Great Lakes rant

Good plane when it was state-of-the-art but that was then.

The Beech 99 was never a "good plane". It was and remains a cobbled-together Frankenstein's Monster of King Air and Queen Air parts, bolted together and shoved out the door for the unsuspecting masses to huddle in to the back of and pray for their lives. And aside from the cost of acquisition, I can almost guarantee you it's a lot more expensive to operate than a PC-12 (which, admittedly, has its own problems).

Now, that said, I can see how a new-build 99 would actually be a pretty reasonable solution for some of the EAS routes that are too thin for a 1900, but too thick for a 402 or Caravan. You know, short routes where the fact that it drags itself around at (IMS) ~220 knots on ~1200shp isn't a big problem. But that doesn't make it any less crappy, either in the past or the present. And who would fly the damned thing for $30k/year and a set of four-stripe epaulettes? It's a lot better in ice than a Caravan (from what I can tell), but at the altitudes available it WILL encounter ice. Often, and without a lot of wiggle-room up or down to get out of the stuff. You put a Jet-U kiddy in that and wait a few minutes, you'll hear a big thud and see some fireworks.

In summary, The Beech 99. Boo! Hiss! ;)
 
The Beech 99 was never a "good plane". It was and remains a cobbled-together Frankenstein's Monster of King Air and Queen Air parts, bolted together and shoved out the door for the unsuspecting masses to huddle in to the back of and pray for their lives. And aside from the cost of acquisition, I can almost guarantee you it's a lot more expensive to operate than a PC-12 (which, admittedly, has its own problems).

Now, that said, I can see how a new-build 99 would actually be a pretty reasonable solution for some of the EAS routes that are too thin for a 1900, but too thick for a 402 or Caravan. You know, short routes where the fact that it drags itself around at (IMS) ~220 knots on ~1200shp isn't a big problem. But that doesn't make it any less crappy, either in the past or the present. And who would fly the damned thing for $30k/year and a set of four-stripe epaulettes? It's a lot better in ice than a Caravan (from what I can tell), but at the altitudes available it WILL encounter ice. Often, and without a lot of wiggle-room up or down to get out of the stuff. You put a Jet-U kiddy in that and wait a few minutes, you'll hear a big thud and see some fireworks.

In summary, The Beech 99. Boo! Hiss! ;)
You love. It's cute how much you pretend to hate the mighty beech airliner, but deep down you would fly nothing less.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
deep down you would fly nothing less.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Flying less would be nearly impossible. Maybe a Seneca. They're pretty awful, too. But they don't have Adherents, so the whole thing becomes less fun. I dunno, what's worse? I mean, Kingair 90s are pretty bad, but they're obviously better than a 99, at least! I don't much like Caravans, but there are jobs they're great at (just not maybe some of the jobs they do). Citation III/VII? Lotsa problems, but if you've got a long runway and a big checkbook, they might make a certain amount of sense for the robber-baron who mostly pulls the thing out of the hangar to impress his golf buddies. Starship? They seem to suck in every quantifiable way, but they have cachet, which a 99 most emphatically does not. No, sorry, I'm hard pressed to come up with a worse airplane than the Beech 99. Cessna 411? They seem to be pretty bad. I dunno, what's your nomination?
 
The Beech 99 was never a "good plane". It was and remains a cobbled-together Frankenstein's Monster of King Air and Queen Air parts, bolted together and shoved out the door for the unsuspecting masses to huddle in to the back of and pray for their lives. And aside from the cost of acquisition, I can almost guarantee you it's a lot more expensive to operate than a PC-12 (which, admittedly, has its own problems).

Now, that said, I can see how a new-build 99 would actually be a pretty reasonable solution for some of the EAS routes that are too thin for a 1900, but too thick for a 402 or Caravan. You know, short routes where the fact that it drags itself around at (IMS) ~220 knots on ~1200shp isn't a big problem. But that doesn't make it any less crappy, either in the past or the present. And who would fly the damned thing for $30k/year and a set of four-stripe epaulettes? It's a lot better in ice than a Caravan (from what I can tell), but at the altitudes available it WILL encounter ice. Often, and without a lot of wiggle-room up or down to get out of the stuff. You put a Jet-U kiddy in that and wait a few minutes, you'll hear a big thud and see some fireworks.

