USAF Recalling 1,000 Pilots

I’m starting to notice trends in senior leadership patterns as I continue my service and they aren’t good.

1. It seems more often than not the boss and the task masters in senior positions either don’t have families or are dual military families. They lack the empathy or experience in some cases to factor in why that assistant Ops Officer or E7 doesn’t want to miss another anniversary or birthday so they can stay late and plan something or go on that field exercise that’s only half executed and feels largely like a waste of time.

2. Those same leaders seem to not understand why everybody doesn’t make the same choices they did/do but they try and fake it. There is nothing more insulting than being told something like I understand family is important but then not letting a non essential guy out of a field problem until his wife goes into labor or some crap like that. We react to put out fires instead of being smart enough to get in front of them.

3. The best people often have options and get tired of banging their heads against the wall trying to redirect the glacier that is military politics and policy. They don’t have to take it so they go, and lesser people get the next level job that should have been theirs.

4. They don’t know anything else and fear it, therefor they believe everybody else is just as afraid to leave. News flash it’s not 2007 and shaming people or telling them they will be bankrupt and homeless without the military isn’t working anymore.

5. They dismiss genuine real complaints as mere sport-b!tch!ng. Complaining about the chow is sport gripes. Saying your marriage can’t take the 365 to Al Udied your boss wants you to do because it’ll be “career enhancing” is not. Somehow they can’t tell the difference.

It’s unfortunately going to get worse before it gets better.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

These "leaders" have long ago forgotten where they came from, or in some cases have never been there in the first place.

I had one fellow pilot in my reserve unit. This guy went from active duty, separated and went straight to the reserve as a full time ART. Essentially active duty who never PCSs anymore. He's GS during the week, and military on drill weekend or during AT days. He has the gall to tell me one day that he "needs the part timers to be participating more, and he fully gets-it what the part timers deal with because hey....he has to manage his civilian and military jobs too." What? You freaking moron, your civilian and military jobs are the same damn job, in the same location, in the same office...with nothing different than pay status. You don't know eff all about having to balance a civilian and military job as a part timer. It's out of touch people like this who are exactly who you reference. I cannot believe how out of touch the head CWO of the Army is with his fellow aviators.
 
I'm just curious, what about recalling CSOs as well? I've often heard the Air Force heavily prefers Pilots in senior leadership roles and CSOs don't get much of a chance as far as career progression.

Rated jobs are rated jobs. Pilots or Navs can take them unless there's something specified in having one or the other in a specific job. Or even ABMs for that matter.

In general terms, when it comes to pilots and Navs in the AF; the Navs have much more opportunities than they used to in terms of command and such. But the AF still isn't to the level of the USN/USMC in how they view aviators and NFOs as much more equal for career opportunities than the AF has historically. Which is sad as there are some damn capable Navs of all the various disciplines of theirs out there.
 
What I saw in the AF, and complained quite loudly about it when I was at Airman Leadership School because I was disgusted with what they were teaching the future NCO's, was people were being taught to be managers and hand holders, not leaders. Plus imo the promotion system in the AF is just completely jacked, at least on the enlisted side along with the EPR system and this "whole airman" concept.
 
What I saw in the AF, and complained quite loudly about it when I was at Airman Leadership School because I was disgusted with what they were teaching the future NCO's, was people were being taught to be managers and hand holders, not leaders. Plus imo the promotion system in the AF is just completely jacked, at least on the enlisted side along with the EPR system and this "whole airman" concept.

In theory, an airman who simply shows up for work, does his job, and goes home, with nothing more and nothing less done, would be a 3 or maybe a 4 across the board. But, give that guy even one 3 on his EPR, much less 3 across or even one 4, and you've sunk his career. So, all a promotion board sees is 5s across for someone who is maybe average to slightly above average, which makes the EPR system worthless.

How many First Sgts did you ever see who you would call an actual leader of any kind, rather than the babysitter that job has become in the AF?
 
Rated jobs are rated jobs. Pilots or Navs can take them unless there's something specified in having one or the other in a specific job. Or even ABMs for that matter.

