Dilemna: Airline vs. Corporate/Charter

Mrs. Bee

Well-Known Member
I know someone who is a new hire with a very solid regional airline, but the pay is low and "it is what it is" - it's an airline job. This person has to drive 4 hours to work, but has an opportunity to go to work for a charter company only 1 hour from home, and double his/her income with a more manageable schedule. It seems like a great opportunity. The only thing holding him/her back from the choice of going with this new company is that he/she feels like that the airline trained him/her and he/she wants to give the airline the value of that training. There is no training contract with the airline, so it's just a moral dilemna. However, he/she is also concerned that should he/she want to work for an airline in the future, that airline might not look favorably on the fact that he/she left his/her previous airline after just a few months on the line. He/she worked at a 135 company before, and liked it. I would like to get thoughts from other folks on this issue. Thanks in advance for your wisdom.
 
I know someone who is a new hire with a very solid regional airline, but the pay is low and "it is what it is" - it's an airline job. This person has to drive 4 hours to work, but has an opportunity to go to work for a charter company only 1 hour from home, and double his/her income with a more manageable schedule. It seems like a great opportunity. The only thing holding him/her back from the choice of going with this new company is that he/she feels like that the airline trained him/her and he/she wants to give the airline the value of that training. There is no training contract with the airline, so it's just a moral dilemna. However, he/she is also concerned that should he/she want to work for an airline in the future, that airline might not look favorably on the fact that he/she left his/her previous airline after just a few months on the line. He/she worked at a 135 company before, and liked it. I would like to get thoughts from other folks on this issue. Thanks in advance for your wisdom.

Tell your friend to wake up! Corporate america has no respect or loyalty to its workers. It's loyalty is to self,greed,personal profit & shareholders, more especially at the airlines. Bankruptcy profiteering anyone... Tell your friend to cut & run and not only get better QOL at the corporate but a better salary.

Loyalty to corporations today is for suckers. It's what they (corporate america) try to instill in us workers while they rip us off at the executive level all the while smiling and telling us to continue working harder with/for less reach the american dream!
 
im all for loyalty at a small company where they actually have loyalty to you back, but a regional airline? you are a number...
 
Gotta go with the group on this one. If regionals were more loyal to their pilot groups, this dilemma wouldn't even exist. We've got guys that come to my regional, get their turbine time and jet out the door ASAP. Now, if they would just pay the FOs more, they'd actually SAVE money evey year since they wouldn't be training so many replacements.

If it were me, I'd go for the corporate gig. Less time on the road driving and a more manageable schedule would do it for me. More money would be a bonus.
 
If there should be a hiccup in the business plan at the regional airline exactly how much will loyalty, training etc. factor into the decision to furlough your friend? Zero. That's how much they should factor those things into their decisions.

If there was ever such a thing as corporations showing loyalty to their employees it's long gone - it's every person for themselves. If your friend ever does want to come back to the airlines it's easy to explain at the interview.
 
I would say if they are going to type him in the airplane and the job seems like it will be there next year, run, don't walk out of that regional job. You can always get another regional job if you want, and the chances of your pay going down at the corp job is a lot less than at the regional. The QOL issues and commute seem to seal the deal.
 
You said the regional did not make your buddy sign a training contract. That tells me that he / she is free to leave whenever he / she wants.

I'd be gone so fast that I'd leave tracks.
 
Well, since my kids are preventing me from getting actual work done at the moment, I thought I'd add a few points to this.

First, if the charter opportunity is for PIC turbine, it's an easy choice.

Second, though, is although what has been written in terms of loyalty is true, this is also a small biz, and if one of those people in your flight management was later at another carrier and had some sort of hard feeling about it, it would not be good. It's unlikely, but I have seen it happen.

Third point is not really to this, but to the idea that it is cheaper for them to pay more to prevent the attrition. I can't imagine they haven't done the math on that, and that is why the pay is where it is!
 
Third point is not really to this, but to the idea that it is cheaper for them to pay more to prevent the attrition. I can't imagine they haven't done the math on that, and that is why the pay is where it is!

Might be a difference of "fuzzy math" between the union and the company, but I think it's something like $16K worth of difference.....
 
Might be a difference of "fuzzy math" between the union and the company, but I think it's something like $16K worth of difference.....

Well, since they're paying for that "difference", I would venture that the unions math is missing some components. There is a lot more to some of this stuff than meets the eye, and the company may have hidden costs and/or discounts that they are not sharing.
 
Back
Top