I was a member of SAFE and NAFI for my 2.5 years of active instructing. I joined SAFE in order to purchase their sponsored CFI liability insurance, and I joined NAFI just beacuse I wanted to be cool. I almost went for NAFI's Master Instructor accreditation, but I did not have enough activity before I got out of CFI-ing. I've since dropped both memberships.
Each organization had some good information on their website and sent great email newsletters, but honestly, I did not use any of it. I think they are a good resume booster if you are trying to land an instructor job or your first professional job out of CFI-ing (shows professional involvement, yada yada yada).
If you are really burning to spend some money, I would suggest signing up for AOPA's Legal Services Plus (protects Commercial/ATP/CFI) and their Medical Services. I know of several situations where fellow CFI's got in a pickle and really needed a lawyer to speak with. Their information desk will also answer general questions about the regulations and CFI stuff. I think this would be better money spent.
OP's question: the only "peep" I got for a student was some crazy, Nigerian-type scam soliciting flight instructors. My local flight school got the same email and the TSA ended up getting involved. So I'd say it wasn't terribly useful for building connections.