In general terms, when it comes to pilots and Navs in the AF; the Navs have much more opportunities than they used to in terms of command and such. But the AF still isn't to the level of the USN/USMC in how they view aviators and NFOs as much more equal for career opportunities than the AF has historically. Which is sad as there are some damn capable Navs of all the various disciplines of theirs out there.

So if they continue to expand opportunities for Navs/CSOs and work to retain more of them in rated jobs, won't that help solve their pilot shortage as well?
 
service and they aren’t good.
Very thoughtful, and very concerning.

A peacetime military looking for its identity, with 'hotspots' in SW Asia.

  • Aug. 31, 2017
The US military has over 1.3 million men and women on active duty, (Army 475,000) with more than 450,000 of them stationed overseas.

Many of these stationed service members perform training exercises and other duties at rather safe bases. Then there are others who are deployed to conflict zones like Syria or Iraq or potential "hotspots" like Somalia.


http://www.businessinsider.com/us-m...ding-places-like-iraq-syria-and-afghanistan-1

Screen Shot 2017-10-21 at 9.53.35 PM.png
 
Very thoughtful, and very concerning.

A peacetime military looking for its identity, with 'hotspots' in SW Asia.Aug. 31, 2017
The US military has over 1.3 million men and women on active duty, (Army 475,000) with more than 450,000 of them stationed overseas.
Many of these stationed service members perform training exercises and other duties at rather safe bases. Then there are others who are deployed to conflict zones like Syria or Iraq or potential "hotspots" like Somalia.

http://www.businessinsider.com/us-m...ding-places-like-iraq-syria-and-afghanistan-1
View attachment 40700
What does that have to do with what is being discussed here? Can you stop cutting and pasting crap that has nothing to do with the subject. That's twice you have done that now in this thread. Jesus. People want to read what members who actually know what they are talking about, have to say. Take a hint, that would NOT be you!
 
Last edited:
So if they continue to expand opportunities for Navs/CSOs and work to retain more of them in rated jobs, won't that help solve their pilot shortage as well?

In a number of ways yes. In terms of filling many rated staff jobs with Navs, of the jobs which allow either pilot or Nav in them.

The problem is, the AF isn't afraid of Navs being sucked up by the airlines, so the AF has never had any incentive to offer them good bonuses or better opportunities. And Navs have the same complaints as pilots as they go on the same deployments, separated from family the same amount of time, etc; yet don't have the easy career opportunities on the outside that pilots do. And the AF knows this, and instead of doing the right thing by these guys, instead treats them as second class in terms any bonus or career possibilities. Yet there are some damn smart people as Navs, again, of all their various disciplines, in the AF.

The decline started as the Nav career field has seriously shrunk since the early-mid 1990s, and the AF has figured them to be a dying breed in a number of airframes. When in the late 1980s and early-mid-1990s the F-4C/D/E/G and RF-4 Phantom series retired, the F-111A/D/E/F Aardvark and EF-111 Raven jets retired. C-5, C-141 and KC-135 aircraft stopped using table Navs, B-52G models retired, C-130E/Hs swapped to J models that have no Navs. That's a hell of allt of WSO, RSO, table Nav, EWO, and Radar Nav positions to lose, if you think about how many actual airframes those aircraft represent and the Nav manning associated with them. So the AF has figured they're dinosaurs who eventually die off, so why take care of them? Which for the AF, is their usual idiotic, off the wall thought process.
 
What does that have to do with what is being discussed here?
I was responding to Lawman's observations of the Army, something I relate to post Vietnam when the Army experienced a massive RIF, coupled with trying to find its identity and moving to an all-vol service.
I’m starting to notice trends in senior leadership patterns as I continue my service and they aren’t good.
 
