Pilot doesn't know how to use a transponder...

Suffice to say, I have no idea who Redwood is either.

I learned who "Mercury" was last month.

Yes, but that's to be expected. You're an expert at the Speedbirds and Springboks of the world. But a guy doing 3-5 legs per day into JFK? I thought seeing a Virgin America would at least raise a "ZOMG! Foreign ownership! Cabbage! That Branson is taking yer jobs!!!!"
 
Yes, but that's to be expected. You're an expert at the Speedbirds and Springboks of the world. But a guy doing 3-5 legs per day into JFK? I thought seeing a Virgin America would at least raise a "ZOMG! Foreign ownership! Cabbage! That Branson is taking yer jobs!!!!"

Meh, it's not that shocking.

I used to fly for Skyway. When people didn't know who Skyway was, it really wouldn't register on my ego's "Geiger Counter".
 
Meh, it's not that shocking.

I used to fly for Skyway. When people didn't know who Skyway was, it really wouldn't register on my ego's "Geiger Counter".

I understand. I don't mind if others don't know, no one knows them all. I'm just a nerd type and will jot down one I don't know and look it up later. Or strange plane liveries I haven't seen, I'll jot down their tail number and search them to see who they are.
 
I understand. I don't mind if others don't know, no one knows them all. I'm just a nerd type and will jot down one I don't know and look it up later. Or strange plane liveries I haven't seen, I'll jot down their tail number and search them to see who they are.
There's usually beer and internet porn I'm more concerned with on layovers.
 
That was stressful just listening to it.

I think "they" should make all the ATC staffers police. What a much more peaceful world we would have. What psych screening is given to ATC? It's obviously awesomely effective. Who among us could put up with that kinda "stuff" with such calm and aplomb? Bravo, ATC.
 
Just a week ago I was on a long final, started making calls about 20nm while still with center. As I got closer saw a diamond flying in circles about 5nm on the other side of the field, tried calling him a few times but he didn't answer. As I pulled back the power in the flare, there he is on about a mile final for the opposite end. I tried telling him to go around, nothing. I had to slam on the brakes to make the first taxiway halfway down. It wasn't till I had half the plane off the runway and he was around 50ft that he went around...and then finally came on the radio and said sorry didn't see you. What!? The sun was in my face and behind him, how is it possible to not see me rolling on the runway you're trying to land on?

I'm always amused how two pilots are involved in an incident and it's always 100% the other guys fault.

A couple of years ago my friend was NNW bound VFR at 10,500 not talking to anyone. Over a popular SoCal VOR he has a near miss with west bound traffic at HIS altitude. He wished he could have gotten the other guys tail number so he could turn him in to the FAA because the other guy almost hit him. ???

Here we got a pilot who made a 20 mile straight in to an uncontrolled airport. Sees a Diamond making turns to the opposite runway. Lands against the flow and it's 100% the other guys fault.

Am I missing something here?
 
I'm always amused how two pilots are involved in an incident and it's always 100% the other guys fault.

A couple of years ago my friend was NNW bound VFR at 10,500 not talking to anyone. Over a popular SoCal VOR he has a near miss with west bound traffic at HIS altitude. He wished he could have gotten the other guys tail number so he could turn him in to the FAA because the other guy almost hit him. ???

Here we got a pilot who made a 20 mile straight in to an uncontrolled airport. Sees a Diamond making turns to the opposite runway. Lands against the flow and it's 100% the other guys fault.

Am I missing something here?

Yes you are, why would you automatically assume I landed against the flow? When I saw him he wasn't maneuvering toward the runway in any way, then he tried to land with a significant tail wind. I said I started calling at 20nm, I can cover that pretty quickly.
 
Last edited:
I'm always amused how two pilots are involved in an incident and it's always 100% the other guys fault.

A couple of years ago my friend was NNW bound VFR at 10,500 not talking to anyone. Over a popular SoCal VOR he has a near miss with west bound traffic at HIS altitude. He wished he could have gotten the other guys tail number so he could turn him in to the FAA because the other guy almost hit him. ???

