DOT axes 27 subsidised routes over poor load factor

The United States Department of Transportation (DOT) has found that 27 communities have not met the criteria for eligibility for subsidised Essential Air Service (EAS) in fiscal year 2016. The requirements relate to the numbers of passengers transported or to the subsidised cost per passenger. Accordingly, the DOT has tentatively removed 19 of those communities from eligibility.

0d98c8edfa10b1c3e57145be8728c567efdf9f4cdb2b68a3dcaf57b8ee2e6095.jpg
 
People don't just choose to live in the far places because they are far. They have families, businesses or jobs, etc. They are citizens, pay taxes, and have certain expectations of government.

Sure, remove the ones that are egregiously expensive, have so little traffic, or are +/- an hour away from an airport with multiple airline services. Most of those I am familiar with are reasonable candidates to end subsidies. Salina KS is an hour plus away from Wichita, under 3 hours from Kansas City, straight shots with low traffic. No one complained when the Air Force gave them the airport with 2+ mile long runways. Pueblo CO is less than an hour from Colorado Springs. If the car gives out, they can get an FBO to fly them in a 172 if they have to.

But to dump the whole EAS thing would be like mandating that the exit ramps on the Interstate be torn up for towns under -X- population. What's the cost of a full-overpass & ramps built to 4-lane Interstate standards, compared to operating a Caravan?
 
Heck, I live IN the metro Seattle area, and it takes me longer to get to SeaTac than it would take me to drive from a lot of those places to a different airport.

I'm a fan of this news. The faster subsidies go away, the faster garbage airlines operating on the balance of subsidies vs. underpaid crews will go away.
 

It never made too much sense to me that any of these routes existed. The furthest from a major airport is Du Bois and that's only a little over 2 hours to Pittsburgh International.

Bradford's an hour and a half from Buffalo, Oil City's less than that to Erie and under 2 hours to PIT and CAK as well, Lancaster's a little over a half hour to Harrisburg or an hour and a half to Philadelphia and Johnstown's under two hours to PIT and maybe an hour to Latrobe where they can catch flights on Spirit. I've met some great guys who flew for Southern Airways Express, but it's probably for the best that the government is getting rid of the subsidy for these routes as there are much better things they could be spending that money on.

It's the same thing with Hagerstown, Md which is an hour and a half from Harrisburg or an hour fifteen from BWI.

Pendleton, OR can drive an hour and get service in Pasco or less than that and fly on Horizon in Walla Walla.

Jackson, TN had a reasonably busy Caravan when I saw them unload one evening, but they're like an hour and a half drive from Memphis and two hours from Nashville.
 
Heck, I live IN the metro Seattle area, and it takes me longer to get to SeaTac than it would take me to drive from a lot of those places to a different airport.
Same thing for some FIPs...I mean, Chicagoans. They come over here to SW Michigan and commute to work in Chicago because it is cheaper, less crowded, more beautiful, less crime, and has the same commute time, or less than if they lived and worked in Chicago.
 
I've always had mixed feelings on EAS, and this is with a lot of research.

In the case of Owensboro, that is an example of EAS money probably wasted. You have Evansville less than an hour away by car in a largely non-congested area far outside of any metropolitan that would pose issues to driving. Evansville has air service from the 3 legacy carriers to 5 major hubs plus Allegiant to SFB. Owensboro is connected to STL by Cape Air as an EAS route but also has Alleigiantserving SFB despite being within an hour of EVV. Seeing as SFB is a non-hub(as far as connecting onto other airlines) and Allegiant doesn't deal with connecting tickets, I doubt the Cape Air EAS Cessna route is much of a threat to that service. If Owensboro loses Cape Air and the limited destinations from STL, oh well. Drive 50 minutes and connect thru ORD, DFW, DTW, ATL, or CLT. And if Allegiant leaves, they fly to SFB up the road. Local commerce should not be affected as a drive within an hour to visit a place like Owensboro for business is not unacceptable. No real argument there.

But for every place like Owensboro, there is a place like Imperial/El Centro. Those people(unless the cross the border to travel within Mexico) are about an hour and 15 minutes with no traffic from Yuma. Yuma is, itself, highly isolated with just a few daily CRJ flights to PHX. When ATC delays impact PHX, flights places like YUM are among the first to cancel. These people are isolated. Yes, many of them choose to live there. But there is a big military presence and enough going on in the Imperial Valley to justify the area having some kind of reliable air link, in my opinion. Giving these people the option of LAX and flying right out of Imperial in a Caravan so that any very time sensitive transportation issue at least has a chance is what EAS was really created for.

I understand the people who are against EAS, and I am as well in many markets. But I personally am not against EAS funding for outlying but moderately populated areas over 1.5 hours away from any commercial airport with decent service, so long as they maintain the boarding numbers required to justify air service vs. driving.

I love these out of the way places. Never been to Imperial but I think Inyokern will get service soon.

So much empty space out west, doubt there's any EAS in FL?
 
