The Last C-17

If I had money, I would buy the rights to produce the C-17. I don't think thy should have closed the line. There is always going to be a need for that long range intermediate airlift aircraft. I don't see anything else on the horizon, so why shut the doors on this.
I am no expert on this, but Boeing stated that the international orders just weren't there and keeping the plant open wasn't financially feasible any longer. The C-17 fleets are currently used in UK, Canada, Qatar and Australia. Remember too that Congress kept cutting the budgets of the Military here and the Air Force orders wound up being far less than what Boeing believed they would be. There were two or three years when the AF didn't even order any. The last one they built (you see it in the photos in this thread) was for the Qatar Air Force.
 
So the C-17's big gain is that half of the things hanging are allowed to just hang? I guess I've only been on around 10 C-17's, but every single one has a laundry list of things not working, and always seems to have things loose hanging from the top. I also thought that after the upgrade the C-5's take off and land in shorter distance than the C-17's now. The C-5's problem was being old in a new world. Funding was lacking to upgrade and the contract wards began, the C-17 won.

I'm still a sucker for the C-5 obviously, I love them. The C-17's got me home, but not all of our gear or really on time. Always seemed to be a mx delay out of Kuwait.
Comparing the two is like apples to oranges, no?



Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk
 
So what will replace this? Had no idea the c17 was at the end of the line.

Nothing at the moment. And really with the new tankers being more optimized for transporting more than just gas we have a lot more flexibility coming than we did years ago. Biggest thing with the 17 was its wide body. A lot of military equipment wouldn't fit on a C141, like almost all of our Armor and most of our heavier stuff. 141 had pretty much been relegated to palletized cargo and troops while C5s hauled the gear. But there are not enough C5s to go around, and because the minimum equipment list expands as soon as they leave the conflict zone they always seem to be "broke" in Rota Spain and Rammstein waiting on parts so again another tail out of the fight.

When we started the war on terror we were really in a bad place with Air Mobility. The 141 fleet was gone and we hadn't bought enough 17s yet to replace them. The C5's were great but they are constantly broke so we ended up carrying a lot of freight via contract 747 and AN-124s and we still move a lot of Cargo that way. Some items though are required to go via military cargo just due to the sensitive nature of the Cargo. Same as if they went by ship they would go by military sea lift (Grey bottom USN ships) and not by commercial transport like break bulk freighters or Ro-Ro's.

There is a drawing board somewhere with the future Joint Cargo Aircraft idea but at this point it's all theory. Meanwhile the C5M upgrade has been going through and it's a big improvement mechanically and can lift nearly a million pounds so we aren't just going down hill on Air Mobility. The question for future air cargo is gonna really be stuck waiting to see what the future of ground equipment requirements looks like. 30 years ago it was all "how do we move Abrams/Bradley to Europe fast." Now we have equipment we never thought about like MRAP and go places we never worried about for example Kandahar at the beginning of the war before we spent millions on modern ramps and taxiways.
 
@Lawman I would assume that many of the C-17's still have a couple of decades of life left to them. Do you think that the Military will look to one new airframe to replace both the Globemaster and the Hercules or will they go with two different designs? Or is it just too early to know.
 
@Lawman I would assume that many of the C-17's still have a couple of decades of life left to them. Do you think that the Military will look to one new airframe to replace both the Globemaster and the Hercules or will they go with two different designs? Or is it just too early to know.

I don't think the 17/Hercules will ever be merged into a single platform.

Honestly the Herk does way to many non cargo jobs out there to ever find its size class just folded away into a bigger plane. And at the same time we don't want to support a fleet of multiple aircraft to do all those little roles. If the Herc does anything it'll be evolution of the platform into a K or M or whatever model when 10 years from now the J models are all getting long in the tooth.

The 17... It'll last a while if we can stop running them ragged like we have been. Talking to 17 guys I worked with during the opening years they basically lived on deployment and vacationed at home. We put a lot of hours on airplane's going back and forth moving ass and trash. What was ridiculous was some of the gross misuse of cargo planes to just be there all the time like an airline routes with no importance placed on making a profit. I've seen C17s full of open pallet space or with a whole lot of empty seats because the CAOC treating it like a subway schedule, same as a lot of people have complained about C130s flying around with a single pallet of cargo or even empty. We gotta knock that crap off or we are gonna run out the fleet sooner than we want to or can pay to replace them.
 
The 17... It'll last a while if we can stop running them ragged like we have been. Talking to 17 guys I worked with during the opening years they basically lived on deployment and vacationed at home. We put a lot of hours on airplane's going back and forth moving ass and trash. What was ridiculous was some of the gross misuse of cargo planes to just be there all the time like an airline routes with no importance placed on making a profit. I've seen C17s full of open pallet space or with a whole lot of empty seats because the CAOC treating it like a subway schedule, same as a lot of people have complained about C130s flying around with a single pallet of cargo or even empty. We gotta knock that crap off or we are gonna run out the fleet sooner than we want to or can pay to replace them.

