College degree requirement


This is the book I wish I had when I was starting out, by none other than my undergrad college's former enrollment director. It's honest, refreshing, and pragmatic almost to the point of shrewd.

I'd also point out COVID-19 has turned the higher ed business on its ear, possibly more vigorously than it turned the airline business on its ear.

This one is rather unflattering about the whole selection process for undergrad, too:
 
Which is complete and total •. I was asked point blank why my undergrad GPA was a 2.96 and not higher at a career fair, and the truth is my Dad got cancer in my sophomore year of school and my GPA never recovered. That same person also didn't want to hear anything about me attending law school.

But other people being • bags isn't a reason for us to bag on others without knowing their story. Success is success however long it takes you to overcome the barriers that exist in life.

I don't understand the question about a GPA. Back in the day, that narrative may have meant something. Today? My believe is that a GPA means little. No one cares really. Truly. Various reasons why people do not graduate cum laude or more. People work and go to school. I know at least three law school grads with high GPAs who are still struggling to pass the bar exam. . .huh?

It's the whole person that matters. Period. I also think it's stupid when people say they know good pilots and bad pilots. That sounds dumb to me. Good/bad is a rather subjective viewpoint, right? What's education got to do with it? What's race or sex have to do with it? What political/religious or sexual preference have to do with being a good/bad pilot? Answer? Zippo.

This "degree narrative" seems only to come up. . .when people don't have degrees. Silly.
 
I don't understand the question about a GPA. Back in the day, that narrative may have meant something. Today? My believe is that a GPA means little.
It's merely a measure of how person X can complete a course of study and how much time they can spend on it, I think. Which is why, just like years of college, as opined above by @jtrain609 it can be a BS metric, because life happens.

When I was on Associated Students at the CSU, one of the things I realized in a hurry is that the majority of college dropouts and academic probation or disqualification cases were not solely for academic reasons. More often than not there was an economic or family reason for the disqualification or probation. Simply, there was not enough time in the day to do it all.

(I favor far more lenient institutional policies, especially as regards part-time or flex enrollment and longer withdrawal for "serious and compelling" reasons windows, but don't try to tell an administration who are obsessed with their FTES count, which is where they get their money, of course, such a thing!)

It's a metric with limitations. Nothing more or less.
 
Let's be clear that you're humping the pine for flight ops and not the Association right now, thanks. ;)

I feel like I opened him up to your slight dig, by posting what I did, and that wasn't my intent. ALPA (any union actually) at certain properties does an awesome job of running off good volunteers who really do want to help the pilot group but don't always bow to leadership or parrot a leadership line if it's wrong or dumb. Unfortunately, in many cases, leadership of a union is a popularity contest and the guys who say the things that pilots want to hear, regardless of their basis in reality, tend to get elected. In general, committee workers grind out the hours, but you serve at the pleasure of the MEC and often times become collateral during an MEC change or an MEC trying to keep the pilots happy by making big gestures rather than putting in the work.

It's not unusual for guys who really do want to make a difference for the pilots to end up in Flight Ops after a union boots them. This isn't to be confused with union leadership who move over to Flight Ops leadership to keep being somebody in a position of power.
 
I feel like I opened him up to your slight dig, by posting what I did, and that wasn't my intent.
Oh, indeed. I'm mostly giving Dr. F/O @jtrain609 J.D. (aka "•er") a hard time and with the best of intentions as I have for a decade plus now.

(Familiar with the remainder, and agreed wholeheartedly.)
 
My daughter took the PSAT as a Sophmore in HS as all Texas students do in the fall. Starting in January she started getting mail. The first week it was fun - all these big envelopes and glossy brochures. We figured it'd go a week or two tops. In continued daily for the next 2 years - minimum 10 pieces per week. She eventually just stopped opening them daily - she created piles to be read every couple weeks based on Conference - SEC/PAC12/Big 10/Ivy etc. She even had one stack, from Sarah Lawrence/Bryn Mawr/Vassar/Wellesley that she named "Man-hating militant lesbian schools". These schools offered bigly stuff.

Anyway, I asked her what she really wanted out of college. She said "I want to do something with math. And make a lot of money".

She ended up going to UT-Dallas because she wanted to stay in Texas, and because they offered her the best deal - a full-ride for 4 years plus a stipend. She said an actuarial science degree pays the same wherever it's from and that was her decision. Couldn't fault the logic, but I did want her to pursue more "flashy" things. Anyway, she is now graduated, no debt, got paid to go to school and has her first big girl job. So it worked out for her.

