Demographics are way, way more important than contract language and pay rates. That was probably a big reason why PSA did the deal they did. Places like ExpressJet and Eagle (and even Skywest to some extent) are WAY too top heavy to compete, even if they were to take some place like GoJet's contract, section for section. The "pref hire"/flow through things actually do work, when the Big Boy companies actually take people, especially senior ones.
I was talking to a friend at PSA the other day and he was listing some of the VERY senior captains that recently took a spot at Airways. These are guys that were never going to go anywhere (and probably couldn't go anywhere) and would spent the next 15 years of their careers topped out, being a huge financial drain on the company. Instead, they are now moving on, will recoup their payrates within a few years and have allowed a large number on the balance sheet to be replaced with a much, much smaller one.