Screw 117.27/.15

I'm not saying 117 is stupid. I'm saying it's stupid that this piece of it was written specifically for CDOs and this specific example I'm using just slipped through the crack.

It's stupid that I can do 4 standups in a row, but not 4 early shows given the regulation.

I'm just pissed at the technicality, I don't think all of 117 is dumb.
There's a good handful of regulations that end up effecting something I'd imagine they were never intended to. And it's annoying. But thems the rules.
 
It is the lesser of the Table B limit plus four hours OR sixteen hours, although I assume you're talking about FDP extensions.

Good Captains, since Captain concurrence is required for any FDP extension, will ask you if you want to extend. I'll be saying "no" at that point. If he decides to be unpleasant about it, I'll call in fatigued.

117.27 Consecutive Nighttime Operations

A certificate holder may schedule and a flightcrew member may accept up to five consecutive flight duty periods that infringe on the window of circadian low if the certificate holder provides the flightcrew member with an opportunity to rest in a suitable accommodation during each of the consecutive nighttime flight duty periods. The rest opportunity must be at least 2 hours, measured from the time that the flightcrew member reaches the suitable accommodation, and must comply with the conditions specified in § 117.15(a), (c), (d), and (e). Otherwise, no certificate holder may schedule and no flightcrew member may accept more than three consecutive flight duty periods that infringe on the window of circadian low. For purposes of this section, any split duty rest that is provided in accordance with § 117.15 counts as part of a flight duty period.

Here's the problem.

The WOCL is defined as 0200-0559 during a physiological night. We don't do any re-acclimation here, so we're stuck with Pacific (OP is Fresno based). (A thought I had in the shower one morning was "what happens when the DST thing happens," and it's never been thoroughly addressed.)

It is entirely possible that we're doin' it wrong and have misread it, and have been misreading it for almost ten months, and if we are, please enlighten us so I can go back to AM 4-days, but this regulation prohibits a traditional morning-shift four day with reports of (say) 0530, 0435, 0435, 0500 - or the example that the OP gave us. All four flight duty periods infringe upon the window of circadian low without meeting the requirements of of the regulation.

So, if any portion of the FDP touches the WOCL (0200-0559) it is a Night Duty.
You may only be scheduled for more that 3 consecutive but no more that 5 night duties when you are given a break of two hours in all the FDP's that touch the WOCL of at least 2:00, between the 22:00 and 05:00 after the 1st flight leg of the FDP.

So if you have an Airport Standby that starts at before 05:59, its a Night Duty, but a Short-Call Reserve that starts before 05:59 is not, cause it is not a FDP.

The FAA actually answered my question back on 05-March-23:

A4A, Jeppesen, and Alaska Air asked whether an FDP that begins during the WOCL infringes on the WOCL
for purposes of § 117.27. As discussed above, § 117.27 prohibits a flightcrew member from accepting and a
certificate holder from scheduling five consecutive FDPs “that infringe on the window of circadian low” if the
flightcrew member assigned to these FDPs does not receive mid-duty rest periods that are specified in § 117.27.
In the preamble to the final rule, the FAA explained that “[t]he consecutive-night limit is intended to apply to
FDPs that infringe on the WOCL because operations conducted during the WOCL significantly increase
cumulative fatigue.”
Accordingly, an FDP “infringe on the window of circadian low” for the purposes of § 117.27 if any portion of
that FDP takes place during the WOCL. Thus, an operation that begins during the WOCL would “infringe on
the window of circadian low” and be subject to § 117.27 because a portion of that operation would be conducted
during the WOCL. An operation that remains entirely free of the WOCL would not “infringe on the window of
circadian low” for the purposes of § 117.27 because no portion of that operation would be conducted during the WOCL.
 
Hot damn. So far my domestic experience has been mixed between "how is this legal?" and "I'm fatigued just trying to figure this out"
 
So, if any portion of the FDP touches the WOCL (0200-0559) it is a Night Duty.
You may only be scheduled for more that 3 consecutive but no more that 5 night duties when you are given a break of two hours in all the FDP's that touch the WOCL of at least 2:00, between the 22:00 and 05:00 after the 1st flight leg of the FDP.

So if you have an Airport Standby that starts at before 05:59, its a Night Duty, but a Short-Call Reserve that starts before 05:59 is not, cause it is not a FDP.

