Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

I agree that Saudi Arabia is the original cause of basically all radical terrorism since the early early days of the Taliban…..read any account of Afghanistan around the time of the Soviet withdrawal, and it will include "brown desert people with no affiliation to Afghanistan" pouring in. Same could be said about a lot of other places. If only we had the balls to stand up to our true world enemy, the Sauds, rather than wasting time on the Iranians, who in spite of their geriatric and out of touch leadership, are largely pro-American when it comes down to the general population. Oh well……they don't pay me to write policy.

The rise of ISIS is not unlike the rise of the house of Saud; absolute violence and brutality. Saud was just smart enough to negotiate with larger powers that offered some semblance of stabilization.

I think that a lot of people mis-categorize ISIS as simply a bunch of violent jihadis trying to set up the promise land which leads to turbulent operational victories without stable long term strategy. There's a bit more to it than that with a certain emphasis on neo-Baathist and playing on the Shi'ite-Sunni conflict.
 
The US doesn't have the stomach or the guts for the kind of sheer brutal efficiency it will take to simply wipe ISIS people off the face of the planet. Whether we get them all or not is immaterial, it's the message that you will be a target, forever. We said the same thing in 2001, but didn't have the intestinal fortitude to actually follow through with our threat. Russia isn't here to play moral high ground, white hat cowboy. They're simply there to job-it, and do what they need to do. And I hope they do.

America lives in the post-heroic warfare society, where the quality of a war is decided by how fast you can declare victory with the least amount of casualties (civilian or military) in the "just war" fashion. We plan a "post-conflict solution" before knowing the dynamics of the war.

I think there's a certain truth in smart weapons blurring the lines between operational, tactical, and strategic decision making - to a very negative degree. Airpower definitely has its limitations.. just look at the Israel-Hezbollah campaign in 2006 or the NATO bombing of Serbia.

Interestingly enough, we did little to minimize CDE and civilian casualties during World War II. It was definitely a different, more industrialized war, but often enough military targets were near schools, etc. Equally interesting, despite enormous civilian losses and property damage, there was not a century long insurgency waged by Nazis from the Alps. The civilian population was too focused on survival.
 
America lives in the post-heroic warfare society, where the quality of a war is decided by how fast you can declare victory with the least amount of casualties (civilian or military) in the "just war" fashion. We plan a "post-conflict solution" before knowing the dynamics of the war.

I think there's a certain truth in smart weapons blurring the lines between operational, tactical, and strategic decision making - to a very negative degree. Airpower definitely has its limitations.. just look at the Israel-Hezbollah campaign in 2006 or the NATO bombing of Serbia.

Interestingly enough, we did little to minimize CDE and civilian casualties during World War II. It was definitely a different, more industrialized war, but often enough military targets were near schools, etc. Equally interesting, despite enormous civilian losses and property damage, there was not a century long insurgency waged by Nazis from the Alps. The civilian population was too focused on survival.

This is the bullshat we did to ourselves in Desert Storm. What many here might not remember are the many press briefings given during Desert Storm by General Schwartzkopf himself, showing strikes from our bombs on various targets. Keywords were constantly used, such as "surgical", "precision", etc with regards to the videos of targets being hit; which gave the impression of the war being akin to a video game, but worse, gave the impression to the American public that wars can be fought "clean" and "nice". In this first major air action since the Vietnam War, we were attempting to make a PR campaign that we weren't just carpet bombing , but all this cool new technology we had, now made an air war "easy".

Now, this has backfired on us, because some dimwit sees unguided munitions and automatically assumes that it = indiscriminate bombing. When I was in the A-10 in my day, ALL I had was unguided munitions. We didn't have the PGMs and target pods that we have today. And you'd better believe that I could place my unguided bombs where I wanted them to go.....with a small CEP, either system dropped or even *GASP*.... unaided/manually dropped. And I did, many times. Even manually with troops in contact once. Talk about pucker factor. But hell, that's how it'd been done as standard LONG before me.

Precision munitions aren't the only effective munitions, and lack of PGMs doesn't mean ineffective or indiscriminate bombing; despite what we preached for so long during Desert Storm.
 
This is the bullshat we did to ourselves in Desert Storm. What many here might not remember are the many press briefings given during Desert Storm by General Schwartzkopf himself, showing strikes from our bombs on various targets. Keywords were constantly used, such as "surgical", "precision", etc with regards to the videos of targets being hit; which gave the impression of the war being akin to a video game, but worse, gave the impression to the American public that wars can be fought "clean" and "nice". In this first major air action since the Vietnam War, we were attempting to make a PR campaign that we weren't just carpet bombing , but all this cool new technology we had, now made an air war "easy".

