Vectors and lost comms?

newty

New Member
Coming into SLC today I had a flight that brings this question to my mind, here's the breakdown. I'm about 30 north of SLC and I get "fly heading 165" I know from the atis that they are landing north and I am being vectored to the south for one of the approaches so I fly 165 and as I am abeam the airport I would like to brief an approach so I ask approach controller"which approach can I expect?" The controller has a bit of a confused sound in voice, like maybe he thinks he already told me but he replies "expect ILS 34L and contact approach on125.70" ok got it. I brief approach and call next controller. All he says is ""turn left heading 090" I make the turn and as I m crossing the LOC for 34L and headed into the Trangression zone for the simuls I get "fly heading 360 maintain 7000 until established on the LOC cleared for the ILS 34RIGHT. so here are my questions. If I had lost comms after the initial vector of 165 and before I asked what approach to expect. What approach am I supposed to fly? My clearance limit is the airport and I have no approach to "expect" so do I just pick one? What if I lost comms on the vector of 090 that was taking me to the loc for 34L? at this point I had not been told that I was actually going to get 34R.. I guess I answered this one in my mind just now that I was last told 34L so I would have intercepted the loc for 34L. but the first question still stands. hope this all makes sense.
 
When you were given the 'expect' clearance, that would be the approach I would choose.

If lost coms on radar vectors for an approach, navigate directly to the IAF, and begin the approach.
 
When you were given the 'expect' clearance, that would be the approach I would choose.

If lost coms on radar vectors for an approach, navigate directly to the IAF, and begin the approach.
But what if you have not been given the "expect " clearance?
 
Same really, navigate to your IAF and begin the approach. Which approach you choose is up to you, preferably the one with the lowest minimums.
 
Same really, navigate to your IAF and begin the approach. Which approach you choose is up to you, preferably the one with the lowest minimums.

I would agree wtih that. And make sure you put 7600 on the transponder.
 
"Avenue F" is still a good rule of thumb...

Assigned altitudes or headings
Vectors -- follow the last one given by ATC
Expect Further Clearance -- do what they are expecting you to do when the EFC time, if you had one, expires
Filed -- do what you filed in your flight plan (good reason to use an IAF as the last point on your flight plan)

In all cases, when you're NORDO squawk appropriately and fly either the approach you filed for or what you expect to fly based on the ATIS or what you heard before going NORDO.
 
I was under the impression that when ATC first gives you vectors off-route, they're supposed to tell you what you're getting vectored for. For example, "Newty 01, fly heading 165, vectors ILS 34L." I could be wrong, that's just what my experience has been in my (very) limited amount of instrument flying. If you lose comms then, just follow AVEF. Contrary to what Hacker15e said, you don't follow the last vector given to you by ATC. You fly direct to whatever they were vectoring you to, in this case, ILS 34L, Ref. 91.185 (c)(1)(ii). Obviously, you would want to use some common sense (if there's a mountain between you and the FAF, don't go straight at it :crazy:).
 
Contrary to what Hacker15e said, you don't follow the last vector given to you by ATC. You fly direct to whatever they were vectoring you to, in this case, ILS 34L, Ref. 91.185 (c)(1)(ii). Obviously, you would want to use some common sense (if there's a mountain between you and the FAF, don't go straight at it :crazy:).

Dude, it's a rule of thumb that gives you a prioritized list of options that you (the pilot...doing that pilot #####) have to decide on using.

As in, if you went NORDO 300 miles from your destination, you wouldn't immediately start setting yourself up to fly the approach by going direct to the IAF.
 
Dude, it's a rule of thumb that gives you a prioritized list of options that you (the pilot...doing that pilot #####) have to decide on using.

Hey, no need to hate on me, I meant no harm. I never said that the rule was applicable in all cases. I just know way too many people that think that they're supposed to fly off into infinity on the vector that was last given to them, either until they hit a mountain or they run out of gas. I was just pointing out that that's not the case.
 
I was under the impression that when ATC first gives you vectors off-route, they're supposed to tell you what you're getting vectored for...

They are. But sometimes the reason for the vector might not give you much useful information, like "vectors for descent" or "vectors for traffic". If you were to lose comms right after hearing that, you'd have to revert back to the old AVE F, but you wouldn't really have an "expected" clearance.

XcalibeR said:
You fly direct to whatever they were vectoring you to, in this case, ILS 34L, Ref. 91.185 (c)(1)(ii). Obviously, you would want to use some common sense (if there's a mountain between you and the FAF, don't go straight at it :crazy:).

Yeah, this is correct, but I think the original poster's question was related to what he would have done if they hadn't given him an approach to expect yet. Then basically you fly to ANY IAF for an approach that's suitable for your aircraft. You're expected to use some judgement and common sense here, but the general rule of thumb is to try to remain predictable.
 
They are. But sometimes the reason for the vector might not give you much useful information, like "vectors for descent" or "vectors for traffic". If you were to lose comms right after hearing that, you'd have to revert back to the old AVE F, but you wouldn't really have an "expected" clearance.



Yeah, this is correct, but I think the original poster's question was related to what he would have done if they hadn't given him an approach to expect yet. Then basically you fly to ANY IAF for an approach that's suitable for your aircraft. You're expected to use some judgement and common sense here, but the general rule of thumb is to try to remain predictable.

There you go. That answers my question. I had not been given an arrival, nor had I been given an approach, AVEF would not work because I had not been assigned an approach, the vector was just that, a heading and nothing more, I had no expected approach nor had I filed for one. My last clearance was Direct OgdenVor Direct KSLC. when I finally asked for an approach they were unsure about it and ended up changing it on me last minute, as in about 3 miles from the FAF with a 90degree intercept angle. Thanks for the answers.
 
There you go. That answers my question. I had not been given an arrival, nor had I been given an approach, AVEF would not work because I had not been assigned an approach, the vector was just that, a heading and nothing more, I had no expected approach nor had I filed for one. My last clearance was Direct OgdenVor Direct KSLC. when I finally asked for an approach they were unsure about it and ended up changing it on me last minute, as in about 3 miles from the FAF with a 90degree intercept angle. Thanks for the answers.

It happens to me also. They try and keep us smaller guys out of the approach but there just in case they can fit us in quick. What I find is that Im flying the bear 4 arrival but not cleared for it than they slam us in. Was that friday? I got nasty ice that night
 
It happens to me also. They try and keep us smaller guys out of the approach but there just in case they can fit us in quick. What I find is that Im flying the bear 4 arrival but not cleared for it than they slam us in. Was that friday? I got nasty ice that night
They Never ever give us an arrival. I had a pretty good Idea what they were doing with me because just like you guys they like to keep us high and close and the all of a sudden wham bam get on the loc and get down which isn't that easy in a chieftain. The most frustrating thing for me was that I haven't flown for a few months and not IMC for quite a while and I just wanted to brief the approach but it was like pulling teeth to get them to tell me which one, then I brief it and just outside the faf they switch approaches on me, it makes for some lively times in the cockpit. This was on Sat morning about 11, I got mod rime at 10,000 about 9am
 
Come on and jump over to AMF, flying the 99 is so easy a caveman can do it. Saturday sucked I did the SGU it blew.

The Chieftain is no easy plane I started in it with AMF I understand your pain
 
Come on and jump over to AMF, flying the 99 is so easy a caveman can do it.
I have been thinking about it and I talked to your ACP last week. I'm headed back to the grand canyon for 3 weeks and then when I get back I have to find a new job, It'll either be AMF or skywaste. I have an offer to fly a chieftain in alaska but I think I'll stay in Utah for a while. I like the chieftain but the thing will not slow down and come down at the same time.
 
Back
Top