Dispatching an Aircraft with no usable approaches.

Is it legal to dispatch?


  • Total voters
    18

TN-DX

Well-Known Member
So, We have been having a two hour long discussion on whether or not you are legally able to dispatch and aircraft to an airport with no usable approaches. Here is the information for the particular flight..

KLAX-PAED

Part 121 Supplemental Cargo Flight with revenue.

OPS SPEC B051 is NOT authorized.

Runways 06/24
16/34

Approach - ILS or LOC DME RWY 6

M0503/16 NOTAMN
Q) ZAN/QMRLC/IV/NBO/A/000/999/6115N14948W005
A) PAED
B) 1608021400
C) 1610020700
E) RWY 06/24 CLSD

TACAN Approach to 16 is not authorized due to OPS SPEC.

Some starting material for reading

http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-id...72fd217&mc=true&node=se14.3.121_1117&rgn=div8

http://fsims.faa.gov/wdocs/8900.1/v03 tech admin/chapter 25/s_03_025_004.htm

Let the HEALTHY discussion begin. Thank you to everyone who puts in their input.
 
At my airline if we no longer have a ground based IAP we require an alternate and MVA to dispatch. Although...I'm not 100% positive that would be legal on a international flight...hmmm.
 
At my airline if we no longer have a ground based IAP we require an alternate and MVA to dispatch. Although...I'm not 100% positive that would be legal on a international flight...hmmm.

Is this implied, an Ops Spec or a Reg that your shop is determining this on? Just curious.
 
2 things - does your ops specs allow circling, even if only in VMC? Because the ILS/LOC Y&Z 6 has circling mins. The Y even specifies higher circling for RWY 34. So, yes there is an approach right there. Second, do your opspecs allow VFR and or visual approaches? A visual approach is an IFR procedure so even if you're not authorized to be VFR that doesn't mean you can't go to an airport with no approaches.
ANC, all of 2 mins away will work as a great alternate.
I think B051 is VFR flight, but I don't have access to a copy of it, so I'm not sure.

At my airline if we no longer have a ground based IAP we require an alternate and MVA to dispatch. Although...I'm not 100% positive that would be legal on a international flight...hmmm.
Did Alaska secede or something recently and no one told us? ;)
 
Top of our Jepp tailored approach plate for ILS/LOC Y requires TACAN so the Y approach is out. To answer the question we do have authorization for circle to land but since Z is the only one available and its only authorized for RWY 6 we cannot use the circle to land for Z either. Second, we do have authorization to accept the visual approaches. The Ultimate question would be...Can you dispatch the plane to the airport knowing that you can only accept a visual?
 
Top of our Jepp tailored approach plate for ILS/LOC Y requires TACAN so the Y approach is out. To answer the question we do have authorization for circle to land but since Z is the only one available and its only authorized for RWY 6 we cannot use the circle to land for Z either. Second, we do have authorization to accept the visual approaches. The Ultimate question would be...Can you dispatch the plane to the airport knowing that you can only accept a visual?
The Z approach just says not authorized south of RWY 6. You can still circle north to 16 and 24(if it wasn't closed). Interestingly, the govt chart that I was looking at makes no meantion of requiring TACAN azimuth for the approach, though clearly you need it for the missed.
I can't see why you wouldn't be able to send an airplane to an airport with nothing but a visual. It's also a type of approach. Though I do wonder how you derive the alternate fuel requirements.... use 1000-3 as the approach mins? Or the MEA? The practical person in me says just make sure they have a good alternate and go!
 
We are having that same discussion at my shop right now with the FAA. We can't not dispatch to a visual but are working on adding language to our manuals to do plan a visual but our POI does not like it.
Part 91 allows it which 121 is based on. Check ops spec 77 may be able to help but it says may accept a visual approach but nothing about dispatching to a visual.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
We are having that same discussion at my shop right now with the FAA. We can't not dispatch to a visual but are working on adding language to our manuals to do plan a visual but our POI does not like it.
Part 91 allows it which 121 is based on. Check ops spec 77 may be able to help but it says may accept a visual approach but nothing about dispatching to a visual.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This is exactly how and why the discussion came up last night. We had our DX inspector in the night before but unfortunately it did not come up while he was there.

The Z approach just says not authorized south of RWY 6. You can still circle north to 16 and 24(if it wasn't closed). Interestingly, the govt chart that I was looking at makes no meantion of requiring TACAN azimuth for the approach, though clearly you need it for the missed.
I can't see why you wouldn't be able to send an airplane to an airport with nothing but a visual. It's also a type of approach. Though I do wonder how you derive the alternate fuel requirements.... use 1000-3 as the approach mins? Or the MEA? The practical person in me says just make sure they have a good alternate and go!

I'm pretty sure that our tailor Jepp Charts have the bold print "TACAN Azimuth Required" due to the missed approach prof. It's a great food for thought question and scenario and exactly why myself and one of the other JC members threw it up here.

The practical person in both of us do not like it. Mountains on one side of the airport, lost comms and no missed proc were one of the many topics.
 
This is exactly how and why the discussion came up last night. We had our DX inspector in the night before but unfortunately it did not come up while he was there.



I'm pretty sure that our tailor Jepp Charts have the bold print "TACAN Azimuth Required" due to the missed approach prof. It's a great food for thought question and scenario and exactly why myself and one of the other JC members threw it up here.

