Right rudder

bc2209

Well-Known Member
I fly the small Diamond 40 which requires a good amount of right rudder at the appropriate times. I can only assume this to be true with the other small single engine trainers.

However, I started thinking about the bigger single engine airplanes that I get to see here and there.

What about the Pilatus's and the Caravan's and the TBM's. Do they also require a significant amount of the rudder on the takeoff roll and the like?

It could be a stupid question but I've yet to fly in a bigger single engine.
 
The lovely 207 requires a good amount. Caught me off guard after spending a year in a twin.
1530299_10151917361962391_665236283_n.jpg
 
I fly the small Diamond 40 which requires a good amount of right rudder at the appropriate times. I can only assume this to be true with the other small single engine trainers.

However, I started thinking about the bigger single engine airplanes that I get to see here and there.

What about the Pilatus's and the Caravan's and the TBM's. Do they also require a significant amount of the rudder on the takeoff roll and the like?

It could be a stupid question but I've yet to fly in a bigger single engine.
Yes larger single engine aircraft tend to be even more rudder intensive. However they also have rudder trim.
 
The 210 is the only big engine single I have time in. I don't remember it being all that dramatic though. Flight Express had us pre-dialing in a little bit of rudder trim though and that plane has a decent sized rudder for how small the plane is.

Some multis are quite rudder intensive too, though not quite for the same reasons.

Not on the takeoff roll, but Barons and Beech 99s get into some of the craziest yaw oscillations in turbulence that I've seen out of all the planes I've flown. Maybe it's a Beech thing...

I imagine something like a beech 18 would need a lot of right rudder on the takeoff roll when the tail comes up.
 
I never understood how these things kept it straight on TO with their dinky little rudders...

c3e32f8909ddd197f053607949259658.jpg
Well that wheel back there helps, but mostly you don't jam the power forward like an idiot. Not only can it torque roll the thing on the ground, but you'll probably blow a few jugs off to.
 
Yes larger single engine aircraft tend to be even more rudder intensive. However they also have rudder trim.
Tailwheel aircraft tend to be a lot more rudder intensive. It's fun to hand the controls over to someone and watch them try to make a turn. "Uh, ya, that's a slip, let's try turning now." While you're approaching 60 degrees of bank but going straight.

Something like a Maule with a 540 up front also requires the aforementioned don't add power like an idiot.

Then there's floats! Rolling the power on 45+ degrees to the direction you want to go.
 
Tailwheel aircraft tend to be a lot more rudder intensive. It's fun to hand the controls over to someone and watch them try to make a turn. "Uh, ya, that's a slip, let's try turning now." While you're approaching 60 degrees of bank but going straight.

Something like a Maule with a 540 up front also requires the aforementioned don't add power like an idiot.

Then there's floats! Rolling the power on 45+ degrees to the direction you want to go.

Get your float rating yet? If not Don Lee up in TKA is awesome.
 
The rudder trim position for takeoff in the PC-12 was almost all the way to the right limit, and every now and then you'd get an airplane that you had to put a bootfull in to help. 1200 horseys swinging that big prop makes for a lot of torque! Thankfully the autopilot did a really good job of trimming the rudder, and I want to say the yaw damper drove the rudder trim too, but I've been out of the airplane for a while. Also, go arounds could be fun if you weren't ready for them, but like most airplane things, as long as you're ready to fly the frickin' airplane, there was no issue.
 
The rudder trim position for takeoff in the PC-12 was almost all the way to the right limit, and every now and then you'd get an airplane that you had to put a bootfull in to help. 1200 horseys swinging that big prop makes for a lot of torque! Thankfully the autopilot did a really good job of trimming the rudder, and I want to say the yaw damper drove the rudder trim too, but I've been out of the airplane for a while. Also, go arounds could be fun if you weren't ready for them, but like most airplane things, as long as you're ready to fly the frickin' airplane, there was no issue.

You know, the rudder trim indicator has that little green mark so that you know where to trim to before flight. ;)
 
You know, the rudder trim indicator has that little green mark so that you know where to trim to before flight. ;)

Right thats what I meant, the little green mark is waaaaaay to the right. But I think some airplanes were a little out of rig, and you'd have to help on the rudder a lot more than some other airplanes.
 