One of my jobs in the AF was electronic combat officer for my unit, a job normally held by a Nav who is an EWO (Electronic Warfare Officer), but in single seat fighter squadrons is held by a pilot and is someone who works with the Weapons/Tactics officer. It's a fairly in depth training course at Neliis and is taught by some damn smart people whose knowledge of enemy threat radar, AAA, and SAM systems, their threat to us, and how to avoid/suppress/kill them, is second to none. These guys were old school EF-111 and F-4G Wild Weasel EWOs, and their instructors were often old school Vietnam B-52D/G and F-105G Wild Weasel EWOs who had flown in, and cut their teeth in, the toughest air defenses in the world that we have ever faced in war: Hanoi 1972. And they passed their hard lessons learned to the next generation of EWOs, who themselves passed it on to the next generation of Nav EWOs and we ECO pilots who were doing "EWO lite". One of the instructors, he could listen to damn near any enemy early warning, acquisition or tracking radar audio, and tell you exactly what the hell system it was, what mode it was operating in, how screwed you were at that particular moment with regards to what mode it was in against you, and what he would need to do to begin defeating it. That's pretty bad ass.
 
I was responding to Lawman's observations of the Army.
You are completely out to lunch. He already told you that back on page two when you posted some other cut and paste crap that was way off the mark, yet you continue to post more cut and paste tripe that has nothing to do with what is being discussed here. What you posted has nothing whatsoever to do with what he said. You posted where our Military (all the branches) is deployed world wide. lmao How brain dead are you? Just stop already. Damn.
 
Last edited:
In theory, an airman who simply shows up for work, does his job, and goes home, with nothing more and nothing less done, would be a 3 or maybe a 4 across the board. But, give that guy even one 3 on his EPR, much less 3 across or even one 4, and you've sunk his career. So, all a promotion board sees is 5s across for someone who is maybe average to slightly above average, which makes the EPR system worthless.

How many First Sgts did you ever see who you would call an actual leader of any kind, rather than the babysitter that job has become in the AF?

I was a solid 4 airman. (Kept getting in trouble for calling my NCO's stupid because they were.). I missed Staff twice by less than a point. Had any one of my EPR's been a 5 I'd have made it by well over 10 points. I scored best in my shop on the SKT portion (job related) and ok but not great on the PCG because I never studied it (I knew I was a one termer) But all the people being promoted scored mediocre on the job portion but knew the PCG useless crap and had a lot of volunteer stuff so we had a facility full of NCO's who apparently didn't have job knowledge and spent more time volunteering than working. Good times.

As for 1st Shirts my first one at Tyndall was actually excellent. The one after him was terrible.
 
I was a solid 4 airman. (Kept getting in trouble for calling my NCO's stupid because they were.). I missed Staff twice by less than a point. Had any one of my EPR's been a 5 I'd have made it by well over 10 points. I scored best in my shop on the SKT portion (job related) and ok but not great on the PCG because I never studied it (I knew I was a one termer) But all the people being promoted scored mediocre on the job portion but knew the PCG useless crap and had a lot of volunteer stuff so we had a facility full of NCO's who apparently didn't have job knowledge and spent more time volunteering than working. Good times.

As for 1st Shirts my first one at Tyndall was actually excellent. The one after him was terrible.

Part of the problem is the language invented for evaluation purposes.

Excellent and outstanding are synonyms.... you shouldn’t need a special code book to decipher which one is “more better” than the other when you read about a guy. What’s more, we should drop this everybody is a winner but some winners are bigger winners than their peers crap. Tell people they suck. Tell people they are mediocre performers destined to float within the pack. Do it early and often and maybe just maybe one of two things will happen, they will change something about themselves or they will find somewhere else to suck/drift. Either way it’s a win for the board that has literally 6.9 minutes total to evaluate everything about a person and decide if they make the cut to the next rank.
 
Part of the problem is the language invented for evaluation purposes.

Excellent and outstanding are synonyms.... you shouldn’t need a special code book to decipher which one is “more better” than the other when you read about a guy. What’s more, we should drop this everybody is a winner but some winners are bigger winners than their peers crap. Tell people they suck. Tell people they are mediocre performers destined to float within the pack. Do it early and often and maybe just maybe one of two things will happen, they will change something about themselves or they will find somewhere else to suck/drift. Either way it’s a win for the board that has literally 6.9 minutes total to evaluate everything about a person and decide if they make the cut to the next rank.

And get rid of this HYT crap. Some people are destined to be 20 year Staffs and that's not necessarily a bad thing. The AF's "get promoted or get out" is what drives half of this crap. Everyone looking for that next bullet because they need it to survive.
 
In a number of ways yes. In terms of filling many rated staff jobs with Navs, of the jobs which allow either pilot or Nav in them.

