An uninformed opinion

If you figure the cost of flying recreationally the same amount you get to fly as a pilot out of your salary at another "higher paying" job, how much are you really gaining at said job? If you truly love to fly, why not fly and consider the flying time as money in your pocket (that the government cant touch) and live off the "small" salaries as a pilot?

There's a big difference. It's all about having control over your life. An example:

Situation A: $25,000 a year as a professional pilot
100 units of flying fun as a professional pilot

Situation B: $50,000 a year as a professional outside of aviation
$25,000 of that is used to buy 100 units of flying fun doing
aerobatics, or something else that suits you

These situations might be equivalent to you, and perhaps they are, if your life is running smoothly. However, let's suppose you run into a challenge and life gets real. Perhaps you and your wife just had a child that unfortunately has some disability that needs special care, which costs money. In situation B you can immediately cut off your flying to have more resources to take care of your family. In situation A you are stuck with your flying, which is no longer as important. You are left wondering how you will give your child the life he or she deserves.

Another thing, which young pilots might gloss over, is health insurance. While training to get your ratings and working at the lower level jobs (CFI) it is unlikely you will have health insurance from your employer. While at the beginning of your career you are likely in tip-top shape and it is unlikely that you will develop a nasty medical condition, these things do occur. I've had a couple of things pop up that in the end were neither life altering nor medical-affecting, but they were costly and needed to be taken care of. Also, accidents and injuries happen to everyone and are blind to your youth. If you are unlucky and get in an accident without health insurance, it could bankrupt you and anyone who cares for you. At least with the jobs I am looking at, health insurance is more readily provided outside of professional aviation.

Once upon a time assuming these risks was part of how one earned the reward of a big airline job and a very good life for one's family. Those jobs are fading, yet the risk remains.

Life is full of risk, and one should not be afraid of engaging in risky activities. By all means, figure out what your dreams are and pursue them with gusto. Just be aware of the risks you take and make an informed decision.
 
DAnbert,

While getting opinions is great and will help you form a picture in your mind. The truth is that only YOU can decide what matters to you. I for one can't deal with staying still and working in an office or restaurant or hotel. I guess I just have itchy feet and like to see different things. I have planned and made good decisions early on that have made the financial aspect of this industry a little less painful.

I can honestly say that my opinions have changed on a great many things over the past 8 months being on this forum. I can say that in my current family situation that taking out loans and going after this career would not be an option at all. However, on the other hand if I was a single guy, it would not be too terrible to deal with.

My family is used to me being gone for 3-4 weeks at a time and only seeing me 2-3 days a month. This career will bring those numbers down greatly but I will still be away from home quite a bit. I am going to miss some important things in my kids lives. I can only hope they will understand.

I also however know kids that had two parents that both worked and they never saw either parents. What I can do for my kids is give them a mother at this point. Again though that comes down to past planning and decisions I have made.

Be aware of the pros and cons of the business, and try to picture yourself in that situation. Now take a good deal of the fun factor and newness of it all away. Can you still see yourself happy? That is the question you need to ask yourself.
 
I'd really like to look at the flying community in black and white as it seems a lot of people do. Either you love to fly and you've sold out or you're in it for the money. To some, there is no in-between. I'm double-damned since I work for the regionals. To some, it's cool to like to fly in 135 or at FedEx and UPS, they get paid a bit more. If you like your job at the regionals, then you're a sell out and dragging the industry down. I call BS on that. I'm doing all I can to pull the pay and QoL up, but b/c of my attitude towards my job and my job itself, I'm often called a "sell out" or "bottom feeder." That's the main reason I read FlightInfo about once or twice every six months. It normally takes one post on PCL for me to go "Oh yeah. That's why." I knew what I was getting into when I started down this path, almost entirely because of THIS website and the people that contribute to it. I still decided it was better than making $16K a year telling people that their kid's too short to ride Space Mountain.....
 
Naw, the guys that are selling out are the guys that vote for pay cuts for growth at the regional level, fly larger equipment for the same or less money than they're making on their smaller equipment and guys that think that as soon as they get their 1,000 TPIC or whatever it is that they want.

Every entry level aviation job is a bottom feeder job.
 
Situation A: $25,000 a year as a professional pilot
100 units of flying fun as a professional pilot

Situation B: $50,000 a year as a professional outside of aviation
$25,000 of that is used to buy 100 units of flying fun doing
aerobatics, or something else that suits you

The $25,000 as a professional pilot doesn't last forever, though. I think someone can make just as good of a living as a pilot, as they can being a desk jockey. Too many people overexaggerate this idea that being a pilot is a life of poverty, meanwhile everybody else is living the good life. That simply is not true.

