I bought a house

I love BB&B!!!!!!
We've had our differences in the past, but you're not helping your cause. Like I told @mikecweb a few minutes ago on here, you make it too easy. Stop making it easy.:D

And, seriously, adding about their coupon policy...really?? Okay, then...:D;):):cool::confused:
 
Last edited:
The probability of it increasing in value is very high. The associated tax deductions will typically drive you well above the standard deduction level. There is an exclusion for the capital gain made on a house that doesn't exist with the majority of investments. There are options open to home owners that aren't available to others such as home equity lines of credit and reverse mortgages.

On the other side, it is one of the few investments that you get to pay taxes on -EVERY YEAR YOU OWN IT. Substantial taxes - mine run well more than 10% of my original "investment" per year. They also go up every year. Unlike other investments, you also need insurance (acceptable types mandated by the government), which may well be more than the tax. The rates may go up 800% overnight if Congress feels like it. When you want sell, you get to pay a 6% commission. And unlike a stock or bond, that may pay interest or dividends, you get to pay for maintenance when anything breaks.

There are some great advantages, tax and otherwise, to owning a house (I have one). I don't think that it is a very good investment, most folks that claim it is do a poor job of accounting for all of the expenses they have incurred.
 
On the other side, it is one of the few investments that you get to pay taxes on -EVERY YEAR YOU OWN IT. Substantial taxes - mine run well more than 10% of my original "investment" per year. They also go up every year. Unlike other investments, you also need insurance (acceptable types mandated by the government), which may well be more than the tax. The rates may go up 800% overnight if Congress feels like it. When you want sell, you get to pay a 6% commission. And unlike a stock or bond, that may pay interest or dividends, you get to pay for maintenance when anything breaks.

Everything you wrote is true, and I can even throw in one from personal experience. The government can come along and take all or part of your land under eminent domain, give you what they say it is worth and make it financially impractical to try to get them to pay what it is really worth. On top of that they give the money to your mortgage holder, not to you.

However, you're going to pay all of those taxes and interest and maintenance no matter what. It's only a matter of to whom they are paid. You can pay it to the person who owns the space where you live or you can pay it to directly to the end source.

There are certainly situations where buying is a bad idea. Not many people want to buy their crash pad. The frequency of relocating is probably the single greatest factor in the rent versus buy equation. But if a person is going to be in one location for any length of time, buying is the hands down winner and it's not because people like to spend their Saturdays spraying crabgrass or painting.
 
Congrats Beef. Novato is awesome. Close enough to the city that it's easy to get to (thank you Larkspur Ferry!) and far enough away that you can actually afford to live there. And a short drive to the coast.
 
I've always said you can't live in a stock. I will admit I've been burned in the last 10 years. I'm not a fan of stocks as it's part of the corporate bourgeois that keeps the man down, so I have chosen to not play that game. My way at sticking it to the man (but I am the man). I'm sure I've lost out on a great fortune but I still feel good about it. Ask me again in 20 years. Anyhow, both my latest home purchase (a good deal on a unique property in a resort town with a lot of upward potential) and my ocean view condo in San Clemente both make me feel like I've turned the corner in real estate as an investment. Hoping for the best. But owning a home because you need a place to live and don't want to piss money away to a landlord....I think it's usually a pretty good idea if you can swing it.
 
The probability of it increasing in value is very high. The associated tax deductions will typically drive you well above the standard deduction level. There is an exclusion for the capital gain made on a house that doesn't exist with the majority of investments. There are options open to home owners that aren't available to others such as home equity lines of credit and reverse mortgages. I also think (but not positive) that being a home owner helps your credit rating.

There is a related line from from Gerald O'Hara in Gone With the Wind, "land is the only thing in the world worth workin’ for, worth fightin’ for, worth dyin’ for, because it’s the only thing that lasts.”

Real estate can be a great investment if you know what you're doing and you're doing it for cash flow rather than for capital appreciation. When it comes to capital appreciation, real estate is pretty awful. Even over long periods of time, at best, you're looking at compounding in the 3-5% range. When even a monkey throwing darts can expect a 7-9% return in equities, that's not very attractive. The key to success comes in when you learn how to use real estate as a cash flow generating investment. If you can buy a house at $30k with 25% down, put in less than $10k in repairs, and then lease it for $750/mo, then you're blowing the doors off of any stock portfolio. But you need to know what you're doing in order to accomplish that. Far more often, I have clients coming to me who paid $80k cash for a house that needs $10k in repairs and is only worth $60k, and it might get $650/mo in rent. They think they've done good because they have no mortgage payment, and I'm just shaking my head and trying to explain to them that a 3.25% mortgage is practically free money, and they could have bought 3 better investment properties for the same capital outlay and beaten Warren Buffett's returns in the process.

