1099 CFIs are basically a class action lawsuit waiting to happen; there's no way we shouldn't be W2.
Why not? I have never given any instruction as an employee. If you want to be an employee, great, find an employer willing to hire you. If you are finding clients as a contractor? Great, handle the payroll, taxes, and insurance and such yourself.
Sadly, there is no litmus test for determining when to classify someone as a contractor vs. as an employee. Generally, setting their own schedule, managing themselves, and providing their own supplies. You can get the opinion of a CPA, but it is just that, an opinion. The IRS may well have a different one. If a flight school is setting your hours, having you answer phones, or sit behind a desk - that would likely fall on the W2 end of the spectrum.
For what it is worth, it has always worked out better for me being 1099 than being a W2 employee. When I became a W2 for a customer I had been working as a 1099 for, they still did not reimburse my business and travel expenses. While as a 1099 you deduct these right off the top of a schedule C, as a W2, you can and will run into the Alternative Minimum Tax, which really really really really sucks. So be careful what you wish for.