OpenAirplane

+1

A VX pilot told me a story when he tried to rent from Palo Alto and for the checkout, the CFI spent a full 40 minutes doing nothing but going through his logbook. Apparently, being told that one is a A320 pilot who hasn't flown GA planes in 10 years was not enough. I can understand wanting a cursory glance just to gauge experience level, but a full 40 minutes is just a ludicrous attempt to collect the Bay Area CFI rate.

Take a big sniff of air, plop down hard into a chair, and with your best Boss Hogg impression say, "I'm not paying you one cent to read my logbooks there, sonny-boy. I'm paying for a checkout in that bug-smasher over there. (points lazily with one thumb, and back at himself) The plane I'm paid to fly burns more dead dinosaurs idling for 30 seconds than you do all day. Since I've been flying planes since you were just an itch, why don't you hop to it there, stop wasting my time, and fetch me someone who shaves more than twice a month along with your printed syllabus and standards for this here checkout. You make it back here with that, a cup of coffee, and a smile - and maybe... just maybe, I'll teach you (points with a finger at the instructors chest) how to fly right."

(The funny thing, is that is an amalgamation of about the 6 or so worst Captains I have flown with in my career... and I can see most of them doing this exact thing.)

Seriously, how about... what Derg said. My money + experience in this insane industry = not being taken for a ride by overzealous CFI's & flight schools. It might be time to head across the field to a more reasonable school/facility.

Or, what I would do... right at the beginning the simple, "What are your standards and syllabus for this checkout, with an expected timeframe for each item listed. And give me and example of what you are looking for a base knowledge standard for a sample question" And a friendly but firm reminder that you are not paying for a logbook review.

If they want to chat with me about flying or my experience in the 121 world, that will be a pleasure for me and gratis for both of us.
 
Unfortunately, you're right. For most of us on this forum, a checkout shouldn't be the slightest deal, but we have to set the basic standards for the lowest common denominator (for example...a good portion of the weekend warrior population).

If it keeps "Mom and Pop" in business, I'm okay with that. Aviation isn't cheap anymore. The way I see it is accept it, or don't. And when I say keeping Mom and Pop in business, I'm talking about keeping rental rates down with insurance rates as low as possible.
 
Unfortunately, you're right. For most of us on this forum, a checkout shouldn't be the slightest deal, but we have to set the basic standards for the lowest common denominator (for example...a good portion of the weekend warrior population).
This looks awfully meticulous (PDF target) to me. As in, I'd sort of like someone to take me out in my GA airplane and put me through it. *shrug*

If it keeps "Mom and Pop" in business, I'm okay with that. Aviation isn't cheap anymore. The way I see it is accept it, or don't. And when I say keeping Mom and Pop in business, I'm talking about keeping rental rates down with insurance rates as low as possible.
Just as the hourly pay rate in a working arrangement is meaningless if you don't have good work rules, a low rental/insurance rate is meaningless if I have to buy more hours in a checkout than is necessary for the safety of an operation.
 
Or, what I would do... right at the beginning the simple, "What are your standards and syllabus for this checkout, with an expected timeframe for each item listed. And give me and example of what you are looking for a base knowledge standard for a sample question" And a friendly but firm reminder that you are not paying for a logbook review.
That sounds somewhat like every 121 training event I've ever had. Ever.

"Here's the objective, how we'll get there, and the completion standards. Now let's go can some engines."
 
This looks awfully meticulous (PDF target) to me. As in, I'd sort of like someone to take me out in my GA airplane and put me through it. *shrug*


Just as the hourly pay rate in a working arrangement is meaningless if you don't have good work rules, a low rental/insurance rate is meaningless if I have to buy more hours in a checkout than is necessary for the safety of an operation.

There is no denying that some checkouts are arduously long. And that's the main reason why I am skeptical about this program. It's because of the variance in flight instructors/flight schools. You know the reputation CP has over the hill. Very competent capable instructors that Clay and Judy aren't afraid to let go if they don't meet expectstions. Then, look at a place like American or Vista in the valley. This is what I'm getting at. To much variation between rental/instruction places.
 
That sounds somewhat like every 121 training event I've ever had. Ever.

"Here's the objective, how we'll get there, and the completion standards. Now let's go can some engines."

I must be getting old, because that's what I expect every time I show up at the schoolhouse. I would hope to find the same thing at a flight school... with that same relaxed atmosphere of learning.

