Cut rate Virgins

Status
Not open for further replies.
That can be the pay here for airlines in the United States as long as we, as pilots, get on the same page, and have a strong collective bargaining voice.

IMO, after doing a lot of reading on macroeconomic issues and the globalization of world economies, collective bargaining agreements at individual companies won't serve to increase the plight of the piloting profession. Strong collective bargaining agreements could even serve to accelerate the "creative destruction" of the profession. I just don't think you can stop the enormous capitalistic forces that ultimately set compensation levels with individual CBA's.

However, revamping the accreditation process of pilot certification, instituting baseline aptitude testing for entrance into the profession and establishing new qualification guidelines for certification would serve to strengthen the profession and THEN would strengthen the CBA's as a result.

Worldwide professional associations should, IMO, work to establish stringent entrance guidelines. Good things will follow. However, I don't see ANY work towards, or acceptance of, this type of philosophical baseline whatsoever.

I.E., I don't believe this needs to eliminate low time pilots. Low timers with high aptitude scores, I believe should meet revamped entry requirements.
 
For any of you still wondering what the effect of $95 an hour Captains has on the industry in general:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119369814616075510.html?mod=dist_smartbrief

And you want to help these guys cut your throat by giving them jumpseat rides to SFO?

I understand non-union = bad. And Velo's jumpseat = political tool. And I'm cool with that.

But I can't for the life of me see what is *bad* about that article? Is your point that the effect of $95 an hour Captains has on the industry in general is ...lower fares?
 
But I can't for the life of me see what is *bad* about that article? Is your point that the effect of $95 an hour Captains has on the industry in general is ...lower fares?


Why would established medical doctors care if some young guns fresh out of med school decided to go to work for a hospital that specializes in $99 surgeries? Of course the new doctors would have to agree to work for $17 per hour in order to make those prices possible. Chances are the hospital will be out of business in a few years but hey, at least the upper management will have made their millions. Some would say the employees, who are now out of work, should have known better.

Meanwhile, the established hospitals are wondering why their physicians are making so much more than the young guys are willing to work for. Would anyone argue that the new guys did anything to make being a physician a better career? Some would suggest they sold their peers out.
 
Why would established medical doctors care if some young guns fresh out of med school decided to go to work for a hospital that specializes in $99 surgeries? Of course the new doctors would have to agree to work for $17 per hour in order to make those prices possible. Chances are the hospital will be out of business in a few years but hey, at least the upper management will have made their millions. Some would say the employees, who are now out of work, should have known better.

Meanwhile, the established hospitals are wondering why their physicians are making so much more than the young guys are willing to work for. Would anyone argue that the new guys did anything to make being a physician a better career? Some would suggest they sold their peers out.
Ah yes, that all sort of ties together.
 
Why would established medical doctors care if some young guns fresh out of med school decided to go to work for a hospital that specializes in $99 surgeries? Of course the new doctors would have to agree to work for $17 per hour in order to make those prices possible. Chances are the hospital will be out of business in a few years but hey, at least the upper management will have made their millions. Some would say the employees, who are now out of work, should have known better.

Meanwhile, the established hospitals are wondering why their physicians are making so much more than the young guys are willing to work for. Would anyone argue that the new guys did anything to make being a physician a better career? Some would suggest they sold their peers out.

We saw major changes in tech, major changes in airlines...changes afoot now in the auto industry. Next is education and health care. Tenured professors are being replaced by adjunct faculty. IMO, competition in health care is right around the corner...even sooner if a republican is the next president.

Have you seen their health care proposals? Company sponsored health plans will be gone soon (like pension obligations) and a person will not be calling their insurance provider to see if they have health coverage....they will be calling 5 different doctors to find the best price...or surfing the internet sorta like Priceline.com for the best prices on medical procedures.

As capitalism takes hold in the ruins of the central planning economies in eastern europe...and the globalized economy is flooded with a new supply of workers...I am not sure US workers can look forward to further big increases in their standard of living. A lot of the data I read sure points to that conclusion.
 
B767Driver,

Interesting points.

