A-10's in the News - AF Keeping them a little longer.

fholbert

Mod's - Please don't edit my posts!
Is the A-10 headed for the graveyard?

"When we made the decision on retiring the A-10, we made those decisions prior to ISIL, we were not in Iraq, we were coming out of Afghanistan to a large extent, we didn't have a resurgent Russia," Goldfein said in an interview on "Defense News with Vago Muradian," scheduled for broadcast this weekend, according to the Defense News website.

Goldfein's office confirmed the general's remarks to CNN.

Video Here and story here: http://www.cnn.com/2016/01/21/politics/air-force-a-10-isis/index.html
 
An airplane kept alive strictly by the social outrage of retiring it....
You will never have a fair argument on retiring this plane. Not when one side is arguing from a standpoint of money/numbers/aircraft that can substitute for its role on the air task order and meanwhile the other side is screaming about Brrrrrt.

Seriously if we want to talk about capability gaps going away without a replacement look no further than the Navy S-3 Vikings.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
An airplane kept alive strictly by the social outrage of retiring it....
You will never have a fair argument on retiring this plane. Not when one side is arguing from a standpoint of money/numbers/aircraft that can substitute for its role on the air task order and meanwhile the other side is screaming about Brrrrrt.

Seriously if we want to talk about capability gaps going away without a replacement look no further than the Navy S-3 Vikings.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
It is not as if the USAF actually procured a viable replacement, so....
 
It is not as if the USAF actually procured a viable replacement, so....

It's not as if it's the only plane dropping bombs in close support of the ground force.

The writing on the wall of multi-role or no role has been there for 30 years. If an airplane as critical to a single role mission as Raptor had to pick up multi role strike when it's a mission only one plane (C model Eagle) was doing you aren't going to get to justify a 4.5 or God forbid 5th gen single role attack aircraft for CAS when you have 4 other planes in that weight class alone doing it. And more specifically in a med-high threat environment the A-10 isn't going to be able to do that role, it's going to be Strikes and 35s and Super Hornets that are viable and survivable. A-10 got its lunch eaten by SA-13... Put it on a battlefield with Gauntlet and Greyhound and no way are Hawgs gonna just roll in guns blazing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
That's when I go out with my wife and she's had two margaritas.

The man speaks truth.

I gotta wonder where she defines "permissive" or "permission" though. :-)

In all seriousness, the a10 is a FANTASTIC conversation grenade in DC circles. Nowhere will you elicit as much armchair tactical debate and Janes-worthy fact quoting (among civilians) as an A10 discussion.
 
In all seriousness, the a10 is a FANTASTIC conversation grenade in DC circles. Nowhere will you elicit as much armchair tactical debate and Janes-worthy fact quoting (among civilians) as an A10 discussion.

Even now, generally speaking because that's all I can do here, while A-10s are operating in the Iraq/Syria area, they aren't operating everywhere. Depending on the assessed threat in different areas of that AO, determines which aircraft will be tasked into those areas. That said, Hogs don't go everywhere over there.

It's no surprise that the Hog is susceptible to various S/A threats. Even back in the Fulda Gap days with the Warsaw Pact, we knew that the 81st (and later also 10th) Tac Fighter Wing's 6 squadrons would be attrited in a couple of weeks or so, against the Pact's ADA forces. That isn't including jets which are taken out on the ground at the 6 German FOLs, or if things are going bad enough, at their home bases in Bentwaters/Woodbridge/Alconbury in the UK. The war would probably have gone tactical nuke by then, so it may not have mattered anyway, but we'll never know.

Desert Storm, we learned a big lesson when we brought the Hog with it's daytime low-level Europe employment tactics to a threatre with flat sand and no terrain features, pushing them up to medium altitude and forcing two squadrons to pick up a night mission (this was before the time of NVGs or any night capabilities for the A-10). In addition to the pushing of Hogs far forward of the lines in order to go hunt mobile Scud missile systems, to which they had to be pulled back from after being shot up and shot down. Losses to systems like SA-9/13 and 14/16.....fairly old systems, but deadly anyway.....were what got our Hogs there. In fact, apart from a Roland, no US aircraft have been lost to any modern SAM systems.....yet. Everything we've lost has been legacy systems, interestingly enough.

So there are places Hogs can and can't go, in terms of survivability. Of course, its doubtful we'd send a Hog into a highly contested environment anyway, and even so, many platforms play in the CAS game.....they just do it in slightly different ways. Depending on the effect desired by the ground commander, determines the apppropriate asset to send. Sometimes though, only certain assets are available.