This looks awfully meticulous (PDF target) to me. As in, I'd sort of like someone to take me out in my GA airplane and put me through it. *shrug*

I like it... you can combine a lot of items and run it like an abbreviated checkride, also give the person the checklist before they show up and they can have a bunch of the pre-flight stuff done. It reads like a PTS to me. A little work on the part of the instructor getting a flow set up, but I would guess that just about every CFI @ every flight school knows the 'local gouge' for a PPL checkride and you can shave off the serial numbers and make it your own.

Anyhoo, all this talk makes me want to go get checked out down in Camarillo and burn a few holes in the sky in a 172 or something like that. Instead, I guess I should go fly this red-eye back to the east coast and see if I can trick FIFI into behaving like an airplane.
 
Hi folks,

I'm Rod, I'm a co-founder at OpenAirplane.

I'm late to the thread, but I wanted to make myself available here to answer questions on how we're making this work. We always imagined that pilots flying in the 135 and 121 environments would take quickly to how we've applied the concepts of standardization / evaluation to part 91 flying.

We try our best to explain how OpenAirplane works online here:

http://pilots.OpenAirplane.com

Please feel free to drop me a line or reply here if you have questions or I can be of help.

I look forward to you flying with us soon.

~ Rod

email: rod@OpenAirplane.com
Operation Support: (888) 998-1721
 
Hi folks,

I'm Rod, I'm a co-founder at OpenAirplane.

I'm late to the thread, but I wanted to make myself available here to answer questions on how we're making this work. We always imagined that pilots flying in the 135 and 121 environments would take quickly to how we've applied the concepts of standardization / evaluation to part 91 flying.

We try our best to explain how OpenAirplane works online here:

http://pilots.OpenAirplane.com

Please feel free to drop me a line or reply here if you have questions or I can be of help.

I look forward to you flying with us soon.

~ Rod

email: rod@OpenAirplane.com
Operation Support: (888) 998-1721

I'm all for it. I would join as soon as you guys find/open places in the Ohio and/or western Pennsylvania area. Btw, it seems all the places available right now are flight school/FBOs. I read that you guys are opening the program to private aircraft owners. Have any signed up so far?
 
I'm all for it. I would join as soon as you guys find/open places in the Ohio and/or western Pennsylvania area. Btw, it seems all the places available right now are flight school/FBOs. I read that you guys are opening the program to private aircraft owners. Have any signed up so far?

Thank you.

We're working on it. Collaborative Aircraft Rental is still new, and we're still tuning the program. We've heard from over 200 aircraft owners expressing interest and we're working to on-board individually owned airplanes to the fleet.

We're working to add new locations as quickly as we can. (We're averaging about one a week now.) If you know a great place to rent, we'd appreciate the introduction. Our pitch to flight schools, flying clubs, and FBOs is online here:

http://operators.OpenAirplane.com

I hope we can make flying easier, safer, and more fun.

~ Rod
 
Rod, good luck with your venture. I founded a flight school 10 years ago and we really wanted such an operation. Hope you can make it work.

Our problem was human factors. You can machine a piece of metal to a certain tolerance and it works every time. But two pilots - each with X hours over Y years, Z of which have been in the past 30 days (which meet checkout requirements) - will operate very differently, and just because one is safe and prudent doesn't mean that they'll ALL fly that way. We've had more than our share of guys who met the criteria on paper, but you wouldn't trust them to competently parallel park a car. We've had to tell some that they couldn't take our airplane into Class B. Pisses them off to be sure, and I'm sure they badmouthed us later, but they simply weren't safe or competent, and they weren't using one of our birds to fly their girlfriend to DFW for the weekend.
 
I like it... you can combine a lot of items and run it like an abbreviated checkride, also give the person the checklist before they show up and they can have a bunch of the pre-flight stuff done. It reads like a PTS to me. A little work on the part of the instructor getting a flow set up, but I would guess that just about every CFI @ every flight school knows the 'local gouge' for a PPL checkride and you can shave off the serial numbers and make it your own.

Anyhoo, all this talk makes me want to go get checked out down in Camarillo and burn a few holes in the sky in a 172 or something like that. Instead, I guess I should go fly this red-eye back to the east coast and see if I can trick FIFI into behaving like an airplane.
Camarillo Flight Instruction would be my recommendation for that. (Based at Air7) They'll check you out and toss you a key and the rest is up to you. A very grown-up way of checking people out for rentals. The owner is a cool guy too.