I completely agree with you about increasing the standards of the certification process. Do you think we should go to more of a JAA type of process with a multitude of tests? Or more outside of the box training processes?
 
B767Driver,

Interesting points.

I completely agree with you about increasing the standards of the certification process. Do you think we should go to more of a JAA type of process with a multitude of tests? Or more outside of the box training processes?

It's my understanding that some regional airlines have a 50% washout rate for new hires. This statistic alone illustrates a problem with the "qualified" supply of commercial pilots in the system. The current answer has been to relax minimums and hire enough people to find enough who can make it through the training process.

This is a killer to our profession, let alone an embarrassment, and a poor way to find our fellow professionals of tomorrow.

I don't think the training processes are the problem. I think it's a matter of getting people with the proper aptitude and skills in the pipeline. If you cannot find people with a baseline aptitude, then incentives must be given to attract them. At that point, the professional piloting career will become a respectable profession again.

To underscore how outdated current regulations have become, a pilot needs 1200 hours to fly cancelled checks in a single engine Cessna, however the FAA allows a pilot with 250 hours (less for Part 141 trained pilots) to fly SIC in Part 121 passenger carrying jets. This makes no sense.

To cut to the chase, I think ALPA and the other professional pilot associations should take a hard look at accreditation, certification and testing standards for professional pilots. Tightening parameters in those areas would go along way towards improving all sorts of standards in the profession.

Doctors, lawyers, CPA's, pharmacists, professors, engineers are all examples of professions with stringent aptitude, accreditation and educational requirements. I'm not sure our profession is measuring up in these areas.

I mean six months to go from zero to hero? I don't think this type of thing should exist. This type of entrance into the profession really bothers me.
 
"I mean six months to go from zero to hero? I don't think this type of thing should exist."

I don't either. That's why I rail on the 90 day program that ATP has. They call me a hater, but I really think it's a bad idea.
 
B767driver excellent points. I would like to add a few things and I would like to hear what you have to say.

I know at our regional they have added two sim sessions for initial training candidates to 'get them up to speed'. Is it their skills per se or a combination of their skills as long as the attitudes of new hires coming to the regionals?

You have WAY more experience than me so please correct me if I am wrong. The way I approached and will continue to approach the 121 training environment, is cooperate/graduate. Are these new hires sticking by this creed of cooperate/graduate or are they trying to do their own thing when in initial training, thinking they are hot shizzle? Could new hires doing their own thing, questioning multiple instructors, be leading to a higher washout rate?

The attitude I have seen and the complete lack of professionalism out there on some of these new hires is scary. Couple this with the fact that these zero to hero programs really aren't fostering a learning environment and we could be headed for disaster.

Guys at fast track programs are thinking they can "go to any regional, build their time, and go onto a major within three years". What is even more scary is how these training programs limit the outside exposure to situations while in the training environment and prevent pilots from making tough decisions. You are told when to fly, who to fly with, where to fly, if you can fly on a particular day, etc. Take someone who has not made pilot in command decisions in their training environment, stick them in the right seat of a regional jet for three years, then when their number is up they are sitting in the left seat, with a green First Officer both who have been training in a very controlled setting. If/when crap hits the fan do these captains have the ability to think 'outside of the box' if need be.

These guys are also flying for the wrong reasons. Ever since I could remember, flying has been my passion. Some of my earliest childhood memories were my father taking me to the airport and watching the planes for hours. I love my job, have a passion for it, and don't want to lose it. It does seem like guys today are doing it just to do it and giving up other life experiences. We have had multiple crew members have to turn down trips because they were to busy with their online school work. If they enjoyed the journey they would have their four year degree BEFORE getting on with a regional.

I agree with you ALPA does need to do something to educate those that want a career in aviation. They should have a program from high school students, college students, FBOs, and of course these zero to hero schools to show how to enjoy the journey and most importantly BECOME a professional. They should do a study to see how these guys with 255 hours can be a liability in the cockpit of a commercial airliner. Unfortunately, to many regs are written in blood.

