Delta RFP Results

Good find Cherokee. . . was just reading that and was going to post it here.

Anyways. . . I'm surprised to see that ALPA even cared enough to meet in Utah, considering the previous trend of ignoring regional issues. Seems that with the PNCL and Mesaba incidents of the recent months, more attention has been provided by ALPA to the regional level.
 
And shortly followed by these words of wisdom for the Mesa employees from the man himself...JO

"It is extremely unfortunate that while we are actively attempting to grow our business and provide new opportunities for our people that the ALPA leadership has chosen to put the interests of employees at other companies ahead of folks here at Mesa. This is the second time this has happened recently regarding new Delta flying. Clearly this press release will do nothing more than hurt our chances at earning new business. One has to wonder if this public opposition to the bid process is given by our local ALPA leaders purposefully or unwittingly. Either way it certainly does not have the best interests of the Mesa pilots in mind, plays into the hand of employee groups outside of our company and could well impact Delta's willingness to direct new business to an ALPA carrier, including Mesa. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions, comments or concerns. Most sincerely, Jonathan"



Cav, where did you get this from? Do you have a link?

Not that I don't believe you, but I would really like to see this. Un-friggin-believable if this is true!









If there was unity at the regional levels, and more and more pilot groups stood up and said NO to this kind of bidding, then management would learn.

If that above is true, and JO said, "Clearly this press release will do nothing more than hurt our chances at earning new business" then that clearly shows you that pilots can make a difference against.


Stand united! I wish all regional pilot groups could unite and stand up. ALPA needs more of these kinds of meetings, and with more regional carriers.
 
Lets see, they just announced that mediated meetings are starting again late this month in our contract negotiations and now these 12 jets from the Delta RFP are up for grabs to the "most cost effective" carrier. Concede or you'll lose those airframes...

I doubt ASA will be painted on the side.
 
Cant we all just get along. Good for Skywest I say. And Sorry to Comair for the loss.

Sorry but I don't think that makes any more sense than the "it's just business and not in my control" excuse. I realize that there are many factors at play here but you know what, you get what you negotiate. By what you negotiate, you enable your management to negotiate.

I really don't mean that personally Kingairer because you seem like a nice guy and generally I agree with what you say. However I just don't think that taking that stance is really feasible. Not to mention you guys at CHQ have a contract coming up and I would think you guys are looking to raise your 70 seat rates. So yes you do have a vested interest in what happens here.
 
Isn't it funny that you never hear people at PDT, XJT, Comair, Horizon, Air Wisconsin, ASA, or ACA (back when) say "it's just business" or "I have control over what management does so I just fly where and what they tell me."????
 
Isn't it funny that you never hear people at PDT, XJT, Comair, Horizon, Air Wisconsin, ASA, or ACA (back when) say "it's just business" or "I have control over what management does so I just fly where and what they tell me."????

Out of curiousity, how many Skywest pilots have you actually seen or heard say "I don't care about Comair pilots" or "It's just business"?

Just wondering who you were talking to.

Just go ahead and move this thread over to FI.

Let's wait until someone calls skywest pilots •. I'd like to see that, personally.
 
Isn't it funny that you never hear people at PDT, XJT, Comair, Horizon, Air Wisconsin, ASA, or ACA (back when) say "it's just business" or "I have control over what management does so I just fly where and what they tell me."????

Maybe they see the big picture, and "get it"
 
Out of curiousity, how many Skywest pilots have you actually seen or heard say "I don't care about Comair pilots" or "It's just business"?

Just wondering who you were talking to.



Let's wait until someone calls skywest pilots •. I'd like to see that, personally.


I never said that I heard anyone say, "I don't care about Comair pilots." However I have heard numerous people at a lot of regionals use the "it's just business" excuse.

Could someone at Skywest confirm that you are voting on a proposal that increases all rates by 1% plus a 5% override for all 70/90 seat flying?
 
All regional pilots are •. Delta wants to get off. You can get a quality, clean • down at Comair, or a cheap nasty one over at SkyWest. Since all that Delta wanted was to get off and fly whey chose SkyWest. It will backfire down the road when Delta gets the crabs.

There I called SKW pilots •

:sarcasm:
 
Regardless, the override that has been proposed for you guys is NOT a division of the single rate system in place since it is still tied to the -200 payrate. So in other words, any future paycuts on the -200 would have an equal negative effect on the -700 and -900.
Nice. In your hypothetical, you're saying that a company in need of paycuts to be competitive would seek only -200 paycuts and not -700/900. That's absurd. If XJT flew 70 seat aircraft and your management needed pay cuts from the pilot group they would seek concessions from all payrates.

Furthermore, all of this is only after every other pilot group has paid the price at the negotiating table for Skywest's single pay rate.

Nonsense. You're shifting blame from the results of 9/11 to SkyWest's pay. How much did a 3 year FO and 5 year CA at XJT get compensated on the 145 back in 2003?
 
I never said that I heard anyone say, "I don't care about Comair pilots." However I have heard numerous people at a lot of regionals use the "it's just business" excuse.

