Excessive back-pressure stall?

Cessnaflyer

Wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
I have to teach some lessons tomorrow and I am getting some notes put together. One of the subjects within stalls is excessive-back pressure stalls. I've never heard of one and I can't find that term used in any of my books. What does this pertain too?
 
I have no idea what the term refers to, but I can say with certainty that a plane will never stall unless excessive back-elevator input is applied. The yoke can be used as a poor man's AoA indicator. The further back the yoke is (be it because of trim or muscle forces applied), the higher the AoA and the closer to a stall the aircraft is.
 
someones been reading stick and rudder...jrh

Haha...not to brag, but I actually realized that little tidbit of knowledge on my own! The things your mind realizes after teaching stalls for the hundredth time is amazing...

Then, about a year after I realized this on my own, I ended up reading Stick and Rudder and thought, "Hot dog! I'm a genius and didn't even know it!"
 
And that is the one aviation book that I don't have!

Honestly, I wasn't *that* impressed by it. No doubt it's a good read, but I don't think it breaks things down any better than some other good quality textbooks.

It was probably a revolutionary text in its day, but many of the "new" ideas in that book are commonly known and taught by everybody today.
 
Well thats good but I can't think of what to say because I already have all the other stalls done. I'm not sure how to make 10 minutes out of a subject I've never heard of.
 
Haha...not to brag, but I actually realized that little tidbit of knowledge on my own! The things your mind realizes after teaching stalls for the hundredth time is amazing...

Then, about a year after I realized this on my own, I ended up reading Stick and Rudder and thought, "Hot dog! I'm a genius and didn't even know it!"


Yup. There's a great demo we do in the tweet about this, but I wouldn't try it in most airplanes. Basically you put the airplane 70 degrees nose high and as the speed slows to close to the "stall" speed (or more properly, the level flight unconfigured stall speed) you use the rear-view mirrors to look at the elevator. Using the mirror, you make the elevator perfectly faired, and the airplane won't stall, even as slow as 40 knots below stall speed. It just flys a parabolic arc, like what a dart would do if you threw it. But there is no buffet, no increased AoA, no wing drop, no stagnating nose track...

It's a great way to prove that the airplane won't stall unless you make it stall by increasing the angle of attack.
 
I read it as a student pilot; the point point I took from the book is that the "flippers" control airspeed. That alone, for a student pilot, is worth the read.

Oh, yeah, I'm not disputing that it's a good book. It's definitely worth reading.

It's just that I'd heard so much about it that when I read it I expected to have my mind opened to some alternate universe of all things flying. I thought it would make me see flying in a whole new light. It didn't...to me it came across as a good book that told me lots of things I'd already read elsewhere. Sort of a let down after I'd heard so much praise for it.
 
I read it as a student pilot; the point point I took from the book is that the "flippers" control airspeed. That alone, for a student pilot, is worth the read.

but when I move the flippers on the runway it doesn't go anywhere.
 
I have to teach some lessons tomorrow and I am getting some notes put together. One of the subjects within stalls is excessive-back pressure stalls. I've never heard of one and I can't find that term used in any of my books. What does this pertain too?

Just throwing this out...could they be talking about secondary stalls??? That's about the only thing that I could make somewhat fit the description...

I second the say "we've already taught this, so we're good" theory also. It's much easier!:D
 
Sort of a let down after I'd heard so much praise for it.

I think a lot of people praise things because they're supposed to. I feel a lot of older people do that when talking about Shakespeare. Honestly, given how hard that is to read, I suspect that no one would like it much if they didn't know how *great* was.
 
I have to teach some lessons tomorrow and I am getting some notes put together. One of the subjects within stalls is excessive-back pressure stalls. I've never heard of one and I can't find that term used in any of my books. What does this pertain too?

Who and/or what are you writing to? Since I/we and no one else has heard of this particular expression, you must be writing to non-aviation language people.

All stalls are caused by excessive back-pressure. That's a given. What we call a "secondary stall" is excessive back-pressure-too-soon-after-initial-stall-recovery. Is that what you are looking for?
 
Well I found the stall in the old AC61-21A. I think it was the old flying handbook that hasn't been in use for many years.

It is a stall omitted from the new handbook and is like an accelerated stall but it is used to show that even in very steep banks +60 that an aircraft won't roll if it is coordinated.
 
Tgrayson,

I think Cessna's mysterious "excessive back pressure stall" is something that I teach as an "accelerated" stall. Basically I think that he's talking about how the airplane can be stalled in ANY attitude, including pointing straight down, and at ANY airspeed (although you may over-g before getting to the stall).

We do this one also in the tweet, and it's really useful if you are talking about 1 v. 1 maneuvering (for example). Basically, it doesn't matter how fast you go, if you pull the stick or the yoke back you can still stall the airplane (with a few exceptions-- canard aircraft, e.g.).

So if you are trying to turn around on a guy, don't pull to the point of being in the buffet and nose track stopping. You're in a stall at that point, and the other guy will come around the circle and shoot ya!

As for whether you roll or not, that's probably more of a factor if you fly something with a prop. In a jet, you don't get much, if any, roll.
 
Back
Top