In their defense- buying stock back benefits them (mgmt) the best, benefits the shareholders the most, and keeps them in a position for leverage to acquire more, and it works as insurance to assure no private equity firms can sneak up on them buy buying up the shares outstanding. Now in retort- They could have settled the contract AND bought back stock. That would be a good gesture to EVERYONE. By buying shares back they are still looked at as a very vulnerable player due to labor unrest with pilots. I don't know what to say- I know the negotiations with the NMB in kansas start tommorrow, and buying the stock last fall was one of my better stock purchases. I still have high hopes and low expectations from this "paper" company. They have enough cash (320mil-ish) To not only purchase Colgan's Q400's, the CR9's, but also to meet the $18M difference in the pilot contract. They could have done that and bought back $50M in stock. Instead they are having to keep money aside for more penalties that could be looming to NWA for cancellations, training costs due to attrition, and money set aside in case a strike shows up. But heck, I am just a first year FO and a small shareholder.... What do I know?