Controller Questioning A Pilot's Technique . . .

I thanked him for his advise, and told him that the only time that safety was compromised was when the tower controller canceled my approach and landing clearance and cleared me to land, all in the same sentence. He didn't really respond to that, and I'm sure that he didn't like it.

LOL. I love it.

On a side note, the next morning, myself and the other FLX pilot heading into KMEM that morning made an effort to ensure that we were slowed to 120 KIAS, flaps and gear down, and stabilized 40 miles out.

We configured the airplanes a lot earlier. ;)

"Be careful what you wish for; you just might get it."
 
I dunno. I've only been into JAN twice now, but it seemed sort of dead both times. Not to mention, the overnight we have there is officially in the middle of nowhere. The cab driver told us "it's fine to walk that way (points south) but DON'T even think about walking that way (points north)".
 
Geez, no love from the tower watch sup. You think he'd some what be happy you kept your speed up to accommodate the RJ behind you. I know I always thank the pilot when they help me out like you did.

Usually the approach controller will tell the tower, "Hey FLXxxx is maintaining max forward speed on final," or something to that effect.
 
The very reason I like the Air Force wheels down check.


Most definitely, reminds me of my flight training at the Aero Club at Osan AFB in S. Korea. Tower would give me that same clearance...."Cessna 94 Echo Romeo, winds 240 at 6, runway 27, number 1 cleared to land, check gear down."

My CFI and I always enjoyed hearing that in our super cool 1983 172....lol
 
Well, here's the story.

I was going into KMEM the other morning, and I just happened to be in a 210 that day (had to swap an aircraft with another pilot). I am EXTREMELY comfortable in that airplane. While on with Approach, the controller asked me if I could maintain 160 KIAS to the runway, and I replied that I could give him 160 until a VERY short final, and then slow down - maybe land a little long, but that it would be no problem. So, he sequenced me in on the visual, and turned a CRJ in behind me from the downwind.

The final controller cleared me for the approach, and again asked me to maintain max forward speed if possible. No problem . . . nothing unsafe about it. With a VLO of 165, VFE of 160 for 10 degrees, 130 for 20 degrees and 115 for 30 degrees . . . piece of cake.

So, on with the tower, cleared to land, and just coming up on about a mile final, i pull the power out, gear down, and flaps 10. Just as soon as I lowered the handle, the tower controller says, "FLX305, cancel approach and landing clearance - um, cleared to land [obviously seeing that my gear was coming down]. I continued slowing, but arrested the descent, preparing for a go-around, and replied with "FLX305, confirming cleared to land?". She replied, "FLX 305, you are cleared to land".

So, I landed, made the same turn-off that I always do, and she started to explain that she noticed that my gear wasn't down, and was going to have me go around. She followed it up with the always-dreaded "I need you to call the tower supervisor . . . . advise when ready to copy".

So, after I shut down, I gave the tower supervisor a call. He started by saying that I wasn't being violated (good thing - I didn't do anything), and advised me that I had created a "moment of anxiety", and that they don;t like to see pilots that close to the runway with the gear up. He then proceeded to tell me the correct way to fly the airplane, and that I should configure the airplane a lot earlier. I thanked him for his advise, and told him that the only time that safety was compromised was when the tower controller canceled my approach and landing clearance and cleared me to land, all in the same sentence. He didn't really respond to that, and I'm sure that he didn't like it.

And, that was that!

On a side note, the next morning, myself and the other FLX pilot heading into KMEM that morning made an effort to ensure that we were slowed to 120 KIAS, flaps and gear down, and stabilized 40 miles out.

We configured the airplanes a lot earlier. ;)

Well Lloyd, I have to commend you on your restraint. That is the most ridiculous thing I've heard in a long time. I would've had a hard time not telling him what was up. What a dork.:rolleyes:
 
I guess I will be the unpopular one. Take not tower guys/gals, us pilots do not want you looking out for us, blindly do things and pay no regard to the fact we MAY not be configured for landing (gear down) and let us belly land the airplane since questioning someone or being proactive on a situation may bruise someones ego.


Geeeesh, come on people, there was a miscomm somewhere and the tower didn't realize what was going on and did what she though was in the best interest of safety at the moment, after realizing there was no issue and no need to further delay Lloyd she cleared him to land. If the cancelled clearance and subsequent reclearance to land was such a threat to safety Lloyd should have gone around himself.
 
I guess I will be the unpopular one. Take not tower guys/gals, us pilots do not want you looking out for us, blindly do things and pay no regard to the fact we MAY not be configured for landing (gear down) and let us belly land the airplane since questioning someone or being proactive on a situation may bruise someones ego.


Geeeesh, come on people, there was a miscomm somewhere and the tower didn't realize what was going on and did what she though was in the best interest of safety at the moment, after realizing there was no issue and no need to further delay Lloyd she cleared him to land. If the cancelled clearance and subsequent reclearance to land was such a threat to safety Lloyd should have gone around himself.

I think you must have missed the point. Your above post is not correct. Lloyd wasn't preturbed by the fact of the controllers concern but of the way she handled it, and more importantly being issued a phone number and getting lectured by the tower supervisor that didn't know his place. Correct me if I'm wrong Lloyd.
 
Curious . . . at what point is it appropriate for a local controller to cancel a landing clearance, because the pilot was waiting too long to lower the gear?


I guess I missed that part in the above post JB about him being perterbed about the Cab Super. "lecturing" him.
 
I guess I missed that part in the above post JB about him being perterbed about the Cab Super. "lecturing" him.

Yeah, it's the last part of the story that's kinda jacked up. Controllers have enough to do, they certainly don't need to be telling professional pilots or any pilot for that matter, how to fly the airplane. Just a big pet peeve of mine I guess. Dang! I should've put that on my list from the past thread.:)
 
I agree a controller shouldn't critique or be a critic BUT that wasn't the case here. A controller was on her toes, noticed an airplane close to landing without the gear down. Granted what she did wasn't the "by the book way" but if Lloyd was as close to the ground and runway as he makes it seem, I think the cancelled landing clearance was the better option than "check gear down".
 
I see what you're saying - and if the controller had said, "FLX305, confirm gear down?", then I'd have absolutely no problem. However, the super giving me his little speech - well, that was over the line.
 
The super, yup over the line, you showed more restraint than I would have. But also keep in mind, he doesn't know you, doesn't know your comfort level with the airplane and he most likely jumped to the conclusion that you were some rooky hot shot that simply forgot to put the gear down. Not exactly the best way to approach the situation, but not the worst either.

Me, I tend to put the gear down too far out, I'm paid by the minute, why not.
 
I don't know how many times that I have had to go around when I was TDY to TPA because I was going 30 knots faster than the A320 that was ahead of me on an intersecting runway. It was always the Citrus gang. But I know the Mil tower are required to ask about the gear, I just cannot believe that a Civ tower would lecture like that. All though, some ATC controllers think that they are god, ATC at CPS (For those who know).
 
Back
Top