people may be underestimating the public's will for us to go to war. Again.

You're right. A ground war is not the right thing.
image.jpeg
 
AAPalmTree said:
From what I understand we had all the components ready to go. Oppenheimer actually stopped the delivery of the 3rd core until getting directives from Truman himself.
I don't remember anything mentioned on it at the atomic museum in Vegas, but it's been some years since I've been to it.
 
I don't remember anything mentioned on it at the atomic museum in Vegas, but it's been some years since I've been to it.

I think you're correct in thinking that the bomb wasn't ready to be loaded on a bomber. I understand it would have taken time to put the components together.
 
So.............. carpet bomb all of Iraq and Syria is your solution?


Ok. Now the dust has settled. People still pop up in what is Iraq/Syria. Now they are going to form a government form/ruling party. What's to stop another fanatic group coming into power?

Or, more importantly, while you are busy carpet bombing them, what about all the lone wolf sympathizers who then come out and go suicide bombing in large western cities, and probably increasing in numbers the more indiscriminate the killings get in Iraq/Syria?
 
Back
Top