I never understood how these things kept it straight on TO with their dinky little rudders...

c3e32f8909ddd197f053607949259658.jpg

If you watch videos of big piston fighters taking off, you can hear the pilots make two different power applications on the takeoff roll. They'll initially apply enough power to get rolling, get airflow over the rudder, and get the tail airborne, and then once there's more flight control authority they'll go to full takeoff manifold pressure.

The airplanes have a long history of fatal accidents with low speed losses of control during go-arounds. This is generally a result of plain ol' pilot error, due to negative-transfer of habits learned in other aircraft where you can jam the throttle to the firewall during a go-around or balked landing without losing control.
 
I never understood how these things kept it straight on TO with their dinky little rudders...

c3e32f8909ddd197f053607949259658.jpg

Lots and lots of flight testing including some innovative aerodynamic solutions. Good book called Whistling Death chronicles the tons of sweat and a little blood that went into the design, Naval acceptance, and improvements of the Corsair.
 
I never understood how these things kept it straight on TO with their dinky little rudders...

c3e32f8909ddd197f053607949259658.jpg

The engineers who designed the WW2 fighters also employed several tricks to augment the rudders.

The vertical stabilizer was not always aligned with the longitudinal axis of the airplane, rather it was sometimes a degree or so off center for a permanent amount of rudder trim. Also the engine was not installed straight either to offset some of the torque. Furthermore, look at how much of the vertical fin is rudder on that Corsair, it's almost 70% rudder on a fairly long arm so there is quite a lot of authority.

As was posted before, they did not go to full power until they had some decent amount of airflow over the controls. Modern high power singles with free castering nosewheels have to do the same thing. In the SR-22, I throttle up by 1/3rds as it accelerates (1/3 to get rolling, 1/3 to 40 kts, and full power near Vr). If you just jam the throttle forward from a standing start, it will head for the left side of the runway pretty quickly.
 
I never understood how these things kept it straight on TO with their dinky little rudders...

c3e32f8909ddd197f053607949259658.jpg

The engineers who designed the WW2 fighters also employed several tricks to augment the rudders.

The vertical stabilizer was not always aligned with the longitudinal axis of the airplane, rather it was sometimes a degree or so off center for a permanent amount of rudder trim. Also the engine was not installed straight either to offset some of the torque. Furthermore, look at how much of the vertical fin is rudder on that Corsair, it's almost 70% rudder on a fairly long arm so there is quite a lot of authority.

As was posted before, they did not go to full power until they had some decent amount of airflow over the controls. Modern high power singles with free castering nosewheels have to do the same thing. In the SR-22, I throttle up by 1/3rds as it accelerates (1/3 to get rolling, 1/3 to 40 kts, and full power near Vr). If you just jam the throttle forward from a standing start, it will head for the left side of the runway pretty quickly.
 
I remember setting rudder trim far right for takeoff in the pilatipus

The t-28 took a bit as well iirc
 
The engineers who designed the WW2 fighters also employed several tricks to augment the rudders.

The vertical stabilizer was not always aligned with the longitudinal axis of the airplane, rather it was sometimes a degree or so off center for a permanent amount of rudder trim. Also the engine was not installed straight either to offset some of the torque. Furthermore, look at how much of the vertical fin is rudder on that Corsair, it's almost 70% rudder on a fairly long arm so there is quite a lot of authority.

That's pretty interesting. I never knew any of that. Thanks for the info.
 
What I've noticed about the pilatipi is that with rudder trimmed for takeoff, it does a pretty good job on it's own although just as the airplane comes off the runway you need a fair bit of right rudder added, similar to what it took in a -172...for about the three seconds you're airborne before you turn on the yaw damper, at which point you may commence sandwich-making. The other thing Pilatus did when they built the thing is offset the engine/propeller axis by 2 degrees right and 2 degrees down from the airplane's longitudinal axis. Seeing the airplane from a distance you can't really tell but if you stand directly in front of the airplane you can see the offset.
 
Back
Top