Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

CSp2zqcXAAA8r1p.jpg:large

Uh...that's interesting. Here is a crash site video.


And Egyptian authorities denying the earlier info of a mayday from the airliner:
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-34689870


Why is it that all those foriegn countries from that part of the world, the men always stand with their hands behind their backs like that?
 
There have been many tailstrikes on the bus around the world. This aircraft has thousands of cycles since 2001.
I think the that's a rabbit hole.
 
Probably BS, however if true.......the Russians will clean out the house of islam.
They haven't yet in the Stans or the Caucuses. This gonna be diff'rnt this time? Kinda like the US was gonna be diff'rnt in Afghanistan ?
 
As already alluded to, a botched tail-strike repair has to be considered/looked at. China Airlines 747 that disintegrated midair had a botched tailstrike and repair job that was a decade old. JAL's aft pressure bulkhead blow-out was from a poor repair job even older than that (20 yrs?).

Point being, the investigators have confirmed today that the aircraft disintegrated mid-air, based on the vast spread of wreckage and most likely not finding all 4 corners at the primary crash site.
 
Obviously a hopefully thorough investigation ahead, but yeah a disintegration at 310 is not the "normal" thing you see in an accident. On the other hand this was a Russian flight. Maybe they let a kid fly the airplane again.
 
It bothers me how quick the Egyptian authorities were to say "This wasn't terrorism this was a technical fault" and then revert right back to "we have no idea what happened let's leave it to the experts". Ok. Cool.

I really hope the French have a big part in this investigation, I'm not so sure we can fully trust Russian and Egyptian authorities to come forward if a bomb did indeed slip onto the aircraft and blow it out of the sky.

On that note, it is worth pointing out that one could not simply buy a ticket on this flight and put a bomb on it. The flight was operating for an all-inclusive tour package. Every pax on the flight back to Russia had also come in on another Metrojet plane days before. This aircraft ferried down from Russia empty in fact, and authorities claim it was fueled in Russia not Egypt. Even coming down empty, though, I find it hard to believe they packed enough gas on the plane in Russia for almost 8 hours of flying with a full boat headed home. I've been on US Airways A321s that had to make fuel stops in places like MCI doing CLT-SFO transcons which are of similar length, and that's just one leg.
 
There have been many tailstrikes on the bus around the world. This aircraft has thousands of cycles since 2001.
I think the that's a rabbit hole.

Not far fetched at all. Poor maintenance does not show its ugly head right away as others have commented on here it has indeed happened before. JAL 123 is a perfect example of this. Boeing go team of all things botched that one. I can name plenty of aircraft disasters that poor repairs or poor maintenance have caused that took years to manifest itself.
 
According to the news this evening, Russia is saying the aircraft broke up in flight, the tail was found 3 miles away from the cockpit. Not sure if that means anything, however the report went on to say the Metrojet A321 fleet has been grounded...

BP244
 
According to the news this evening, Russia is saying the aircraft broke up in flight, the tail was found 3 miles away from the cockpit. Not sure if that means anything, however the report went on to say the Metrojet A321 fleet has been grounded...

BP244
Sure it means something. It narrows things down a bit. Painting with broad brush, something lead to structural failure. What that something was(pressure bulkhead failure or bomb most likely), is left to be determined, but at least now it can be said that the engine problems reported before departure are likely a cold trail to follow.

I fully agree that a ramper or really anyone with AOA access could have slipped a bomb through. If there are enough holes for drug smuggling at the US airports which are fortresses in comparison, it can happen in the sandbox.
 
Sure it means something. It narrows things down a bit. Painting with broad brush, something lead to structural failure. What that something was(pressure bulkhead failure or bomb most likely), is left to be determined, but at least now it can be said that the engine problems reported before departure are likely a cold trail to follow.

I fully agree that a ramper or really anyone with AOA access could have slipped a bomb through. If there are enough holes for drug smuggling at the US airports which are fortresses in comparison, it can happen in the sandbox.

Where are the black boxes in the Bus - in the tail? Would sudden tail separation mean the boxes would just cut out all of a sudden?
 
Where are the black boxes in the Bus - in the tail? Would sudden tail separation mean the boxes would just cut out all of a sudden?

I don't know much about these things but I looked into the MH flight that was shot down and when the cockpit separated from the rest of the aircraft the black boxes went dead.
 
Where are the black boxes in the Bus - in the tail? Would sudden tail separation mean the boxes would just cut out all of a sudden?
My understanding is that blackboxes are usually if not always in the tail end of airliners, and once the electrical systems lose power, the boxes stop recording. Though I'm not sure if the FDR has a backup but the CVRs seem to cut out at power loss, as in incidents like AA191 and PSA182 where they cut out well before impact.
 
Man, that jump to "well maybe it's a bomb" just makes me sad. Working on the ramp was always a subject of pride. For me, at least. And it's easy, I know, to come to that conclusion of "some sap slipped something in the aft bin," since no one on the ramp is paid worth a damn, but boy doesn't that just make life difficult for the rest of us if it's true? Especially with the smurfs already running around saying "HA HA YOU DIDN'T BADGE CHALLENGE ME, I WAS HIDING BEHIND THE JETBRIDGE PILLAR OUT OF SIGHT THE WHOLE TIME!!" and getting you or a co-worker suspended for a few days.

I do hope the cause is determined quickly. I would not be surprised if it's a botch repair job....But I really hope it wasn't a bomb.
 
Man, that jump to "well maybe it's a bomb" just makes me sad. Working on the ramp was always a subject of pride. For me, at least. And it's easy, I know, to come to that conclusion of "some sap slipped something in the aft bin," since no one on the ramp is paid worth a damn, but boy doesn't that just make life difficult for the rest of us if it's true? Especially with the smurfs already running around saying "HA HA YOU DIDN'T BADGE CHALLENGE ME, I WAS HIDING BEHIND THE JETBRIDGE PILLAR OUT OF SIGHT THE WHOLE TIME!!" and getting you or a co-worker suspended for a few days.

I do hope the cause is determined quickly. I would not be surprised if it's a botch repair job....But I really hope it wasn't a bomb.
If it does turn out to be a bombing, I wouldn't assume that a Russian charter flight being attacked from a port that is home to ISIS-allied agents will affect much here on the home-front. Doesn't put US airliners from US ports any more at risk.
 
Back
Top