Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

I'll raise my hand and say I'd like airline security to presume it was an explosive device and move toward a more realistic passenger and luggage screening technique. I'd rather foreign policy stay on low boil until the investigation is complete. I'd like whoever made "Richard Quest" an aviation expert to be sent to a desert isle without cellphone coverage alongside "Wilson".

Oh yeah, I forgot… Everyone's all aflutter about the So Cal UFO conspiracy.

I'll second that. Especially the part about everything.
 
I'll raise my hand and say I'd like airline security to presume it was an explosive device and move toward a more realistic passenger and luggage screening technique. I'd rather foreign policy stay on low boil until the investigation is complete. I'd like whoever made "Richard Quest" an aviation expert to be sent to a desert isle without cellphone coverage alongside "Wilson".
It is unfortunate that a 95% FAILURE rate under simulated threat circumstances on the part of the TSA isn't enough of a threat to get the government to wake up, but the mere suggestion that a bomb brought down a single airliner 6000-some miles away, not originating from the US and not killing any Americans gets politicians to start asking questions.
 
Last edited:
Phoenix lights
#PhoenixLights
#Aliens

Ok... good. That should be enough to bring the crazies to your living room again.

You're welcome.

Pekingduck.jpg
 
Do you maybe mean "personally, I think that most Americans..."?

Yes. I meant that exactly.


{Quote/}What do you find in Diamond's work to be inconsistent with the notion that European societies became more complex more quickly than, say, African ones? To the best of my recollection, he rather explicitly agrees with that.

I don't disagree with some of Diamond's conclusion. My disagreement with is that he attributes the evolution of societies mainly to advantages based on what was available to the cultures locally (i.e, I have water and soil therefore I can farm, make money, raise an army vs I have no water therefore I can't farm and I must be nomadic and can't be a good warrior).

What I've experienced is that the cultural differences are biased by whether the culture can separate church and state. That's not to say that the separation of church and state results in a western culture; instead, I believe that culture that were able to successfully govern independent of a religious basis for legitimacy are more apt to evolve to better serve all the people in the culture. Now, homogenous cultures are somewhat the exception, but as they expand to include minority cultures with differing religious beliefs, I've found those that tend to set the religious differences to the side (separate church from state) are more adept at evolving than those that don't.


A lot of commentators and self proclaimed experts like to attribute Colonial border lines to Middle East violence, which is shortsighted and mostly wrong. People always like to overstate how arbitrary Middle Eastern borders are and they completely overlook every other "arbitrary" border in the world. It isn't that there weren't borders, rather the borders have just shifted over time. Interestingly enough the only country that didn't really have any type of ancient borders was Jordan, which has been one of the least violent places in the region. If only there could have been an international commission to craft a magical line between Sunni and Shi'ite with oil right in the middle, there would be peace right now. :rolleyes:

Generally speaking, 'arbitrary' borders based on historical, geographic, or cultural barriers tend to be more resilient than any other type of border.
 
If only spineless weak Obama would get more involved in the Middle East! Look at how Putin is flexing his big strong muscles! Whatever... Mr Putin meet the wonderful never ending Middle Eastern mess.. Enjoy!
 
If only spineless weak Obama would get more involved in the Middle East! Look at how Putin is flexing his big strong muscles! Whatever... Mr Putin meet the wonderful never ending Middle Eastern mess.. Enjoy!
I think he may take what they learned from their Afghanistan war and apply it to Syria.
 
"We'll fix [Middle Eastern conflict] with what we learned from [historical Middle Eastern conflict]!" is a plan that never fails to go swimmingly. :sarcasm: :biggrin:
 
Good one!

Lessons from Afghanistan: Don't fight a proxy war with the US.

Ooh! We do have a refugee from that war that posts here too.
Yeah I guess that is what he is essentially doing fighting a US supported rebel group again.
 
The most powerful Sunni country in the ME is Saudi Arabia and the most powerful Shia country is Iran. Before the 2003 Iraq War, the Sunnis ran Iraq. We took a Sunni-run Iraq and left it as a Shia-run Iraq. Once we withdrew the inevitable power struggle ensued and the 'civil war' erupted to bring balance back to the Sunni side. That's ISIS now. We cannot win this war. It is a civil war and it will have to be played out itself naturally. Saudi backs the Sunnis and Iran backs the Shias. It's a proxy war between Iran and Saudi.