Sorry, that was someone else. However, the question remains: have you heard a Skywest pilot say, "well it's just business"? Because it sounds kind of like you're insinuating that they have that attitude, and that is not what I've found to be the case.

Could someone at Skywest confirm that you are voting on a proposal that increases all rates by 1% plus a 5% override for all 70/90 seat flying?

The pay proposal at skywest (which is all over the internet, including here in the pro pilot forum) is not the only thing currently being considered...
 
I still find it hilarious that pilots are defending their own companies. . . wtf guys? They are all screwing you. No matter who you work for. Colgan Screws you, Comair Screws you, ASA Screws you, SKW Screws you, PNCL Screws you, Mesaba REALLY SCREWS you, XJT. . . well, maybe they don't screw you, Horizon. . . yeah they seem okay too. . .and finally . . . MESA. . . well. . . they RAPE you.

Why defend them?

I suppose it's good that there is still some company pride, but christ. . .not when the rest of the career field is eating poo for it.

I know I'm only a 25 hour newbie pilot person. . . but one thing I've learned in my time spent in the military. . .and working on my ATC-CTI education is that the government is going to take advantage of you, so you better not be hesistant to take advantage of them. Take it for all it's worth, and forget! Perhaps my opinion on this will change, but I doubt it. It's a job, and I want to be paid well for dealing with the responsibility and the risk associated with it. . . and that means more than $19 an hour, or $24 or $35 an hour at 2nd year. . . no matter what company. The love of flying, while great, is not going to put food on the table, savings in the bank, for that day when / if one loses their medical, or go down in a rudder reversal accident, or any other hellish incident that causes death and a family losing a husband or father.

Reference: Why Airline Pilots should make 200K thread in Pro Pilot forum.
 
Nice. In your hypothetical, you're saying that a company in need of paycuts to be competitive would seek only -200 paycuts and not -700/900. That's absurd. If XJT flew 70 seat aircraft and your management needed pay cuts from the pilot group they would seek concessions from all payrates.

Seeing that in most regionals (SKYW included) the -700/-900 pay is normally x% over the 50 seat rate, then the concessions on the -200 would equal concessions on the -700/-900. Re-read what he said. Negative effects on the -200 WOULD have an effect on the -700/-900 pay. I never saw where it said there wouldn't be cuts on the 70+ seaters.

We all need to face facts. Skywest didn't win the contract b/c they're the best regional out there or have the best performance record. They won b/c they low bid everyone else. Comair's 70 seat rates (based on 3rd year pay) are $74 for CAs and $44 for FOs. Skywest? $60/$36. That's a pretty decent chunk of change right there, which allows Skywest management to throw in a lower bid contract. Let's look at XJT. $64/$35. But wait! That's for a 50 seater. Odds are, IF XJT had a pay scale for the 70 seater, it would be more than a $2/$1 an hour raise at 3rd year pay. Even ASA's 70 seat rates are higher than Skywest. So, I DO believe that Skywest's one rate plan allowed them to win the contract. Those of you that point to the new pay proposal, it had nothing to do with the RFP. I highly doubt Skywest said "Well, this is what we THINK is gonna happen, so here's our numbers." They based it off what they had to get the 12 planes and are banking on performance or other wage issues in order to get more flying. Bottom line is, the lower bid due to lower pay scales won the RFP. The only one who could possibly underbid due to wages is Mesa, and their 3rd year CA pay is only $2 an hour less than Skywest on the -700. But Delta's been burned in the short past they've had with Mesa already.....
 
Sorry, that was someone else. However, the question remains: have you heard a Skywest pilot say, "well it's just business"? Because it sounds kind of like you're insinuating that they have that attitude, and that is not what I've found to be the case.



The pay proposal at skywest (which is all over the internet, including here in the pro pilot forum) is not the only thing currently being considered...

zmiller4, in my research I have only come up with the 1% (maybe as much as 1.2%) pay increase along with the 5% override on all 700 and 900 flying. I also understand there is no increase for the E120 Brasilia guys which is a nice divide and conquer tactic. Am I missing anything here? GaTechKid also claims that with these rates Skywest will also exceed the 700/900 pay for everyone but Horizon. I'm not sure that is correct but with my calculations the 700/900 pay with the proposed 1% and 5% override is still only a $1 maybe $2 more per hour than CA pay at XJT on a 50 seater until you get to like 14 year pay. Are you including profit sharing or some other bonus pay in saying that they are the highest paid 700/900 drivers GaTechKid? Is the incentive pay defined and guaranteed or is determined by the company based on "profit" which we all know is a moving target. Please tell me if I'm missing something I want to learn why this is a good proposal. My information is second hand at best.
 
How much did a 3 year FO and 5 year CA at XJT get compensated on the 145 back in 2003?

Well we did something about it! What are Skywest pilots doing about it? Voting yes on this mediocre pay raise AND MOST IMPORTANTLY voting ALPA to stay away surely aren't moving things in the right direction.
 
I'd just like to explain that my point isn't to say SKW is better than regional X. It's to dispute the implied statement I read that SKW (and CHQ) are bottom feeders along with Mesa.

