With falling oil prices, why hasn't cost of learning to fly reduced?

Navi

Well-Known Member
It might be a novice question, but since oil prices have been coming down and I understand that airlines still want to make the most they can out of the current situation (jic if they incur losses in the future), why haven't flight schools reduced (even if a bit) the cost of training?
 
A lot of flight schools are struggling to find instructors as well and pay has gone up for instructors pretty much everywhere. I know flight schools used to be able to count on CFIs working 6 or 7 days a week so they could utilize the hell out of their fleet and never had a plane sitting for too long on specific days. Falling demand can and has actually pushed up prices in some instances as well. The flight school I started out with was associated with a university that killed off its aviation department and as a result their prices went up noticeably as the planes were utilized less and they still had many of the same fixed costs. Flight instruction is not as profitable of a business as you'd like to think.
 
Fuel is one of many costs associated with instruction. Even if the others remained constant, you wouldn’t see much - or any - of a decrease. We added a fuel surcharge years ago when fuel costs increased.
 
A lot of schools are flying new Cessnas and Cirrus' now. Gone from a C172 worth about $35000 to a Cirrus worth $350000
 
It might be a novice question, but since oil prices have been coming down and I understand that airlines still want to make the most they can out of the current situation (jic if they incur losses in the future), why haven't flight schools reduced (even if a bit) the cost of training?
For the same reason the airlines didn't end their $25 a bag "fuel surcharge" when the oil prices tanked; it's a great way/excuse to make money!!
 
Here's a basic cost for you: my Cessna 180 is roughly $160/ hour operate, all in. Included in that cost is: 12-15gal/ hour @ $52 ish.

Quick point, fuel isn't the biggest factor in operating cost.

Keep in mind, my insurance isn't the same as a schools, nor am I in a location that has super expensive hangar/building costs.
 
This is an excellent question.

In 1989, you could go zero hero (0 time to CFI/II/MEI) for around $12k. Throw in sone living expenses, and you could reasonably do it for $15k. Just a private was around $3k.

Plug that into a CPI calculator, and in 2017 dollars that's about $25k. Expensive but not totally unreasonable.

The actual cost today is north of $65k, and the average cost is probably closer to $80k.

Fuel really isn't a player. If you track the inflation adjusted cost of 100/100LL over the years, it's pretty much has tracked flat, with a slight increase of about 25%.

I haven't really been able to determine a single causal factor, but I posit the following:

GA was always expensive, but not wildly so. The first bout of serious price inflation came in the late 70s. Changes in tax and GI bills caused the initial collapse of GA in the early 80s. It's was tricking long in a sort of parasitic mode, using up the remaining industry resources until 2001.

During that same period, say 1970 onward, explosive urban/suburban populations growth consumed the dozen or more "4th tier" airports that surrounded most urban areas. These were the airports where low cost operations could be found. The closing of these airports pushed the operators remaining to the remaining fields, causing an increase in costs.

By 2001, the people who were doing aviation stuff began to age out. The rapid increase in business insurance and other commercial hassles probably pushed whatever old timers left out. The GA industry coasted along for another few years buoyed by aircraft value until the entire financial market collapsed in 2007.

Manufacturers aren't in it like William and Olive were. When aircraft companies got subsumed in the conglomerate frenzy of the 70s, they became not a labor of love, but an entry on a balance sheet.

The cost of new aircraft is a whole other issue. Every nut and rivet on an airplane comes with a "aviation tax" made up of all kinds of increased costs. That tax is added to every sub-component, component, assembly...basically every value added step in the construct plus a dollop on top for the final engine and aircraft. It compounds at every step of the process. That's how a 172, which sold new for $10k in 1970, and should sell for $125k in 2017, sells for $400k today.
 
Flight schools have many costs a student doesn’t see nor even think about. Just off the top of my head:
Tie down fee
Taxes on the tie down fee
Yearly airplane tax
Fuel
Maintenance (direct)
Maintenance reserve
Insurance
Advertising
Scheduling system fee
Marketing
CFI pay has increased A LOT

Oh did I mention an extra set of tires to replace the new ones we just put on but now have to replace because a student slammed on the brakes and peeled off all the rubber in one spot of the tire.
Oh how about the battery a student left on for the third time that now has to be replaced for $600. Oh and yeah we talked to him about that the first, second, and now third time.

Hmm, oh how about replacing a fuel cap because a student didn’t put it back on securely and flew back from another airport with fuel spewing out? That was $99 plus lost fuel.

Oh oh oh, we didn’t make money on one of our planes for 4 months while it was being repaired because a student flew the nose into the ground even though he had 50 hours and swore up and down he was good to go. Yes the school still has to make payments on that plane that’s down for 4 months. And tie down fees, and insurances, and taxes :)

Oh how about the tow bar we had to buy 4 Times in one year because students forget them in random airports. (No no I swear it wasn’t me).