I see why we are involved. We started the 2003 Iraq War and are responsible for the ensuing mess. But I was extremely surprised to see Russia get involved and start bombings in Syria. What do they really have to protect? It was an attempted slap in the face to the United States, a proxy war between the US and Russia, and it backfired badly with the terrorist retaliation strike against Russia. Obviously they can't attack Russia in conventional ways so a soft target is what they chose and now 224 passengers/crew are dead. Frankly, if I was a Russian citizen, I'd be pissed my government decided to bomb and get involved in a power struggle that we (Russians) have no business to be in. This crash should be a wake up call for the Russians.
 
The most powerful Sunni country in the ME is Saudi Arabia and the most powerful Shia country is Iran. Before the 2003 Iraq War, the Sunnis ran Iraq. We took a Sunni-run Iraq and left it as a Shia-run Iraq. Once we withdrew the inevitable power struggle ensued and the 'civil war' erupted to bring balance back to the Sunni side. That's ISIS now. We cannot win this war. It is a civil war and it will have to be played out itself naturally. Saudi backs the Sunnis and Iran backs the Shias. It's a proxy war between Iran and Saudi.

I see why we are involved. We started the 2003 Iraq War and are responsible for the ensuing mess. But I was extremely surprised to see Russia get involved and start bombings in Syria. What do they really have to protect? It was an attempted slap in the face to the United States, a proxy war between the US and Russia, and it backfired badly with the terrorist retaliation strike against Russia. Obviously they can't attack Russia in conventional ways so a soft target is what they chose and now 224 passengers/crew are dead. Frankly, if I was a Russian citizen, I'd be pissed my government decided to bomb and get involved in a power struggle that we (Russians) have no business to be in. This crash should be a wake up call for the Russians.

Russia gets a warm water port if they keep Assad in power, who I believe should stay in power, compared to the alternatives. Lets look at the alternatives: The former FSA, or Free Syrian Army....the "rebels" to Assad. Who are they now? They don't exist as-such, they've merely become mostly the current Al Nusra front, otherwise known as Al Queda Syria, which is a mish-mash of all groups who oppose Assad, except for the Kurds (who they don't like), and ISIS (who they're afraid of). And.......Al Nusra is backed by......you guessed it.....Saudi Arabia. No wonder we aren't attacking Al Nusra, even though they are Al Queda, who supposedly were the bad bad guys in Afghanistan and Iraq. And this is who we are supporting over there with arms/supplies/training? Are we as a nation REALLY that stupid?

These, along with ISIS, are who the Russians have been hitting, as they simply don't give a rats ass about whether these groups are supported by Saudi Arabia or other Gulf nation two-faced bastards. Essentially all who are trying to topple the Assad government, are legit targets for the Russians. Russia knows Assad is a bastard, but he's the best bastard there is of all the bastards that are available there, and they know that. In that vein, Russia is attacking and killing all, with no BS, no Rules of Engagement that don't benefit them, and no Law of Armed Conflict to hamstring them.......all things that we tie ourselves down with when it comes to our own US military, and which just serves to get our own guys dead, as we successfully screwed up in 15 years of fighting in Afghan and Iraq.

Russia is not attacking the Kurds because they have no beef with them one way or another, however Russian strikes against ISIS in areas where ISIS is opposing Assad forces, has a secondary benefit to Kurd forces in that it's "indirect air interdiction" of ISIS forces that helps them. Russia also isn't messing with Turkish forces who come out and attack the Kurd forces, which are the same Kurd forces that we are supporting and trying to protect with US warplanes. How messed up is that.......the Turkish warplanes attacking the Kurds, are likely parked right next to US warplanes at the Turkish bases, who are trying to protect Kurd forces.

Russias first priority is hitting forces which are closest to Assad held areas of Syria, which are the Al Nusra (so-called moderate by us) Al Queda forces. ISIS is located further east and closer to Iraq. Russia will get around to them as a secondary priority, but will also hit them as they come across them.

At least Russia has a strategy. The US is just dilly dallying over there with no strategy whatsoever, making ineffective piecemeal airstrikes here and there, and essentially wasting taxpayer $$$ while putting our own troops' lives at risk, for who knows what end-game right now. Other than "Assad bad!".

Russia, is sending us to school right now.
 
Last edited:
Russia gets a warm water port if they keep Assad in power, who I believe should stay in power, compared to the alternatives. Lets look at the alternatives: The former FSA, or Free Syrian Army....the "rebels" to Assad. Who are they now? They don't exist as-such, they've merely become mostly the current Al Nusra front, otherwise known as Al Queda Syria, which is a mish-mash of all groups who oppose Assad, except for the Kurds (who they don't like), and ISIS (who they're afraid of). And.......Al Nusra is backed by......you guessed it.....Saudi Arabia. No wonder we aren't attacking Al Nusra, even though they are Al Queda, who supposedly were the bad bad guys in Afghanistan and Iraq. And this is who we are supporting over there with arms/supplies/training? Are we as a nation REALLY that stupid?