In summary, The Beech 99. Boo! Hiss! ;)
Your 99 rants always make me LOOOOOOL pretty hard! Just flew a B model the other day and thought it was FUN! :) It's a friggen toy compared to the Metro.
 
Flying less would be nearly impossible. Maybe a Seneca. They're pretty awful, too. But they don't have Adherents, so the whole thing becomes less fun. I dunno, what's worse? I mean, Kingair 90s are pretty bad, but they're obviously better than a 99, at least! I don't much like Caravans, but there are jobs they're great at (just not maybe some of the jobs they do). Citation III/VII? Lotsa problems, but if you've got a long runway and a big checkbook, they might make a certain amount of sense for the robber-baron who mostly pulls the thing out of the hangar to impress his golf buddies. Starship? They seem to suck in every quantifiable way, but they have cachet, which a 99 most emphatically does not. No, sorry, I'm hard pressed to come up with a worse airplane than the Beech 99. Cessna 411? They seem to be pretty bad. I dunno, what's your nomination?
182.
 
It's a friggen toy compared to the Metro.

The ones with the big engines climb really well (at like 100 knots). And it's pretty hard to crash because it's "flying for Dummies" easy to fly. Here ends the list of Virtues.

I'll hit you with the Vices when I have time to write the book.
 
The ones with the big engines climb really well (at like 100 knots). And it's pretty hard to crash because it's "flying for Dummies" easy to fly. Here ends the list of Virtues.

I'll hit you with the Vices when I have time to write the book.
You flew an A model though, right? The C and the B trim in particular is quite different, with the B being quite infuriating. I did always thought our Cs climbed like 6 legged squirrels when empty though.

STUPID easy, even under AMF SOPs.
 
Last edited:
I flew a couple. One was an "A", I think. Which was Less Bad. Bigger engines, for sure, anyway. The other was a 1967 data plate. I don't think it was even an "A". It was a "". Just a 99. The serial number had two digits, IMS, and I got the impression that it was sometimes hard to find parts for the engines, likely because they'd been out of production for several decades.

I will say that even the "", with like 40,000+ hours on the clock, climbed like a raped ape empty. And the later one (like I said, I think it was an A, but I wouldn't swear to that), obviously even moreso. They both had brakes and tires from a Hot Wheel and were slower than molasses in January for the power, though. If there'd been an autopilot, I think my attitude would be more "scathing contempt" than "outright jihad". But there wasn't.

The only saving grace of that job was that I worked for a really good company that paid well and tried as hard as they could to take care of the troops. If it'd been Amflight, I think I'd have gone Postal about week 3. I doff my hat to the guys who fly those things around for, what, like 30k/year in all weather.

Edit: Looked em up. One was a 67, the other a 69. The 69 was noticeably spunkier, so it must have been an "A". To the best of my recollection, the trim system was the same on both of them. Which is to say "infuriating".
 
Last edited:
I flew a couple. One was a "C", I think. Which was Less Bad. Bigger engines, for sure, anyway. The other was a 1967 data plate. I don't think it was even an "A". It was a "". Just a 99. The serial number had two digits, IMS, and I got the impression that it was sometimes hard to find parts for the engines, likely because they'd been out of production for several decades.

I will say that even the "", with like 40,000+ hours on the clock, climbed like a raped ape empty. And the later one (like I said, I think it was a C, but I wouldn't swear to that), obviously even moreso. They both had brakes and tires from a Hot Wheel and were slower than molasses in January for the power, though. If there'd been an autopilot, I think my attitude would be more "scathing contempt" than "outright jihad". But there wasn't.

The only saving grace of that job was that I worked for a really good company that paid well and tried as hard as they could to take care of the troops. If it'd been Amflight, I think I'd have gone Postal about week 3. I doff my hat to the guys who fly those things around for, what, like 30k/year in all weather.
Knock on wood, still haven't flat spotted a 99 tire. :p

Yep, 30k for the 99s here. Operationally though, WAY easier than Flight Express. I didn't "feel" the pay cut so to speak. It's funny, Metro now, STILL not making FLX pay in a 210, nor would I in the Broseph! LOLOL, I mean :bang:

Yeah, that trim doesn't stop running in the B when you let go of the button. The C, you could stab it and get it right, eventually. The SJU legs are so short on the 99 though, I'd just say fuggit, and strong arm that thing into St. Croix.
 
