Allegiant article

Yes. In the 135/91 world, there are still people way undercutting or doing work for free. Boggles the mind.
Prior to discovering JC, I asked my cousin- a commercial rotor head about paying for SIC 100 hours- he told me get hours any way to get time
Later I joined JC and I learned there is a penalty
For 'Pay to Play'
Don't be that guy!
 
How much of this is contract shenanigans, how much of this is media bias? Let's see how the dust settles for a year. My guess is that MX issues magically go down quite a bit. Not defending Allegiant, but they do get picked on quite a bit.
 
How much of this is contract shenanigans, how much of this is media bias? Let's see how the dust settles for a year. My guess is that MX issues magically go down quite a bit. Not defending Allegiant, but they do get picked on quite a bit.

You may be confusing the media choices of stories to tell vs the assembling of facts and adding understanding & context to them. The media have an inherent bias towards David & Goliath stories, and against things contrary to the public interest. The media do not like to be played by specialized interests (such as contract negotiations, among others). This is a genuine public service story, looking at a problem of interest to their community. The paper invested a lot of time & money in telling this story!

The story itself is exceedingly well researched, and certainly gave Gallagher & Allegiant plenty of chance to be heard. The sheer quantity of incidents really does speak for itself, and if you took a JC poll, the career aviators on this board (of whom I am not one) would and have tended to decry many Allegiant behaviors and find fault with some of their corporate and managerial choices. I've heard the same thing from FAA inspectors I know (none of whom inspect Allegiant themselves, but are aware of the situation from a different perspective). The story pointed out a problem that is real.

There is a tendency to pig-pile, to join into activities that are aligned with our own belief sets. People on internet sites are quite guilty of this, as are some media outlets. This story isn't an example. A year from now, amongst other things, we'll see this story winning journalism awards for public service.

If Allegiant's MX issues decline in the next year, it will be because of two things: (1.) Retiring more elderly MD-80-90 series aircraft. Older aircraft do break more often and require more maintenance, period. and (2.) Greater attention to problems & reliability by Allegiant's management, at all levels. The tone for this is set at the top. Little, if any of the MX problem list, is caused by the pilot labor force over-reporting failures.

This airline is circling the danger zone of safety. I will not fly them, and I encourage family to make the same choice. I hope that improvement is not caused by a tragedy, but history has many examples where this has happened, in many fields, not just aviation.
 
I'm not saying they don't have their issues, both culturally and MX related especially. What I am saying, is that everytime an Allegiant plane chips paint, it makes the 5 o'clock news. I still stand by the fact that their dispatch reliability goes up after the contract, and they make the news less. It happens at every company during negotiations and the relationship between management and the pilot group was contenscious at best when they were waiting for a contract. What the article doesn't address, was how many of those writeups could not be duplicated because nothing was wrong. At least I missed it if it was addressed.

I still won't fly them, and I am in a position to where I wouldn't even think about leaving my current job to go work there. I am just trying to play devils advocate to the witch hunt.
 
How much of this is contract shenanigans, how much of this is media bias? Let's see how the dust settles for a year. My guess is that MX issues magically go down quite a bit. Not defending Allegiant, but they do get picked on quite a bit.

I used to work there and this article didn't surprise me at all. In fact I thought it was well done, I won't fly on them and neither will my family, new contract or not.
 
They start flying into EWR in a couple weeks. I have been brushing up on emergency procedures in preparation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bp
... I still stand by the fact that their dispatch reliability goes up after the contract, and they make the news less. It happens at every company during negotiations and the relationship between management and the pilot group was contentious at best when they were waiting for a contract....

Dispatch reliability could well get better, although the cause may not be a new flight crew contract. I'm quite sure that management doesn't like the present reliability either, but they have not shown signs of being willing (or able?) to take effective corrective action.

What the article doesn't address, was how many of those write-ups could not be duplicated because nothing was wrong. At least I missed it if it was addressed.

The article is silent on this, but that information would be proprietary to Allegiant and not readily available to an outsider (short of an employee as whistle-blower.) A certain number of MX write-ups at all airlines can't be duplicated - they can be one-time glitches or have a cause which no longer exists. But the quantity at Allegiant has been way above comparable airlines, leading to natural suspicion.

.... I am just trying to play devils advocate to the witch hunt.

A fair thing to be. But to have a witch hunt, you usually have a witch. Then, and only then, does the pig pile effect kick in. In the case of this airline, there be witches under the pig pile. I'm glad it isn't blood.
 
As an aside, I find it interesting how many folks on pilot forums scoffed and scolded people going to Allegiant. But then when their pay raise came like two months ago all that noise died down (no pun intended). What gives? Are we that shallow as a group that we overlook blatant hazards in the name of money - like we always scold management for doing?

It's because at the same time the raise came the maintenance was also improved significantly. They ordered new planes for the first time ever and put growth on hold to park all of the 80's within 2 years. Lots of management changes and increased maintenance staffing occured.
 
I'm just curious, how many of you would feel comfortable flying on Allegiant now? Has their safety really improved a lot over the past year or two?
 
I'm just curious, how many of you would feel comfortable flying on Allegiant now? Has their safety really improved a lot over the past year or two?

I flew them over the holidays. It was a pleasurable experience, granted that I was on a 319 over an MD-80. My only complaint would be the lack of IFE, it made for quite a boring four hour flight.
 
I'm just curious, how many of you would feel comfortable flying on Allegiant now? Has their safety really improved a lot over the past year or two?

Took them a long time to get that truly wretched reputation. Seems like they're heading in the right direction with retiring senile mad-dogs, some management shoved out and down the chute, and the CEO demanding improvements in the corporate culture.

But personally, not yet with me and my family. We know how a very small failure can start the chain leading to a big disaster.
 
Back
Top