These, along with ISIS, are who the Russians have been hitting, as they simply don't give a rats ass about whether these groups are supported by Saudi Arabia or other Gulf nation two-faced bastards. Essentially all who are trying to topple the Assad government, are legit targets for the Russians. Russia knows Assad is a bastard, but he's the best bastard there is of all the bastards that are available there, and they know that. In that vein, Russia is attacking and killing all, with no BS, no Rules of Engagement that don't benefit them, and no Law of Armed Conflict to hamstring them.......all things that we tie ourselves down with when it comes to our own US military, and which just serves to get our own guys dead, as we successfully screwed up in 15 years of fighting in Afghan and Iraq.

Russia is not attacking the Kurds because they have no beef with them one way or another, however Russian strikes against ISIS in areas where ISIS is opposing Assad forces, has a secondary benefit to Kurd forces in that it's "indirect interdiction" of ISIS forces that helps them. Russia also isn't messing with Turkish forces who come out and attack the Kurd forces, which are the same Kurd forces that we are supporting and trying to protect with US warplanes. How messed up is that.......the Turkish forces attacking the Kurds, are likely parked right next to US warplanes at the Turkish bases, who are trying to protect Kurd forces.

Russias first priority is hitting forces which are closest to Assad held areas of Syria, which are the Al Nusra (so-called moderate by us) Al Queda forces. ISIS is located further east and closer to Iraq. Russia will get around to them as a secondary priority, but will also hit them as they come across them.

At least Russia has a strategy. The US is just dilly dallying over there with no strategy whatsoever, making ineffective piecemeal airstrikes here and there, and essentially wasting taxpayer $$$ while putting our own troops' lives at risk, for who knows what end-game right now. Other than "Assad bad!".

Russia, is sending us to school right now.

That's too much risk for one warm water port. There are others to be had. And Russia has proven with Crimea and Ukraine that they are a "take, take" country and the rest of the world can't do much except verbal admonishment.

The US has no strategy because there is no strategy. There is no solution to this, except leave them be and let the war settle. It's going to be bloody, but it's bloody today anyway. You can't control the ground situation with air strikes only. Boots on the ground would be necessary. I really, really hope we aren't going down that route again. The balance will most likely go back towards the Sunnis for Iraq.
 
That's too much risk for one warm water port. There are others to be had. And Russia has proven with Crimea and Ukraine that they are a "take, take" country and the rest of the world can't do much except verbal admonishment.

The US has no strategy because there is no strategy. There is no solution to this, except leave them be and let the war settle. It's going to be bloody, but it's bloody today anyway. You can't control the ground situation with air strikes only. Boots on the ground would be necessary. I really, really hope we aren't going down that route again. The balance will most likely go back towards the Sunnis for Iraq.

True, it's alot to pay for a port, but the port isn't the only deal, it's also maintaining a strategic foothold location in the middle east, which they don't want to lose.

And, boots on the ground has occurred, in the form of a few hundred US special forces "advisors". Which is exactly how Vietnam started.

So far as Russia is concerned, they're going to do what they feel they need to do to protect that foothold. They're not going to get into a protracted bogged down situation, but they will help Assad's forces with the support they need to get their butts in gear and retake the country.

If the intel coming out on the Russian A321 is true, ISIS may be moving much farther up the priority list of forces to wipe off the face of Syrian soil......and maybe even Iraq soil. And I hope they do.
 
Last edited:
True, it's alot to pay for a port, but the port isn't the only deal, it's also maintaining a strategic foothold location in the middle east, which they don't want to lose.

And, boots on the ground has occurred, in the form of a few hundred US special forces "advisors". Which is exactly how Vietnam started.

So fa as Russia is concerned, they're going to do what they feel they need to do to protect that foothold. They're not going to get into a protracted bogged down situation, but they will help Assad's forces with the support they need to get their butts in gear and retake the country.

If the intel coming out on the Russian A321 is true, ISIS may be moving much farther up the priority list of forces to wipe off the face of Syrian soil......and maybe even Iraq soil. And I hope they do.

You can't beat 'em. If it's a bomb as suspected, and loaded at the airport by an Egyptian airport worker, that shows you that it wasn't an ISIS person per say. It was a sympathizer type person, but not an Iraqi nor Syrian. If ISIS can reach people like this, no amounts of bombing or ground boots can defeat ISIS.

I gotta say, as bad as WWII was at least you had known enemies, with known boundaries, with known territory. ISIS is a physical force, sure, but it's also an ideology. You can't bomb or kill an ideology off.
 
Back
Top