Bill collectors do not care that it is only first year pay, or that you "love what you do". I understand that. It is easy to say, "well, you have to love what you do", but somehow you do have to pay the bills. Being a professional pilot is a career that allows you to pay the bills. I agree pilots should make more than a desk jockey, but what I don't understand, is when I hear peopel talk about quitting a "cushy" $70K desk job, and then talk about a $70K regional captain as though they are in poverty, and can't pay bills.

I'll say what I've said before; there is a difference between not making good money, and not making what you deserve. You can make "good" money as a pilot, just not what you deserve.
 
I'll say what I've said before; there is a difference between not making good money, and not making what you deserve. You can make "good" money as a pilot, just not what you deserve.


That's probably a good way of putting it. The thing pilots have against them is that it's a high profile profession that very few of the general public can associate with. They can identify that doctors get paid well b/c they save lives. What the general public often DOESN'T think about is that pilots often do the same thing. Maybe not as often as doctors, but when the pilot manages to get a plane in during a t-storm with hail and a few wind shear alerts or during an engine fire or flight control failure, he/she saves more than one life at that point. Also, if a doctor loses a patient, life goes on for him. Most times, if a pilot fails, life does NOT go on for them. However, the general public sees men and women in uniforms that get to fly all over the place, get paid to do so, and get to stay in hotels without paying a dime. Essentially, the general public, at least in my part of town, think the pilots are paid to be on full-time vacation. This is why people get so upset when "Them dern piluts wahnt mur muhnee!?!?" I'd wager that if most of them got to follow us for a day or two, they wouldn't want to do our jobs as much. My neighbor (the one that said "Wait? Why are you in THIS neighborhood?" when I begrudingly told him I was an airline pilot) was shocked when I told him I could be at work for up to 15.5 hours and only get paid for up to 8.
 
Another problem we face is that I've found most pilots don't really want to talk about how hard the job can be. I mean why would you want to scare the crap out of people? Imagine if you were standing in the cockpit door and somebody complained about the abrupt dive you did out of the middle of nowhere...

"Yes sir, we're sorry about that. You see, air traffic control screwed up and tried to vector us into a 737, so when we got the TCAS advisory we decided that making sure nobody on either flight got killed was a little bit more important than your comfort. Oh and those thunderstorms? Yeah it's not easy picking our way around those, remember that Delta L1011 windsheer accident in Dallas? That would have been us if we didn't fly the windsheer escape profile properly."

But we don't say those things, that would be rude and out of line. We tell people that our job isn't really too hard, we put in long hours but we love what we do! But that's a sham. I sure do enjoy what I do, but I don't do it for the love of it alone. I fly for a living because I'm halfway decent at it, I can tolerate it, it pays the bills, it's challanging and I have room for advancement.

It's all about the love of the game until the rent comes. And believe me, flying for a living looks COMPLETELY different when your on the inside, I can tell you about that one from personal experience. After 3 moves across the country from one coast to the other, a relationship or two sunk because I'm never around and making crap money with no benefits the luster of this career kind of wears off.

But as Lloyd would say, I haven't manned up to quit yet. But I'm with Steve; I'm here to make a POSITIVE impact on the pay rates and work rules that we have to deal with.
 
By not having a lot of clutter in my life I meant my home life. I know that no matter where I work, there will be stuff to deal with that you really didnt want to sign up for. Every police officer I know loves their job but they hate the paperwork that takes the first 2 hours of their day. My boss makes about 3 times what I do but he has to deal with the stress of people like me.
I am not saying that all I want to do is fly no matter what I get paid. What I was trying to say is that I will fight right along with the rest of you to get the pay to where it should be. But I am realistic in thinking that it might not happen right away.
As far as insurance goes, My wife works for the county where we live and gets full paid medical, dental, & vision at no cost for the whole family. This is not an issue for us.
Realm... I do see that side of the coin that is there cashing in on your flying money in a crisis.
 
I know that the first few years suck as a pilot. However, only one or two of my friends from college are making that much more than me. I'm not sure what these "cushy" high paying jobs are. I see a lot of these guys working for a 30-35 thousand dollar salary and putting in 10 hour days. Granted I'm only making 10,000 this year, but I plan on making 20,000 next year and going up from there. I'm guessing that I'll surpass them in about 5 to 10 years.

Furthermore, my Dad is a Capt at a major and will make 300,000 this year, he also has 3.5 million in profit sharing. I honestly don't know anyone else that makes as much as him. Now, even if you topped out at 120,000 at a major you're making more than most people do.
 
