Direct question

ASpilot2be

Qbicle seat warmer
So say you are going to North Bend and atc says clear direct north bend, are you clear to the airport or vor. I have always been under the impression that if they don't say airport then you are clear to the navaid.

Thoughts?
 
So say you are going to North Bend and atc says clear direct north bend, are you clear to the airport or vor. I have always been under the impression that if they don't say airport then you are clear to the navaid.

Thoughts?

Lucky. All I ever hear is "descend via, except maintain 200 knots...actually turn left 40 degrees for spacing".
 
Actual answer, I'm not sure.
But if you're landing at North Bend, I'd expect you to take direct the airport. If you're not landing at North Bend, I'd expect the VOR.
Realistically, the controllers probably don't care either way.
 
I've seen it answered before, but it's the airport.

Weird I've seen it answered before too - and the answer I saw was "the VOR". I suppose the 7110.65 might have the answer?

Edit: 7110.65 4-2-1: "when clearance limit is an airport, the word "airport" must follow the airport name."

My answer also assumes that the VOR was part of the flight plan before the airport.
 
Last edited:
Most of the time, a nav aid and airport that share the same name are generally colocated, so it doesn't matter which you go direct too. In the instances where they're not, the controller should specify the airport or the navaid. If you're not sure which they mean, easiest answer is just to ask. We had this when I was in the AF with Marrianna Airport and VOR, with the VOR being about 15 miles north of the airport.
 
Most of the time, a nav aid and airport that share the same name are generally colocated, so it doesn't matter which you go direct too. In the instances where they're not, the controller should specify the airport or the navaid. If you're not sure which they mean, easiest answer is just to ask. We had this when I was in the AF with Marrianna Airport and VOR, with the VOR being about 15 miles north of the airport.
Thanks. That makes sense
 
Edit: 7110.65 4-2-1: "when clearance limit is an airport, the word "airport" must follow the airport name."

Pretty sure that if ATC intended to give you a new clearance limit, they would have given hold instructions as well, or at least an EFC time. They meant direct to the airport.
 
Reply with "direct whichever vor" and see what happens. About 20% of the time I get "you can proceed direct destination", rest of the time I get silence.
Most recently it was CAE the VOR, which was a part of the plan, vs KCAE the airport, the destination. 6 nm between them. Got cleared Columbia direct, replied with "Columbia VOR", got "uhm.. no, proceed direct destination"
 
Back
Top