F16 down in Germany

You mean the last 35 years?

There's a reason for the "lawn dart" nickname.

Talked to an old test pilot once an that name came up. It is amazing how long people kept flying them with P&W looking at them going "I don't know why the engines keep failing."

Apparently it took a guy losing his engine on climb out and having enough altitude and testicle fortitude to flip it around and land it to let them figure it out.

Solution.... Buy GE Engines.
 
Talked to an old test pilot once an that name came up. It is amazing how long people kept flying them with P&W looking at them going "I don't know why the engines keep failing."

Apparently it took a guy losing his engine on climb out and having enough altitude and testicle fortitude to flip it around and land it to let them figure it out.

Solution.... Buy GE Engines.

PW motors weren't the problem really......still plenty of block 32/52's flying around just fine with them, as well as all F-15C and a decent portion of the F-15E fleet (though many are now -229 powered). The issue was the initial motor, the F100-PW-200, had a ton of rollback and locked-in stall problems early on, causing a rash of accidents. The EEC (analog FADEC) was replaced in the F100-PW-220 with the DEEC (digital version of this early FADEC), and the problems pretty much went away starting with the block 10/15 -220 equipped jets. I believe the early F-15A's had the same issue, with the same motors. The -220 isn't a bad motor at all, pretty simple, reliable, and with the digital engine control (PRI mode) it will generally keep you out of trouble. SEC, or the backup system is a lot more needy, but that is really just a "get-home" type of system if something major has already gone wrong with the motor, DEEC, or ignition. At least I have yet to have one, or know someone who has had one, poo the bed on them. I have a couple friends who have had a SEC reversion, but that really isn't a big deal......just shoot a straight in to a long runway and don't land long (nozzle stays closed for "get home" purposes so you have way more thrust at idle than in PRI)
 
PW motors weren't the problem really......still plenty of block 32/52's flying around just fine with them, as well as all F-15C and a decent portion of the F-15E fleet (though many are now -229 powered). The issue was the initial motor, the F100-PW-200, had a ton of rollback and locked-in stall problems early on, causing a rash of accidents. The EEC (analog FADEC) was replaced in the F100-PW-220 with the DEEC (digital version of this early FADEC), and the problems pretty much went away starting with the block 10/15 -220 equipped jets. I believe the early F-15A's had the same issue, with the same motors. The -220 isn't a bad motor at all, pretty simple, reliable, and with the digital engine control (PRI mode) it will generally keep you out of trouble. SEC, or the backup system is a lot more needy, but that is really just a "get-home" type of system if something major has already gone wrong with the motor, DEEC, or ignition. At least I have yet to have one, or know someone who has had one, poo the bed on them. I have a couple friends who have had a SEC reversion, but that really isn't a big deal......just shoot a straight in to a long runway and don't land long (nozzle stays closed for "get home" purposes so you have way more thrust at idle than in PRI)

Your right they weren't after the fix was made, but the reputation was set. It's like the Fiero, yeah the last year it was built it worked but by then who cares.

Really you can't blame big Blue for pushing into an alternative engine after all those issues when the entirety of its fleet was using those engines save for the F-4s and guard 106s. When you need a fully survived post crapped it's self motor to figure out what's wrong with it, your not building a lot of confidence.

End of the day GE got the best part of the deal on this.
 
Well for sure the GE motors are the ones you would like to have, at least for the power output, and hell, they make almost every other engine for US fighter aircraft. I had a GE (F404) completely run out of oil and there was no damage whatsoever to the motor.......though I did shut it down after the caution came on. However, in terms of PW motors, I'm surprised they never fitted the F-15C with the -229. That is like the mother of all F100s. I heard they test fitted it/test flew it in the airframe, but it didn't go anywhere.
 
Well for sure the GE motors are the ones you would like to have, at least for the power output, and hell, they make almost every other engine for US fighter aircraft. I had a GE (F404) completely run out of oil and there was no damage whatsoever to the motor.......though I did shut it down after the caution came on. However, in terms of PW motors, I'm surprised they never fitted the F-15C with the -229. That is like the mother of all F100s. I heard they test fitted it/test flew it in the airframe, but it didn't go anywhere.

That would simplify logistics tails and lower overall operational costs.... Can't have that now can we.

Sorta like how the Army still has 3 versions of the 701 engine in service in the 64 alone. And we are supposedly getting a 4th.
 
I'm surprised they never fitted the F-15C with the -229.

They would probably be better off with just taking the CFTs off of the E model... as far as airframe goes.

Our 229s are pretty solid motors. For how much fighter engines get abused and cycled, it's pretty amazing how reliable they really are. You can definitely feed the difference in the -229s over the -220s.
 
They would probably be better off with just taking the CFTs off of the E model... as far as airframe goes.

Our 229s are pretty solid motors. For how much fighter engines get abused and cycled, it's pretty amazing how reliable they really are. You can definitely feed the difference in the -229s over the -220s.

I'm curious has the Air Force ever done a study comparing airframe fatigue between the two?

Seems like the mass of something like CFTs vs Wing Tanks would be interesting given the age of our fleets and how long we are expected to keep riding these horses.
 
Back
Top