We should have these high standards for those that want to be in this career. Medical, Engineering and Law Graduate School can be extremely difficult to get into. Why not make it difficult to get into a flight school that trains you to be a commercial pilot? Why should we settle for anything less?

PS-Purdue seems to be having a pretty good year this year. I think they will go 9-3 easily. You go to any games this year?
 
Seggy, I talked with Captain Rice a few months ago, and he was working on several programs that dealt with educating wannabe pilots at the earlier stages, especially at aviation colleges. The goal is to eventually get some sort of "pre-apprentice" membership status so that pilots can have an ALPA status before actually becoming ALPA members when they join an ALPA airline. With all of the other issues going on right now (Multi-crew pilot license, the AAA/AWA fiasco, etc...), this has probably had to go to the back burner for a bit, but things are in the works.
 
ALPA NEEDS to do that. If they did we would have won the vote. A lot of guys that went to these zero to hero programs/aviation universities didn't vote, which is a no vote.
 
B767driver excellent points. I would like to add a few things and I would like to hear what you have to say.

I know at our regional they have added two sim sessions for initial training candidates to 'get them up to speed'. Is it their skills per se or a combination of their skills as long as the attitudes of new hires coming to the regionals?

You have WAY more experience than me so please correct me if I am wrong. The way I approached and will continue to approach the 121 training environment, is cooperate/graduate. Are these new hires sticking by this creed of cooperate/graduate or are they trying to do their own thing when in initial training, thinking they are hot shizzle? Could new hires doing their own thing, questioning multiple instructors, be leading to a higher washout rate?

The attitude I have seen and the complete lack of professionalism out there on some of these new hires is scary. Couple this with the fact that these zero to hero programs really aren't fostering a learning environment and we could be headed for disaster.

Guys at fast track programs are thinking they can "go to any regional, build their time, and go onto a major within three years". What is even more scary is how these training programs limit the outside exposure to situations while in the training environment and prevent pilots from making tough decisions. You are told when to fly, who to fly with, where to fly, if you can fly on a particular day, etc. Take someone who has not made pilot in command decisions in their training environment, stick them in the right seat of a regional jet for three years, then when their number is up they are sitting in the left seat, with a green First Officer both who have been training in a very controlled setting. If/when crap hits the fan do these captains have the ability to think 'outside of the box' if need be.

These guys are also flying for the wrong reasons. Ever since I could remember, flying has been my passion. Some of my earliest childhood memories were my father taking me to the airport and watching the planes for hours. I love my job, have a passion for it, and don't want to lose it. It does seem like guys today are doing it just to do it and giving up other life experiences. We have had multiple crew members have to turn down trips because they were to busy with their online school work. If they enjoyed the journey they would have their four year degree BEFORE getting on with a regional.

I agree with you ALPA does need to do something to educate those that want a career in aviation. They should have a program from high school students, college students, FBOs, and of course these zero to hero schools to show how to enjoy the journey and most importantly BECOME a professional. They should do a study to see how these guys with 255 hours can be a liability in the cockpit of a commercial airliner. Unfortunately, to many regs are written in blood.

We should have these high standards for those that want to be in this career. Medical, Engineering and Law Graduate School can be extremely difficult to get into. Why not make it difficult to get into a flight school that trains you to be a commercial pilot? Why should we settle for anything less?

PS-Purdue seems to be having a pretty good year this year. I think they will go 9-3 easily. You go to any games this year?

Good questions Seggs! I've been flying for over 6 years now. I had a lot of PIC time before I went to DCA. I noticed exactly what you described above about who, where, and when you fly. These academies and "fast track" schools really limit outside exposure when flying. At every stage check and end of course I had more PIC time than the check instructors! That's sad! They limit solo PIC time even during the commercial course. I had all sort of varieties of airfields in my logbook; short fields, grass fields, Class B airports like LAX and OAK, and so on. When I did my private at an FBO, I got to choose any airfield I wanted for my cross country flights. At DCA they have specified "cookie cutter routes" to choose from for every single course. Everyone has the same damn airports in their logbook from 0 hours till they get hired by a regional, unless they get smart and fly on their own, on their off time. These student fly in the same type of weather conditions as well there entire time at these schools.
 