Ohhhh and the starter motor that’s only 6 months old that we had to replace when the student went to the run up to check the mags and kept going to start and grinded our the teeth. In Catalina island. Oh yeah we had to fly another plane and go get him and we couldn’t charge him for any of that. But the school still had to pay the CFI to go get the other plane. And when we got there the student claimed he didn’t notice anything wrong even though there were literally tons of metal shavings on the ground under the prop from the motor grinding out :)


There’s a lot going on in the background students don’t see. Schools don’t just put gas in the tank and fly.
 
Flight schools have many costs a student doesn’t see nor even think about. Just off the top of my head:
Tie down fee
Taxes on the tie down fee
Yearly airplane tax
Fuel
Maintenance (direct)
Maintenance reserve
Insurance
Advertising
Scheduling system fee
Marketing
CFI pay has increased A LOT

Oh did I mention an extra set of tires to replace the new ones we just put on but now have to replace because a student slammed on the brakes and peeled off all the rubber in one spot of the tire.
Oh how about the battery a student left on for the third time that now has to be replaced for $600. Oh and yeah we talked to him about that the first, second, and now third time.

Hmm, oh how about replacing a fuel cap because a student didn’t put it back on securely and flew back from another airport with fuel spewing out? That was $99 plus lost fuel.

Oh oh oh, we didn’t make money on one of our planes for 4 months while it was being repaired because a student flew the nose into the ground even though he had 50 hours and swore up and down he was good to go. Yes the school still has to make payments on that plane that’s down for 4 months. And tie down fees, and insurances, and taxes :)

Oh how about the tow bar we had to buy 4 Times in one year because students forget them in random airports. (No no I swear it wasn’t me).

Ohhhh and the starter motor that’s only 6 months old that we had to replace when the student went to the run up to check the mags and kept going to start and grinded our the teeth. In Catalina island. Oh yeah we had to fly another plane and go get him and we couldn’t charge him for any of that. But the school still had to pay the CFI to go get the other plane. And when we got there the student claimed he didn’t notice anything wrong even though there were literally tons of metal shavings on the ground under the prop from the motor grinding out :)


There’s a lot going on in the background students don’t see. Schools don’t just put gas in the tank and fly.
Thanks for reminding me why I don't want to get into the flight school ownership game...
 
Because in the big picture the cost of fuel is a small part of the expenses.

Besides, AvGas hasn't gone down. I'm paying fifteen cents more than I was paying six months ago.
 
28,000 to 50,000 and even more depending on the extra responsibilities you want.

Some places are charging $200 for a C172RG....absolutely absurd. When doing your training pick the cheapest airplane, not the best looking one.

Dang. About 10 years ago I was pulling in about half of the lower number as a CFI. Glad to see things have gotten so much better. Not good for learning to fly though
 
The cost of new aircraft is a whole other issue. Every nut and rivet on an airplane comes with a "aviation tax" made up of all kinds of increased costs. That tax is added to every sub-component, component, assembly...basically every value added step in the construct plus a dollop on top for the final engine and aircraft. It compounds at every step of the process. That's how a 172, which sold new for $10k in 1970, and should sell for $125k in 2017, sells for $400k today.

My dads 182P brand new in 1976, he paid I believe ~45K or so from the Cessna dealer at GYR.

And these planes are made to order these days, not mass produced on Cessna's assembly line like the old days, I believe.
 
28,000 to 50,000 and even more depending on the extra responsibilities you want.

Some places are charging $200 for a C172RG....absolutely absurd. When doing your training pick the cheapest airplane, not the best looking one.
Thats slightly higher than average. The older these planes get, the MORE they cost to maintain. Just like an old airliner that gets parked because airlines don't want to do heavy mx. Take the 172RG I did my ASEL commercial in in 2002. That plane at that time had about 2500 hours on it and maybe 1000 cycles on the landing gear. It was newer(still 20 years old when I got to it) and less crap was breaking. It now has 6000+ hours and 10,000+ cycles on the gear. Were talking about a Cessna 172 doing 10,000 cycles on the landing gear. Not a B737. All the parts and airframe of these planes have lifespans that aren't defined anywhere. Everything starts breaking at some point. In order to keep it flying, it's gonna take $200/hour. And trust me, the school wants to get rid of it even at $200/hr because its sucking up resources and money but they keep it around for commercial students. I've been a student, a 121 guy, a corporate guy, and now a flight school guy. Theres TONS of crap we(students, 121 guys, 135 guys) didn't think about. The only way flight schools make money is to keep planes flying(just like every other aviation business) which requires a lot of parts in stock, a crew of good CFI's to closely watch the students, and a knowledgable A&P. And all that takes a lot of time and money.
 
How much can a CFI make these days?
Depends on the part of the country you're in. In Socal $25-35 working for a school. $50-70 as an independant but that requires time to build your reputation, a decent website, money for advertising and then some. You will be the accountant, advertiser, mx guy, and everything else. It's not going to be the easy CFI gig we all did at 21. Some 141 schools in socal are charging $82-88/hour and people are paying it, all day long.
 
Back
Top