If you're going to invest in real estate beyond buying your own place to live, you really need to know what you're doing, or hire a professional with lots of experience. I've seen way too many people burned. Hell, I see new ones practically every week.
 
Hey, @BEEF SUPREME - this is about congratulations - I find it a bit rude for folks to be debating the financial merits of your decision in your own thread.

Novato is lovely. I used to go out to Petaluma regularly for business and always passed through and loved it. I have just finally gotten to the point where I can walk through HD or Lowe's and NOT have to get something for the remodel. That's done for now.
 
Like Don said, Real Estate is a good investment that you can live in at the same time. I am chomping at the bit to get some investment properties but right now they are just out of our reach.
 
Real estate can be a great investment if you know what you're doing and you're doing it for cash flow rather than for capital appreciation. When it comes to capital appreciation, real estate is pretty awful. Even over long periods of time, at best, you're looking at compounding in the 3-5% range. When even a monkey throwing darts can expect a 7-9% return in equities, that's not very attractive. The key to success comes in when you learn how to use real estate as a cash flow generating investment. If you can buy a house at $30k with 25% down, put in less than $10k in repairs, and then lease it for $750/mo, then you're blowing the doors off of any stock portfolio. But you need to know what you're doing in order to accomplish that. Far more often, I have clients coming to me who paid $80k cash for a house that needs $10k in repairs and is only worth $60k, and it might get $650/mo in rent. They think they've done good because they have no mortgage payment, and I'm just shaking my head and trying to explain to them that a 3.25% mortgage is practically free money, and they could have bought 3 better investment properties for the same capital outlay and beaten Warren Buffett's returns in the process.

If you're going to invest in real estate beyond buying your own place to live, you really need to know what you're doing, or hire a professional with lots of experience. I've seen way too many people burned. Hell, I see new ones practically every week.
So let me get this straight. Lets say you have a house with a mortgage around 3.25%, if you get done paying your bills and putting money in your retirement and have a $50-100 left, you'd advise either throwing it at your retirement or an investment for income portfolio vice paying down extra on the mortgage, because those investments over time will average better than the interest you're paying on the mortgage?
 
So let me get this straight. Lets say you have a house with a mortgage around 3.25%, if you get done paying your bills and putting money in your retirement and have a $50-100 left, you'd advise either throwing it at your retirement or an investment for income portfolio vice paying down extra on the mortgage, because those investments over time will average better than the interest you're paying on the mortgage?
Yes. Do all the math and you get a better return on the investments. It might not be much but mathematically you will be coming out ahead in the end. Another good thing is to breakup your mortgage payments and pay it twice a month. You'll pay the same each month but you will have accrued less interest.
 
Another good thing is to breakup your mortgage payments and pay it twice a month. You'll pay the same each month but you will have accrued less interest.
Interesting. I would think that works well for most people anyway, since most people get paid twice a month it would make the budgeting process flow a little easier.
 
Interesting. I would think that works well for most people anyway, since most people get paid twice a month it would make the budgeting process flow a little easier.
It makes it a little easier to swallow doing a smaller amount after each paycheck. It is not a huge savings on average I think it is $100-200 a year but it is a few Benjamins you can put to use in other places. Also, make sure that your mortgage companies allow this some try to get every penny out of you and might penalize you for doing it this way.
 
So let me get this straight. Lets say you have a house with a mortgage around 3.25%, if you get done paying your bills and putting money in your retirement and have a $50-100 left, you'd advise either throwing it at your retirement or an investment for income portfolio vice paying down extra on the mortgage, because those investments over time will average better than the interest you're paying on the mortgage?

Absolutely. Unless you've got a mortgage rate over 6%, you shouldn't be paying it down faster than you have to. And if you do have a mortgage rate that high, you should be refinancing it. Most people can qualify for a streamline loan that doesn't even require an appraisal or cash at closing.
 
Back
Top