I hate hearing the oft-repeated "troops will die if no Hogs are around!"; because for one, it implies that our US ground troops are either too inept or too incapable of doing anything regarding their job, unless an A-10 is overhead. And two, since A-10s can't be everywhere where CAS is needed, and there were times when they weren't even in theatre, troops were still involved in situations that required CAS, and the aircraft that responded got the job done, even if not possibly the most optimal platform. Again, Hogs can't be everywhere, doing everything.

The second stupid thing I get tired of hearing ad-nauseum, is the argument of "just give them to the Army or the USMC". For one, the Army doesn't want Hogs. Sure, they love the fire support they get from the jet, but the Army is happy as a clam to have the AF shoulder the cost of doing that, especially since that's the AFs designated job anyway following the Key West agreement. Too, the Army would rather spend $$$ on ground systems and doesn't have, nor want to spend money on (nor should have to) the infrastructure required to now have their own fixed-wing Air Force, and the huge financial burden that would be.

The USMC, the masters of CAS, while they appreciate the A-10, has no use for it as it has no shipboard capability. In addition, they're happy with what they have in inventory serving their CAS needs already. For a service that can take unlikely planes like the F-4 Phantom and F-8 Crusader, and make them effective CAS platforms, then these guys know what they're talking about in terms of what they need for themselves. And, they don't have any dying need for the A-10, although again, they appreciate that aircraft's capabilities.
 
Last edited:
Guns, guns, me, and guns. Well, MikeD ain't guns no more, he's just utility trash like me now. :)

Oh, and isn't Hacker just an RJ gear puller now? :)

It's much worse than that; Hacker had to pull gear for me for a trip.

If someone had told you 10 years ago that would happen, would you have believed it?
 
It's much worse than that; Hacker had to pull gear for me for a trip.

If someone had told you 10 years ago that would happen, would you have believed it?

I heard about that... That's actually very cool. But no, that would have been a stretch 10 years ago!

And who knows... It could be me in your right seat in two years or so. I might just retire.
 
It's not as if it's the only plane dropping bombs in close support of the ground force.

The writing on the wall of multi-role or no role has been there for 30 years. If an airplane as critical to a single role mission as Raptor had to pick up multi role strike when it's a mission only one plane (C model Eagle) was doing you aren't going to get to justify a 4.5 or God forbid 5th gen single role attack aircraft for CAS when you have 4 other planes in that weight class alone doing it. And more specifically in a med-high threat environment the A-10 isn't going to be able to do that role, it's going to be Strikes and 35s and Super Hornets that are viable and survivable. A-10 got its lunch eaten by SA-13... Put it on a battlefield with Gauntlet and Greyhound and no way are Hawgs gonna just roll in guns blazing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I think the C model will be around for a good while longer. The curious thing about that particular single role aircraft is that their "single role" is in high political demand. It's not really an offensive weapon unless combined with a A/G asset. You can place it in key strategic locations without over-escalating things - reference the insane amount of TDYs they have.
 
I think the C model will be around for a good while longer. The curious thing about that particular single role aircraft is that their "single role" is in high political demand. It's not really an offensive weapon unless combined with a A/G asset. You can place it in key strategic locations without over-escalating things - reference the insane amount of TDYs they have.

True but if we had bought the requisite amount of Raptors planned that thing would be gone.

That's more my point, we haven't developed a pure single role tactical aircraft like that in any service since back when cars had carburetor and drum brakes. When you look at all the single role aircraft that went away to be supplanted by a multi role aircraft either in development or already in service(A6, A-7, F-111, F-106, F-4G, etc) it should have been obvious.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I know im a lurker here, but I was waiting a few more months to post a meaningful update. When I saw the A-10 thread i could not resist.
This is my perspective as a ground troop coupled with what I know about CAS and the current/preposed systems. It has largely to due with anecdotal evidence more so than firsthand matters, but there is a bit of both. My two cents

1) The A10 is unique in its role. It is dedicated ground attack and packs the fuel endurance, ordinance and ability to absorb punishment that NO OTHER AIRCRAFT comes close to matching in any of those aspects. Pilots of this beauty are notorious for ignoring the SA threat, why, because they know their bird can withstand a withering amount of fire, and their duty lies to friendlies below them.

2) A10s are designed to loiter and protect the troops on the ground / eliminate ground threats. Their subsonic capabilities and weapons load ensure once they enter a situation, they arent running for fuel, or rearm anytime soon. Sure a F35 can supercruise into and AO and drop a few PCMs then run for rearm, but with fluidity on the battlefield, lower altitude, endurace and a general interest in securing an AO. The A10 wins all day long.

