As the airlines bounce back, will the pay follow suit?

intern_mike

E-175 f/o
After many years of hard times, the airlines seem to be doing better. My question is, will the pay follow suit or just increase to keep up with inflation? From what I understood, everyone sacraficed their pay in order for the airlines to stay alive. Now that they are doing better, will things start looking better for the employees?

For example, my cousin, who is a capn. for United, took a 50% pay cut after 9/11 to keep his job. Can he expect his pay to come back up or is the new standard of pay set. It just seems like if they have made it work with the pay the way it is now, I can't see them doing much about it. Certainly not paying what they were pre 9/11.

FYI: My cousin was a 15 year captain with United flying a 747-400 internationally at $250,000 per year. He now flyes a 777 at around $175,000 per year. Not bad, but certainly not $250,000.
 
I think Steve's right on this one. Why would an employer ever pay somebody more to do a job when theY KNOW they can get them to do it for less?
 
My thinking, while somewhat idealistic, is that the airlines are going to need to increase the QOL for ALL of their employees or face either strikes or a shortage of manpower. Especially if they are turning larger and larger profits. I'm not saying we're at that point now, but things are looking up. From what I understand, FA's are getting screwd the most. When the airlines start seeing serious profits, people will expect to be paid accordingly.

Is it unrealistic to think that if the airlines don't start increasing the QOL for employees there will be a shortage of employees?... at least competent ones.
 
The only way I can see it remotely going up is if ticket prices increase substantially (IMHO they shouldve a long time ago) and as a result unions take some of that extra pie left over. Back in the day, it was a luxury to fly and folks actually dressed up. Unless it gets there again, I don't think so. At least not in todays economy.
 
Naw, after 5 years of this crap there are STILL probably ten thousand resumes at CAL, and they're one of the worst legacy carriers to work for. Even if an entire company jumped ship today, there are MORE than enough over qualified people for those jobs.

I think something that have not realized is that with all this growth at the regional level, people seem to think that if you stick around long enough at a regional you'll get a job at a major airline for sure. But those regional carriers have taken a good chunk of the mainline work, so in addition to providing thousands of qualified jet captains, there isn't even as much work to move to anymore.

My thinking, while somewhat idealistic, is that the airlines are going to need to increase the QOL for ALL of their employees or face either strikes or a shortage of manpower. Especially if they are turning larger and larger profits. I'm not saying we're at that point now, but things are looking up. From what I understand, FA's are getting screwd the most. When the airlines start seeing serious profits, people will expect to be paid accordingly.

Is it unrealistic to think that if the airlines don't start increasing the QOL for employees there will be a shortage of employees?... at least competent ones.
 
Intern mike,

Most pilots, who have not reached top of scale, receive what is called a COLA (cost of living adjustment) in their CBA's (collective bargaining agreements). The trouble is that this "COLA" is, by most measures, not keeping pace with real inflation numbers.

We are still very much in a concessionary environment as, not only paycuts but inflation, errode our compensation and quality of life.

Hope this helps.
 
Intern mike,

Most pilots, who have not reached top of scale, receive what is called a COLA (cost of living adjustment) in their CBA's (collective bargaining agreements). The trouble is that this "COLA" is, by most measures, not keeping pace with real inflation numbers.

We are still very much in a concessionary environment as, not only paycuts but inflation, errode our compensation and quality of life.

Hope this helps.
Concessionary to me means temproary. Eventually the paycuts will end. Also, union contracts expire. What then?
 
Might "bounce" back, might not.

It won't be automatic by any means and each time we agree to fly bigger airplanes for not much more money or just to 'get em on campus' we decrease the probability of bringing the profession back where it used to be.

It'll take A LOT of work, but we have to stop selling ourselves out first.
 
After many years of hard times, the airlines seem to be doing better. My question is, will the pay follow suit or just increase to keep up with inflation? From what I understood, everyone sacraficed their pay in order for the airlines to stay alive. Now that they are doing better, will things start looking better for the employees?

