I bought a house

Absolutely. Unless you've got a mortgage rate over 6%, you shouldn't be paying it down faster than you have to. And if you do have a mortgage rate that high, you should be refinancing it. Most people can qualify for a streamline loan that doesn't even require an appraisal or cash at closing.

I'm in the process of doing this. We bought our house 7 years ago with an 80/20 loan. Just over 6% on the interest rate for both. Refinancing down to 4.25%. Shortens the loan life by 3 years and lowers our payment by 100 bucks.
 
So let me get this straight. Lets say you have a house with a mortgage around 3.25%, if you get done paying your bills and putting money in your retirement and have a $50-100 left, you'd advise either throwing it at your retirement or an investment for income portfolio vice paying down extra on the mortgage, because those investments over time will average better than the interest you're paying on the mortgage?

Just about any investment is going to be better than paying down mortgage principal at 3.25%. That interest rate is effectively even lower than that, since you are likely deducting that interest from your taxable income - so you can essentially reduce that figure by whatever your marginal income tax rate is - in my case it would be more like 2.34% that I am really paying. That is a really good rate for something I have effectively 27 year terms on.

A ROTH IRA is the best place to put extra money, if you can. You can take the money you put in back out, at any time, tax and penalty free.
 
Traditional IRAs & 401k's, post tax Roth IRAs are different
Unless some rules changed this year there are penalties if you take it out before 59½ or it hasn't sat for 5 years.

Exceptions. You may not have to pay the 10% additional tax in the following situations.
  • You have reached age 59½.

  • You are totally and permanently disabled.

  • You are the beneficiary of a deceased IRA owner.

  • You use the distribution to buy, build, or rebuild a first home.

  • The distributions are part of a series of substantially equal payments.

  • You have unreimbursed medical expenses that are more than 10% (or 7.5% if you or your spouse was born before January 2, 1949) of your adjusted gross income (defined earlier) for the year.

  • You are paying medical insurance premiums during a period of unemployment.

  • The distributions are not more than your qualified higher education expenses.

  • The distribution is due to an IRS levy of the qualified plan.

  • The distribution is a qualified reservist distribution.
 
Thanks @killbilly and a few others for the kind words.

Just to add a little fuel to the buy or not to buy fire (hehehe) The situation in Marin is really unique. It is super expensive to live out this way as you all know. My home purchase was basically a hedge on the rental situation. I've had a room in a house with a bunch of 20 somethings for over 5 years now and my rent was a paltry 700 bucks a month + utils. The house is being sold and I started to look for other rentals. Basically the rental market is out of control. Our house when it was rented to a family in 2007 was 3000 a month. It has 5 bedrooms. It was too much of a PITA to rent so the owners rented it to their son and he rented out the rooms basically making the same amount of $ but a lot less work.

When I found out I would lose my rental in May my 3 year home search switched to overdrive. I also looked for rentals and the two bedroom place with 1 parking spot across the street was 3400 dollars a month - its a condo with shared walls. 1 and 2 bedroom condos in less expensive parts of town were 2000 - 2600 bucks. To rent.

Also I rented the house back to the people I bought the house from for 30 days because they couldn't find a rental that they could afford. The poor couple have been priced right out of town. I'm not sure why they sold. I've already got a roommate ready to move in and even with all expenses and a little extra for projects my monthly housing expenses should be less than renting a crappy 2 bedroom condo.

It is a 3 bedroom place with a pool and a couple of outbuildings nice yard walk to downtown 2 parking spots one covered. In less than five years I'll be renting it out at a pretty decent rate. Or I'll have a lot of equity built up. I couldn't afford to buy the same house now only 2 months after we went into contract. The housing market is growing at a rate that will no doubt cause a crash again.
 
So after my year end bonus, saving and scrimping my entire joke of a "career" and borrowing from both sides of the family, I bought a house in Novato, CA.

There is not one day that goes by that I don't thank my lucky stars for being given an opportunity to leave XOJET and get a real job with some potential for growth. Looking back at my decisions over the last 10 years the only mistake I made was "sticking it out" and trying to "prove myself" to people who wouldn't bother to pee on me if I were on fire.

So when is the housewarming party??? I'll bring lots and lots of beer. Nice going, BTW. I've never understood how people with "normal" jobs can possibly afford to buy a house in California.. Honestly, I just don't get it. But, I'll still bring lots and lots of beer.
 
Just about any investment is going to be better than paying down mortgage principal at 3.25%. That interest rate is effectively even lower than that, since you are likely deducting that interest from your taxable income - so you can essentially reduce that figure by whatever your marginal income tax rate is - in my case it would be more like 2.34% that I am really paying. That is a really good rate for something I have effectively 27 year terms on.

A ROTH IRA is the best place to put extra money, if you can. You can take the money you put in back out, at any time, tax and penalty free.

Are you serious?! The "markets" have always been only marginally better than Vegas and for the same "house rules" reasons. Nowadays, with HFT, you will never win as an individual in the "markets". If you are not buying tangible assets, you are buying vapor and dreams.
 
Are you serious?! The "markets" have always been only marginally better than Vegas and for the same "house rules" reasons. Nowadays, with HFT, you will never win as an individual in the "markets". If you are not buying tangible assets, you are buying vapor and dreams.

This is the biggest bunch of nonsense I've ever heard. Any idiot can look at the market returns over any extended period of time and see that this is BS. HFT should be outlawed, but it certainly isn't going to harm the individual investor.
 
