American air carriers need to learn from Asia (sad)

I had a business class ticket going to Vegas this year on USAirways, and I was quite pleased with the level of service I received. A pretty good meal served for lunch, the FAs asked if they could hang my jacket before I even sat down, a pillow and blanket were waiting for me on my seat, the FAs checked if I needed anything repeatedly during the flight, etc. I don't see the complaints with the service. If you're looking for a 22 year old Russian blonde, then yeah, you'll probably be disappointed, but I don't see the reason for all of the complaints about the service itself. Perhaps the problem is that you're paying $200 and expecting $1,000 service.
 
That's nice, but their safety cultures are lagging decades behind US Carriers. Doubt it will ever be on par with US Carriers due to vast cultural differences engrained in their society.

Also, US Carriers are enhancing their international (and domestic) products so any service gap is quickly being closed.
Very true on both counts. I mentioned this in another thread, but biz class on the AA 777 I was on recently from LHR-MIA was fantastic.
 
Perhaps the problem is that you're paying $200 and expecting $1,000 service.

NO!!! I'm expecting that employees (not limited to aviation) show up for work prepared to act in a professional, courteous and respectful manner towards the customers. As someone else posted in this thread, don't rush the cabin service and then retreat to the galley to catch up on personal business.
 
I would wager that I spend more time than you in the back of airplanes, and I very rarely see anything remotely like what you're describing. And that goes for many airlines, not just my own.
 
I had a business class ticket going to Vegas this year on USAirways, and I was quite pleased with the level of service I received. A pretty good meal served for lunch, the FAs asked if they could hang my jacket before I even sat down, a pillow and blanket were waiting for me on my seat, the FAs checked if I needed anything repeatedly during the flight, etc. I don't see the complaints with the service. If you're looking for a 22 year old Russian blonde, then yeah, you'll probably be disappointed, but I don't see the reason for all of the complaints about the service itself. Perhaps the problem is that you're paying $200 and expecting $1,000 service.

no no no.

Don't lump me in that crowd because I do not buy a $200 fare from DFW-DEN and expect anything but to sit there for a couple hours and maybe a Dr. Pepper.

Now no matter what the fare cost when you are on a 14 hour flight there a few little things you can do to make the flight more enjoyable and comfortable to get......REPEAT CUSTOMERS.

It shouldn't matter what the cost of the ticket was. Just a little professionalism and a smile is all I am asking for.
 
I like the American exceptionalism, normally a far-right concept, that you display here.

:D

And I agree too.

In aviation, it's a very valid concept.

Exceptionalism is somewhat fascinating, because in some ways the areas in which we excel are based on a lack of a strong underlying culture. I was thinking about it recently, and came to the conclusion that America is (almost) alone by that standard; as a "volunteer" nation, comprising many cultures but integrating them into our own shared experience, we are uniquely positioned to break through the constraints which "strong" cultures place on society. Other nations are forced to change their deeply-rooted national culture to keep up with the world, which often proves an insurmountable challenge... leading to them attempting to adapt their culture to the new reality.

It's a pretty fascinating piece of fluff, if you start really thinking about it.

-Fox
(Canada ;)
 
Ok, I get it, safety and CRM....

Obviously there was a huge lapse in CRM on the Asiana flight, but what about the dumbass that plowed the Colgan aircraft in the ground or Air France? I know the air france pilots get much more training than US pilots.


I was posting about the actual service as a consumer.

Look up Korean Air's crash history. Poor CRM is a huge problem in Korean aviation (to their credit, I think things have improved).
 
Like what? What exactly are you expecting for a coach seat? Because it seems to me that the U.S. carriers do pretty good with in-flight entertainment and such.

They both do good with inflight entertainment.

Look, I'm not asking for a foot massage or anything when I buy a coach ticket. It is nice to feel like a paying customer for once and not like they are doing me a favor for flying me somewhere.

I have traveled overseas plenty of time on AA, BA and now KA. AA gets a D- in the service department.

I'm just a consumer making an observation is all....
 
ryanmickG said:
They both do good with inflight entertainment. Look, I'm not asking for a foot massage or anything when I buy a coach ticket. It is nice to feel like a paying customer for once and not like they are doing me a favor for flying me somewhere. I have traveled overseas plenty of time on AA, BA and now KA. AA gets a D- in the service department. I'm just a consumer making an observation is all....

But that's just it: you aren't making any observations at all. You're saying that you want better service, but you're not saying what that better service would be. I really don't have a clue what you're looking for.
 
The truth of the matter is, when a perfectly airworthy airplane is flown into the ground on a clear and a million VFR day, there is something wrong with the people-ware.

(Pending official NTSB determinations of cause, but this is a true statement.)

So is outright stalling a perfectly flyable airplane right outside BUF and killing everyone. This thread stinks of "us better than them" when the truth of the matter is whatever reason a foreign airliner crashed an airplane, we Americans have done the same. Blame CRM all you like, but the end result of lives saved in Asiana speaks for itself. Those FAs coordinated with each other as best as possible and 95 lb women dragged out passengers on their backs. I'd like to see the grannies here try that. And lets not forget the CFR rescue was responsible for 1 death out of 3 total in that crash.

Where are the UPS comments? Or are they given a pass for being an American crew in which CRM would never be an issue?
 
Back to the OP, god forbid the glideslope at your destination goes down for maintenance. Not the ILS mind you... the GLIDESLOPE!!!


"Ah, crap." -rummages for LOC DME Y 28R plate-

....or when the ILS runway goes down and the only option is a LOC 18 approach.
 
So is outright stalling a perfectly flyable airplane right outside BUF and killing everyone. ...
Yeah, no (redacted), Buckwheat.

Where are the UPS comments? Or are they given a pass for being an American crew in which CRM would never be an issue?
Nope. I've been an American crewmember with a CRM issue.

I still maintain that I'd rather ride on an FAA-certificated air carrier than most others, though.
 
Yeah, no (redacted), Buckwheat.


Nope. I've been an American crewmember with a CRM issue.

I still maintain that I'd rather ride on an FAA-certificated air carrier than most others, though.

I'd agree, but I'll still take other first/second world countries airlines as well. I'd take Korean Air or Asiana any day if I was going to Seoul and in fact if you are flying out of ATL to ICN, that Delta flight number is actually a Korean Airline flight.
 
But that's just it: you aren't making any observations at all. You're saying that you want better service, but you're not saying what that better service would be. I really don't have a clue what you're looking for.

Todd, you're killing me. You know exactly what I'm talking about. My observation would be that US air carriers can learn a lot about in flight service from the rest of the world.

Don't think for a second that service is not a deciding factor from the ticket buying public.

I know it is just a culture issue. In Asia pilots are treated like gods. They are also compensated as such. I'm sure the air hostesses are treated with a lot more respect over there too. I'm sure that has a lot to do with their attitude toward their job.
 
Todd, you're killing me. You know exactly what I'm talking about.

No, I honestly don't. You keep posting without saying what you really want. I'm getting the feeling that you won't say it because all you're really looking for is a 22 year old Russian or Korean girl with a tiny waist, and it actually has nothing to do with service. If that's not the case, then please, explain.
 
Back
Top