For example, my cousin, who is a capn. for United, took a 50% pay cut after 9/11 to keep his job. Can he expect his pay to come back up or is the new standard of pay set. It just seems like if they have made it work with the pay the way it is now, I can't see them doing much about it. Certainly not paying what they were pre 9/11.

FYI: My cousin was a 15 year captain with United flying a 747-400 internationally at $250,000 per year. He now flyes a 777 at around $175,000 per year. Not bad, but certainly not $250,000.

It all depends, first off, the airlines have to start recording consecutive quarters of a profitability before the conversation comes to the table, also, some of the airlines have ignored their infrastructure, & more money comes to the table, that will need to be addressed sooner or later.

Some of the airlines, have payraises built into the contract already, which may have kicked in already? There are also cost living increases that are automatic.

Also, who knows if the pay raises will ever return to what it was? If the airlines is making money with the new pay rates, then, they have to find out, what is going back to normal? Returning to the old pay rates, could be running in the red again.

So, in the next couple of years, there is going to be plenty of conversations between the Unions & the Airlines.....
 
I think the pay will come back, eventually. Right now, most of the legacies are operating under bankruptcy contracts, intended to save the company from going under. These contracts will be up in the next few years, or so. I think as the airlines start, and continue making large profits, the pay will come back up.
 
It'll take A LOT of work, but we have to stop selling ourselves out first.

That would never happen because of two reasons 1) Alot of people are getting more frugal financially and choosing to live lives that reflect that and will take 40 grand a year very happily and 2) As Brotha J noted there are tons of qualified applicants that will accept piloting jobs at current wages. The only way I see a significant pay increase is if the airlines make significantly more and an orginization (ie. union) fights for those increased profits.
 
One would think that before they agree to give up $$ to save the company, the pilots/employees would have made sure that it was written in the contract that when the company is profitable again, they will get their money back.

Or will the United pilots have to go through another one of those "summers of hell" to get their pay increase like they did before 9/11?
 
Concessionary to me means temproary. Eventually the paycuts will end. Also, union contracts expire. What then?

Gofish has tagged a VERY valid point in CoL increases in contracts. Take PCL and ASA for example. We are/they are taking a CUT every year due to inflation since we're still operating on a contract that became amendable over a year ago. ASA's in worse shape since they've been in negotiations for 4 years(?) now. The only way for those cuts to "end" is to sign a new contract. Right now, if we were to sign the contract management has offered us, we'd be taking some serious hits in not only potential pay but in work rules as well.

As far as union contracts expiring, technically they don't under the RLA. They become amendable. What happens is labor works under the existing contract until a new agreement is signed. It's not like a lot of labor contracts not under the RLA where when the contract expires you find yourself without a net. The downside to this is management can stretch things out in order to prolong any increases in pay or work rules. I doubt our management is chomping at the bit to put any pay increases into play ASAP....

Now, will it bounce back? Don't expect it to bounce back to what it was before. Once the bankruptcy contracts and concessionary contracts become amendable, I think we'll see another upward push. We're starting to see it now thanks to FedEx and UPS. We just need that to happen on the passenger side of things. Unfortunately, I don't think it will happen for several years. Delta and NWA will have to be out of bankruptcy for a few years and management will have to actually RUN THE AIRLINE so they don't go back into bankruptcy. I do feel that the days of going to labor with hat in hand for help are drawing to a close. Too many pilots have been burned too many times by too many different airlines. "Take this pay cut, and we'll grow and get more flying." Ask the Indy Air/ACA guys how well that worked for them. A LOT of those guys wound up at PCL when the music stopped, and I seriously doubt they want to go through that crap again. Most are the biggest STFD supporters in the current negotiations.
 
One thing that I read was that once Southwest's fuel surplus runs out and they raise thier prices then most everyone will follow suit. THEN maybe some of that money might go to the pilots, from the increase in tix. I think that when things are going bad pilot should give a little BUT when things are going well thier respective employers should give a little.
 