Which is why the AF should've not meddled in the C-27 program and taken it from the Army, where the planes went to the boneyard after 1 year of operation. The Army could've done their own intratheatre airlift separate from the C-130 rotator. I rode the -130 rotator from Iraq to Qatar one time, where I was the only cargo onboard.

Talk about waste. That was about as much waste as the C-130 showing up to Kuwait with sand from the USA for a volleyball court, since the sand in Kuwait wasn't the right consistency.
 
Which is why the AF should've not meddled in the C-27 program and taken it from the Army, where the planes went to the boneyard after 1 year of operation. The Army could've done their own intratheatre airlift separate from the C-130 rotator. I rode the -130 rotator from Iraq to Qatar one time, where I was the only cargo onboard.

Talk about waste. That was about as much waste as the C-130 showing up to Kuwait with sand from the USA for a volleyball court, since the sand in Kuwait wasn't the right consistency.

It cuts both ways with stupid though.

When I was leaving Afghanistan there were about 30 of us that had been cut away from the unit and sent to Shank to help support another battalion during the hand off while the rest of our unit just sat at the big FOB. We all were redeploying from Bagram so we caught the 130 rotator into there and were sitting in the terminal. Another 50 guys down at Kandahar who had to do the same thing, get up to Bagram and wait though they had come into country separate of the main group.

When my group of 30 got to Bagram there was a C17 headed to Rammstein (2.5 hours drive from home station) with something like 60 open seats of space A. All of us were thinking the same thing, I could be home tomorrow morning if we got on that thing. But we were forbidden to move forward of Bagram without the rest of the unit because redeployment ceremonies were in place and troops were not allowed to just show up at home though their tour was over. So instead of taking advantage of the space availability and telling Rear D to get off its half day working ass and set up to receive us, we and other groups spent about 2 weeks all collapsing into Bagram so we could then get our own special C17 to transport our Battalion alone, with empty seats of our own because nobody needed to go to Romania except us.

And at that point I was on month 11 of what was supposed to be a 10 month deployment and every problem seemed to best be resolved by burning the building down because my pocket of F's to give was completely empty by that point.
 
I don't think the 17/Hercules will ever be merged into a single platform.

Honestly the Herk does way to many non cargo jobs out there to ever find its size class just folded away into a bigger plane. And at the same time we don't want to support a fleet of multiple aircraft to do all those little roles. If the Herc does anything it'll be evolution of the platform into a K or M or whatever model when 10 years from now the J models are all getting long in the tooth.

The 17... It'll last a while if we can stop running them ragged like we have been. Talking to 17 guys I worked with during the opening years they basically lived on deployment and vacationed at home. We put a lot of hours on airplane's going back and forth moving ass and trash. What was ridiculous was some of the gross misuse of cargo planes to just be there all the time like an airline routes with no importance placed on making a profit. I've seen C17s full of open pallet space or with a whole lot of empty seats because the CAOC treating it like a subway schedule, same as a lot of people have complained about C130s flying around with a single pallet of cargo or even empty. We gotta knock that crap off or we are gonna run out the fleet sooner than we want to or can pay to replace them.
Thanks for your answer and opinion. I would have thought that the Herk model would stay and just be changed/upgraded, but really I know very little, so I thought I would ask someone in the Military. I really like the Hercules but am just out of the loop on these things as much as I try to keep up. I have also read in a few places here and there on some Military forums (which I don't have near the amount of time to frequent as a lurker as much as I would like) about the overuse and wasted use of the C-17's and that being an issue. Does make me wonder. Some of the oldest of that airframe are getting up there and I am betting will have to be retired sooner rather than later. The orders in the last several years have been so reduced, one can only hope they come up with a replacement requirement before a serious shortage would take place.
 
Last edited:
Allow me to present the JCA....
They will have to use some other synergystic catch phrase next time....

http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/joint-cargo-aircraft-we-have-a-winner-03372/
That's an interesting site, never ran across it before. Should make for some good perusal. Thanks for linking it. I thought I had read some time back that the AF had sent many of the C-27 J's to Davis Monthan for storage because of of some issues regarding landings and take offs on short fields and in rough terrain?? But I lost track after that and have no clue what became of them or if they found other uses for them or what. I thought that the Forestry Department and the Coast Guard took some, but not sure on that or how many, etc. . Maybe @MikeD knows. I don't even know if the AF is currently using any of them or not either.
 
Last edited:
That's an interesting site, never ran across it before. Should make for some good perusal. Thanks for linking it. I thought I had read some time back that the AF had sent many of the C-27 J's to Davis Monthan for storage because of of some issues regarding landings and take offs on short fields and in rough terrain?? But I lost track after that and have no clue what became of them or if they found other uses for them or what. I thought that the Forestry Department and the Coast Guard took some, but not sure on that or how many, etc. . Maybe @MikeD knows. I don't even know if the AF is currently using any of them or not either.

