skydriverdc6
Well-Known Member
Does anyone have any good examples of a pre-solo written for C172? I've got 3 students almost ready to solo and I've been trying to put one together. Any suggestions?
Thanks in advance
Thanks in advance
From the AOPA Air Safety Foundation (no, like all ASF materials you do not need to be an AOPA member):
http://www.aopa.org/asf/publications/sa04.pdf
jrh, my only comment is that I personally prefer open ended question of multiple guess.
I agree, open ended questions are a much better indicator of knowledge than multiple choice.
Ah. A good reason to use at least some open-ended questions. A chance to highlight early what may be a problem in getting ready for the oral.and sometimes their answers are ambiguous due to poor verbal skills.
Ah. A good reason to use at least some open-ended questions. A chance to highlight early what may be a problem in getting ready for the oral.
Tedious, yes; but also revealing. Time consuming, yes; but that comes with the package. And yes, I'll say it;what about 61.63(c) which seemingly is being ignored:"be able to read, speak, write, and understand..."Allowing the student to have free-form text entry is tedious to grade and sometimes their answers are ambiguous due to poor verbal skills.
it;what about 61.63(c) which seemingly is being ignored:"be able to read, speak, write, and understand..."
It's being ignored because it's irrelevant. Every native born American qualifies for that. The reg is geared towards a minimal competency that is only relevant for those who are not native English speakers.
One size does not fit all.You will not succeed in teaching reading and writing skills that 15 years of schooling could not do.
Both actions can have a learning/teaching value. Why limit youself to one way? A long hand written answer to a scenario question may provide insight you otherwise would not have gotten.Don't buy that. Performing engine out procedures in the airplane is much more valuable than having him write down a list.
The ability to communicate in writing is probably more useless in aviation than almost any other field that comes to mind.
Speaking of English debates, remember that many terms used in FAA lingo, even if they don't have specific FAR definitions, are "terms of art" rather than everyday English. You are making the assumption that "knowledge test" means "a test of any form, written, computerized, or oral, using any form of communication, that tests knowledge." I've heard that interpretation of the reg. It may even be correct, but have never seen any official support for it. Every FAA-related "knowledge test" I'm aware of uses the phrase to mean to a "written" test (although definitely medium-neutral, so computerized tests would be included). Perhaps you can point to just one or two examples where the FAA has used the phrase "knowledge test" to mean something other than "a written or computerized test."As an aside and more a point of useless trivia:
The presolo test does NOT have to be written!
It can be administered orally. You just need to have some sort of documentation you did it. Food for thought concerning the fruitless English debate going on in this thread...
61.87 reads:
(b) Aeronautical knowledge. A student pilot must demonstrate satisfactory aeronautical knowledge on a KNOWLEDGE TEST that meets the requirements of this paragraph:
Ok, I think your experience is with well schooled American kids who are intelligent and can do well with the 3 R's, so a multiple choice is probably all you really need, but there are many other types of people learning to fly here that do need a closer look.
One size does not fit all.
While you're looking around for an FAA example that supports the concept of an oral "knowledge test", you might come across this paragraph in FAA-H-8083-27 - STUDENT PILOT GUIDE:
FSDOs are among the worst sources for regulatory interpretations. They are infamous for shooting from the hip and getting things wrong. Especially orally when there's deniability, but even in writing.The only "example" I can offer you is asking a Minneapolis FSDO inspector face to face and a Denver inspector over the phone