The FAA actually answered my question back on 05-March-23:

A4A, Jeppesen, and Alaska Air asked whether an FDP that begins during the WOCL infringes on the WOCL
for purposes of § 117.27. As discussed above, § 117.27 prohibits a flightcrew member from accepting and a
certificate holder from scheduling five consecutive FDPs “that infringe on the window of circadian low” if the
flightcrew member assigned to these FDPs does not receive mid-duty rest periods that are specified in § 117.27.
In the preamble to the final rule, the FAA explained that “[t]he consecutive-night limit is intended to apply to
FDPs that infringe on the WOCL because operations conducted during the WOCL significantly increase
cumulative fatigue.”
Accordingly, an FDP “infringe on the window of circadian low” for the purposes of § 117.27 if any portion of
that FDP takes place during the WOCL. Thus, an operation that begins during the WOCL would “infringe on
the window of circadian low” and be subject to § 117.27 because a portion of that operation would be conducted
during the WOCL. An operation that remains entirely free of the WOCL would not “infringe on the window of
circadian low” for the purposes of § 117.27 because no portion of that operation would be conducted during the WOCL.
That's...that's exactly what I said.
 
So if there's a 2 hour sit somewhere in the FDPof one of the days, then it's legal to go more than 3 in a row, or does each of them need a 2 hour sit to go say 4 in a row?
As was pointed out during my recurrent, there are some rather nasty scheduling scenarios that could result from this. Like...IAH-ONT, 2 hours of 'rest' and then back. Sounds like it could be awfully wearing.
 
I swear, some people are never satisfied. For years, we've been asking the Feds to do something about fatigue. Now they've done, uh, well, something. And you're still complaining!

Red eyes are hands down more fatiguing than anything I did in my 8 years at a commuter. The majority of F/Os in my pad report having their CA fall asleep at least once while doing them.

10 hours min rest would've fixed 80% of the issues at the commuter level (why the FDP thing was brought up in the first place).
14 hours max duty time would've fixed another 15%
9 hours scheduled block (but actual un-restricted) would've given the airlines more flexibility with the max duty time capped.

Done. Finite.

FAR 117 still permits high speeds and red eyes, here's a surprise, if you fly during the night on little rest you're going to be tired.

Instead we ended up with this convoluted metric that can't even be deciphered let alone applied.
 
Red eyes are hands down more fatiguing than anything I did in my 8 years at a commuter. The majority of F/Os in my pad report having their CA fall asleep at least once while doing them.

10 hours min rest would've fixed 80% of the issues at the commuter level (why the FDP thing was brought up in the first place).
14 hours max duty time would've fixed another 15%

FAR 117 still permits high speeds and red eyes, here's a surprise, if you fly during the night on little rest you're going to be tired.

Instead we ended up with this convoluted metric that can't even be deciphered let alone applied.
They goofed. They should have given us controlled napping too.
 
They goofed. They should have given us controlled napping too.
Nope, 117 was based on science. Which is unquestionable and never improved upon given better evidence. Also, there were no industry pressures at all when the rule making was taking place.
 
Nope, 117 was based on science. Which is unquestionable and never improved upon given better evidence. Also, there were no industry pressures at all when the rule making was taking place.
I think the SDO/highspeed thing is the best example of industry pressure.

I hate, hate, hate, standups, and refuse to believe that I'll be safer on the third or fourth consecutive one than just sucking it up and having a "normal" rest period that happens to terminate during my WOCL.
 
I think the SDO/highspeed thing is the best example of industry pressure.

I hate, hate, hate, standups, and refuse to believe that I'll be safer on the third or fourth consecutive one than just sucking it up and having a "normal" rest period that happens to terminate during my WOCL.

They're trying to push "high speeds" on us.

Side A says "That doesn't sound safe"

Side B says "Oh man, they used to go SENIOR at XYZ!"

I hated standups at Skyway, they used to kick my ass, I'd microsleep the next and spend most of the last day recovering.

It was something lie MKE-MSN-MKE-MQT (sit for 4 hrs) MQT-MKE-MDW-MKE

Some guys love 'em. I think you can create some very unsafe pairings with loose contract language and stretching the FARs.
 
I think the SDO/highspeed thing is the best example of industry pressure.

I hate, hate, hate, standups, and refuse to believe that I'll be safer on the third or fourth consecutive one than just sucking it up and having a "normal" rest period that happens to terminate during my WOCL.
Red eyes here have a 22-27-ish hour layover.

The new thing however is "pink eyes"
Show is around 6:30-7:30am, 11-12 hours "rest" from 2-8 pm, then fly back 10-5:30 to 6:30 am.

Besides a quick nap, you're basically up for 24 hours straight. Last one I did I bought a 2 liter of Diet Coke to keep me going.
 
Now I want to vomit.

I would rather lick a toilet bowl than take a gullet full of aspartame. Ick!
Uh, get the splenda diet coke DUH!
image_dietcokesweetenedwithsplenda_official2.jpg
 
Ungh, no thanks. I just treat regular coke like a dessert/treat and mostly drink ice tea.
 
Back
Top