Angry Vet and USAirways

Airlines don't like to budge on policy when stuff like this blows up in the media. It allows people to think they can get around airline policy if they make enough noise, and that isn't how it works with these huge cooperation's. Besides, as an airline guy, I can tell you that the MAJORITY (caps because its true) of service animals on airplanes are not legit service animals. I can also tell you letting service dogs occupy seats on planes would just lead to delays as rampers or cabin cleaners would be cleaning unrine and doo-doo off of seats left by the scores of fake service animals that fly each day. Is it fair to the people who really do have service animals they need to travel with? No, it's not. But as you said, its not a perfect world.

If you need someone to blame, blame the people who claim their un-housebroken yappy toy dog is a service animal and abuse the system to save money and time.

Well in my airline experience, limited as it is, animals are the least offensive travelers. Most people just don't give a F about how they treat the cabin... Or lav. Just seems like you're describing a world where fake service animals run rampant and destroy the lives of airline crews and the traveling public. All I'm saying is: I haven't experienced that.
 
Well in my airline experience, limited as it is, animals are the least offensive travelers. Most people just don't give a F about how they treat the cabin... Or lav. Just seems like you're describing a world where fake service animals run rampant and destroy the lives of airline crews and the traveling public. All I'm saying is: I haven't experienced that.
Everything you said is true. But sadly, as you can probably gather from the other responses, I'm not making this stuff up. Maybe things will change one day, but for now, airlines will enforce the policies. If an airline gets a thank you letter from a pax saying the crew was great and let the dog take a seat, that crew member could be fired. You have to remember that the FAA works with the airlines on these policies they have set, and they audit flights from time to time. A hefty fine may ensue for granting favors to service animals on a case-by-case basis, unfortunately.
 
Jetcareers forums, belittling the handicapped since 2013. (tm)

Did you watch the video? I think the person doing the belittling was the guy with the green ball cap.

Being a disabled veteran is never a pass to not obey the law, nor is it an excuse to act like a jerk. He might be surprised who the pilots are that he belittles (e.g. "how they ever were made a pilot is beyond me!")....they might just also be a combat veteran.

For a guy whose main defense is that "the law says" he can have that dog, he sure seems happy to ignore what "the law says" in terms of where that dog has to sit on the airplane. Cuts both ways.
 
Last edited:
This guy lost the argument as soon as he said he deserved special treatment because he's a veteran. While I usually do go above and beyond for the military guys (asking the FAs to move them up to first class, asking the gate agent to let them board early, etc.), it's different when they demand special treatment and feel entitled.
 
I guess I'm just a little jaded about the service dog.

I've seen people that are blind and deaf that refuse special accommodations, or when they do, they're about the nicest people on the jet, but the high-heeled Scottsdale socialite hops on a jet with a yappy Pomeranian with the "Service Animal" smock on, they want the world to come to an end because of their "comfort animal".

I can only imagine Jabba the Hutt boarding a jet with Princess Leia, chained and in-tow, early boarding a 757 saying "EETS A MAH COMFORT CONCUBINES!".

Wait... That was more Jar-Jar Binks. Sorry. #fail.
A month ago I wouldn't have believed the stories about fake service animals. Then this elderly but still very much not handicapped asian lady boards my plane with her yipper and insists that he can't ride behind the cargo net because he's a "service animal". Fortunately we had an empty seat and apparently Mr. Fluffies in his purse style carrier found that to be satisfactory.
 
Jetcareers forums, belittling the handicapped since 2013. (tm)

Let me be clear.

No one is doing that.

I am disgruntled over a system where people abuse the system to get around fees and kenneling. There are many legit service animals onboard, and there are a lot of people that are abusing the system.

People that legitimately need service animals need to come down hard on those that are abusing the system.

A lot like the Handicapped parking hang tag. My father had one when he was dying that my mother would use when she would drive him somewhere.

I don't think his body was even cold yet before able-bodied people would ask about if they could have the tag.
 