The practical person in both of us do not like it. Mountains on one side of the airport, lost comms and no missed proc were one of the many topics.
So like I said, use the Z approach. It IS legal to 16. The only real difference between the 2 is the missed. One to a fix off the TACAN and the other to a VOR.
I looked at our tailored jepps and no tacan azimuth requirement for the Z approach.
 
The Z approach just says not authorized south of RWY 6. You can still circle north to 16 and 24(if it wasn't closed). Interestingly, the govt chart that I was looking at makes no meantion of requiring TACAN azimuth for the approach, though clearly you need it for the missed.
I can't see why you wouldn't be able to send an airplane to an airport with nothing but a visual. It's also a type of approach. Though I do wonder how you derive the alternate fuel requirements.... use 1000-3 as the approach mins? Or the MEA? The practical person in me says just make sure they have a good alternate and go!

The Z approach is not authorized by company policies as we do not train Circle to Land. We have the ops spec (C075) but because it says we must train for it and we don't, it is illegal.
 
The Z approach is not authorized by company policies as we do not train Circle to Land. We have the ops spec (C075) but because it says we must train for it and we don't, it is illegal.
Most 121 doesn't, but you can still "circle in VMC" which is 1000-3, which would be your new approach mins. It's what's on the type certificate as a limitation since you don't train for it. It's more or less the same thing as a visual approach at this point, but you could use the localizer to get you to that 1000ft.
 
Most 121 doesn't, but you can still "circle in VMC" which is 1000-3, which would be your new approach mins. It's what's on the type certificate as a limitation since you don't train for it. It's more or less the same thing as a visual approach at this point, but you could use the localizer to get you to that 1000ft.

Regardless if the company will not allow a circle to land or circling in VMC it doesn't matter, the plane isn't allowed to shoot any approach published. So again the real question is can you Plan to dispatch without a published approach, VFR, as a 121 carrier?
 
So like I said, use the Z approach. It IS legal to 16. The only real difference between the 2 is the missed. One to a fix off the TACAN and the other to a VOR.
I looked at our tailored jepps and no tacan azimuth requirement for the Z approach.

Because our tailored charts do say required on the plate, that approach becomes a completely unusable approach. Your company may not have the required but ours does. 1000-3 for the circle to land is correct for us but we can only circle to land for 24 which happens to be closed.
 
Regardless if the company will not allow a circle to land or circling in VMC it doesn't matter, the plane isn't allowed to shoot any approach published. So again the real question is can you Plan to dispatch without a published approach, VFR, as a 121 carrier?

No. OPSPECS B051 NOT AUTH would kill it.
 
You done made me look at the Op Specs on my day off (something I really try to avoid on days I work, they just muddle my opinions with facts), and I haven't had coffee yet.. so could be wrong.

The Z approach is not authorized by company policies as we do not train Circle to Land. We have the ops spec (C075) but because it says we must train for it and we don't, it is illegal.

Company policy aside, our C075 has paragraph "d" that allows us to do a circle to land "maneuver" without training. It does also list the aircraft types authorized to do non-trained maneuvers with.

Did Alaska secede or something recently and no one told us? ;)

If your ICAO airport code don't start with a K you're not in Amurrica anymore!!!! :)

Regardless if the company will not allow a circle to land or circling in VMC it doesn't matter, the plane isn't allowed to shoot any approach published. So again the real question is can you Plan to dispatch without a published approach, VFR, as a 121 carrier?

You must work for a different airline than I, if our company policy or procedure prohibits something that causes a delay or cancellation, it's changed within the hour. Our FOM is written on a dry erase board.

Seriously, we used to run into this issue weekly, if not daily. Lots of airports we served would take down their approaches at night (it's truly a fly by night company) and leave you with some kind of RNAV approach or nothing at all. Since the light twins we send to these s$$%tholes aren't equipped for such fancy things, we would have to wait till the out of service period ended. Then they came up with the same procedure mentioned above with the MVA and alternate requirement. (Which every time I call to get the MVA I get multiple answers... not the clearest thing we do). Which I believe is authorized by C077 in the paragraph pertaining to airports without a CVFP. The MVA+500' (or 1000' whichever is higher) and 3 miles vis procedure we use should ensure we meet the the requirements for ceiling/vis spelled out in C077 b(4). We are required to carry an alternate in this situation, but not sure if that's just being cautious or a requirement spelled out somewhere in the FARs/Op Specs, and it's too early to dig into that.

SO, I'd say if you are unable/unwilling to do a circle to runway 16 based on the ILS to 6 and have no procedure for dispatching to a No IAP airport based on C077, then you're probably stuck.

At my airline if we no longer have a ground based IAP we require an alternate and MVA to dispatch. Although...I'm not 100% positive that would be legal on a international flight...hmmm.

Ours is legal for use anywhere we operate. The example given in the manuals is actually for a foreign airport. The trick is trying to get an MVA out of the controllers, either they don't understand what you are asking for or refuse to give it.

But since its supplemental ops,I say you call the DO and he/she and the captain can get together and operate the flight without you being involved if they really wanna move the plane, and you can just forget all this stuff :bounce:
 
The thing about that is...dispatch is based on visibility.

P6SM VV001 is totally legal to dispatch to. Landing is another question...

3SM and OVC008 technically is at the vis you need...though its not VMC...Can you send it or not?

Like the first scenario, you are basically sending a flight with a very high chance of diverting, but its legal. Why is it not the same? Company regulations being more conservative than FAR's?
 
Back
Top