Shot down Russian SU34 pilot / Interrogation/Interview on YouTube

gliderboy

Well-Known Member
Fascinating look at Russian pilots. Ukrainian journalist talks with shot-down Russian pilot, English subtitles in captions. Search YouTube for: Bomber Pilot major Krasnoyartsev Aleksandr / Zolkin Volodymyr
 
"Talk" seems generous, looked like an interrogation to me, but I couldnt make it through the whole hour
 
Not to be THAT guy, but isn’t putting POW’s on tv/internet classified as a war crime? And weren’t we upset when the Vietnamese did it? Did anyone watch his blinking for Cyrillic Morse code? I haven’t watched it (links exist bro) so I can’t tell the context of the “interview” though
 
Last edited:
Not to be THAT guy, but isn’t putting POW’s on tv/internet classified as a war crime? And weren’t we upset when the Vietnamese did it? Did anyone watch his blinking for Cyrillic Morse code? I haven’t watched it (links exist bro) so I can’t tell the context of the “interview” though
They're not 'at war', it's a 'special military operation'. At the end of the interviews (he's done a great many of them) the prisoners are allowed to call home and the interview video is posted on a Russian language site for those family members who want to learn about their loved ones.
 
I'm not a fan of any entity with physical/coercive control over a person putting out anything more than the name, rank and unique identifier stipulated by the Geneva Convention.

I can't get too uppity about war crimes though, because our own legislators and executive enacted a law that said we could invade Den Hague if the ICC tried to prosecute an American soldier (cf. 2002's "American Service-Members' Protection Act").
 
This is an interrogation.......soft as it may be, as imperceptible as it may be to the Fullback pilot. It is funny, putting myself in his shoes, how many SERE alarm bells are ringing as I watch. Still an interesting video. I bounce between feeling an ounce of compassion for a guy who seems to be my nearly exact counterpart (in rank, type of flying, and in flying years) in an enemy Air arm, and being disgusted by the lot of them. @Minuteman, on the notion of war crimes, I'll just say that western/US pilots went to incredibly great lengths to avoid civilian casualties in AFG/IRQ/etc. Like to the point of failing on the battlefield due to conservative rules of engagement. That much is fact, and I saw it first hand in my own cockpit. What russia has repeatedly demonstrated is the exact opposite.....whether the folks pressing the pickle button (such as our Maj here) were aware, the senior level policy is and always has been, burn it to the ground. It is disgusting. I don't think we need to be too introspective when we are disturbed by a complete lack of regard for (innocent) human life on the part of the russian leadership. There isn't an example in nearly 100 years where human life was ever valued by that disgusting "country".
 
This is an interrogation.......soft as it may be, as imperceptible as it may be to the Fullback pilot. It is funny, putting myself in his shoes, how many SERE alarm bells are ringing as I watch. Still an interesting video. I bounce between feeling an ounce of compassion for a guy who seems to be my nearly exact counterpart (in rank, type of flying, and in flying years) in an enemy Air arm, and being disgusted by the lot of them. @Minuteman, on the notion of war crimes, I'll just say that western/US pilots went to incredibly great lengths to avoid civilian casualties in AFG/IRQ/etc. Like to the point of failing on the battlefield due to conservative rules of engagement. That much is fact, and I saw it first hand in my own cockpit. What russia has repeatedly demonstrated is the exact opposite.....whether the folks pressing the pickle button (such as our Maj here) were aware, the senior level policy is and always has been, burn it to the ground. It is disgusting. I don't think we need to be too introspective when we are disturbed by a complete lack of regard for (innocent) human life on the part of the russian leadership. There isn't an example in nearly 100 years where human life was ever valued by that disgusting "country".

And I would add - given the massive agitprop of the Russians - truly the only thing they seem great at - and the overwhelming Russian (and Crimean) broadcasts of the war and public perception - this serves as both a counter to that, as well as an important historical marker for future generations (i.e. Ike ordering documentation/filming of liberated concentration camps). Just as with the Holocaust, there will be deniers. Document the atrocities from as many viewpoints as possible.

And for all the "Fake News!" protests from the right-wing here - Russia's skill at propaganda and the USA's seeming incompetence in combating that is absolutely something that needs to be improved. If part of the current models of counter-insurgency is "Hearts and minds" winning...our incompetence at the anti-agitprop stuff really makes that not workable.
 
possible.

And for all the "Fake News!" protests from the right-wing here - Russia's skill at propaganda and the USA's seeming incompetence in combating that is absolutely something that needs to be improved. If part of the current models of counter-insurgency is "Hearts and minds" winning...our incompetence at the anti-agitprop stuff really makes that not workable.
I agree with this to an extent.

