Airbus 321 crash in Egypt

From what I've gathered, a distress call from the crew requesting to divert to the nearest field is confirmed and investigators have pretty much ruled out a missile impact from the wreckage but a bomb is entirely possible. There have been various incidents in the past where a bomb has lead to structural failure causing a rapid climb, stall, and steep decent/breakup. CVR and FDR are already recovered so those should lend some reports soon. What's creepy is a Egyptian translated news report that said the "voices" heard by rescue teams turned out to be electronics still running(I'm guessing iPads and the like).

I know we have some A321 drivers on the forums. This A321 was in a max density all-coach config(i.e. a heavy bird) and yet made it above FL390(some reports say 310 so I'm not sure if this is correct) before the rapid descent? If it did indeed get to 390, that would have to have been from some outside force disrupting the aerodynamics, right? Everything I've ever read suggests the 321 flies like a pig compared to the smaller 320s, no way it could have got up there by the crews own hand, correct?

Surely that third picture isn't from the Airbus crash site?
No, that is an An-12.
 
Last edited:
I know we have some A321 drivers on the forums. This A321 was in a max density all-coach config(i.e. a heavy bird) and yet made it above FL390(some reports say 310 so I'm not sure if this is correct) before the rapid descent? If it did indeed get to 390, that would have to have been from some outside force disrupting the aerodynamics, right? Everything I've ever read suggests the 321 flies like a pig compared to the smaller 320s, no way it could have got up there by the crews own hand, correct?

She's is indeed a pig. And here is why:
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1446332177.747536.jpg


This chart shows an idea of a heavy, hot day.
Also, if you're really lazy, you can simply look at the FMS, at it will tell you, a "max" cruise altitude for you current configuration. ASSuming you programmed it correctly on the ground.
 
Surely that third picture isn't from the Airbus crash site?
Don't know, found them in several foreign papers reporting the story. They said that the bodies had been brought to those waiting ambulances for conveyance by helicopters, so I am guessing that no the ambulances are not at the crash site, but I have no clue where they are.
 
Last edited:
From what I've gathered, a distress call from the crew requesting to divert to the nearest field is confirmed and investigators have pretty much ruled out a missile impact from the wreckage but a bomb is entirely possible. There have been various incidents in the past where a bomb has lead to structural failure causing a rapid climb, stall, and steep decent/breakup. CVR and FDR are already recovered so those should lend some reports soon. What's creepy is a Egyptian translated news report that said the "voices" heard by rescue teams turned out to be electronics still running(I'm guessing iPads and the like).

I know we have some A321 drivers on the forums. This A321 was in a max density all-coach config(i.e. a heavy bird) and yet made it above FL390(some reports say 310 so I'm not sure if this is correct) before the rapid descent? If it did indeed get to 390, that would have to have been from some outside force disrupting the aerodynamics, right? Everything I've ever read suggests the 321 flies like a pig compared to the smaller 320s, no way it could have got up there by the crews own hand, correct?


No, that is an An-12.
You don't see a heavy 321 above 350 often. She gets heavy and it's hard to get it up.
 
Egyptian's aviation authority will investigate the accident. The same one that refused to accept the NTSB's final report for Egypt Air 990, did not acknowledge pilot suicide, and claimed in their report it was a "technical malfunction" of the aircraft which is what led to the crash.

Considering an Egyptian official is already saying "we don't know why it crashed, but most likely due to technical fault" , one has to dismiss their ridiculous demeanor.

Please send the black boxes to the USA (NTSB), UK (AAIB), France (BEA) or Germany (BFU). These 4 are world renowned and a much better alternative than the Egyptian authorities.
 
So as a bit of a study of aircraft accidents, the accident photos indicate to me, low if not zero forward speed on impact...

Interestingly, in the second photo, we see the nose of the airplane, with the cockpit area either sheared off, which contradicts the other wreckage, or pancaked from an inverted impact position, while somehow not crumpling the bottom side of the airframe... poor photos to ascertain exactly the condition, but from the angle, the cockpit appears completely destroyed...

metrojet_a321_ei-etj_sinai_151031_9.jpg


metrojet_a321_ei-etj_sinai_151031_8.jpg
 
Egyptian's aviation authority will investigate the accident. The same one that refused to accept the NTSB's final report for Egypt Air 990, did not acknowledge pilot suicide, and claimed in their report it was a "technical malfunction" of the aircraft which is what led to the crash.

Considering an Egyptian official is already saying "we don't know why it crashed, but most likely due to technical fault" , one has to dismiss their ridiculous demeanor.

Please send the black boxes to the USA (NTSB), UK (AAIB), France (BEA) or Germany (BFU). These 4 are world renowned and a much better alternative than the Egyptian authorities.

Religion and culture trump factual evidence. Asiana 214 was another example.
 
Religion and culture trump factual evidence. Asiana 214 was another example.

Huh? The NTSB was not motivated nor deterred by anything religious or cultural in their handling of the Asiana accident. It was handled with professionalism and a probably cause and explanation of the sequence of events that was spot-on accurate of what happened.
 
Huh? The NTSB was not motivated nor deterred by anything religious or cultural in their handling of the Asiana accident. It was handled with professionalism and a probably cause and explanation of the sequence of events that was spot-on accurate of what happened.

I should have been slightly more specific. The Korean government spun the NTSBs findings to absolve the crew of fault, and made them out to be heroes.
 
Back
Top