Unless some rules changed this year there are penalties if you take it out before 59½ or it hasn't sat for 5 years.

You pay penalties on the earnings, not on the original deposit amount. For example, if you deposit $5k in the Roth, its value builds up to $6,500 a few years later, and you withdraw the entire amount, then you pay taxes and a 10% penalty on the $1,500 in earnings, not on the original principal.
 
Unless some rules changed this year there are penalties if you take it out before 59½ or it hasn't sat for 5 years.

That is not correct. The 5 year "seasoning" rule determines whether you are making a "qualified distribution," in which case, it is possible that no tax may due on the earnings, or any penalty applied in addition.

The original contribution (not earnings), can be withdrawn tax and penalty free at any time.

Direct contributions to a Roth IRA (principal) may be withdrawn tax and penalty free at any time.[1] Earnings may be withdrawn tax and penalty free after 5 years if the condition of age 59½ (or other qualifying condition) is also met. Rollover, converted (before age 59½) contributions held in a Roth IRA may be withdrawn tax and penalty free after 5 years.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roth_IRA#cite_note-contributions-1

The IRS says the same thing, but not as clearly:

http://www.irs.gov/publications/p590/ch02.html#en_US_publink10006523
 
This is the biggest bunch of nonsense I've ever heard. Any idiot can look at the market returns over any extended period of time and see that this is BS. HFT should be outlawed, but it certainly isn't going to harm the individual investor.

Curious why HFT should be outlawed, as opposed to any other program trading that has been the majority of market activity for the last 30+ years anyway? It used to be that putting up a few million up for a seat at the exchange was the price of admission for faster and more accurate pricing (and a way to profit through arbitrage), now that faster computers and networks have replaced the human market makers, what exactly is different?

The black boxes have been running the show for a while now.
 
Curious why HFT should be outlawed, as opposed to any other program trading that has been the majority of market activity for the last 30+ years anyway? It used to be that putting up a few million up for a seat at the exchange was the price of admission for faster and more accurate pricing (and a way to profit through arbitrage), now that faster computers and networks have replaced the human market makers, what exactly is different?

The black boxes have been running the show for a while now.

You're talking to someone who thinks there should be a 90% tax on any capital gains made from a stock that is sold in less than 6 months from when it was purchased. I don't like trading. I'm definitely not going to like the high frequency kind. :)

But besides my distaste for trading, there are also systemic problems with HFT. The "flash crash" should have been a wake-up call.
 
You're talking to someone who thinks there should be a 90% tax on any capital gains made from a stock that is sold in less than 6 months from when it was purchased. I don't like trading. I'm definitely not going to like the high frequency kind. :)

But besides my distaste for trading, there are also systemic problems with HFT. The "flash crash" should have been a wake-up call.

That is actually a pretty interesting concept, your 90% tax. A few years ago I would have been strongly opposed to it, but now I can see some validity to it...
 
That is actually a pretty interesting concept, your 90% tax. A few years ago I would have been strongly opposed to it, but now I can see some validity to it...

It would make the short sellers on Wall Street even richer, and screw the individual investor even more. With such a tax disincentive to sell, it is likely retail investors will hold things even longer than they should, which they already do now.

If you buy a stock tomorrow and it goes up 100% the next day, what is the only smart thing to do?
 
It would make the short sellers on Wall Street even richer, and screw the individual investor even more.

Ah, short selling, something else that should be outlawed. :)

If you buy a stock tomorrow and it goes up 100% the next day, what is the only smart thing to do?

That depends. What's the company's intrinsic value? I currently own shares in a company that I purchased about a year ago that went up in price by 100% within about 6 months. I'm still holding those shares, because they've got a another couple hundred percent to increase before they'll reflect the company's true value.
 
It would make the short sellers on Wall Street even richer, and screw the individual investor even more. With such a tax disincentive to sell, it is likely retail investors will hold things even longer than they should, which they already do now.

If you buy a stock tomorrow and it goes up 100% the next day, what is the only smart thing to do?

Sell, of course.

But I think ATNs concept would make take a lot of that kind of volatility out of the market.

You do bring up a good point though, and I'm not saying that kind of tax is perfect. I'm just really starting to hate the super short term outlook of the markets.
 
That is actually a pretty interesting concept, your 90% tax. A few years ago I would have been strongly opposed to it, but now I can see some validity to it...

We need to be encouraging investment, not trading. People moving in and out of stocks simply to gamble on price movements is not productive. People argue that it's necessary to have that sort of liquidity, and while liquidity is important, it's not necessary to have penalty-free liquidity for short-term trades.
 
We need to be encouraging investment, not trading. People moving in and out of stocks simply to gamble on price movements is not productive. People argue that it's necessary to have that sort of liquidity, and while liquidity is important, it's not necessary to have penalty-free liquidity for short-term trades.

It is productive, at least in the sense that it limits bubbles in prices to some extent.

I remember back in the days before decimalization (stocks were quoted in quarters and eighths!), the spreads and commissions were such that Wall Street was making money on every trade, and that was money that was coming out of Widow and Orphan pockets. (It might have been a nickel here, dime there from a sale for a pension payment, but it was still way less fair for the little guy).

People that are gambling on price movements are usually doing so with futures contracts and options anyway, it is rarely just the individual security.

But what is the "good reason" for trades to be more expensive? They are smart folks doing the trading, even with a tax, they'll figure out another way to make money. Not much different than a 90% tax on pawn shops or supermarkets or consignment shops. They are all essentially doing the same thing (buy low/sell high) :)
 
Back
Top