B767driver excellent points. I would like to add a few things and I would like to hear what you have to say.

I know at our regional they have added two sim sessions for initial training candidates to 'get them up to speed'. Is it their skills per se or a combination of their skills as long as the attitudes of new hires coming to the regionals?

You have WAY more experience than me so please correct me if I am wrong. The way I approached and will continue to approach the 121 training environment, is cooperate/graduate. Are these new hires sticking by this creed of cooperate/graduate or are they trying to do their own thing when in initial training, thinking they are hot shizzle? Could new hires doing their own thing, questioning multiple instructors, be leading to a higher washout rate?

The attitude I have seen and the complete lack of professionalism out there on some of these new hires is scary. Couple this with the fact that these zero to hero programs really aren't fostering a learning environment and we could be headed for disaster.

Guys at fast track programs are thinking they can "go to any regional, build their time, and go onto a major within three years". What is even more scary is how these training programs limit the outside exposure to situations while in the training environment and prevent pilots from making tough decisions. You are told when to fly, who to fly with, where to fly, if you can fly on a particular day, etc. Take someone who has not made pilot in command decisions in their training environment, stick them in the right seat of a regional jet for three years, then when their number is up they are sitting in the left seat, with a green First Officer both who have been training in a very controlled setting. If/when crap hits the fan do these captains have the ability to think 'outside of the box' if need be.

These guys are also flying for the wrong reasons. Ever since I could remember, flying has been my passion. Some of my earliest childhood memories were my father taking me to the airport and watching the planes for hours. I love my job, have a passion for it, and don't want to lose it. It does seem like guys today are doing it just to do it and giving up other life experiences. We have had multiple crew members have to turn down trips because they were to busy with their online school work. If they enjoyed the journey they would have their four year degree BEFORE getting on with a regional.

I agree with you ALPA does need to do something to educate those that want a career in aviation. They should have a program from high school students, college students, FBOs, and of course these zero to hero schools to show how to enjoy the journey and most importantly BECOME a professional. They should do a study to see how these guys with 255 hours can be a liability in the cockpit of a commercial airliner. Unfortunately, to many regs are written in blood.

We should have these high standards for those that want to be in this career. Medical, Engineering and Law Graduate School can be extremely difficult to get into. Why not make it difficult to get into a flight school that trains you to be a commercial pilot? Why should we settle for anything less?

PS-Purdue seems to be having a pretty good year this year. I think they will go 9-3 easily. You go to any games this year?


I agree with your post and thanks for the ALPA work you volunteer to do. The above philosophical viewpoints we've been discussing are HUGE paradigm shifts in the piloting profession.

Well, yes, but not really.

We used to have the military who, by and large, did all of the screening and training for the nation's airlines. The airlines really didn't have to worry much about the screening process because the military was so selective to begin with. As a result, the airlines had very intelligent and capable individuals, almost by default, in their cockpits.

As the military could no longer meet the needs of the nation's airlines, the career has been opened up to the civilian population, which is great...and produces thousands of great pilots. But, unfortunately, maybe a lot without the aptitude prevalent in prior generations of pilots due to the fact that there is no aptitude/entrance testing.

Here, I believe, is where we are slipping in our profession. To change the entry requirements at this porthole of the profession is important and would require drastic change in accreditation of training institutions and the selection of students into those institutions.

Concurrently with this massive change, the regionals need to get their first year pay around $40k.

I know there are thousands of other factors that economically impact these issues and those objectives.

But from the standpoint of restoring the profession and providing for it's future...IMO...the above objectives are important to acheive or else we're not going to be satisfied with the level of talent sitting next to us in future years.

PS: Yea...6-3 now. Was hoping for a win against Penn State. Too many errors, turnovers. Illinois and Indiana to go. Could be 8-3 or 6-5 at the end of November. Never sure what this team is going to do. Went to the Ohio State and Iowa games. On a bright note, we've got a great basketball recruiting class coming in...so looking forward to better times on the hardwood over the next couple of years!