The problem is, the AF isn't afraid of Navs being sucked up by the airlines, so the AF has never had any incentive to offer them good bonuses or better opportunities. And Navs have the same complaints as pilots as they go on the same deployments, separated from family the same amount of time, etc; yet don't have the easy career opportunities on the outside that pilots do. And the AF knows this, and instead of doing the right thing by these guys, instead treats them as second class in terms any bonus or career possibilities. Yet there are some damn smart people as Navs, again, of all their various disciplines, in the AF.

The decline started as the Nav career field has seriously shrunk since the early-mid 1990s, and the AF has figured them to be a dying breed in a number of airframes. When in the late 1980s and early-mid-1990s the F-4C/D/E/G and RF-4 Phantom series retired, the F-111A/D/E/F Aardvark and EF-111 Raven jets retired. C-5, C-141 and KC-135 aircraft stopped using table Navs, B-52G models retired, C-130E/Hs swapped to J models that have no Navs. That's a hell of allt of WSO, RSO, table Nav, EWO, and Radar Nav positions to lose, if you think about how many actual airframes those aircraft represent and the Nav manning associated with them. So the AF has figured they're dinosaurs who eventually die off, so why take care of them? Which for the AF, is their usual idiotic, off the wall thought process.

That's too bad, but I don't think they will completely get rid of all the CSO positions for a while. There's still a lot of EWO, WSO, FCO, and Nav positions out there. When you compare it to the Navy/Marines, there's a lot more platforms for CSOs to be placed on. I've heard of a lot of NFOs who go onto the airlines, they get their certificates and hours on the side, and then have a pretty good resume to move along in the airlines pretty quick. The Navy does offer retention bonuses for NFOs, and actually is experiencing a shortage of NFOs alongside pilots right now.

The mentality of treating Navs like second class citizens can't be healthy. Where do RPA pilots fall into things? Are those guys sticking around at all?
 
And get rid of this HYT crap. Some people are destined to be 20 year Staffs and that's not necessarily a bad thing. The AF's "get promoted or get out" is what drives half of this crap. Everyone looking for that next bullet because they need it to survive.

That was one of the biggest mistakes the Army made getting rid of the specialist ranks.

Now everybody makes Sergent because “everybody is a leader” even the crappy people that don’t want too or shouldn’t be. So instead of perfectly capable people who want to learn their trade and be good at it we have a collection of inept immediate supervisory leadership growing other poor leaders by their example.
 
That was one of the biggest mistakes the Army made getting rid of the specialist ranks.

Now everybody makes Sergent because “everybody is a leader” even the crappy people that don’t want too or shouldn’t be. So instead of perfectly capable people who want to learn their trade and be good at it we have a collection of inept immediate supervisory leadership growing other poor leaders by their example.

Wasn't the Army considering bringing back Spec5/6/7?
 
That's too bad, but I don't think they will completely get rid of all the CSO positions for a while. There's still a lot of EWO, WSO, FCO, and Nav positions out there. When you compare it to the Navy/Marines, there's a lot more platforms for CSOs to be placed on. I've heard of a lot of NFOs who go onto the airlines, they get their certificates and hours on the side, and then have a pretty good resume to move along in the airlines pretty quick. The Navy does offer retention bonuses for NFOs, and actually is experiencing a shortage of NFOs alongside pilots right now.

The mentality of treating Navs like second class citizens can't be healthy. Where do RPA pilots fall into things? Are those guys sticking around at all?

The CSOs will still be around, but not remotely in the numbers that they used to be. Mainly for B-1/52, F-15E, AC/MC/EC-130, RC-135 and a few others. Some guys have gotten ratings and time on their own and have eventually gone to airlines, but not near the rate as pilots, and the AF realizes that. And hasn't worried about it.

Drones are their own career field, and if one wants to go there and make their mark with promoting up within that community, it's entirely possible to do so.
 
I should know this, but is ABM not considered to be a CSO? I had always assumed they were, based on the wide variance of NFO jobs we have in the USN, though I suppose we have no real dedicated equivalent to ABM.....at least in the sense of their career track and job specialty.
 
Back
Top