Here we got a pilot who made a 20 mile straight in to an uncontrolled airport. Sees a Diamond making turns to the opposite runway. Lands against the flow and it's 100% the other guys fault.

Am I missing something here?
Nope, sounds spot on to how I read it. If you have visual on traffic in the vicinity of the airport you're landing at, wouldn't you try and maintain that contact to see what he's doing? He's not required to make calls, it's the whole see and avoid thing. I think your assessment is spot on @fholbert.
 
Yes you are, why would you automatically assume I landed against the flow? When I saw him he wasn't maneuvering toward the runway in any way, then he tried to land with a significant tail wind. I said I started calling at 20nm, I can cover that pretty quickly.


Your first statement makes you dirty as heck.
  • If you can ID the aircraft make he's a lot closer than 5 miles off the other end
  • You see the guy making turns to the runway but you continue your 20 mile straight in to the opposite runway.
  • You see a hazard developing but you continue your approach.
  • Short final you issue a go around command to the other pilot so you can land.
But forget about all that...

You land nose to nose with another aircraft at an uncontrolled airport you're at least 50% at fault.
 
Visible traffic near the pattern and no comms, I'm assuming standard pattern. If I think he hasn't seen me, I'm not going to continue my straight-in approach, it's his airspace until I have a better idea what he's doing.
 
Where I used to work a commercial checkride ended during preflight because of the alternator belt that "drives the propeller" of a 182RG. I wish I made that up. Fortunately the low cut shirt she wore didn't sway the examiner.
You mean a 182 doesn't have a belted PSRU?
 
If you can ID the aircraft make he's a lot closer than 5 miles off the other end
Didn't ID him till he was on the ramp.
You see the guy making turns to the runway but you continue your 20 mile straight in to the opposite runway.
You obviously didn't read what I wrote above.
You see a hazard developing but you continue your approach.
Huh? If I thought he would try to land against me, I had the right of way by the way, do you really think I would have continued?
Short final you issue a go around command to the other pilot so you can land.
You mean after I already landed. Do I really need to spell out why going around in that situation would be a bad idea for me?
But forget about all that...

You land nose to nose with another aircraft at an uncontrolled airport you're at least 50% at fault.
Sure, whatever you want to think.

Listen, I gave my most recent example of why guys with no situational awareness keep me up at night. This exact situation didn't even get me excited, but it's an all too common scenario I've seen out there and some of those do get my heart going. I'm In a SP jet with no TCAS. I get really busy below 10k, the last thing I need is some idiot in his TAA piston SE that one, cant figure out the right frequency, two, can't enter a traffic pattern correctly, and three, can't bother himself to look outside and see if there is other traffic on the runway he's landing at. If it had been a super cub with no radio, no problem, mistakes are made, but it's the totality of this pilots lack of SA that scares me. I upheld my end of the bargain, I expect something better than total incompetence on his end.
 
Last edited:
You land nose to nose with another aircraft at an uncontrolled airport you're at least 50% at fault.
I'll give you another situation.

Coming into an airport from the North, I get delay vectors about 40nm out because there is an IFR baron coming in from the south that's going to beat me. I can hear him, center asks if he has the field in sight, he says yes and is cleared for the visual. Center tells him there is an IFR arrival from the North, if you don't need IFR can you cancel so he can get in. All he says is "Roger". A minute goes by, center asks again, again he just says "Roger". I told center not to worry about it, about that time the pilot finally says he's going to cancel now, so I get my vectors in. 10-15 min later I've cancelled and I'm on the CTAF, where it's extremely busy with training flights, but everyone is talking and working together so it's easy going. I ended up doing a couple 360's so I could finally fit myself into the flow on downwind. Right as I roll wings level on downwind, I look down to see a baron landing opposite direction without a single call, making the 172 on short final go around. After I land I see it's the same tail number as the guy who supposedly had the field in site and landed 15 prior to me.

So do we all share a percentage of fault for what happened, or should that guy be called out for being an idiot and endangering people?
 
Back
Top