A quarter or two of modest profits does not, in my opinion, constitute a recovery of the industry. A few years of sustained, increasing profits does.
That said, there was a lot more going on then just cutting employee wages. That was just the most visibile component of it. In bankruptcy, virtually every contract the airline had was subject to renegotiation. So it wasn't just the employees who were giving back. Every vendor, supplier, mx shop, weather service, catering company, etc probably had to give concessions to XYZ airline, or lose the airline's business.

I experienced it first hand at Air Wisconsin. United wanted us to provide cheaper lift for them. We gave them the best bid we could and still be a viable company ourselves, and it still wasn't good enough. So we lost the contract. Luckily we were able to secure other flying business with USAir. But it was a hell of an upheaval for the company and most of its employees. Unfortunately that's the way it goes.

Another problem with wage givebacks is the "me too" factor. If an airline restores pilot wages to some previous level, it will be about 4 seconds before the rest of the employee groups start clamoring for raises as well. And it won't stop there. Uutside vendors see their airline customers throwing more money at the employees and thinkg "If they can afford that, then they can afford to pay me more as well."

Bottom line. Wages will increase, as nearly all wages do over the course of time, but your won't see any kind of magic "snapback" to days gone by.

This is the new reality of the airline industry. Good or bad, right or wrong.
 
In a macro sense, there really isn't a 'new reality' just that the dynamics changed faster than pilot's attitudes did.

For the history of professional aviation, there have been boom and bust times. In the past, during the 'bust' times, there was a lot more control over the flying, but what's changed today is the amount of flying allowed to be outsourced and the pool of pilots willing to fly it at any cost.

Could you imagine in the 1970's, Northwest outsourcing all of it's DC-9 flying to LowestBidAir? But that's what's being done as we speak under the guise that the world has changed.

It really hasn't beyond our willingness to take it in the rump.
 
You mean UAL isn't going to come banging down my door when I hit 1,000 turbine PIC!? You mean that for every Mesa CRJ-900 that comes online it means that 0.75 of a 737 isn't going to come back online? You mean that we're destroying the industry without thinking ahead?

Oh and BTW, I'm not bitter; I'm realistic. The only people trying to convince me that things are great beacuse the regionals are hiring and that you can make $X a year at Skywest as a captain and that happy days will return are the people that are not quite in this industry yet.
 
You mean UAL isn't going to come banging down my door when I hit 1,000 turbine PIC!? You mean that for every Mesa CRJ-900 that comes online it means that 0.75 of a 737 isn't going to come back online? You mean that we're destroying the industry without thinking ahead?

Oh and BTW, I'm not bitter; I'm realistic. The only people trying to convince me that things are great beacuse the regionals are hiring and that you can make $X a year at Skywest as a captain and that happy days will return are the people that are not quite in this industry yet.

Ya know, I hope PCL does get the 76 seaters, but not b/c I wanna fly a shiny new airplane with a first class section. It's b/c if we don't we'll lose flying. Even if we get them, we're gonna get blamed for taking mainline routes. Guess who's fault it is? The mainline guys that sold the scope out. We WERE limited to 50 seaters, but when the mainline NWA pilots signed that thing they called a TA, it opened the flood gates to sell their own jobs to the lowest bidder. At least they were given a regional airline to go to if they get furloughed.....

The point is the regionals only fly the routes mainline gives them, and mainline only gives them the routes they are allowed to in the pilot contract. Trust me, if NWA could, they'd outsource Airbus flying to the lowest bidder, too. Wouldn't be us. Hell, we might not get the CRJ-900s since we actually want a DECENT wage to fly them. Might wind up over at Mesaba instead....
 
AA management sure was quick to get to the bargaining table. They want to hammer out a new contract before they post some really big number$$$$.

ALPA and the other unions need to grow some balls.
 
Back
Top