3) That "Brrrt" we all love isnt just because it sounds wicked, but because it represents 1100ish rounds of 30MM that make us safe. Even if equipped for another mission, the A10 packs enoigh ground support on a moments notice to be a decisive factor in a large or small scale close in battle.

Maybe im just a tad bit nostalgic, and maybe i love the sounds of those engines. Whenever I see that they want to retire this bird for some PoS JSF, I die a little inside.
 
Pilots of this beauty are notorious for ignoring the SA threat, why, because they know their bird can withstand a withering amount of fire, and their duty lies to friendlies below them.

I know a lot of Hog pilots, and not a single one ignores the surface-to-air threat. In my experience, Hog pilots are more skittish around certain SA threats (like the ZSU, or the Roland, or Crotale, etc) because they understand the limitations of their steed.

I have also flown a lot of CAS in combat, and I assure you that pilots in other platforms hold their support for ground troops as a sacred duty they are willing to give their life for.
 
I know im a lurker here, but I was waiting a few more months to post a meaningful update. When I saw the A-10 thread i could not resist.
This is my perspective as a ground troop coupled with what I know about CAS and the current/preposed systems. It has largely to due with anecdotal evidence more so than firsthand matters, but there is a bit of both. My two cents

1) The A10 is unique in its role. It is dedicated ground attack and packs the fuel endurance, ordinance and ability to absorb punishment that NO OTHER AIRCRAFT comes close to matching in any of those aspects. Pilots of this beauty are notorious for ignoring the SA threat, why, because they know their bird can withstand a withering amount of fire, and their duty lies to friendlies below them.

Can't ignore the SA threat necessarily, but I know what you are meaning. In areas where there's not a known threat system present, but there's the ever-present small arms/automatic weapons that I can't do anything about, I'll take it with some amount of a grain of salt if I happen to be going in low for a particular reason. But for known threat systems, the bad thing is that I can get shot down just like anyone else. I can take some punishment, but can be taken down with one round too if it hits in the right place. So known threats still have to be honored in that respect. We do have good ordnance and fuel endurance, but these days, the ordnance we drop is optimized for medium altitude anyway, just like everyone else. JDAMs, LGBs, Targeting Pods. Not like it was back in my day with dumb bombs and the only highest tech piece of ordnance being the AGM-65.

But the nice words are appreciated nonetheless. Just understand that we aren't invincible, as much as we'd like to be.

2) A10s are designed to loiter and protect the troops on the ground / eliminate ground threats. Their subsonic capabilities and weapons load ensure once they enter a situation, they arent running for fuel, or rearm anytime soon. Sure a F35 can supercruise into and AO and drop a few PCMs then run for rearm, but with fluidity on the battlefield, lower altitude, endurace and a general interest in securing an AO. The A10 wins all day long.

The thing is, there are many, many ways to "do" CAS. The A-10 does it in a few different ways, other platforms do it in their particular ways. Depending on the effects requested (and even the platform available at the time......Hogs can't be everywhere) as well as the threat present, will depend on what a particular airframe can do in a particular situation. Sometimes, A-10s will be optimal, sometimes not. Sometimes a different platform will be optimal, sometimes not. If you're looking for sorting a danger close of some small units in contact and the surface-air threat allows some permissiveness, then an A-10 is pretty optimal. If you're looking to destroy an enemy brigade massing outside a base camp preparing to attack, then a B-52/B-1 is optimal. Both situations are CAS, with the latter being closer to BAI, but still CAS these days. Point being that the A-10 is just a tool in the CAS toolbox. There are jobs that its the best tool for, and others it isn't.

3) That "Brrrt" we all love isnt just because it sounds wicked, but because it represents 1100ish rounds of 30MM that make us safe. Even if equipped for another mission, the A10 packs enoigh ground support on a moments notice to be a decisive factor in a large or small scale close in battle.

Maybe im just a tad bit nostalgic, and maybe i love the sounds of those engines. Whenever I see that they want to retire this bird for some PoS JSF, I die a little inside.

There are times when an A-10 will indeed be decisive, there are times where it might not be. It all depends. The gun is a great weapon, but it too has both its pro's and con's insofar as usage.

The F-35, it's going to be simply doing CAS in its particular way, with its particular weapons systems. I'm very curious to see what TTPs the USMCs VMFA-121 and follow on VMAs that are transitioning to VMFA and the F-35, come up with. Being the masters of CAS, as well as the first service to go IOC with the F-35, what they come up with in that regard will be interesting to see.
 
Back
Top