Well, since my name was mentioned in this thread, I feel compelled to respond. Take it with a grain of salt... After all, I entered the airlines with less than 500 hours, an I spent nearly $8000 on a "Boeing transition course."
First, you need to remember that at the great majority of airlines these days, it is not pilots on the selection board or setting the minimum requirements. It is Human Resources. A few men or women who likely have never stepped foot into the cockpit of any airplane, let alone an airliner, decide the number of hours their new-hire pilots should have, or what background they would like to see in their candidates. In all honesty, most line pilots (and most of the people in flight operations management) would like to see qualified pilots with a decent chunk of flight time, good flying skills, a high level of knowledge, and most importantly a great attitude.
Personally, as a line Captain, I don't care how many hours my First Officer has, where they went to school, or if they dropped a substantial amount of money on an RJ transition course. I want them to have good situational awareness, a good attitude conducive to learning, and to be a good stick. There is nothing more frustrating for me as we try to move people safely across the country than keeping an eye on the First Officer. It is especially frustrating when that First Officer is making mistakes, but is also unwilling to listen and learn.
I do not expect the guy or gal in the right seat next to me to be perfect. God knows I wasn't when I started flying in the airlines. I made mistakes, but I knew that the only way I would have a successful career was to admit when I didn't know something, observe, and listen. That seems to be lost with most pilots today, which is my only beef with these courses. They run pilots through a few weeks of "jet training" and give them the idea they have learned it all. Trust me: You do not know it all. Even as I sit here approaching 4000 hours with 3000 hours of jet time, I still learn things
every single day. In fact, I still have mentors that I turn to for advice, because I am still trying to grow, even as the Pilot-In-Command.
In my time in the left seat, I have flown with guys from every walk of life (even Gulfstream Academy). I never paid much attention to where they came from, because what matters to me is how they fly today. I've flown with CFIs who were lost, and who had a "know it all" attitude. I've also flown with RJ transition guys who did a great job, and most importantly had a great attitude. It all depends on how you approach your training, and what you want from this career. If you are just looking for the polyester uniform and stripes, then by all means, do it as fast as you can. You'll achieve your goal, but you likely will be a burden upon your Captain. When you get to that left seat, you will then likely be a burden upon your First Officer. However, if your goal is to become a professional pilot, then relax and know that it is a process of continuous growth.
There is no "quick route" to being a true professional. That is because true professionals career goal is continuous learning, not getting a job and a uniform. I believe the goal of JetCareers is to try and encourage pilots to become true professionals; we are not here to try and help you get a job. That is why you will find many here with the opinion that you should get your degree, get your CFI, build up your time and experience, and start your trek at the airlines. We want to see you develop into a well-rounded professional, who can weather all the challenges that will come over a 40-year career.