Now, this has backfired on us, because some dimwit sees unguided munitions and automatically assumes that it = indiscriminate bombing. When I was in the A-10 in my day, ALL I had was unguided munitions. We didn't have the PGMs and target pods that we have today. And you'd better believe that I could place my unguided bombs where I wanted them to go.....with a small CEP, either system dropped or even *GASP*.... unaided/manually dropped. And I did, many times. Even manually with troops in contact once. Talk about pucker factor. But hell, that's how it'd been done as standard LONG before me.

Precision munitions aren't the only effective munitions, and lack of PGMs doesn't mean ineffective or indiscriminate bombing; despite what we preached for so long during Desert Storm.

Hot damn, Daffy.

You have won the internet.

2430224-applause-gif.gif
2430224-applause-gif.gif

2430224-applause-gif.gif
2430224-applause-gif.gif

​
 
Mike, your post is really spot on. Something I have noticed over the years is the type of media reporting on whatever conflicts we have been involved with over the last few decades. Politics of course comes into play here as well. There is a serious disconnect I believe, in what the general public really knows, really understands and has a grasp on. I won't get started on an entire rant about how badly real journalism has devolved, but it has. The media does a terrible job in portraying the truth and the reality of war. Everything gets white washed, it's all dumb downed, it's brief and hardly a mention in broadcasts and in print media, everything is aimed at covering somebody's ass and there is no true understanding of what has actually taken place and what is taking place currently in the world with our Military.

It's almost like the men and women on the ground are forgotten. No one knows/understands how they live and what they have to contend with on a daily basis while in a combat zone. No one understands what happens to soldiers when they return home again, nor the many issues they have and why. The type of reporting and the journalists who were embedded in previous wars are all long gone. All the conflicts now appear so remote. Battles, and the men and women who fight them are even more distant from our own realities. People don't understand real history, the history of the various nations in detail, the various leaders past and present, and what the situations really are in many parts of the world. This is why you see many people questioning, well why do we need this, why do we need that, why don't we just do so and so instead, when really they have no clue what they are talking about. People are just too damn lazy and unmotivated to educate themselves and do some real research to find the answers and the truth. Even when reality and the truth is presented to them, many people don't/refuse to believe/accept it.

None of this furthers anyone. It doesn't help the Military when wars are run by politicians. It is of no benefit to them when everything is white washed, must be PC and the PR machine is running in overtime. It disconnects the servicemen and women when people have no clue as to the realities of their situation in theater and what they have to cope with when they return home. people are mostly clueless as to how wars/conflicts are really managed, waged and fought. I really blame the politicians in Washington from the top down and the media for this bullcrap. So we have mostly, an ignorant public where nothing is explained or presented in detail, let alone truthfully to them. Disconnect.

This is all part of why we don't fight the wars/conflicts the way we really should any longer, why they drag out forever with no real winners in the end, and why we lose so many of the best that this country has to offer.
 
Last edited:
Wait. I thought I posted the same thing on page 8. I want to win the internet. :)

I've always thought smart weapons did this to us. During the first Gulf War, I remember watching the briefings on tv where they showed a a guided bomb going down the "chimney's" of the target. Precision. From then on every one in the west at least assumed there should never be any civilian casualties. We can place a bomb within a few meters of the target. There's was no more carpet bombing the crap out of a town like in WWII and even Vietnam when we wanted to. The public now thinks war is clean and almost clinical in nature. We know it's not but perception rules. They used to say "War is hell" for a reason.
 
This is the bullshat we did to ourselves in Desert Storm. What many here might not remember are the many press briefings given during Desert Storm by General Schwartzkopf himself, showing strikes from our bombs on various targets. Keywords were constantly used, such as "surgical", "precision", etc with regards to the videos of targets being hit; which gave the impression of the war being akin to a video game, but worse, gave the impression to the American public that wars can be fought "clean" and "nice". In this first major air action since the Vietnam War, we were attempting to make a PR campaign that we weren't just carpet bombing , but all this cool new technology we had, now made an air war "easy".

Now, this has backfired on us, because some dimwit sees unguided munitions and automatically assumes that it = indiscriminate bombing. When I was in the A-10 in my day, ALL I had was unguided munitions. We didn't have the PGMs and target pods that we have today. And you'd better believe that I could place my unguided bombs where I wanted them to go.....with a small CEP, either system dropped or even *GASP*.... unaided/manually dropped. And I did, many times. Even manually with troops in contact once. Talk about pucker factor. But hell, that's how it'd been done as standard LONG before me.

Precision munitions aren't the only effective munitions, and lack of PGMs doesn't mean ineffective or indiscriminate bombing; despite what we preached for so long during Desert Storm.

Desert Storm is where everyone started to become obsessed with reducing the enemy to a system of systems (i.e. 5 ring model). We simply assume we know how the enemy will respond if we take out what WE believe they value the most. Fast forward to now and we're paying $300k to take out a $5k truck. Sometimes we're right, sometimes we're not. However, history has proven that many enemies don't simply surrender using a cost-benefit analysis. The resilience of their will isn't decided by the attrition of material good nor is their ability to adapt and overcome the tactical projections that we use. I think that PGMs allow policy makers, and to a lesser extent military planners, to be seduced by a low risk, rapid application of force rather than achieving stable foreign policy objectives on more favorable terms.

