"Practice approach approved"

One other thing to consider is that as a CFII a practice approach will allow us to let a student make a mistake that would not be legal if receiving an actual IFR clearance even in VMC. Such as descending below step-downs or screwing up a missed approach.
 
One other thing to consider is that as a CFII a practice approach will allow us to let a student make a mistake that would not be legal if receiving an actual IFR clearance even in VMC. Such as descending below step-downs or screwing up a missed approach.

Does it actually allow that though? Ive been curious since when i had been doing CFII training we were always told. "Fly in vfr and do practice approaches...your license isnt on the line at that point".

Im not asking for "freebies" or anything, just whether atc view it as practice or a real hard cut procedure with limitations. Im always worried about letting my students go too far and usually take controls or offer input (breaking the evaluate status) well before what id perceive as a violation (like 300 feet off assigned altitude enroute, or failing to maintain vectored headings). I worry i prejudge my students as failing a given task, predominently early in the training...near the end its easy to use the ACS as a rulebook....Under actual ifr (given the student is almost always in foggles unless i want them to experience "real IMC") i use it as an opportunity to push CRM and act very much like an FO assisting a CA. But in practice attempts Id really like to push what I allow them to do "single pilot"., I just dont know how far i can legally go....obviously I dont intend to cause traffic separation or sequencing issues, but I worry I sell my students short when they make mistakes that experienced/competent Instrument pilots would be reamed over.
 
One other thing to consider is that as a CFII a practice approach will allow us to let a student make a mistake that would not be legal if receiving an actual IFR clearance even in VMC. Such as descending below step-downs or screwing up a missed approach.

The "practice approach approved" asked by the OP would not be done for an IFR filed aircraft. You would have still received an approach clearance and all that jazz. Mistakes made by the student still wouldn't be legal. Now if you told ATC it was a student and they were doing a practice approach, yeah we aren't going to bust your balls unless you let them screw it up reeeaaaallll bad. But the fact you are on an IFR clearance still means you need to obey all the rules that come with it, practice approach or not.
 
Does it actually allow that though? Ive been curious since when i had been doing CFII training we were always told. "Fly in vfr and do practice approaches...your license isnt on the line at that point".
From the same section of the AIM on practice approaches I referred to earlier:

Except in an emergency, aircraft cleared to practice instrument approaches must not deviate from the approved procedure until cleared to do so by the controller.​

It doesn't distinguish between VFR and IFR.

Personally, I'd be surprised if it were a real issue in most cases, but I recall a story of a pilot doing a VFR practice approach when I lived in Denver who was busted when the deviation created a traffic conflict. Never verified it so don't know the details of even if it's true.
 
From the same section of the AIM on practice approaches I referred to earlier:

Except in an emergency, aircraft cleared to practice instrument approaches must not deviate from the approved procedure until cleared to do so by the controller.​

It doesn't distinguish between VFR and IFR.

Personally, I'd be surprised if it were a real issue in most cases, but I recall a story of a pilot doing a VFR practice approach when I lived in Denver who was busted when the deviation created a traffic conflict. Never verified it so don't know the details of even if it's true.

This could be the case in the tracon world but I promise if you're doing it with a center a lot of it is going to be non radar and on top of that the only vfr separation requirement for en route is don't let them hit so unless you really try something crazy any error by a student shouldn't get close to being an issue.
 
This could be the case in the tracon world but I promise if you're doing it with a center a lot of it is going to be non radar and on top of that the only vfr separation requirement for en route is don't let them hit so unless you really try something crazy any error by a student shouldn't get close to being an issue.
Yes, that's what I thought. Looks like we agree.
 
@MidlifeFlyer
The bottom line is, if not for the "practice approach approved" language, a lot of vfr requests for practice approaches would be met with "unable." That is the advantage to the pilot.
 
From the same section of the AIM on practice approaches I referred to earlier:

Except in an emergency, aircraft cleared to practice instrument approaches must not deviate from the approved procedure until cleared to do so by the controller.​

It doesn't distinguish between VFR and IFR.

Personally, I'd be surprised if it were a real issue in most cases, but I recall a story of a pilot doing a VFR practice approach when I lived in Denver who was busted when the deviation created a traffic conflict. Never verified it so don't know the details of even if it's true.

4-3-21 f. Huh. Oops. Learn something new all the time. Thanks for that.
 
Back
Top