We’re only seen bad at anti-right wing agitprop in America. Our anti-left wing prop is on point; people working at Amazon and Walmart often oppose unions. Our anti-left wing agit prop is so good we actually we had police murder a dude on camera and a large percentage of the population wore a logo supporting the cops! During the subsequent riots people were more worried about a burnt down Target than the roving police gangs that shot people with paint balls on their porch.

We are really good at knocking down any sort opposition to the status quo that is remotely opposed to power structures here in America. Foreign stuff, and nationalist stuff? We ain’t great at it.
 
This is an interrogation.......soft as it may be, as imperceptible as it may be to the Fullback pilot. It is funny, putting myself in his shoes, how many SERE alarm bells are ringing as I watch. Still an interesting video. I bounce between feeling an ounce of compassion for a guy who seems to be my nearly exact counterpart (in rank, type of flying, and in flying years) in an enemy Air arm, and being disgusted by the lot of them. @Minuteman, on the notion of war crimes, I'll just say that western/US pilots went to incredibly great lengths to avoid civilian casualties in AFG/IRQ/etc. Like to the point of failing on the battlefield due to conservative rules of engagement. That much is fact, and I saw it first hand in my own cockpit. What russia has repeatedly demonstrated is the exact opposite.....whether the folks pressing the pickle button (such as our Maj here) were aware, the senior level policy is and always has been, burn it to the ground. It is disgusting. I don't think we need to be too introspective when we are disturbed by a complete lack of regard for (innocent) human life on the part of the russian leadership. There isn't an example in nearly 100 years where human life was ever valued by that disgusting "country".

Been on both sides of that "interaction" both as a training exercise and a live or death situation. Train as you fight; fight as you train. The fear factor is going to kick in cause you don't know what you don't know.

Pilot did his job. Wasn't as successful as he would have liked to have been. Better to have been a pilot than a ground pounder in that same situation. . .if there's any upside to his situation.
 
Ukraine is definitely the “good guys” but this and the “war crimes” trial they just put on leave a bit of a bad taste in my mouth. I can’t even imagine what it’s like having your country flattened by your neighbors who want a bit more land for…reasons…but I feel like there will be plenty of opportunities to chat with shot down Russians and conduct war crimes trials after this is all over.
 
Ukraine is definitely the “good guys” but this and the “war crimes” trial they just put on leave a bit of a bad taste in my mouth.
Should they wait the ~25 years it takes for the Hague to get around to processing the interminable appeals and points of order? The guy is on (digital) film shooting an unarmed old man in the back, and much of the purpose of enforcing the Law is deterrence. Would you feel differently about it if they just tried him in a normal criminal court? The reason we haven't seen more of this sort of thing over the last ~50 years is that the countries suffering the war crimes no longer had a functional government...which was of course the obvious intention of the Russian invasion. Achievement NOT unlocked. The Ukraine persists as a State. With courts. And gallows.

Edit: I do think that the uh "interviews" are pretty obviously contrary to the rules of War, but the Russkies aren't exactly following those to the letter themselves, and I suppose the Ukranians made the calculation that countering Russian agitprop was more important than maintaining a squeaky clean image for the consumption of...who, exactly? Brussels? I don't think the civilized world is going to switch sides because they engaged in some naughty camera-work, and the countervailing force is not just their soldiers and civilians dying in serious numbers, but their economy and infrastructure being crushed for a generation to come.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely. He committed murder and can be tried for such. We’ve tried our own troops for the same in similar circumstances. Calling it a war crime is propaganda and counter to Ukrainians wanting to be seen as a EU/NATO candidate state with the same values.
 
This is an interrogation.......soft as it may be, as imperceptible as it may be to the Fullback pilot. It is funny, putting myself in his shoes, how many SERE alarm bells are ringing as I watch. Still an interesting video. I bounce between feeling an ounce of compassion for a guy who seems to be my nearly exact counterpart (in rank, type of flying, and in flying years) in an enemy Air arm, and being disgusted by the lot of them. @Minuteman, on the notion of war crimes, I'll just say that western/US pilots went to incredibly great lengths to avoid civilian casualties in AFG/IRQ/etc. Like to the point of failing on the battlefield due to conservative rules of engagement. That much is fact, and I saw it first hand in my own cockpit. What russia has repeatedly demonstrated is the exact opposite.....whether the folks pressing the pickle button (such as our Maj here) were aware, the senior level policy is and always has been, burn it to the ground. It is disgusting. I don't think we need to be too introspective when we are disturbed by a complete lack of regard for (innocent) human life on the part of the russian leadership. There isn't an example in nearly 100 years where human life was ever valued by that disgusting "country".
Oh, gawd I watched 60 secs. of this video. Name your classmates, nothing will happen to them? Either he was tortured threatened or a stooge. and I have never been through SERE but there was nothing voluntary about that interrogation.
 