Airpower may be able to bring the enemy to the negotiating table, but we can't control their behavior once the strikes cease unless we have occupation and political structure changes - which do not run the same timeline as the RDO style campaigns we're used to seeing.
 
Desert Storm is where everyone started to become obsessed with reducing the enemy to a system of systems (i.e. 5 ring model). We simply assume we know how the enemy will respond if we take out what WE believe they value the most. Fast forward to now and we're paying $300k to take out a $5k truck. Sometimes we're right, sometimes we're not. However, history has proven that many enemies don't simply surrender using a cost-benefit analysis. The resilience of their will isn't decided by the attrition of material good nor is their ability to adapt and overcome the tactical projections that we use. I think that PGMs allow policy makers, and to a lesser extent military planners, to be seduced by a low risk, rapid application of force rather than achieving stable foreign policy objectives on more favorable terms.

Airpower may be able to bring the enemy to the negotiating table, but we can't control their behavior once the strikes cease unless we have occupation and political structure changes - which do not run the same timeline as the RDO style campaigns we're used to seeing.

Col John Warden's airpower theories did indeed have merit, when fighting a war against an established nation with an established military that had some form of tech. When trying to apply that same theory to crap third world nation X, it didn't really fit that mold, we indeed found out.

Two thoughts we need to get rid of as the U.S. when dealing with these situations, are ideas of bringing anyone to a negotiation table, or of making any political changes or occupation; something I think Putin realizes with the way he's handling his campaign in a gloves off manner. I don't think he has any trouble attriting the people that need to be taken out, wherever it needs to be done.
 
Col John Warden's airpower theories did indeed have merit, when fighting a war against an established nation with an established military that had some form of tech. When trying to apply that same theory to crap third world nation X, it didn't really fit that mold, we indeed found out.

Two thoughts we need to get rid of as the U.S. when dealing with these situations, are ideas of bringing anyone to a negotiation table, or of making any political changes or occupation; something I think Putin realizes with the way he's handling his campaign in a gloves off manner. I don't think he has any trouble attriting the people that need to be taken out, wherever it needs to be done.

He also controls RT, which is more or less drives public opinion in Russia.

Russia, from the little I've seen of it, doesn't seem to be the easily insulted, "ZOOOOOMG congressional hearings about Starbucks not putting a snowflake on a coffee cup", can't curse at a recruit who almost killed himself and his unit during an exercise because you might hurt his feelings, passive-aggressive culture we're fostering here in the states.

I don't know.
 
Pretty standard RT:



Nailed it. That is the classic Russian Times, I mean "RT" approach to the American perspective.

It's idiotic how the original guy became disenfrachised and moved to… Holland. Really? Ha! Let me know how he feels about freedom of speech, opportunity and taxation as a monolingual American after his first year.

"I am NOT paying for ketchup! This is an OUTRAGE!" :)
 
It's idiotic how the original guy became disenfrachised and moved to… Holland. Really? Ha! Let me know how he feels about freedom of speech, opportunity and taxation as a monolingual American after his first year.

Much like illegal aliens coming here and then demanding services, the right to vote, drivers licenses, etc. If any of us hopped the border into Mexico and tried the same thing, we'd be sent direct to a Sinaloa gualg.
 
Ehh, you'll find dumbasses in any country.

Granted, ours is exacerbated by our geography. It's easy to talk smack about another country we have to sit on a plane for 11 hours to see rather than hop on a train to it.

I'm not jingoistic, but this is the best damn place on earth… for me.
 
Oh I agree. I love it here. Of course it isn't perfect and has many faults, but it's still the best place for me as well.

Wifey is a Canadian citizen though (had green card when I met her), so if thinks go bad here, my backup plan is Canada.
 
Oh I agree. I love it here. Of course it isn't perfect and has many faults, but it's still the best place for me as well.

Wifey is a Canadian citizen though (had green card when I met her), so if thinks go bad here, my backup plan is Canada.

If things go bad here, they'll probably be worse in Canada.

If my house catches on fire, it's going to probably engulf my neighbors as well if we're not careful.
 
If things go bad here, they'll probably be worse in Canada.

If my house catches on fire, it's going to probably engulf my neighbors as well if we're not careful.

Well true, but I guess that depends on what 'bad' really is. I don't think I mean like an all out anarchy.

On a side note, although I like the Purge and Purge 2 Anarchy movies, I always wondered, it's just one night and there is no restriction on travel. Why couldn't one just go to Canada for the 12 hrs during purge night and just get away from it all? :D
 
If things go bad here, they'll probably be worse in Canada.

If my house catches on fire, it's going to probably engulf my neighbors as well if we're not careful.
I'd say when 50% of their economy is generated by us, in some fashion.
 
Back
Top