PIREP's affected area and known icing

PanJet

Well-Known Member
Well, flying the NW in Cessna's and Piper's is a bit of a hassle this time of year. Too much "known icing." A couple other CFI's and I were talking the other day about how large of an area a PIREP affects if it reports known icing. No one seemed to know. We've had several situations where the airport about 40 miles away has had PIREPs of moderate ice while ours has had no reports, and without any AIRMETS we were curious how close the PIREP would have to be to affect us as far as legalities go. I was just wondering if anyone knew anything about this.

Also, another interesting bit of info is that we seem to have come to the conclusion that the only thing preventing Part 91 aircraft (and Part 135 as well I believe) from flying into known icing is whether or not the manufacturer has placarded against it or published it in the POH/AFM. If it's not placarded or plublished as a limitation, there's no legalities against flight into known ice in terms of AIRMETs etc. Any comments/corrections here?

By the way, my comments above are on the legalities of this, not whether or not it's smart. Obviously flying a 152/172 in icing conditions is not smart. ;)
 
If the aircraft is not equiped to deal with icing then the FAA will pin you on 91.13 (a).

At least thats what I would think
 
Also, another interesting bit of info is that we seem to have come to the conclusion that the only thing preventing Part 91 aircraft (and Part 135 as well I believe) from flying into known icing is whether or not the manufacturer has placarded against it or published it in the POH/AFM. If it's not placarded or plublished as a limitation, there's no legalities against flight into known ice in terms of AIRMETs etc. Any comments/corrections here?

Avweb had an interesting article recently:

http://www.avweb.com/news/pilotlounge/194321-1.html

Specifically this part:

If the airplane has a Pilot Operating Handbook and has a limitation or prohibition against flight into known icing conditions, it is clearly not legal.

If the airplane was manufactured prior to about 1976 and has an Owner's Manual (as opposed to a Pilot Operating Handbook) and no Approved Flight Manual, that Owner's Manual probably does not say a word about operation in "known icing conditions," and to do so is probably, but not certainly, illegal. (There was also a period of time when the FAA did not formally certify airplanes for flight into known icing conditions, so whether such operation is legal or not on such things as a Beech 18 involves some serious homework.) There is a gap in the FARs on those airplanes, and it may be that flight into known icing conditions constitutes "careless and reckless" operation rather than operating contrary to the operating limitations of the airplane. The discussion on the legality of flight into icing conditions in those airplanes can get much longer than I'm in the mood to explore. Suffice to say it would make sense if one did not have to do in-depth research to find out if the airplane he or she wanted to fly was legal to fly into known icing conditions.
 
Makes perfect sense, and we all agreed that the FAA would get you somehow. So back to the first part of the thread, what about PIREPs? What's their useful area so-to-speak?
 
Makes perfect sense, and we all agreed that the FAA would get you somehow. So back to the first part of the thread, what about PIREPs? What's their useful area so-to-speak?

I don't think there is any way to give a firm rule. One NTSB case I read pointed out that you need to treat the extent of icing forecasts with a grain of salt, implying you need to add a fudge factor. Obviously, one icing pirep could represent a single, small area of icing, or thousands of square miles.
 
I don't think there is any way to give a firm rule. One NTSB case I read pointed out that you need to treat the extent of icing forecasts with a grain of salt, implying you need to add a fudge factor. Obviously, one icing pirep could represent a single, small area of icing, or thousands of square miles.

That's kinda the same conclusion we came to, but we weren't sure if there was a definite answer. On the particular day that I described in the first post, there were no AIRMETs, yet moderate ice was reported by a CRJ at a nearby airport. A DHC8 coming into our airport reported negative ice, so we went up and shot approaches and there was absolutely no ice.

I've also seen a day just recently where there were no AIRMETs to speak of, yet every other aircraft within 100 miles was reporting at least light icing, usually moderate.
 
Unfortunately that is how icing goes. It pops up in one place and is non-existent in others in the same area. Flying in the upper Midwest in the fall/winter/spring we have to come up with icing strategies. Just like everything else in flying take one step at a time. If the conditions are right for icing (visible moisture and temps around 4 to -10) and you have several exit plans and there is no forecast icing I would go up and try. Just make sure your exit plans are in place. I went up with a student last month when the ceilings were 2,000' AGL and the tops were around 4,500' MSL so just about 1,600' of clouds. We did some approaches and only picked up icing in the very tops of the layer. We climbed a bit more into the sunshine and it melted off. On another approach at the other side of the airport we descended through the layer and picked up no ice so that is how fickle it can be.

Please remember, I am NOT advocating flying into icing conditions--even in a protected airplane (remember those systems are designed to get you out of the ice, not to stay in it). I would look at the PIREPs as a big picture--if there is one icing report and 4 neg icing reports, if I had some exits I might go. However, if there are a few icing reports right where you plan to be, stay on the ground.

I don't plan on getting very much actual during the icing months.
 
I do not believe that PIREPs have any radius of area around them. They simply specify the point at which the PIREP is from.

Usually the AWC is pretty quick to issue AIRMETs if PIREPs for unforecasted AIRMET criteria are reported. If you notice they are being slow, do not hesitate to give someone a ring either at the local WFO - or (if you can find the number) call the AWC directly. Or, if you don't want to do it, and you have an FAA certified Dispatcher at your disposal, they can contact the AWC through the land land and find out what the situation is.
 
Back
Top