Question....

Those saying that pilots routinely are "saving hundreds of lives"

When you get that TCAS RA, are you complying to save the passengers' lives or to save your own life?
 
I don't think there really are a lot of high paying, cushy jobs out there, as some people think. I think you have some rare people who pull very large salaries, but for the most part, they are no more than the percentage of pilots pulling in what your dad makes. You may have a real estate agent in California pulling in $300K/year, because he is getting a comission on a multi-million dollar sale, but the average salary for real estate agents is $35K, which means very few make that much. If you look at any career, it works the same way. You have a rare few who make a VERY large salary; while the vast majority make much less. It is the same in aviation.

I find most of my friends in the same situation as yours. I've yet to have a friend, or family member graduate college, and receive a starting salary over $40K. Most are in the $30-$35K range. One of my friends, a computer information systems graduate, graduated two years ago, and is still making $35K. I think for the ones who do get the much higher starting salary jobs ($50K, $70K to start), they usually do not top off much above that, and within 3-4 years, depending on airline, you'll be making just as much; A lot of the jobs that start with higher salaries, often times do not top off much higher than they start, I find, or at least, that has been the way it has been for my friends/family.

I know that the first few years suck as a pilot. However, only one or two of my friends from college are making that much more than me. I'm not sure what these "cushy" high paying jobs are. I see a lot of these guys working for a 30-35 thousand dollar salary and putting in 10 hour days. Granted I'm only making 10,000 this year, but I plan on making 20,000 next year and going up from there. I'm guessing that I'll surpass them in about 5 to 10 years.

Furthermore, my Dad is a Capt at a major and will make 300,000 this year, he also has 3.5 million in profit sharing. I honestly don't know anyone else that makes as much as him. Now, even if you topped out at 120,000 at a major you're making more than most people do.
 
I don't think there really are a lot of high paying, cushy jobs out there, as some people think. I think you have some rare people who pull very large salaries, but for the most part, they are no more than the percentage of pilots pulling in what your dad makes. You may have a real estate agent in California pulling in $300K/year, because he is getting a comission on a multi-million dollar sale, but the average salary for real estate agents is $35K, which means very few make that much. If you look at any career, it works the same way. You have a rare few who make a VERY large salary; while the vast majority make much less. It is the same in aviation.

I find most of my friends in the same situation as yours. I've yet to have a friend, or family member graduate college, and receive a starting salary over $40K. Most are in the $30-$35K range. One of my friends, a computer information systems graduate, graduated two years ago, and is still making $35K. I think for the ones who do get the much higher starting salary jobs ($50K, $70K to start), they usually do not top off much above that, and within 3-4 years, depending on airline, you'll be making just as much; A lot of the jobs that start with higher salaries, often times do not top off much higher than they start, I find, or at least, that has been the way it has been for my friends/family.

I wasn't trying to say that we'll all make that. Just that there is a possibility. Just like any other risky field. I do know that there is the possibility though.
 
I don't think there really are a lot of high paying, cushy jobs out there, as some people think. I think you have some rare people who pull very large salaries, but for the most part, they are no more than the percentage of pilots pulling in what your dad makes. You may have a real estate agent in California pulling in $300K/year, because he is getting a comission on a multi-million dollar sale, but the average salary for real estate agents is $35K, which means very few make that much. If you look at any career, it works the same way. You have a rare few who make a VERY large salary; while the vast majority make much less. It is the same in aviation.

I find most of my friends in the same situation as yours. I've yet to have a friend, or family member graduate college, and receive a starting salary over $40K. Most are in the $30-$35K range. One of my friends, a computer information systems graduate, graduated two years ago, and is still making $35K. I think for the ones who do get the much higher starting salary jobs ($50K, $70K to start), they usually do not top off much above that, and within 3-4 years, depending on airline, you'll be making just as much; A lot of the jobs that start with higher salaries, often times do not top off much higher than they start, I find, or at least, that has been the way it has been for my friends/family.

Friends of mine who went to work right out of undergrad in mechanical engineering got offers in the 60-80k range. There is plenty of room for income growth in the fields they went into either through climbing the technical ranks or by breaking into management. Benefits were also excellent. Want a master's? They'll pay for it. They could even live the pilot lifestyle (week on/ week off) if they wanted to by working offshore on derricks in the Gulf of Mexico. Pay starts at a good level and will monotonically increase throughout their careers. If they get laid off, they can move to a different company without a significant loss in salary.