What interested me was how the colleges decided to target her. In the SEC, only Vandy mailed. PAC 12 - only UC Berkeley and UCLA, in fact, the only schools west of the Mississippi that pursued her were Colorado School of Mines, UC-Berkeley, Stanford, UT and UT-D. A YUGE number of the Big 10 - MI, MI State, Wisconsin, Northwestern, OSU, Iowa mailed her frequently. The Ivy's - Harvard, Yale, Brown, Penn, Columbia but not Princeton or Cornell (which I consider the Trump U of Ivy's anyway). It was just odd why some schools within a given league will pursue while others don't. And odd geographically that they had her pegged east of the MS and lightly recruited west.
 
My daughter took the PSAT as a Sophmore in HS as all Texas students do in the fall. Starting in January she started getting mail.

Hah! Even 25 years ago. Jesus, sorry, 30 years ago, this was ops normal. It will surprise exactly no one who knows me that, while I scored well on the PSAT and SAT, I was an utter crap high school student. Like kinda-almost-nearly flunked and got held back from Senior year, due to adolescent got-it-all-figured-out-don't-care-damn-the-man, etc.

Meanwhile, I was getting absolute sheaves of junk mail from schools which would NEVER under ANY circumstances, in a MILLENNIUM of Sundays have admitted me. Not Ivies, obviously, but pretty solid low-second/high-third tier schools, which, again, would have looked at me like something they'd scraped off their shoe once they'd had my transcripts.

The only rational reason I can see for this behavior is that they wanted to up their standardized test score average, and the right hand wasn't talking to the left regarding whether it was worth it to mail all of those glossy brochures to some kid who was basically plutonium by any other metric.

It all worked out for me, weirdly, and I wound up exactly where I should have been. But boy, howdy, the system is BROKEN. I mean I think test scores are important indicators of whether one might have the intellectual horsepower/educational experience to handle what's thrown at them, but at best they're a good barrier to entry, not an indication that one will excel, nor yet even just show up and not suck.
 
And by paying for it will his kids appreciate the education? Shouldn't they be made to find their own way to pay for college.

I mean, debt isn't the only way.

It's a cultural thing.

Yes and no. It depends on how you’re raised and what values are instilled by your parents. While money was never a problem for me as as a kid growing up, I was taught about the value of money, spending, saving, etc.

So compared to my cousin in NYC, he’s also got rich parents and they paid all 4 yrs of his college (Columbia, an Ivy League). My father asked him how much tuition was per semester, and he said 3,000. My father said that sounds low, is that per month? Cousin said, no per semester. Father replied that is way too low. Cousin said, oh, well maybe it’s 30,000 then.

Like I said, clueless about money. A guy who talks nochalantly about 3,000 vs 30,000 is clearly clueless.

Me?

I ran the math of college tuition per semester, then took the total amount of classes per week per semester, broke it down by how many hours of class per week, and finally came up with my hourly cost for college - how much one hour of class cost.

It was $115.

Having worked a min wage job in summer after high school, before college, making $5.15/hr (something by cousin never did), I realized just how much $115 is. I never skipped class in college (unless I was sick). I realized how much it cost and was going to get my money’s worth. Cousin on the other hand, skipped here and there. Still passed but skipped when he wanted.

I try to respect and be careful with money. I think I was taught well, and hope to do that with my kids.
 
Hah! Even 25 years ago. Jesus, sorry, 30 years ago, this was ops normal. It will surprise exactly no one who knows me that, while I scored well on the PSAT and SAT, I was an utter crap high school student. Like kinda-almost-nearly flunked and got held back from Senior year, due to adolescent got-it-all-figured-out-don't-care-damn-the-man, etc.

Meanwhile, I was getting absolute sheaves of junk mail from schools which would NEVER under ANY circumstances, in a MILLENNIUM of Sundays have admitted me. Not Ivies, obviously, but pretty solid low-second/high-third tier schools, which, again, would have looked at me like something they'd scraped off their shoe once they'd had my transcripts.

The only rational reason I can see for this behavior is that they wanted to up their standardized test score average, and the right hand wasn't talking to the left regarding whether it was worth it to mail all of those glossy brochures to some kid who was basically plutonium by any other metric.

It all worked out for me, weirdly, and I wound up exactly where I should have been. But boy, howdy, the system is BROKEN. I mean I think test scores are important indicators of whether one might have the intellectual horsepower/educational experience to handle what's thrown at them, but at best they're a good barrier to entry, not an indication that one will excel, nor yet even just show up and not suck.

You and I had a similar attitude towards high school. I absolutely HATED it, and basically didn’t go to class.