Tell me once you've wheeled a few dozen people up a steep narrow ramp and onto a spacious plane such as the mighty Brasilia in an aisle chair then carried them to their seat, until then, watch the accusations.
Not to mentioned taken guide or service dogs out to have a pee/poop/given the dog water, had a word with the Purser to make sure the needs of any disabled person are met and some extra TLC given, spoken to the person directly yourself and relayed the same and asked if they have any special needs/requests, helped them after landing and made sure they connected with whomever was waiting for them, and when they were children, I visited them personally during the flight at least once, often more times and gave them some little goodies that I always carried for kids, made sure any disabled or ill or frail pax had help to the lav and more. I've done much the same for some really really elderly/frail pax and those who have recently had surgery (on crutches in a cast, may have been receiving cancer treatments at a hospital out of their home town -whatever the case is - as well. If there was room, I would move them up forward. FAs, are more than willing to accommodate those who really need help and they are for the most part wonderful with them, we rely on that and to keep us in the loop on how the pax are doing. Because I have done all of that countless times and so have all the decent Captains that I have known. You have to follow your company SOP's to a point and be aware of potential liability issues......then decency, common sense and humanity take over and guide you. It is your ship.

And all of current nonsense, is what takes away from real people who suffer, are infirm and are truly disabled when everyone and his mother pulls the disabled and/or I have a service dog when this is just not really the case. It's becoming the norm these days. Every truly disabled person I have known really does everything in their power not to ask for or expect special treatment. They have much more courage, self respect and nuts than Miss Tiffaney traveling with her teacup poodle because she claims he helps with her blood pressure and she expects to be waited on hand and foot like the entire crew are her servants and has to announce all of this to the rest of the pax.

The vet in this video from what I can see, behaved like an ass. He had no issue using the F word in front of children on the flight, possibly scaring some of the pax sitting near him, delaying everyone and refusing to understand, comprehend the rules and comply with them. None of this had to happen if he had done so.We don't even have the part of the video at how this all began, but based on how he reacted, if this service dog is supposed to have a calming effect on him, I'd hate to see how he would have behaved if the dog had not been there.
 
Last edited:
Not to mentioned taken guide or service dogs out to have a pee/poop/given the dog water, had a word with the Purser to make sure the needs of any disabled person are met and some extra TLC given, spoken to the person directly yourself and relayed the same and asked if they have any special needs/requests, helped them after landing and made sure they connected with whomever was waiting for them, and when they were children, I visited them personally during the flight at least once, often more times and gave them some little goodies that I always carried for kids, made sure any disabled or ill or frail pax had help to the lav and more.
Holy cow, that's a sentence and a half! ;)
 
The Veteran groups on FB are chewing this guy up. There seems to be a collective air of embarrassment and annoyance.

I haven't seen the video but from everything I have read the vet was in the wrong and US Airways still went out of their way to cover the expenses they did and accommodate him on another flight. Treat others with respect and you will usually get it in return.

Many moons ago we had a service pot belly pig on a flight.
 
I haven't seen the video but from everything I have read the vet was in the wrong and US Airways still went out of their way to cover the expenses they did and accommodate him on another flight. Treat others with respect and you will usually get it in return.

Many moons ago we had a service pot belly pig on a flight.

I watched the video. The guy was an idiot and totally wrong.
 
This is all covered by the air carrier access act (the DOT version of the Americans with disabilities Act). If he really wants to complain, he can call the DOT and wait 12-24 months for them to laugh at him.

@Derg is right, most people with disabilities wanted to be treated like everyone else to the greatest extent possible.

I'm just happy that in the DL system they have specially trained CSRs who can talk in person or on the phone so I don't have to deal with it. Not that I wouldn't if I didn't have too, but if someone else sat through the training so I didn't have to, I have no problem stepping off the green for that one...
 
Is Derg also right that 90% of service animals are phoney?
Except that is not what Doug said.

Reminds me of when I was commuting and there was a dog with the standard eBay "Service Dog" smock on.

The dog had no problem with dropping a deuce in the aisle and barking at cabin crewmembers as they performed their in-flight service.

I don't know, I'm probably an ass for saying this (or a lot of other stuff), but 90% of the "Service Dogs" that I see make me think "Really? REAAAAALLY?"

How is anyone to know these days?? People are getting their cats, goats, monkeys, ferrets, horses, and dogs registered as service animals so they can take them shopping, take them to work, take them into restaurants and so they can rent apartments/houses with a no pet policy. A true service animal use to be only a guide dog for the blind. That expanded to dogs who can warn their owners of a seizure, dogs that can assist their owners with small tasks who are disabled, alerting a deaf person to sirens or alarms, etc. And ALL of these legit service dogs went through years of training for their specific use/job. That is no longer the case.