Oh, and then let me know afterwards and we'll go beer.
 
There is no denying that some checkouts are arduously long. And that's the main reason why I am skeptical about this program. It's because of the variance in flight instructors/flight schools. You know the reputation CP has over the hill. Very competent capable instructors that Clay and Judy aren't afraid to let go if they don't meet expectstions. Then, look at a place like American or Vista in the valley. This is what I'm getting at. To much variation between rental/instruction places.
Yeah, and that checkout is just about as meticulous as you can get, and there's a system in place to weed out bad apples who do manage to slam the airplane through its paces but still shouldn't be permitted to drive around...
 
Yeah, and that checkout is just about as meticulous as you can get, and there's a system in place to weed out bad apples who do manage to slam the airplane through its paces but still shouldn't be permitted to drive around...

I think their checkout was pretty simple. A quick written test on the airplanes limitations, cross country requirements, and basic regs. Sit down and talk with an instructor for maybe 20 minutes so they can get a feel for your flying background. Tell them(renter) about the special checkout for Big Bear and Catalina, then go and fly. A standard take off, show me a stall, take me to either Camarillo or Oxnard(as a diversion, you're going to pick one, then when you head there I'm going to tell you it just closed so you'll have to go to the other one). On the way back, pull the power somewhere for a simulated engine failure, and we're done. Not to tough, but yes, meticulous. It should be. You are not only renting something that can kill you, but if you bend it all up, you can possibly interrupt the revenue stream. Flight schools usually operate on razor thin margins, and they are looking to protect that. It also helps to keep prices reasonable at the good schools.

BTW, that check out usually results in about .5-7 ground and another .7-8 in the air. Pretty reasonable. If you drop out of currency, a few bounce and goes, and were done. I had a policy that I wouldn't charge for any ground on a currency flight, and once we were done with the bounce and goes, there isn't even a need to shut the airplane down. Just drop me off at the ramp, keep the prop spinning, and go have an good time.
 
Last edited:
+1

A VX pilot told me a story when he tried to rent from Palo Alto and for the checkout, the CFI spent a full 40 minutes doing nothing but going through his logbook. Apparently, being told that one is a A320 pilot who hasn't flown GA planes in 10 years was not enough. I can understand wanting a cursory glance just to gauge experience level, but a full 40 minutes is just a ludicrous attempt to collect the Bay Area CFI rate.

That was exactly my experience at Palo Alto as well...
 
+1

A VX pilot told me a story when he tried to rent from Palo Alto and for the checkout, the CFI spent a full 40 minutes doing nothing but going through his logbook. Apparently, being told that one is a A320 pilot who hasn't flown GA planes in 10 years was not enough. I can understand wanting a cursory glance just to gauge experience level, but a full 40 minutes is just a ludicrous attempt to collect the Bay Area CFI rate.

Yeah, after about 3 minutes of that it would be "what are you planning on finding in there?" If it doesn't move on from there, "Okay, we're done here. Thanks for your time."
 
It would be nice to rent a plane fly somewhere for a few days and then fly back. Would this be possible? Would you have to pay a min amount per day, even if you don't fly that day?
 
Rod, good luck with your venture. I founded a flight school 10 years ago and we really wanted such an operation. Hope you can make it work.

Our problem was human factors. You can machine a piece of metal to a certain tolerance and it works every time. But two pilots - each with X hours over Y years, Z of which have been in the past 30 days (which meet checkout requirements) - will operate very differently, and just because one is safe and prudent doesn't mean that they'll ALL fly that way. We've had more than our share of guys who met the criteria on paper, but you wouldn't trust them to competently parallel park a car. We've had to tell some that they couldn't take our airplane into Class B. Pisses them off to be sure, and I'm sure they badmouthed us later, but they simply weren't safe or competent, and they weren't using one of our birds to fly their girlfriend to DFW for the weekend.

Thanks Tom.

We're inspired by the same principles of stan /eval that makes commercial and military flying work. We don't think what's in a pilot's logbook tells the right story. We're finding that a combination of objective evaluation (the Universal Pilot Checkout) and subjective reputation (pilot and review) works well.
 
Back
Top