C919, Chinese-made competitor to the B737/A320

Let's see, Chinese copy of a very complex piece of equipment, which requires multiple complex systems to function correctly... In a field of technology which is very unforgiving of mistakes. Add a dash of the culture to save face by hiding or not recognizing mistakes. I hope I'm wrong, but I give it less than a year from initial in service date and the first major incident.

They're bringing in a lot of western companies to help them out and supervising them on it. They have an Airbus plant in China and were initially set to build the fuselage for the C series in China. Bombardier's working with them on commonality between the C-Series and C919. I think with everything they have in place and have stolen I don't doubt that they can build a narrowbody and they're competing against designs from Boeing and Airbus that have been around since the 80s and 60s. Besides China's anything, but a free market and they've got a large enough economy for them to sell a ton of them without ever exporting a single one. Luckily for the west they didn't have the ability to do composites right just yet and hopefully this gets the management at Boeing to get off their ass and do some revolutionary things on their next narrowbody.
 
The Americans knocked together some boats and called it a Navy. Of course they were all designed by Britishmen, as is only right and proper. But it will be the most powerful navy in the world? Hahaha, my good fellow, you are a wag.

And those tossers couldn't build a racing yacht to save their lives.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bp
They're bringing in a lot of western companies to help them out and supervising them on it. They have an Airbus plant in China and were initially set to build the fuselage for the C series in China. Bombardier's working with them on commonality between the C-Series and C919. I think with everything they have in place and have stolen I don't doubt that they can build a narrowbody and they're competing against designs from Boeing and Airbus that have been around since the 80s and 60s. Besides China's anything, but a free market and they've got a large enough economy for them to sell a ton of them without ever exporting a single one. Luckily for the west they didn't have the ability to do composites right just yet and hopefully this gets the management at Boeing to get off their ass and do some revolutionary things on their next narrowbody.
From the flight deck mockup I saw, it looks like COMAC at least got spacing out the spoiler and flap-slat lever correct, unlike Bombardier, who have those two frobs right next to each other.

(Yes, yes, fly by wire, yes.)
 
Isn't China building a facsimile to the MD80 too?

https://www.flightglobal.com/news/a...-flight-tests-following-design-optimi-436408/

Who knows when the ARJ21 will be ready. I figured it'd be the easier one to build, but I guess it's good that they haven't completely given up on it. It will be interesting seeing how safe their planes are as they'll likely be operated entirely by Chinese crews and seeing with how little training they get before they're flying right seat over there combined with a new aircraft with a lot of kinks I'm not too optimistic that they'll have a stellar safety record.
 
https://www.flightglobal.com/news/a...-flight-tests-following-design-optimi-436408/

Who knows when the ARJ21 will be ready. I figured it'd be the easier one to build, but I guess it's good that they haven't completely given up on it. It will be interesting seeing how safe their planes are as they'll likely be operated entirely by Chinese crews and seeing with how little training they get before they're flying right seat over there combined with a new aircraft with a lot of kinks I'm not too optimistic that they'll have a stellar safety record.

It's already flying and making money in China.

 
It's already flying and making money in China.



I was under the impression they only had three flying for the same customer while they worked out some kinks for the rest of their orders. From what it sounded like they still have a lot to iron out.
 
https://www.flightglobal.com/news/a...-flight-tests-following-design-optimi-436408/

Who knows when the ARJ21 will be ready. I figured it'd be the easier one to build, but I guess it's good that they haven't completely given up on it. It will be interesting seeing how safe their planes are as they'll likely be operated entirely by Chinese crews and seeing with how little training they get before they're flying right seat over there combined with a new aircraft with a lot of kinks I'm not too optimistic that they'll have a stellar safety record.
Flying Upside Down is a great book that thoroughly destroyed any interest I may have ever had in going over there and printing large stacks of bills.

Enhance the CRM, strictly follow the SOPM mandate enhance safety and prevent accident.

Hereby notify.
 
Which?

Avionics are a JV design, engines are direct purchase
Western power plant (with an indigenous option that will likely just rip off the LEAP), western avionics if I recall correctly.

I don't really care too terribly much, but it is interesting to watch.
 
Western power plant (with an indigenous option that will likely just rip off the LEAP), western avionics if I recall correctly.

I don't really care too terribly much, but it is interesting to watch.


Yep, they are using LEAP engines now

Avionics is a mix, a lot of content from Aviage which is a GE / COMAC joint Venture
 
According to their own news, they were so not confident on this test flight that the test pilots wore helmets, parachutes and life vests during the flight.
Not sure if this is a standard test pilot procedure...

This first model will suck, but it will sell just fine because China can require its airlines to buy them. But future models, who knows.
 
929 is the wide body version next up. Though trailing even farther than this one.

I almost left GE to be the Product Support Director at Aviage three years ago.

It's a good story over beers.....
 
According to their own news, they were so not confident on this test flight that the test pilots wore helmets, parachutes and life vests during the flight.
Not sure if this is a standard test pilot procedure...

This first model will suck, but it will sell just fine because China can require its airlines to buy them. But future models, who knows.
Unless they fitted an ejection seat to, I'm not sure what good any of that will do other than make a better looking body for the funeral.... maybe.
 
Maybe they're trying to avoid using this
IMG_4181.JPG

And this
IMG_4180.PNG
Unless they fitted an ejection seat to, I'm not sure what good any of that will do other than make a better looking body for the funeral.... maybe.
 
Back
Top