Thanks for all the help. I still feel that I'm over looking such a simple maneuver but I should be able to knock this out.
A decade! That has to be a JC necro-post record!
Just goes to show... There's some good stuff if you use that there search function.
Power matters, but only inasmuch as how you set it (and thereby create your initial energy) at the beginning of the maneuver. It's an exercise in energy management, so power should really be left alone. If it starts getting all FUBAR and you choose to try to save it, go ahead and adjust power. But then you're adding a bunch of new variables you're going to have to adjust for.How can you account for my example of doing a lazy 8 at idle power or at full power then? They won't work out.
I'm not saying you're wrong, I just don't understand how you can say power doesn't matter. I think part of the commercial manuevers is learning how to use power appropriately to complete a maneuver. I don't think you should be jockeying with the throttle at all once the maneuver is started, but you have to set the power correctly to begin with.
It's been a while since I've done lazy 8's, but if you either end up too high, or at the correct altitude but too fast (because you were going to be too high so you forced it down to altitude, therefore gaining airspeed), that means you initiated the maneuver with too much power.
Think of it this way--if you pull the power to idle and do a lazy 8, you will end too low (duh, obviously, you're just gliding), and if you go to full power, you are going to end up too high, because climbs are the result of excess thrust, and full power will mean you have excess thrust. You have to find the perfect power setting in the middle that puts you out where you want to be at the end.
Also, remember that the outside temperature affect the amount of power required. That means that manifold pressure will need to change based on the weather...a little higher MP in the summer, a little lower MP in the winter. I've never thought about this for a 172 before, but it has manifold pressure too--just no gauge for it and no way to precisely set it. But you get the idea...more throttle in the summer and less throttle in the winter.
Good luck with your flying...I found commercial training to not necessarily be the hardest, but definately the most frustrating training.
I didn't look at the usernames and was happy for the guy that he finally figured out lazy 8s after 10 years.A decade! That has to be a JC necro-post record!
Just goes to show... There's some good stuff if you use that there search function.