Fortunately for me, a high school dropout, I was able to go to community college and then transfer to a very good state school. No SATS required.

That seems to be this amazing hack that people just refuse to acknowledge for some reason. Perhaps ego, I don’t know. But going to community college for a couple of years is very cheap, you take the same classes that everyone does the first year or two, and then you can transfer to a good school when you’re ready.
 
But going to community college for a couple of years is very cheap, you take the same classes that everyone does the first year or two, and then you can transfer to a good school when you’re ready.

Even the weirdo school at which I wound up required that I do a little bit of hell-incarceration at a CC to prove that I was, you know, salvageable. And they weren't wrong to do it. If I had any illusions about what life was going to be like if I didn't straighten up and fly right, they were RAPIDLY dispelled by that experience.
 
You and I had a similar attitude towards high school. I absolutely HATED it, and basically didn’t go to class.

Fortunately for me, a high school dropout, I was able to go to community college and then transfer to a very good state school. No SATS required.

That seems to be this amazing hack that people just refuse to acknowledge for some reason. Perhaps ego, I don’t know. But going to community college for a couple of years is very cheap, you take the same classes that everyone does the first year or two, and then you can transfer to a good school when you’re ready.

Yup. Hidden secret. There’s nothing wrong with going to, say, Penn State satellite campus (over a dozen) and then transfer to University Park the last two years.
 
Perhaps ego, I don’t know.
Hundred percent. When everyone around you is going to (wherever), and so on.

What interested me was how the colleges decided to target her. In the SEC, only Vandy mailed. PAC 12 - only UC Berkeley and UCLA, in fact, the only schools west of the Mississippi that pursued her were Colorado School of Mines, UC-Berkeley, Stanford, UT and UT-D. A YUGE number of the Big 10 - MI, MI State, Wisconsin, Northwestern, OSU, Iowa mailed her frequently. The Ivy's - Harvard, Yale, Brown, Penn, Columbia but not Princeton or Cornell (which I consider the Trump U of Ivy's anyway). It was just odd why some schools within a given league will pursue while others don't. And odd geographically that they had her pegged east of the MS and lightly recruited west.
The institutions all have their little idiot idea of what their ”perfect” incoming freshman class looks like and most public universities that don’t have some sort of requirement to accept from a given local area (in other words, quite a lot of them) further have a “profile” of every high school in a given ZIP Code and know what is exceptional and isn’t. They market thereon; the PSAT is where they start. That Selingo book, above, is a combination of “really?” “ugh” and “huh.” (See also, which is an obvious consequence of that profile.)

I’d imagine Texas and the University Thereof at Dallas likely has some sort of “thing” similar to a Cal Grant for outstanding in-state students, as regards financial aid; from your description of your daughter’s aid package, which was considerable indeed, it sounds far better than a Cal Grant. (I can’t remember what the next tier up from that was for California’s public universities.)
 
You and I had a similar attitude towards high school. I absolutely HATED it, and basically didn’t go to class.

Fortunately for me, a high school dropout, I was able to go to community college and then transfer to a very good state school. No SATS required.

That seems to be this amazing hack that people just refuse to acknowledge for some reason. Perhaps ego, I don’t know. But going to community college for a couple of years is very cheap, you take the same classes that everyone does the first year or two, and then you can transfer to a good school when you’re ready.
That’s what I did for a year to knock out some prerequisites. Whatever, it’s undergrad. No one cares how or where you got the degree, only that you did.
 
That seems to be this amazing hack that people just refuse to acknowledge for some reason. Perhaps ego, I don’t know. But going to community college for a couple of years is very cheap, you take the same classes that everyone does the first year or two, and then you can transfer to a good school when you’re ready.

This is doubly important for the kids who don't know what they want to major in. They can take some time and mature and develop without breaking the bank.

Do NOT go to college without a rough idea of what you want to study.
 
This is doubly important for the kids who don't know what they want to major in. They can take some time and mature and develop without breaking the bank.

Do NOT go to college without a rough idea of what you want to study.

I kind of agree…except for that at a number of schools, you go to figure out what you want to study.

I went to college thinking I wanted to major in Latin American studies or physics, with the idea of going into law or graduate engineering school.

That changed after a year and I ended up majoring in geology, which has worked out really well (but there was a decade of flying in between).

From what I’ve heard, if you want to get into TAMU engineering you pretty much have to declare that as an 8th grader so you get on a stem track in HS.

I think that’s insane and unless my kids show some crazy ability, I won’t support pigeonholing them as 14yr olds.
 
Back
Top