DispatcherSam
Well-Known Member
My first airline used to have an exemption for this in addition to 3585 or whatever you confounded kids are calling it these days. The other exemption was only really good for flights less than 45 mins long
It's essentially when you have weather that is right around mins but the TAF is illegal but generally correct so you call either NWS, WSI or another source of forecasts and hint that you want a forecast that is legal. Even if you don't think the weather will actually be above mins when you get there.What do you mean by "weather shopping"? I've heard of the term "helicoptor shopping" in the HEMS industry. That's when a hospital will call for a helo but get turned down due to wx THEN call another helicopter service but not tell the crew that they were already denied by the first helicopter due to wx.
Is this ever looked down upon by the FAA or examined as a possible accident cause by the NTSB should one occur? A good example would be lets say you have an airport where they are reporting winds that exceed the limits of the aircraft. The better forecast you request deletes the winds. The aircraft overruns the runway on landings. Would the NTSB say that had the enhanced forecast played a role leading up to the accident?It's essentially when you have weather that is right around mins but the TAF is illegal but generally correct so you call either NWS, WSI or another source of forecasts and hint that you want a forecast that is legal. Even if you don't think the weather will actually be above mins when you get there.
Absolutely. You would have to have a good answer for why you wanted a second opinion. On the other hand however, if a forecast says an airport will be 1/4sm for the next 5 or 6 hours and the vis has been increasing and has been at over a mile for a bit, it is perfectly ok to call and ask them to take a look at it.Is this ever looked down upon by the FAA or examined as a possible accident cause by the NTSB should one occur? A good example would be lets say you have an airport where they are reporting winds that exceed the limits of the aircraft. The better forecast you request deletes the winds. The aircraft overruns the runway on landings. Would the NTSB say that had the enhanced forecast played a role leading up to the accident?
Winds are irrelevant when deciding whether it's legal for dispatch or not, beyond carrying a wind alternate. You dispatch off visibility.Is this ever looked down upon by the FAA or examined as a possible accident cause by the NTSB should one occur? A good example would be lets say you have an airport where they are reporting winds that exceed the limits of the aircraft. The better forecast you request deletes the winds. The aircraft overruns the runway on landings. Would the NTSB say that had the enhanced forecast played a role leading up to the accident?
But if the reported winds would be outside the aircraft limitations such as a tailwind, then you couldn't release the aircraft.Winds are irrelevant when deciding whether it's legal for dispatch or not, beyond carrying a wind alternate. You dispatch off visibility.
You land on the opposite runway thenBut if the reported winds would be outside the aircraft limitations such as a tailwind, then you couldn't release the aircraft.
I have never heard of getting a Ram TAF for winds.Just visibility. It usually happens at out stations that don't get ammended TAFs. The TAF is showing a quarter mile but the metar is showing 2SM, you call and get one, and then hopefully in about 15 minutes you have a legal TAF to dispatch too.But if the reported winds would be outside the aircraft limitations such as a tailwind, then you couldn't release the aircraft.
What do you mean by "weather shopping"? I've heard of the term "helicoptor shopping" in the HEMS industry. That's when a hospital will call for a helo but get turned down due to wx THEN call another helicopter service but not tell the crew that they were already denied by the first helicopter due to wx.
But if the reported winds would be outside the aircraft limitations such as a tailwind, then you couldn't release the aircraft.
What's the point of a WIND alternate? All you need for dispatch is visibility. That's it. Have you gotten your license yet? Obviously NOT.But if the reported winds would be outside the aircraft limitations such as a tailwind, then you couldn't release the aircraft.
What's the point of a WIND alternate? All you need for dispatch is visibility. That's it. Have you gotten your license yet? Obviously NOT.
I think you misunderstood me. That's what I was saying. Just because winds are forecasted to be beyond what we need for landing (i.e. crosswinds forecast beyond limits at a single runway airport) doesn't mean you can't dispatch it. I wouldn't bother getting an EWINS forecast in that situation. But yes, you would need a wind alternate if winds are forecasted to be out of limits. A1 was saying you can't release if the winds are forecasted out of limits.121.195(e) says you need one.
But if the reported winds would be outside the aircraft limitations such as a tailwind, then you couldn't release the aircraft.
Maybe I'm being picky....ok I am being picky...but you can't do that at Aspen or Sun ValleyYou land on the opposite runway then
I get that all operators are different in terms of their criteria for a legal dispatch. This excerpt was from a NWA Airlink flight that crashed in traverse city, MO years back. Emphasis mine.Winds are irrelevant when deciding whether it's legal for dispatch or not, beyond carrying a wind alternate. You dispatch off visibility.
Or Oaxaca, but those require a wind alternate at all times if i'm not mistaken.Maybe I'm being picky....ok I am being picky...but you can't do that at Aspen or Sun Valley![]()
Whoever wrote whatever article you are referencing was wrong. I'm guessing they probably never dispatched a flight. Whether you can dispatch a flight or not depends on visibility. Whether you can shoot the approach... different story. Dispatching into crappy weather with an alternate allows you to at least go take a look.I get that all operators are different in terms of their criteria for a legal dispatch. This excerpt was from a NWA Airlink flight that crashed in traverse city, MO years back. Emphasis mine.
National Weather Service (NWS) forecast was for sustained winds of 18 knots with gusts to 30 knots. This forecast, exceeding a 10-knot tailwind sustained component, would mean no dispatch to Traverse City and no use of ILS runway 28, the only precision approach. A VOR approach to runway 10 was not usable because minimums were too high. Visibility was okay.
He spoke with the Northwest meteorology office and they issued a revised forecast. They have the ability to amend forecasts. The revised forecast by the Northwest office was for no gusts.
Nope, but there are special considerations for bothOr Oaxaca, but those require a wind alternate at all times if i'm not mistaken.
Actually that was a summary of an interview the NTSB conducted with the Pinnacle System Operation Control (SOC) Duty Manager on the day of the accident flight.Whoever wrote whatever article you are referencing was wrong. I'm guessing they probably never dispatched a flight. Whether you can dispatch a flight or not depends on visibility. Whether you can shoot the approach... different story. Dispatching into crappy weather with an alternate allows you to at least go take a look.