" For people wanting to take their pets wherever they go, a brisk business has developed in the sale of bogus service animal certificates and vests.

Tim Livingood runs one of many websites that sell certification paraphernalia. For $65, customers can procure papers, patches and vests to make their dogs look official. They can even buy a prescription letter from a psychiatrist after taking an online quiz. Businesses can’t even ask owners to display proof that their dog is a service animal.

The laws are broad enough to allow that, Livingood says. While his business, the National Service Animal Registry, sounds official, he says government-sanctioned registration agencies do not exist — federal law does not actually require registration or identification patches. Property managers or airlines cannot mandate that service animals come with patches, and they can't ask owners to produce ID cards.

Joanne Shortell, who has a service dog, works to educate people about their rights to have service animals. And there's a lot of confusion, she says. Animals are helping more people cope with a range of illnesses and disabilities, but the terminology and web of access rights make it almost impossible to sort out the frauds from the legitimate helpers." http://www.npr.org/2013/09/11/221017467/four-legged-impostors-give-service-dog-owners-pause

Anyone can now claim their pet is a service animal for emotional support and even for companionship.

Examples of certification/registration/ID for a fee schemes:

SARA (Service Animal Registry of America)
USARplus (United Service Animal Registry) *
Goldstar German Shepherds
SDA (Service Dogs America)
Registered Service Dog
SDCA (Service Dog Certification of America, aka Certify My Dog)
NSAR (National Service Animal Registry)
American Service Dogs
Service Dog ID
Certified Service Dog
National Association of Service Dogs
Service Dog Tags, aka emotionalsupportanimals dot org **
Free My Paws
CRTASA (Canadian Registry of Therapy Animals and Service Animals)
USSDR (United States Service Dog Registry) - registration is free, but they also sell official looking certificates and ID
emosdogtags ***

Note: Not a single service listed above tests the dogs they certify, register, or ID. They do nothing to verify the dog's training or the owner's disability. All that is required is that the purchaser fill out a form with the information for the certificate and where to mail it, and include payment ranging from $35 to over $200 depending on the package being purchased.

Here are some scary quotes from some of the sites above:

"Since 2003, Goldstar has certified over 1,300 dogs of various breeds, large, medium, and small."
"SDA recognizes that every person in America may have some form of disability."
"Get an SDA kit so your dog can accompany you everywhere you need."
"This is a site designed to assist disabled people in obtaining a valid certification and ID card for their service dog so that you can take it on public transportation, into public places such as restaurants, grocery stores, etc."
"Service Dog Certification of America recognizes that every person in The United States of America may have some form of disability."
"If your dog exhibits occasional nipping, Service Dog Certification of America recommends muzzling."
"Your "canine helper" is moments away from becoming a Certified Service Dog through Service Dog Certification of America!"
"Yes, You Can Take Your Dog or Cat With You! It's no secret that many businesses simply aren't pet-friendly, even though most of the population is. A large number of our clients register their dogs (cats and other animals) as Certified Service Animals or Emotional Support Animals (ESAs) not just to accompany them into stores, restaurants, motels, hotels, grocery stores, restaurants, or on airline flights (for no extra cost), but to successfully qualify for housing where pets aren't allowed."

At least one business, Free My Paws, has taken it to a new level. They put an expiration date on their ID cards so you have to buy new ones each year, to the tune of $19.99. "In order to remain compliant with most transport administrations requirement that documentation be current within one year, we require our clients to renew their IDs each year. Note that the same rules may also apply to any Doctor's certificates you provide airlines when travelling. If you purchased your ID as part of a kit, an ID renewal is available for $19.99 per annum (normally $39.99)." It's interesting to note that regulatory law does not in fact require ID to be less than a year old, but the doctor's letter which accompanies an emotional support animal or psychiatric service animal must be less than a year old. http://servicedogcentral.org/content/node/509

Again, there is no government certification for service dogs, and owners aren't required to carry proof of a service dog's training. Obtaining collars, vests and tags printed with "service dog" are sold by hundreds of online companies, no questions asked.

I can register my pets here as service animals in 5 minutes and get them a certificate, id tag and vest: http://www.registerservicedogs.com/
 
Last edited:
Back
Top