@z987k ESSENTIAL Air Service really isn't essential. (As it stands)
If the only way in and out of places are by air, 9+ months of the year, yes look at subsidies.
99.99% of anywhere in the lower 48, a hard line no. No one is forcing you to fly to a metroplex.
For those that have never dealt with northern regions, air fare is subsidized as it is, outside of EAS.
 
... doubt there's any EAS in FL?...

No, there isn't. Part of this is a result of the number of training fields built during WWII, when the year-around flying weather made training more efficient on flat, cheap land. Every city that wanted one, has an airport, few have had to build from scratch. Combine that with the phenomenal growth of cities & towns, and you don't need EAS.

Of course, you could say the same thing about Kansas - flat, cheap land close to the bomber factories in Wichita. But the people didn't stay, and some airports have been civilianized (many with EAS!), some plowed up to revert to wheat fields.
 
I think all of these sites are within William Franklin "Bill" Shuster's 9th congressional district. Chairman of the House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee, the committee has House jurisdiction over all modes of transportation: aviation, maritime and waterborne transportation, roads, mass transit and railroads. Shuster, a member of the Republican Party, is son of former Congressman Bud Shuster, and has served on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee since coming to Congress in 2001. https://shuster.house.gov
 
I think all of these sites are within William Franklin "Bill" Shuster's 9th congressional district. Chairman of the House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee, the committee has House jurisdiction over all modes of transportation: aviation, maritime and waterborne transportation, roads, mass transit and railroads. Shuster, a member of the Republican Party, is son of former Congressman Bud Shuster, and has served on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee since coming to Congress in 2001. https://shuster.house.gov

I'm not as familiar with him as I should be, but the only city with eas that's in his district is Altoona. Du Bois, Oil City and Bradford are in the 5th district. Johnstown's in the 12th.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pen...s_congressional_districts,_113th_Congress.pdf
 
I'm not as familiar with him as I should be, but the only city with eas that's in his district is Altoona. Du Bois, Oil City and Bradford are in the 5th district. Johnstown's in the 12th.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pennsylvania's_9th_congressional_district#/media/File:Pennsylvania's_congressional_districts,_113th_Congress.pdf

thanks for the clarification. Bill, with his Chairmanship and close ties to the transport industry (his father Bud held the same position for years) carries lots of weight among Pennsylvania's Republican Congressional 13 member delegation.

from thehill.com
“There are things there I don’t agree with. … Cutting EAS funding for rural airports,” said Shuster, who represents Altoona, which would be affected by the cuts. “It’s such a vital link for rural America.”

In 86 of those communities, Trump received more than 50 percent of the vote, according to an analysis conducted by The Associated Press.

Alaska, a deeply red state that backed Trump with 53 percent of the vote, is home to 61 EAS communities alone.

Shuster (R-Pa.) also said he doesn’t agree with everything in Trump’s budget. But he also pointed out that proposed cuts to EAS have been unsuccessful in the past.

Screen Shot 2017-10-07 at 1.01.48 PM.png
 
thanks for the clarification. Bill, with his Chairmanship and close ties to the transport industry (his father Bud held the same position for years) carries lots of weight among Pennsylvania's Republican Congressional 13 member delegation.

from thehill.com
“There are things there I don’t agree with. … Cutting EAS funding for rural airports,” said Shuster, who represents Altoona, which would be affected by the cuts. “It’s such a vital link for rural America.”

In 86 of those communities, Trump received more than 50 percent of the vote, according to an analysis conducted by The Associated Press.

Alaska, a deeply red state that backed Trump with 53 percent of the vote, is home to 61 EAS communities alone.

View attachment 40547

I'm willing to guess the vast majority of EAS routes are to rural areas that Republicans represent seeing as how Democrats tend to do better in cities and Republicans dominate rural areas. I'm not seeing any huge corruption here. I don't get what your point here is.
 
So you must be for user fees and ATC privatization then....
Yeah, people that say that don't realize the effect that 100% capitalism would have. I wonder if he is also against the ATP rule. Just let people decide if they want to spend their money on an airline with a 250 hour pilot vs a 1500 hour pilot and watch where the industry goes.
 
Yeah, people that say that don't realize the effect that 100% capitalism would have. I wonder if he is also against the ATP rule. Just let people decide if they want to spend their money on an airline with a 250 hour pilot vs a 1500 hour pilot and watch where the industry goes.

There will always be people who think 1st with their wallets than safety. Sadly more than the later.
 
Yeah, people that say that don't realize the effect that 100% capitalism would have. I wonder if he is also against the ATP rule. Just let people decide if they want to spend their money on an airline with a 250 hour pilot vs a 1500 hour pilot and watch where the industry goes.

The 1500 hour rule won't last, especially with all these EAS cuts as there were many low time FOs who were going to ride these routes to 1500 hours. I think it'll be gradually altered to 1000 hours or 750 hours with some additional training in place over the next couple of years. I'd love for it to stick around, but I don't see it happening.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top