Compare this to an airline career, where it would take around 7 years just to reach the salary level you could have had right out of college (1 year of training, 2 years time-building, 4 years FO'ing). Whenever you switch to a major, you get bumped down again. Keep in mind the average number of furloughs each pilot gets throughout his or her career (is it 2?). When this happens you can choose to make nothing while you wait it out or to start over again at the peanut level.

Given this is the way it is, it's hard for me to see how the airline career makes any sense at all. I wish things were different, but they're not. Anyways, maybe that's just me. It all depends on what opportunities you have personally available to you.
 
Just want to chime in here for a sec re: QoL vs. pay issues.

The whole argument on either side is terribly subjective. Guys like Loadmaster and me are going to be taking major pay cuts to go into professional aviation. It's not necessarily that we 'are willing to fly at any price' it's that we've determined that the present course of action (cubicle McJobs, or in my case, home-based McJob about to change) is simply unsuitable for us.

QoL is measured with many more variables than just pay, work rules, retirement benefits, etc - and the scope of that terribly complex equation is entirely determined by the individual sorting it out. I've slugged it out in a field for 13 years which has been good to me, financially and otherwise. I'm ready to do something else. I will eventually fly for a living. And if I get tired of that, I'll do something else. We get only one shot at life. I'm not going to look back on my deathbed and wish I'd flown.

I'm certain that the luster comes off at some point - JTrain's got that. The difference for a lot of us is that we've sampled various careers/lives over the years and we're coming to flying as the next challenge. JTrain may very well decide in a few years to leave flying professionally and maybe...I dunno...teach at the college level - who knows? But his equation will factor differently than Loadmaster's, MTSU's, Doug's, Wheelsup's, DE727's or mine.

Two final thoughts:

1) In any industry, you will never, ever get rich working for someone else. You want real heavy (I call it F. U. money) money? Start your own company. Grow it, sell it.

2) If you absolutely aren't going to start your own company, the next best thing is working in sales. Sales is, in my opinion, the only aspect/position in corporate America where your success is merit-based and financially proportionate to your efforts. Look at the top salesmen at any company - many of them (not all) make as much or more than the CEO, and the CEO is happy with that. They also work their arses off.
 
Bottom line: I'd rather make okay money doing a job I like than rolling in cash doing a job I hate. Notice I said "okay money," which does not mean I'll do it for cheap. Like killbilly said, it's all subjective and it depends a LOT on where you live.
 
Friends of mine who went to work right out of undergrad in mechanical engineering got offers in the 60-80k range. There is plenty of room for income growth in the fields they went into either through climbing the technical ranks or by breaking into management. Benefits were also excellent. Want a master's? They'll pay for it. They could even live the pilot lifestyle (week on/ week off) if they wanted to by working offshore on derricks in the Gulf of Mexico. Pay starts at a good level and will monotonically increase throughout their careers. If they get laid off, they can move to a different company without a significant loss in salary.

Compare this to an airline career, where it would take around 7 years just to reach the salary level you could have had right out of college (1 year of training, 2 years time-building, 4 years FO'ing). Whenever you switch to a major, you get bumped down again. Keep in mind the average number of furloughs each pilot gets throughout his or her career (is it 2?). When this happens you can choose to make nothing while you wait it out or to start over again at the peanut level.

Given this is the way it is, it's hard for me to see how the airline career makes any sense at all. I wish things were different, but they're not. Anyways, maybe that's just me. It all depends on what opportunities you have personally available to you.
I have friends who have gone into engineering too. I'm not saying that ALL jobs that start higher, top off not much higher than that. But, many do. My sister, for example, is in pharmacy school. She will easily get a starting salary in the $70-$80K range, because pharmacists are in huge demand. BUT, most pharmacists do not top off, much above the $90K range, some around the $100K range, if they become a manager, or something like that. BUT, I also know plenty of people who have started in the $60K or so range, and 10 years later, are making maybe $70K. I guess I just look at it from a different perspective. When I look at my family, and friends, I know of none, off the top of my head, making more than $80K. Yet, they all own homes, have families, nice cars, etc. I just don't understand how someone can say those are bad salaries, and they can't pay the bills. I'll agree 100% when someone says it is underpaid for the job; but not when it is made out to be poverty.


Just want to chime in here for a sec re: QoL vs. pay issues.

The whole argument on either side is terribly subjective. Guys like Loadmaster and me are going to be taking major pay cuts to go into professional aviation. It's not necessarily that we 'are willing to fly at any price' it's that we've determined that the present course of action (cubicle McJobs, or in my case, home-based McJob about to change) is simply unsuitable for us.

