Landing Long

obx

Well-Known Member
Curious to know everyone's thoughts. Coming in from a red eye this morning, very slow at the hub. We were in front of a CRJ--not sure if it was a 200, 700, or 900. When they received their landing clearance, they requested to "land long" to be closer to their gate. Tower approved.

I've landed long in a Cessna, but certainly not an airliner--even an RJ or TP. I don't know of any 121 operator that doesn't require you to land within the TDZ. Granted the runway was 12,000 feet long, so I don't think this was unsafe, per se. But a brake failure or some other malfunction that puts you in the weeds would require lots of explaining. I can see requesting to roll to the end, but they specifically requested to land long.

Thoughts?
 
I agree they probably meant a long roll out. Technically is it required to request that? I understand that it's polite and wise to advise the controller of your plan so everyone is on the same page. And in if there are other aircraft of course exit as soon practical. From a technicality stand point though, is there a requirement to request this?
 
I agree they probably meant a long roll out. Technically is it required to request that? I understand that it's polite and wise to advise the controller of your plan so everyone is on the same page. And in if there are other aircraft of course exit as soon practical. From a technicality stand point though, is there a requirement to request this?

I've asked and been told "unavailable" as if ATC could require us to stop faster... We obliged anyway.
 
I agree they probably meant a long roll out. Technically is it required to request that? I understand that it's polite and wise to advise the controller of your plan so everyone is on the same page. And in if there are other aircraft of course exit as soon practical. From a technicality stand point though, is there a requirement to request this?
I guess technically speaking you can just keep saying "unable" when they tell you to exit___, but is that really what you want to do?
 
Good point, probably a phraseology mix up. Didn't see them land, so I don't know that they landed long.
 
Curious to know everyone's thoughts. Coming in from a red eye this morning, very slow at the hub. We were in front of a CRJ--not sure if it was a 200, 700, or 900. When they received their landing clearance, they requested to "land long" to be closer to their gate. Tower approved.

I've landed long in a Cessna, but certainly not an airliner--even an RJ or TP. I don't know of any 121 operator that doesn't require you to land within the TDZ. Granted the runway was 12,000 feet long, so I don't think this was unsafe, per se. But a brake failure or some other malfunction that puts you in the weeds would require lots of explaining. I can see requesting to roll to the end, but they specifically requested to land long.

Thoughts?
Was this in CLT by chance? Drives me nuts when people do that. Just land and un-ass when able... ugh
 
Was this in CLT by chance? Drives me nuts when people do that. Just land and un-ass when able... ugh

Not CLT, but they were courteous and asked if anyone was behind them.

I see this as landing in the TDZ, but using minimum brakes/reverse to exit at a more convient taxiway. Totally kosher.

In the rare occasion that that was my intent, I would ask if we could roll to the end or, "can we exit it at Y3?" The AIM doesn't address the meaning of "landing long," so I guess it's open to individual interpretation. My experience around GA is that sometimes pilots of light aircraft may may request a long landing and literally float down the runway. 121 I've always heard the phraseology "roll to the end" or a specific exit request. Goes to show you how different pilots/controllers might interpret non-standard phraseology. Thanks.
 
I take long landing to mean you're going to take up more runway to exit further down the runway. How you do that is up to you.

Where I flight instructed at we had a 10,000' runway and coming from one direction the turn off to our hangar was about 8,000' down the runway from the threshold. Being a Citabria we would land much further down the runway because if we landed on the 500' markers we'd be taxiing for over a mile... So typically we would request a long landing.

On the jet, that would mean just cracking the reverse and barely using the brakes to rollout to the far end of the runway. Saves wear and tear, and in many cases puts us significantly closer to the gate. Most useful at a place like DEN when you land on a 16,000' runway.

In your situation, I take this to be a "long landing" as well, but you could also call it a "long rollout." No one is going to bust your chops on the phraseology as long as you touch down in the touch down zone. To me it doesn't matter if we're going to roll long, I'm still aiming to touchdown on the 1,000' markers. That doesn't change how I fly the plane or where I land it. It only changes how I execute braking.
 
I don't know that it's codified anywhere but I've always only heard "long landing" refer to touching down well past the usual TDZ. The other thing is just "we'll roll it to Charlie if that's ok".
 
I'd just like to point out one caveat missing from this discussion:

A controller may allow a Cat I to land behind another Cat I or Cat II when the preceding aircraft is only 3,000 down the runway. Likewise, a controller only needs 4,500 feet when landing a Cat II behind a preceding Cat I or II.

If you don't tell the controller that you intend to land long, how fast do you think you're going to eat up that 3,000 to 4,500 feet, especially since neither the controller nor the preceding aircraft know it might behoove the preceding aircraft to not delay exiting, or worse, stop on the runway for some reason?

Yeah, you may "own" the runway with that landing clearance, but so, too, does that preceding Cat I or Cat II. It's joint ownership!

If you don't state your intentions, then you're setting up a situation that might otherwise have been avoided.
 
Last edited:
CAM-1: DUUUUUUUDE!
CAM-2: BROOOOOOOOOO!

rs_1024x759-150917101520-Dude-Wheres-My-Car-Portable.jpg
 
Back
Top