Oh yeah, ubiquitous cameras and the bodies to prove, or even just the looting by soldiers, leaves with me no doubt that Russians are a bunch of •-asses in numbers that should be prosecuted. I did not mean to equate, say, US coalition air mission destroying an electrical substation as exactly same thing as Russia attacking a grain elevator (or using the MSF-provided hospital locations in Syria as a list of targets).

I cringe at Americans' indignation about "war crimes" because the United States has rejected the Hague's authority to prosecute US armed forces; like the administrations really do believe we are the world's police force and should have some kind of qualified immunity. We cannot have it both ways.
 
Oh yeah, ubiquitous cameras and the bodies to prove, or even just the looting by soldiers, leaves with me no doubt that Russians are a bunch of •-asses in numbers that should be prosecuted. I did not mean to equate, say, US coalition air mission destroying an electrical substation as exactly same thing as Russia attacking a grain elevator (or using the MSF-provided hospital locations in Syria as a list of targets).

I cringe at Americans' indignation about "war crimes" because the United States has rejected the Hague's authority to prosecute US armed forces; like the administrations really do believe we are the world's police force and should have some kind of qualified immunity. We cannot have it both ways.

Yeah I gotcha. We (unfortunately) have had examples of wanton disregard for the laws of armed conflict, without a doubt. Just thought it was worth noting that the vast majority of us really have tried very hard to ensure this exact sort of thing never happens on our watch. I wouldn't be able to live with what a lot of these russians will have to, on my conscience.....which is the part that makes me pity them in some small way. F*** them for doing it while being blinded by whatever idiocy they are being told, but one day they will understand the truth, and they will be the only one to answer for it. Whether that is just a self realization that drives them to drink themselves to death, or they actually stand trial in some sort of international tribunal (unlikely), the end is the same.....their lives and their families lives will be ruined, for generations, all so that some despicable moron (putin) could try and establish his legacy before his early death.
 
I cringe at Americans' indignation about "war crimes" because the United States has rejected the Hague's authority to prosecute US armed forces; like the administrations really do believe we are the world's police force and should have some kind of qualified immunity. We cannot have it both ways.
This seems rational to me.

We are a nation obsessed with punishment - we incarcerate so many people, and honestly we’re excited about it. We have TV shows detailing how •ed up our prisons are. We include the idea of being prison raped as a valid punishment for any person misfortunate enough to be subjected to the system. We incarcerate kids, the elderly, those whose crimes literally have no victims. We lock people away who have mental illness, substance abuse issues, and those who came here without permission. As a society, I think the purest manifestation of our puritanical culture is the extent to which we punish. It’s the theological underpinning of our uniquely American identity; many of us truly believe that people are evil and must be punished.

So, I see the outrage not so much as a desire for us to be immune from punishment, or some hypocritical desire to remain unpunished for our collective transgressions.

No - like sharks smelling the blood in the water, we get off on the idea that there is a new badguy that we will soon be able to subject to our authority.

We don’t even see our own transgressions as a culture. We’re blind to it. We’re the “Punisher”- not the recipient of punishment. Through that lens I think this idea makes total sense - combine that with the subtle racism of “these refugees look just like me!” and you end up with a population frothing at the mouth to drag these monsters to The Hague.

Now, don’t get me wrong - I truly believe that the commission of these crimes is an unspeakable horror, and we cannot let this go unquestioned or simply pass by without the requisite consequences being rendered. However the outrage in our society presently over this is completely unsurprising to me. This gives us a new outlet to focus our desire to punish.

The fact that we didn’t care about the war crimes we were committing during the last 20 years of our own wars makes complete sense - we were “punishing” the people of Iraq and Afghanistan, so “they deserved it.”
 
Agree with you about the American fetish for punishment. Disagree that we "didn't care" about war crimes in Iraq and Afghanistan. At least I certainly did/do.
 
We lock people away……..and those who came here without permission.

Not correct. People aren’t locked away merely for coming here without permission. They may be in temporary detention pending deportation, but they aren’t locked away, as in a prison sentence, for that transgression.
 
Back
Top