Act Of Valor

A Life Aloft

Well-Known Member
I thought I would take a plunge and make a post over here to see if any of you have seen this movie yet. I thought it might be of more interest on this forum also. I also didn't want to post it in the lav and have it turn into some political who knows what cat fight or have it turn into a hot mess for other reasons as often happens there. So hopefully, the Mods will let it ride here.

If you haven't seen this film, go see it. You will enjoy it, I promise. It is a great film.

This is not your typical Hollywood b.s. film at all. As some of you may of heard, the film was going to be a documentary sort of recruitment film (the original idea) but it was decided to make an action film but starring real Navy SEALs and not actors. Well, this is what makes the film. It is wonderful. I like action adventure films and especially anything that involves something "military". The problem is that most of them are unrealistic and have lots of issues, so I tend to prefer documentaries. This film though is different. Very different. It amazed me on several levels.

First off, as much I watch the Military channel and watch documentaries on the History channel and others about the military, or read books, nothing prepared me for exactly what Navy SEALs do in this kind of detail, are capable of doing and how they do it. This really just astounded me. I had already seen documentaries about the SEALs and read books on them, but it's not the same as seeing them in action. Not actors, not ridiculous Mission Impossible or James Bond stunts, but the real deal. Just incredibly impressive.

Sure, the "acting" of the SEALs is not polished or "professional". But who cares? What they do, how they perform, how they train, what they are able to accomplish and how and even how they move and carry their weapons and interact is. And THAT is what makes this film so special. The technical aspects of all the weaponry is just amazing to someone like me, because again, it is real. Plus, it shows what the SEALs accomplish on land, in the air and at sea.

The commitment of our military to our country, to their duty and to honor and their courage is something that someone like me can only admire from afar and be eternally grateful for.

Anyways, that is just my review and my suggestion for a terrific film that I encourage anyone to go and see. Hope you get the opportunity to do so.

As one reviewer said:

"Toward the end of the movie, there's a scene that will stay with you: two of the SEALs discuss their latest mission. They turn and walk away from the camera. It's not just a walk... stage direction... exit walking away. It may have been scripted like that but it becomes something else.

As they walk they become larger than life. Professional, authoritative, a certain jauntiness. It's a walk that can only be walked knowing that you're the best in the world at what you do. A je ne sais quoi earned on battlefields around the world, in extreme conditions, a walk of confidence and utter competence.

You haven't seen that walk before in a movie. It's worth the price of admission."

I totally agree. And thank you all for your service, past and present.
 
The trailers made me think it is a sub par movie riding on the backs of the Seal's reputation. Your review makes me now want to see it.
 
Very interesting sounding. Ill have to check it out.
You really should. I am so grateful that someone took the time to make a film like this that is so real and honors our military in a more respectful way than is normally seen in Hollywood. It's a pretty good story too and plenty of action. I cannot imagine that any service member of any branch, past or present, would not like it. When it comes out on DVD in July, I am going to get it.

The reality of the SEALs in the film and just their entire persona and how they execute their missions is far better, more interesting, more exciting and more impressive than anything that Hollywood could ever dream up.
 
Saw it, loved it. Except for the retired Senior Chief, the SEAL acting wasn't great but it didn't take away from the movie.
 
I got to work with a few of the Army side of SOF and it is not really that much fun or glory to it. SOF guys endure much crap before they experience the "moment of truth"
--AA
hughes pic.jpg
 
I assume by know most of you have seen the movie. but if you have don't read below.



I just saw the movie today and thought it was very well done despite the critiques by the liberal media. The ending I didn't care for but that is the reality of the world we live and was hard for me to watch. Of course Military or polie funerals are always hard for me to watch along with how many special ops men and women have died trying to keep this country safe.

What I couldn't believe is people were leaving 1/2 way through it and during the funeral scene heard one jack ass giggle during the funeral scene.

Some people have no clue, respect or class.

*ok done venting*
 
Acting and dialogue were exactly as I figured it be....kinda cheesy. When they kept their mouths shut it was pretty badass. It was even more badass to think that thats exactly what they do for a living and many parts of the movies was live fire. What really got me was the list and the end of the movie. It just kept going and going.

If I had to do it all over again I woulda joined swimming at a younger age and give a shot at being a SEAL. A buddy if mine dropped out after of the program a few months in. He said it dawned on him that his life would be entirely about killing and he wasnt sure how he could live with that. My guess he flunked something and needed an excuse.
 
I for one loved it...granted, the acting by the SEALs (except for the retired Senior) wasn't exactly good, it was well done and showed what SEALs do best :)
 
What exactly were the critiques by the "liberal media"?

From Rolling stone...
Nothing wrong with a tribute to real-life Navy SEALs, the heroes who took down Osama bin Laden. But Act of Valor is an awkward something else. Filmmakers Mike McCoy and Scott Waugh have enlisted real SEALs to play themselves in a movie that's impure Hollywood fiction. The action, involving Chechen rebels, Mexican drug cartels and assorted terrortists, is staged. And it's hardly the fault of these commandos that their acting deserves no salute. In truth, they're a lot better than Charlie Sheen was in the 1990 crapfest that was Navy SEALs. I don't know what to make of Act of Valor. It's like reviewing a recruiting poster

From CNN
Review: 'Act of Valor' is an action movie with a gimmick
 
From Rolling stone...
Nothing wrong with a tribute to real-life Navy SEALs, the heroes who took down Osama bin Laden. But Act of Valor is an awkward something else. Filmmakers Mike McCoy and Scott Waugh have enlisted real SEALs to play themselves in a movie that's impure Hollywood fiction. The action, involving Chechen rebels, Mexican drug cartels and assorted terrortists, is staged. And it's hardly the fault of these commandos that their acting deserves no salute. In truth, they're a lot better than Charlie Sheen was in the 1990 crapfest that was Navy SEALs. I don't know what to make of Act of Valor. It's like reviewing a recruiting poster

From CNN
Review: 'Act of Valor' is an action movie with a gimmick

I think it's a bit of a stretch to say that a) movie reviewers have a political bias they incorporate into their reviews, and; b) these reviews have do to with anything other than the author's critique of the film.

I'd be more convinced had they said something like "another film demonstrating the wrath of the American industrial military complex" ..., etc. etc.
 
At least Top Gun was a recruiting movie that gave a nod to the latent homosexuality rampant in the Navy.

Zing!

Seriously though, all the military guys I know who saw it said the movie was great for action and good for little else. And the ones I'm thinking of are Rush Republicans, god help them.
 
I don't really see any kind of political bias in that Rolling Stone review -- they thought the acting sucked and the story was cheese, all the while acknowledging the fact that the actual SEALs' job is anything but acting and thus not really their fault.

If anything, their critique of 'impure Hollywood fiction' is something I'd expect from a right point of view.
 
Back
Top