Seeing that in most regionals (SKYW included) the -700/-900 pay is normally x% over the 50 seat rate, then the concessions on the -200 would equal concessions on the -700/-900. Re-read what he said. Negative effects on the -200 WOULD have an effect on the -700/-900 pay. I never saw where it said there wouldn't be cuts on the 70+ seaters.

Kell, Cav said one of the main problems with an override is that a cut to the -200 payrates also cuts the 700/900 rates. This is true. However, the point I tried to bring across (and which I failed at) was that it doesn't matter if you have an override or a split hourly rate when it comes to pay cuts. If management at Pinnacle/XJT/XXX wants to cut your pay on the -200, you can bet your bottom dollar that they will cut the -700/900 as well. -200 pay is tied to -700/900 pay regardless of override or split rates.

GaTechKid also claims that with these rates Skywest will also exceed the 700/900 pay for everyone but Horizon. I'm not sure that is correct but with my calculations the 700/900 pay with the proposed 1% and 5% override is still only a $1 maybe $2 more per hour than CA pay at XJT on a 50 seater until you get to like 14 year pay. Are you including profit sharing or some other bonus pay in saying that they are the highest paid 700/900 drivers GaTechKid?

First, I could be totally incorrect about my assertion. What I previously said had a bit of absolutism to it, and usually when I argue something as absolute I'm categorically wrong. Especially when arguing with the wife. She's too damn smart. Frickin' law students. GRRRR :)

Ok, on with the calculations. I started with Year 5 CA pay. It's $63.29. Add the 1% base rate increase. It's $63.92. Instead of adding the 5% override, add a 4% increase. This is because the override is based on block time only, not soft time like duty/trip rigs. It's $66.48. I then added $5/hr for our operational rewards and profit sharing plan. Profit margins do change and this calculation was based on 6% net income. In today's environment that's a pretty good number to use. So the grand total is $71.48.

Now I disregarded any profit sharing that other companies offer. Does XJT have this? Looking at APC I couldn't find a regional that offered a better 5 year CA rate on a 70 seat RJ, sans Horizon.
 
Ok, on with the calculations. I started with Year 5 CA pay. It's $63.29. Add the 1% base rate increase. It's $63.92. Instead of adding the 5% override, add a 4% increase. This is because the override is based on block time only, not soft time like duty/trip rigs. It's $66.48. I then added $5/hr for our operational rewards and profit sharing plan. Profit margins do change and this calculation was based on 6% net income. In today's environment that's a pretty good number to use. So the grand total is $71.48.

$5/hr for operational rewards and profit sharing! Sorry that sounds a bit steep to me. Also "6% of net income" as you stated would be after taxes and deductions for insurance and any 401k contributions. Those numbers really don't add up. That's why I believe it is important to judge apples to apples. The only way to do this in our business is to look at hourly pay rates. Anything else is great but it's in addition to, not part of.

A lot, if not most of the larger regionals offer profit sharing including XJT, Skywest, and CHQ. I'm all for it but to say that it is part of the hourly pay is not quite right. It's like saying per diem is part of your yearly income...it's reimbursement! Sure we all count on hourly + incentives + per diem to pay the bills so to speak, but unless one company's incentives are outrageously better than anothers, the difference is in the hourly pay. We all know that companies taylor their profits through legal, yet creative accounting methods to meet a desired share for their employees. Don't kid yourself the company knows exactly what they will pay you in profit sharing regardless of what the profit really is.

I'm not saying one company is better than another either. In the regional world that really sounds pretty stupid. However I do believe that we all have an obligation to ourselves, our coworkers, our families, our colleagues at other airlines, and our career expectations to do whatever we can in our power to further the profession rather than handicap it. What's good in the short term doesn't always translate into long term success.
 
I wouldn't use the profit sharing. To me, it's like counting on upgrade time. Even Mesaba has a profit sharing bonus built into their TA, but who knows how much or even IF it will kick in. Besides, profit sharing is a bonus the company doesn't use to determine costs, therefore affecting the bid they can submit for the RFP. So, we can use the $66.48 base rate.

ASA, Comair, Chautauqua/Republic, and Horizon (as you already mentioned) have higher 5 year CA pay rates on the -700. Even Mesa and GoJets are within $2-4 of the Skywest rate. XJT is tought to gauge since they don't even have 70 seat rates. Based on their 50 seat rates in comparison to the other regionals, I'd wager they'd be up there with Comair.

Now, if the $5 you figured in would affect what Skywest could bid, I'd say you have an arguement. BUT, you only get that if Skywest turns a profit, so it's not a cost item they use to determine the bid for the RFP.

I'd just like to say I don't hate Skywest or any other airline. I'm just stating that the regional industry is just continuing to slide more towards the lowest bidder. Comair was once a good regional to go to if you were gonna get stuck at the regionals (more and more likely now a-days). But, losing flying to lower bids, has eroded them to the point where even their wages are going to start sliding down. How long before XJT starts coming back down? Those of us fighting to get better wages in our current contracts are feeling the push already. We're getting the "If we give you that much, we'll lose our flying!" all the time.
 
Back
Top