I'm a Big Ten guy and live in SEC country now...SEC fans are insufferable.
 
Seggy, I talked with Captain Rice a few months ago, and he was working on several programs that dealt with educating wannabe pilots at the earlier stages, especially at aviation colleges. The goal is to eventually get some sort of "pre-apprentice" membership status so that pilots can have an ALPA status before actually becoming ALPA members when they join an ALPA airline. With all of the other issues going on right now (Multi-crew pilot license, the AAA/AWA fiasco, etc...), this has probably had to go to the back burner for a bit, but things are in the works.
I'd be interesting in hearing more about that!! Don't see why it only has to happen at aviation colleges (lots of pilots don't come from aviation colleges) as we could have a program here as well?! just a thought....
 
Seggy, I talked with Captain Rice a few months ago, and he was working on several programs that dealt with educating wannabe pilots at the earlier stages, especially at aviation colleges. The goal is to eventually get some sort of "pre-apprentice" membership status so that pilots can have an ALPA status before actually becoming ALPA members when they join an ALPA airline. With all of the other issues going on right now (Multi-crew pilot license, the AAA/AWA fiasco, etc...), this has probably had to go to the back burner for a bit, but things are in the works.

ALPA NEEDS to do that. If they did we would have won the vote. A lot of guys that went to these zero to hero programs/aviation universities didn't vote, which is a no vote.

NATCA (National Air Traffic Controller's Association) has just this...called an Associate membership. Why you ask? To do exactly what ALPA needs to be doing. Developing the educational knowledge with newbie controllers while they are at their CTI programs, so that when they do finally get hired by the FAA the new guys are right where they need to be in regards to labor relations.

ALPA can not put this type of thing off much longer.
 
NATCA (National Air Traffic Controller's Association) has just this...called an Associate membership. Why you ask? To do exactly what ALPA needs to be doing. Developing the educational knowledge with newbie controllers while they are at their CTI programs, so that when they do finally get hired by the FAA the new guys are right where they need to be in regards to labor relations.
ALPA can not put this type of thing off much longer.



There's a big difference between controllers in training and pilots in training. I would say 80% of the pilots that I've met throughout my training had no idea about the big picture and when you try to educate them they brush you off. Controllers by their nature understand the big picture and are willing to look long-term. Just look at the recent vote at Colgan and what I believe is going to be a disappointing turnout at SkyWest. Most younger pilots either don't care or believe they know better.
 
I'd be interesting in hearing more about that!! Don't see why it only has to happen at aviation colleges (lots of pilots don't come from aviation colleges) as we could have a program here as well?! just a thought....

I believe the aviation colleges were meant as a starting point. The problem with any ALPA program is that it requires volunteers. The ALPA National Education Committee is responsible for a variety of things, and they always have problems finding enough volunteers to handle events. For instance, ALPA tries to have a presence at career fairs at Embry-Riddle and Air Inc, but sometimes they miss them because no one is available that will staff the booth. It will take a big volunteer drive to find enough people to staff the various events at a bunch of colleges, so starting with just a hand full of aviation colleges would be the easiest way to get it going.

This initiative was being lead by Captain Rice at last I heard a number of months ago, but since then he's been named as the Chairman of the Rice Committee that has been responsible for dealing with the AAA/AWA seniority integration fiasco, so I doubt he's had much time to deal with anything else. I would imagine that it would be at least another 6-12 months until anything with the educational issues would be moving ahead.
 
shoot.. i bet they could find some good volunteers right here.

might not be a bad idea to open a thread and see what kind of response is attained
 
shoot.. i bet they could find some good volunteers right here.

might not be a bad idea to open a thread and see what kind of response is attained

Sign me up! But I'm not ALPA, thanks to the Apathetic Colganites.....:(
 
You gotta start somewhere. Somewhere in the past couple of years it seems that the "professional" part of being a professional airline pilot went out the window to the whole me first entitlement attitude so prevalent in today's society. The question is what can we do to help the situation? I'm all for it whatever it is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top