QoL is measured with many more variables than just pay, work rules, retirement benefits, etc - and the scope of that terribly complex equation is entirely determined by the individual sorting it out. I've slugged it out in a field for 13 years which has been good to me, financially and otherwise. I'm ready to do something else. I will eventually fly for a living. And if I get tired of that, I'll do something else. We get only one shot at life. I'm not going to look back on my deathbed and wish I'd flown.

I'm certain that the luster comes off at some point - JTrain's got that. The difference for a lot of us is that we've sampled various careers/lives over the years and we're coming to flying as the next challenge. JTrain may very well decide in a few years to leave flying professionally and maybe...I dunno...teach at the college level - who knows? But his equation will factor differently than Loadmaster's, MTSU's, Doug's, Wheelsup's, DE727's or mine.

Two final thoughts:

1) In any industry, you will never, ever get rich working for someone else. You want real heavy (I call it F. U. money) money? Start your own company. Grow it, sell it.

2) If you absolutely aren't going to start your own company, the next best thing is working in sales. Sales is, in my opinion, the only aspect/position in corporate America where your success is merit-based and financially proportionate to your efforts. Look at the top salesmen at any company - many of them (not all) make as much or more than the CEO, and the CEO is happy with that. They also work their arses off.
You are right. The people who make the most money, are the ones who own their own business. If you do some research, look up average salaries, you'll find that only about 9% or so, of jobs, have an average salary that extents beyond the $70-$80K range. Those that are pulling in the $200K+ salaries, usually own their own business, within a given field. And, there is no "get rich quick" job. People try to say not to get into aviation for money; well, what job can you get into for the money? None. Start your own business may be a way, but business fail all of the time.
 
Question....

Those saying that pilots routinely are "saving hundreds of lives"

When you get that TCAS RA, are you complying to save the passengers' lives or to save your own life?
That's the line of thought I follow. I could care less for the pax. If I give myself the safest, most comfortable ride possible, then the pax will get it too. They are just lucky to fly with such a self-centered pilot :D
 
You are right. The people who make the most money, are the ones who own their own business. If you do some research, look up average salaries, you'll find that only about 9% or so, of jobs, have an average salary that extents beyond the $70-$80K range. Those that are pulling in the $200K+ salaries, usually own their own business, within a given field. And, there is no "get rich quick" job. People try to say not to get into aviation for money; well, what job can you get into for the money? None. Start your own business may be a way, but business fail all of the time.

They sure do. The thing that attracts me to starting a company is that you're ultimately accountable for making smart decisions, and for the growth of the company. Risk vs. reward. Neither can solely be measured in terms of dollars.
 
They sure do. The thing that attracts me to starting a company is that you're ultimately accountable for making smart decisions, and for the growth of the company. Risk vs. reward. Neither can solely be measured in terms of dollars.

As an employee, you don't have any control over decisions, at all. You simply work for "the man". Owning your own business gives you complete control, and ultimately, whether the company is successful, or not, is in your hands.

You are absolutely correct. Anytime I hear people state a salary that is in the high six figure range, they own their own business, more times than not.

One positive thing about being a pilot, is that with seniority, you can get a lot of time off. With that time, you can run your own side business, and pull in extra income. I know of guys who are 10+ year captains at regionals, who fly as little as possible, on purpose, have 19 days off per month, and run their own side business on those days off. They pull in a good $80K/year with just guarantee (could probably make $100K if they flew more) basically flying part-time, and earn extra cash with a business. VERY few, if any other jobs, would give someone that option.
 
I think a lot of people are like me - they don't necessarily want to fly for a living, they just want to be a pilot. Let me explain.

I've always dreamed of being an airline pilot. I love to fly, but it was mostly because I just thought being an airline pilot would be an awesome career. I still have a tremendous amount of respect for the airline pilots I see passing through the terminal.

When I was looking at changing careers to go into flying, someone asked me if I'd be willing to fly cargo or do something aside from airline flying. The more I thought about it, I realized that I wasn't the least bit interested in sacrificing my current lifestyle for "that" type of flying. So it wasn't flying I was interested into making a career out of, it was airline flying. Sure, I love to fly, but I was only willing to make the financial (and QOL) sacrifice if it were for the airlines. But in listening to airline pilots, I realized that the job rarely keeps the glamour that people like me take into it - which is why so many regional FOs are quitting. I think if you're like me, and have no interest in flying for a living in a capacity other than the airlines, you should do like I did and walk away.

My current job allows me to own a 172, which I use for various personal and business trips. As such, I've been able to keep the love of flying without having to make into a burdensome career.

And just my 2-cents ... money actually does buy a certain amount of happiness. You just have to have been happy without money before that can happen.
 
Back
Top