AAG transferring 15 ERJs to XJT

Didn't Parker complain that they had too many regionals flying for them? They just
Added three this year alone.

Republic
Skywest
Xjt
Asa
Psa
Pdt
Awac
Envoy
Compass
Tsa
Mesa

Am I forgetting someone?
 
This is the point I was trying to make in another thread. You have the regional shuffle because the ALPA bargaining strategy creates economic incentive to shift flying from on company to another.

Ok....if that's the case wouldn't ALL the flying be shuffled to the lowest paying contract? Then ,can you explain which pilot contract is more lucrative, the XJT or Envoy one?
 
Last edited:
Ok....if that's the case wouldn't ALL the flying be shuffled to the lowest paying contract? Then ,can you explain which pilot contract is more lucrative, the XJT or Envoy one?

No, because the economic incentive does not come having a carrier with the lowest contract costs. It comes from the having the lowest marginal costs. Shifting 50 airplanes to say, Piedmont, creates 500 new pilot positions at the bottom of the Piedmont pay scale. At the same time, it eliminates 500 higher pay jobs at Envoy, at least half of which are on the Captain payscale, and the rest at various points on the First Officer scale. And that's just the pilots. Consider also the transfer of mechanic, ground agent, flight attendant, etc, jobs.

This is the point I was trying to make in the other thread. As long as you have graduated pay scales that pay 150% more at the top than they do at the bottom, there is going to be an incentive to shuffle flying. Every transferred airplane takes 10 pilot positions and puts them at the bottom of the pay scale. Eliminate the pay scale, and you eliminate the economic advantage of transferring airplanes.
 
No, because the economic incentive does not come having a carrier with the lowest contract costs. It comes from the having the lowest marginal costs. Shifting 50 airplanes to say, Piedmont, creates 500 new pilot positions at the bottom of the Piedmont pay scale. At the same time, it eliminates 500 higher pay jobs at Envoy, at least half of which are on the Captain payscale, and the rest at various points on the First Officer scale. And that's just the pilots. Consider also the transfer of mechanic, ground agent, flight attendant, etc, jobs.

This is the point I was trying to make in the other thread. As long as you have graduated pay scales that pay 150% more at the top than they do at the bottom, there is going to be an incentive to shuffle flying. Every transferred airplane takes 10 pilot positions and puts them at the bottom of the pay scale. Eliminate the pay scale, and you eliminate the economic advantage of transferring airplanes.

Then if it is the 'lowest marginal costs' why was the XJT MEC saying that even with the loss of 36 aircraft a few weeks ago from a staffing stand point they were going to be 'ok' and not furlough? Hence you wouldn't have those guys/gals chasing the metal to a new company to get lower 'marginal costs'.
 
Attrition? Already understaffed? Who knows. You'd have to ask them. But staffing decisions are tactical in nature, while the decision to outsource work is strategic (i.e. short term vs. long term).
 
Not really. You have a bunch of flying getting shifted away from high longevity/high cost pilot groups to places where the longevity is less. Doesn't have much to do with a national level strategy at all
Ethan stop that right now! That doesn't fit into CC's narrative.
 
He's throwing airplanes at the wall and seeing what is sticking.

No doubt he wanted a couple to take them all. I would bet whomever can staff the best will get the rest.

One thing to keep in mind. The airplanes haven't even been transferred yet. The announcements have been made but few if any planes have even left the property.

He's banking on the majority of Eagle guys bailing and staffing the new ones it seems.
 
Not really. You have a bunch of flying getting shifted away from high longevity/high cost pilot groups to places where the longevity is less. Doesn't have much to do with a national level strategy at all
I agree with him, and I think you do too by your statement.

If all pilot groups were paid say $50/hr as an FO and $70/hr as a CA with minimal if any longevity raise, similar vacation, etc. this wouldn't have begun in the first place.

Doug is just making a statement here, like DAL did with Comair.
 
Then if it is the 'lowest marginal costs' why was the XJT MEC saying that even with the loss of 36 aircraft a few weeks ago from a staffing stand point they were going to be 'ok' and not furlough? Hence you wouldn't have those guys/gals chasing the metal to a new company to get lower 'marginal costs'.
Because this isn't about costs at this point. It started off like that with all the new hires at PSA, PDT, TSA, etc. but Doug needs to find a place for the remaining aircraft.

Eagle is FUBAR'd.
 
Not really. You have a bunch of flying getting shifted away from high longevity/high cost pilot groups to places where the longevity is less. Doesn't have much to do with a national level strategy at all

And what made high longevity/high cost pilot groups possible? Especially when it comes to Eagle, that 25 yr contract with 5 items negotiable every 4 years led to many 18 yr CAs. XJT had one of the best pilot contracts as well and look where they are now. It is obvious that in the past several years, the shift has definitely happened that the pilot groups signing higher cost pilot contracts end up losing planes and those with cheap labor cost contracts end up gaining planes.
 
And what made high longevity/high cost pilot groups possible? Especially when it comes to Eagle, that 25 yr contract with 5 items negotiable every 4 years led to many 18 yr CAs. XJT had one of the best pilot contracts as well and look where they are now. It is obvious that in the past several years, the shift has definitely happened that the pilot groups signing higher cost pilot contracts end up losing planes and those with cheap labor cost contracts end up gaining planes.

Again... it's not about the cost in the contract but rather the longevity. I'll give you the fact that a higher paying contract (and we are talking total compensation, not pay rates) does probably lead towards high longevity, but they are not directly linked as there are other factors (stability, company culture, future growth and recent growth etc) that play into it as well. None of those things is an "ALPA bargaining strategy" other than the goal to increase compensation at each property, which the union would be at risk of a DFR if they didn't do.
 
Ok noob question. Was Envoy's bet that other regionals would not be able to staff new flying? While that is not the case for the moment, how long (if ever) will that take to affect staffing? A year or two, or more?
 
Back
Top