Personal insurance isn't the issue. My Bonanza's insurance is about $2k a year for a relatively high hull value. My car insurance is more than that (thanks South Florida!).
Commercial insurance is a WHOLE other kettle of poop, and one of the number one reasons I'm told that prices skyrocketed after 9/11. And they never came back down. Besides that, something weird happened between 2001 and the financial crash that manifested itself, but no one can adequately explain what it was, similar to the GA collapse in the early 1980s.
I don't mind paying my shop $95/hr. They know Beeches inside and out, and if they fix something, I know it's fixed. I don't even paying a moderate price some something critical or otherwise important, as long as I get good service out it...starter adapter on big bore Continentals, for example.
What really torques me off is a small gear or other nameless do-funny that Textron wants $5043.34 that would cost 1/100 of that at a local machine shop.
Retractable Cessna singles have it the worst. Their gear parts are beyond wickedly expensive in relation to airframe value for even simple parts like brake swivel fittings, and in some cases, are parting-out events.
The Feds need to do something about PMA authority. It's my number one want from the Feds, next to an "owner maintained" category or "private" A&P.