Last edited:
Knock on wood, still haven't flat spotted a 99 tire. :p

Yep, 30k for the 99s here. Operationally though, WAY easier than Flight Express. I didn't "feel" the pay cut so to speak. It's funny, Metro now, STILL not making FLX pay in a 210, nor would I in the Broseph! LOLOL, I mean :bang:

I think the pressure at FLX was very much about where you were based and to some extent how long you'd been there. I was as nervous as a horsey in church the first six months or so, but once my name got in the top half of the list, it seemed like there was some level of trust built up. I was also fortunate to be in a "base" where (I'm guessing here) Ernst et al could sort of obliquely ask long-timers, mechanics, etc. whether or not I seemed like a dumbass, vs just being all alone with an airplane in the middle of nowhere where all they know is what I tell them. And yeah, FLX was a lot like Subair in that while the equipment was "safe-but-not-exactly-top-shelf", the attitude of management was "tough-but-fair". I'd go back to work for either tomorrow, if the circumstances required it (and if they'd be dumb enough rehire me! ;) ). Even if I had to fly a 99! :eek:

I'm pretty sure the only time I was emphatically told NOT to take a flight that I thought I could do was at Subair. The CP was like "Yeah, how bout you just stay there?" I was nonplussed at the time, but in retrospect, it's a mark of Quality.
 
I wanna say 98, as chq was just converting our just had converted the j31s from scheduled 135 to 121.

I think 97 was the transition from 135 scheduled to 121 or something like that.

I remember how the dispatcher that thought it was copasetic sending me MKE to IND with 200 lbs of fuel that I told to stuff it, that pulled the same thing under 121 and thought he had the authority to argue about it.
 
You flew an A model though, right? The C and the B trim in particular is quite different, with the B being quite infuriating. I did always thought our Cs climbed like 6 legged squirrels when empty though.

STUPID easy, even under AMF SOPs.
The "C" models weren't that bad, but the "B" models were terrible. Does AMF still have some of the "A-converted to B" models? Those were fun..
 
I think the pressure at FLX was very much about where you were based and to some extent how long you'd been there. I was as nervous as a horsey in church the first six months or so, but once my name got in the top half of the list, it seemed like there was some level of trust built up. I was also fortunate to be in a "base" where (I'm guessing here) Ernst et al could sort of obliquely ask long-timers, mechanics, etc. whether or not I seemed like a dumbass, vs just being all alone with an airplane in the middle of nowhere where all they know is what I tell them. And yeah, FLX was a lot like Subair in that while the equipment was "safe-but-not-exactly-top-shelf", the attitude of management was "tough-but-fair". I'd go back to work for either tomorrow, if the circumstances required it (and if they'd be dumb enough rehire me! ;) ). Even if I had to fly a 99! :eek:

I'm pretty sure the only time I was emphatically told NOT to take a flight that I thought I could do was at Subair. The CP was like "Yeah, how bout you just stay there?" I was nonplussed at the time, but in retrospect, it's a mark of Quality.
I just thought the 210 was just a lot more difficult to make decisions with, especially enroute. Not that capable and not a lot of range to get out of things. I haven't seen Ameriflight give guys much gruff for delaying or cancelling. Assistant chiefs at least, seem to back their guys up just fine. FLX was actually a little more pressure, but I was THAT guy in the middle of "no where"(MSP).
 
FLX was actually a little more pressure, but I was THAT guy in the middle of "no where"(MSP).

I was THAT guy (KHKS) for my first few months, too. And I'm pretty sure they thought I couldn't tell my ass from a hole in the ground. Luckily for me, it was summer and the weather was absurdly good the whole time. Think I did one ILS, which is probably one more than I was really prepared for. ;)

Once I got up to CPS, things evened out. Like I said, very circumstantial. That said, I do remember that there was a little bit of menace in Brad's voice once or twice when I said "Uh, I'm not sure that this is a good idea". But it was pretty minimal, and I don't think I ever had to talk to the Big Scando about anything I decided not to do. Probably a "your mileage may vary" kind of thing.
 
Back
Top