No the Air Force sent Spartans to the boneyard because after fighting at the Chief of Staff level to keep the mission and money from going to the Army they decided to "save money" by using the C-130Js instead. They made the argument after getting the plane that one airplane is cheaper to keep than two separate ones that kinda do the same job. Except it wasn't supposed to be their airplane to begin with.

It's some of the most underhanded crap I've seen where basically the Air Force got to increase money into the 130 fleet by killing another services aircraft program because "inter theatre transport is our role."


Coast guard got an absolute steal on some airplanes though. Still as a tax payer it should make you furious that we basically bought a fleet of new airplanes to retire half of them into the desert.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
No the Air Force sent Spartans to the boneyard because after fighting at the Chief of Staff level to keep the mission and money from going to the Army they decided to "save money" by using the C-130Js instead. They made the argument after getting the plane that one airplane is cheaper to keep than two separate ones that kinda do the same job. Except it wasn't supposed to be their airplane to begin with.

It's some of the most underhanded crap I've seen where basically the Air Force got to increase money into the 130 fleet by killing another services aircraft program because "inter theatre transport is our role."


Coast guard got an absolute steal on some airplanes though. Still as a tax payer it should make you furious that we basically bought a fleet of new airplanes to retire half of them into the desert.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Good grief. Thanks for the clarification. What a boondoggle. I had not heard that specific info before. It makes no sense. Are there still many of them sitting in storage?
 
Good grief. Thanks for the clarification. What a boondoggle. I had not heard that specific info before. It makes no sense. Are there still many of them sitting in storage?

It was something like 20 aircraft that were no kidding sent there and mothballed.

The Army Special Ops Aviation ended up getting something like 5 planes after all was said and done but that wasn't why we wanted them. We wanted them to replace the ancient Sherpas flying in the Guard.

I think the Coast Guard got 11 of the planes basically bought and paid for but I'm not sure as to the status on if they took ownership yet.
 
It was something like 20 aircraft that were no kidding sent there and mothballed.

The Army Special Ops Aviation ended up getting something like 5 planes after all was said and done but that wasn't why we wanted them. We wanted them to replace the ancient Sherpas flying in the Guard.

I think the Coast Guard got 11 of the planes basically bought and paid for but I'm not sure as to the status on if they took ownership yet.
I had no idea it was that many planes. The last I had read it was like 12 or 13. Good Lord. Are they now the largest plane that the Army has?? (excuse all the lame questions) Will they be used for personnel transport and for paratroopers?
 
I had no idea it was that many planes. The last I had read it was like 12 or 13. Good Lord. Are they now the largest plane that the Army has?? (excuse all the lame questions) Will they be used for personnel transport and for paratroopers?

They are quite a bit bigger than the C-12, and a bit larger than the Dash 7's. And it was gonna do all sorts of stuff same as they do. Now well they will do swoopy stuff for swoopy people.

We actually have a decent amount of fixed wing in the Army but what it's used for doesn't translate in a lot of leaders minds. And it definitely is hard to fight for when you are trying to convince a congressman who doesn't speak joint service doctrine why you need it.

C-27 gave us a ramp capability to load good sized palletized cargo which was huge. There are lots of parts and equipment for our heavier stuff like the power pack for an Abrams or a 20k generator that aren't going to fit on our existing cargo aircraft. When you talking about having Army airplane's on call specifically for supporting Army requirements that could be the difference in quick reaction. Now instead of waiting 72 hours for the COAC plans cycle to crap me a C-130 to move that Chinook transmission that has one of my 6 helicopters deadlines I can move it now as it's an a brigade asset. It belongs to that ground force commander.

That's the big argument with Air Force doing Cargo is 85% of the time it's fine to request assets from the Army through AF channels into an AF planning cycle and it's more efficient than letting the Army own all the Cargo at the Brigade/Division level. But for that 15% I need assets I own right now to do jobs for me. Same argument on why we have our own UAVs took about a decade to finally be heard.
 
Last edited:
Thanks so much for taking the time to answer my lameish queries. As a civilian, I just don't get to have these sorts of things explained to me unless I ask one of the Military guys on here (usually Mike D in pms) and there just are so many things/information that I have no clue of and especially various operations info. Appreciate your answer. It's nice to get the ancillary info and background that ties the picture together for me also. Unless you are currently in or have been in the service, you often just have no idea how many things work/operate.
 
Thanks so much for taking the time to answer my lameish queries. As a civilian, I just don't get to have these sorts of things explained to me unless I ask one of the Military guys on here (usually Mike D in pms) and there just are so many things/information that I have no clue of and especially various operations info. Appreciate your answer. It's nice to get the ancillary info and background that ties the picture together for me also. Unless you are currently in or have been in the service, you often just have no idea how many things work/operate.
Since you are interested here is an article that you can read about that might give you some insight on the follow on mission post Boneyard debacle....

http://www.airforcetimes.com/story/military/2015/03/19/pilot-error-mid-air-collision-pope/24969663/

If you spend more time googling you can probably find more but as with alot of things DOD, OPSEC is a fine line....
 
Back
Top